Catalan amnesty expected to get court blessing amid political turmoil
On Tuesday
Spain
's constitutional court will start debating the legality of an amnesty law, the country's most divisive piece of legislation of recent decades. The ruling is expected to settle a fierce public argument over the law's technical soundness, although it is unlikely to calm political tensions surrounding it.
The
amnesty law of 2024
sought to withdraw pending legal action against Catalan political leaders who had made a
failed secession attempt
from Spain in 2017, as well as hundreds of activists who had supported the same cause. The most high-profile intended beneficiary was former Catalan president
Carles Puigdemont
, who has been living in self-imposed exile in Belgium.
The law secured for the Socialist prime minister
Pedro Sánchez
the support of Catalan nationalists to keep his left-wing coalition government afloat. He points to the improved political climate in Catalonia, where independence is no longer a live issue, as proof that the policy of engagement has paid dividends.
However, the law has also been at the heart of attacks on Sánchez by the opposition, which has cast it as a legally unsound, cynical ploy by the prime minister to stay in power.
READ MORE
The constitutional court will now consider an appeal lodged against the law by the opposition conservative People's Party (PP). The stridently unionist PP alleged that the legislation breached the constitution by being an arbitrary measure that was the result of a dubious political transaction. The tribunal's ruling is expected later this month, although leaks from a preliminary report it has published in advance of the debate strongly suggest it will reject such objections and broadly endorse the law, while introducing some minor changes.
'The interpretation [of the law] made by the People's Party is incompatible with a constitution that is open, inherent to the democratic state and political pluralism,' reads the leaked document. It adds that the legislature 'can do anything that is not explicitly prohibited by the constitution', which is the case with the amnesty.
The report also dismisses the PP's claim that the political backdrop to the legislation undermined its legitimacy.
Oriol Junqueras, leader of the Catalan Republican Left, remains barred from public office as he waits to be amnestied. Photograph: Josep Lago/AFP
Oriol Junqueras, leader of the Catalan Republican Left (ERC), who remains barred from public office as he waits to be amnestied, described the development as 'another step along a path that is always too long'. He spent three years and eight months in jail for his part in the events of 2017, before being released on a government pardon.
The government has also cautiously welcomed this news. Digital transformation minister Óscar López said the administration has always known the amnesty was constitutional and that it 'has helped to normalise political life in Catalonia'.
Culture minister Ernest Urtasun went further, describing the leaked report as 'good news which reaffirms the government's policy in the face of the judicialisation of [the Catalan] conflict and debunks the lies of the right and the PP'.
Since its approval almost a year ago, 178 Catalans have been amnestied on the case-by-case basis outlined by the law, according to a study commissioned by the civic organisation Omnium Cultural. Another 49 pending cases have been dismissed and nine defendants absolved. Many of those facing legal action were civil servants who had helped the Catalan regional government stage an illegal independence referendum in October 2017.
However, the same report also found that 158 amnesty requests had been rejected, indefinitely postponed, or simply had not been answered.
Pedro Sanchez and his wife Begona Gomez: opponents say the amnesty law is a cynical ploy by the prime minister to stay in power. Photograph: Javier Soriano/AFP via Getty Images
But while the strict legality of the amnesty appears likely to be confirmed in the upcoming ruling, the opposition's fierce response to the leaked court document suggests that its political combustibility is undimmed.
'Now they want to convince us that buying a government with privileges is legal,' said PP leader Alberto Núñez Feijóo. 'I say it's not. It's not ethical, moral or legal.'
His party's spokesman, Borja Semper, suggested that the legal question was irrelevant.
'Constitutional or unconstitutional, it's political corruption,' he said.
With the legality of the law appearing to be settled, the opposition is now placing more emphasis on its morality. Miguel Ángel Rodríguez, the controversial chief adviser to the PP's president of the Madrid region, Isabel Díaz Ayuso, appeared to equate the amnesty with slavery, female genital mutilation, polygamy and paedophilia, 'because they are not expressly prohibited by the constitution'.
News of the constitutional court's anticipated ruling has been well timed for the government, which is being corralled by an array of corruption allegations. Investigations have been carried out into the wife and brother of Sánchez for alleged irregularities, although the government insists these are part of a right-wing witch hunt.
However, another inquiry, into a kickback scheme in which a former minister, José Luis Ábalos, is implicated, is more damaging. So too is a scandal in which a Socialist Party activist, Leire Díez, was apparently caught on tape trying to gather evidence that would discredit the civil guard's organised crime unit, which has been investigating the above cases.
A favourable ruling could also be helpful to the government for parliamentary reasons.
Puigdemont's Together for Catalonia (JxCat) party has seven members of congress whose support is crucial for the stability of the Sánchez government. The relationship between the two has been turbulent since the formation of a new administration in late 2023, with the amnesty law a key part of their deal.
Lola García, a political columnist at La Vanguardia newspaper, noted that 'if the Constitutional Court definitively supports the law in its ruling, the amnesty will be a political fact which will reinforce the [government's] relationship with JxCat and could open the door to a meeting between Pedro Sánchez and Puigdemont'.
However, even if the constitutional court does endorse the amnesty law, its full application is likely to remain pending. That is because the supreme court previously ruled that several politicians, including Puigdemont and Junqueras, had benefited financially from the independence drive, disqualifying them from being amnestied. The constitutional court did not specifically tackle that issue in its preliminary report and it is not known if it will do so in its final ruling.
The conflicting positions of the two top tribunals appear to reflect the political allegiances of their magistrates, with the PP controlling the supreme court and the constitutional court under the Socialist Party's influence.
Commentator Ignacio Varela, writing about the left-leaning balance of the constitutional court, said it is 'the colour of the shirt' of the magistrates that decides their vote, rather than technical considerations. 'Polarisation has reached [the court's] headquarters and the militant vote is embedded there,' he said.
Carles Puigdemont campaigns from his base on the French border with Spain. Photograph: Guy Hedgecoe
Puigdemont's lawyer, Gonzalo Boye, criticised the supreme court for the same reason, albeit from the opposite point of view.
'The supreme court is in a position of rebellion which is incompatible with a democratic system,' he told The Irish Times. 'The judges in the top courts are tremendously ideologically skewed and refuse to apply laws which, ideologically speaking, they do not agree with.'
Boye said that Puigdemont's plans are still uncertain, with his potential return to Spain depending on judicial developments. They include appeals against Puigdemont and others being excluded from the amnesty.
Last summer the former Catalan president made a dramatic public appearance in Barcelona before being whisked away again across the border to escape arrest. Several members of the Mossos d'Esquadra Catalan police force have been investigated for their possible role in the stunt.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
3 days ago
- Irish Times
Donohoe ‘grateful for strong support' to continue as Eurogroup president
Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe said he is 'grateful for the strong level of support' he is receiving from other capitals, to stay on as president of the Eurogroup for a third term. Finance ministers from the 20 euro zone countries have until June 27th to put their name forward to challenge Mr Donohoe for the position. So far Mr Donohoe is the only minister to announce his candidacy, however it is understood Spanish economy minister Carlos Cuerpo has been mulling a run. The Eurogroup brings together the finance ministers from the 20 euro zone countries to co-ordinate economic policy. READ MORE Speaking on his way into a Eurogroup meeting in Luxembourg, Mr Donohoe said he had received a lot of backing to continue in the role. 'I very much welcome the strong level of support that I am getting from many colleagues at the moment', he said on Thursday. A vote to elect the president will take place at the next Eurogroup meeting on July 9th, if another minister stands against Mr Donohoe. The president, who chairs the meetings, holds the role for two-and-a half years. Mr Donohoe was first elected to the influential role in 2020, beating candidates from Spain and Luxembourg. He was re-elected unopposed in 2022 for a second term. The Fine Gael minister has been quietly shoring up support for a third term over recent weeks and months, canvassing his finance counterparts on the phone and in person. Mr Cuerpo, a member of Pedro Sánchez's leftwing government in Spain, is seen as the most likely challenger. The Spanish minister has not ruled out a bid for the Eurogroup presidency. Mr Donohoe would seek to draw on the support of other centre-right governments, in a head-to-head contest with Mr Cuerpo. The process for the election was formally laid out to ministers at the meeting in Luxembourg on Thursday. Candidates have a little over a week to put their name forward. For a period Ireland had two ministers attending Eurogroup meetings, when Mr Donohoe was minister for public expenditure during the previous coalition government. Ireland had to secure a workaround to the tradition that the chair of the group is usually a finance minister, given the finance job was rotated between Mr Donohoe and Michael McGrath in the last coalition. An agreement was made that Mr Donohoe would attend the meetings solely in his capacity as Eurogroup president, with then-minister for finance Mr McGrath in the room to represent Ireland. Former Luxembourg prime minister and European Commission president Jean-Claude Juncker was the longest serving Eurogroup chair, holding the role from 2005 to 2013.
Irish Times
15-06-2025
- Irish Times
Spanish kickback revelations cast doubt on future of prime minister Pedro Sánchez
New revelations that senior figures in his Socialist Party were allegedly involved in a kickback scheme have thrust Spanish prime minister Pedro Sánchez into his deepest crisis since taking office seven years ago. Audio gathered by investigators and made public on Thursday appeared to show Santos Cerdán, the Socialist Party's number three, discussing large sums of money to be charged in exchange for public contracts. Two other men appear to take part in the recorded conversations: José Luis Ábalos, a former senior figure in the party and transport minister who is already being investigated for corruption, and Koldo García, a former adviser of his, who reportedly recorded the audio and is also being investigated. In one of the recordings, Cerdán and García appear to acknowledge that Ábalos is due to receive about €1 million in exchange for the awarding of several contracts. The scandal surrounding Ábalos exploded last year. Although it was damaging for the government, his departure from the cabinet in 2021 and swift removal from the party when he came under suspicion limited its impact somewhat. But the implication of Cerdán, a close ally of Sánchez who he had defended for months from accusations published in the media, comes as a severe blow. READ MORE On Thursday, Sánchez apologised to Spaniards eight times in a televised appearance in which he appeared to acknowledge his former colleague's guilt. 'Until this morning I considered all Santos's explanations to be true,' he said, explaining his mind had been changed by evidence that was 'very, very serious'. 'The Socialist Party and I should not have trusted him,' Sánchez added. Cerdán has resigned from the party and said he will give up his parliamentary seat, although he has insisted on his innocence. Until now, the government had warned that a right-wing witch hunt was being waged by judges and the media to fabricate corruption scandals. Sánchez's wife, Begoña Gómez, has been investigated for possible business irregularities and his brother, David Sánchez, is due to go on trial for alleged influence peddling. Attorney General Álvaro García Ortiz, a Sánchez ally, is also likely to go on trial for revealing confidential information. Meanwhile, a former Socialist operative, Leire Díez, has been caught on tape offering favourable treatment to a businessman in exchange for incriminating information on the police unit carrying out inquiries into several cases affecting the government. The latest development has emboldened the leader of the opposition conservative People's Party (PP), Alberto Núñez Feijóo, who for months has been casting the government as inherently corrupt. 'If anyone had any doubts about what we considered to be a mafia-like network behind the party of government and behind the government itself, I imagine they have now disappeared,' he said. Núñez Feijóo has been calling for Sanchez to call a snap election. Despite the Cerdán revelations, Sánchez has said he intends to see the legislature through until 2027. The Socialist's fate is now in the hands of his parliamentary allies, most of whom supported him in 2018 when he took power by winning a no-confidence motion against a corruption-ridden PP government. His coalition partner, the left-wing Sumar, is among those to express deep concern at the Cerdán scandal. If any of his leftist and nationalist allies were to withdraw their support, as the Catalan Republican Left (ERC) has hinted it might consider doing, depending on how the case progresses, it would almost certainly bring down the government. However, an alternative administration would likely be formed by the PP and the far-right Vox, both of which have alienated Catalan and Basque nationalists with their aggressive unionism. Sánchez's immediate future, therefore, looks bleak but still hard to determine.
Irish Times
11-06-2025
- Irish Times
Attorney general scandal adds to Spanish government woes
The unprecedented legal action being taken against Spain 's attorney general which could see him go on trial and has fuelled calls for his resignation is just the latest in a litany of scandals which have left the Socialist-led government of Pedro Sánchez struggling for stability. This week, a supreme court investigating judge recommended that the attorney general, Álvaro García Ortiz, should face trial for his alleged role in leaking secret information to the media about a tax fraudster. In March 2024, Spanish media reported details of a plea deal which Alberto González Amador, boyfriend of the conservative president of the Madrid regional government Isabel Díaz Ayuso, had proposed to the general attorney's office. The tax office had found that González Amador had avoided paying about €350,000 from earnings made from importing healthcare material during the Covid-19 pandemic. READ MORE The media reports corrected a false claim made by Díaz Ayuso's team that the attorney general's office had been the one to offer a deal. The investigating judge, Ángel Luis Hurtado, has now accused the attorney general himself of being the source of the reports. According to the judge, the leak aimed 'to make clear that, according to [García Ortiz], the attorney general had not offered any deal of this kind'. Díaz Ayuso, a prominent figure on the right, has been a fierce critic of the government. If he does go on trial, which now looks likely, and were to be found guilty, García Ortiz could receive a jail sentence of up to four years. However, the most damaging allegation, as far as the government is concerned, was that the attorney general, who it proposed for the post, was acting on the orders of the prime minister's office. The left-wing coalition government has staunchly defended the attorney general and justice minister Félix Bolanos flatly denied the claim the government was involved in the leak. [ Catalan amnesty expected to get court blessing amid political turmoil Opens in new window ] 'I regret very much that the supreme court should make such a serious assertion without any evidence, because that never happened,' he said. However, the opposition says García Ortiz cannot remain in his post. 'The situation regarding the attorney general is unprecedented in our democracy, you must demand his resignation,' Alberto Núñez Feijóo, the leader of the conservative Popular Party (PP), told Sánchez in Congress on Wednesday. The opposition leader has cast this as the latest in a series of scandals to affect the government. Sánchez's wife, Begona Gómez, has been investigated for possible business irregularities and his musician brother, David, is due to go on trial for alleged influence peddling in being appointed to a public post. A former Socialist minister, José Luis Ábalos, is being investigated on suspicion of profiting from a kickback scheme when he was in government. Meanwhile, a former Socialist party official, Leire Díez, has been caught on tape offering favourable treatment to a businessman in exchange for incriminating information on the police unit carrying out investigations into several cases affecting the government. Many judicial experts have said the attorney general's position is untenable. However, a large number have also expressed concerns about the judge's investigation, pointing to an apparent lack of evidence against García Ortiz. Tensions between the government and the judiciary have been escalating since Sánchez's administration introduced an amnesty law for Catalan nationalists last year. Many on the left see the ongoing investigations as part of a campaign by magistrates with right-wing allegiances. Government spokeswoman Pilar Alegría said that 'at this point certain judges are doing things which are difficult to understand'. A recent poll by the national statistics institute found that 78 per cent of Spaniards do not trust the impartiality of their justice system in cases involving political parties.
