Did Terry Pratchett really write classics?

The news that Terry Pratchett's 2002 novel Night Watch has joined the ranks of the Penguin Modern Classics series may seem, to the Pratchett uninitiated, something of an eyebrow-raiser. Penguin has proudly announced that the book 'which draws on inspirations as far ranging as Victor Hugo and M*A*S*H, is… a profoundly empathetic novel about community, connection and the tenacity of the human spirit' and that it was 'written at the height of Pratchett's imaginative powers'. All this may very well be true. But many people, even those millions well disposed towards Pratchett, might be asking another question: why this book, and why now?
During his lifetime, Pratchett built on the legacy of another great British fantastical author, Douglas Adams, by creating his own universe, Discworld, in which many of his books are set. They have sold over 80 million copies, and even Pratchett's death in 2015 has done little to stem the enthusiasm. At one point, he was the most shoplifted author in Britain, so desperate were his teenaged admirers to get their hands on his stories. And his books have mostly remained books rather than being transformed into big-budget Hollywood spectacles. Pratchett once said that a film studio was interested but he was told to 'lose the Death angle', which would be tricky, given that Death is a major recurring character throughout the series.
I've always enjoyed the Pratchett books and consider him one of the more amiable and less self-consciously literary knighted authors that Britain has produced. The writer Imogen West-Knights summed up Pratchett's admirers as she searched for a description of a certain kind of Briton:
English, Terry Pratchett fan, sardonic humour, left wing-ish, leather jackets, maybe long hair, maybe folk music, Bill Bailey, real ale, usually middle age+. Warhammer adjacent. Likes swords but doesn't necessarily own one?
If I have any disagreement with his elevation to the ranks of the Penguin Modern Classics, then, it is less to do with Pratchett's own writing and more a sense of uncertainty as to what defines a modern classic. There is no stated definition on Penguin's website, and when I interviewed Henry Eliot, the former creative editor of Penguin Classics, a few years ago, he told me that: 'The Modern Classics series gathers the greatest books of more recent times, books that have challenged convention, changed the world or created something new. They are books that speak powerfully to the moment – and time will tell if they speak for more than that.'
I would argue that Night Watch, although a book loved by Pratchett's many fans, is hardly something that 'challenges convention' or has 'changed the world'. Pratchett created something new in his Discworld series, and the love that his admirers hold for his works is testament to their enduring success. Personally I was surprised that Penguin didn't opt to publish 1987's Mort, the first Discworld novel to feature Death and the one usually regarded as Pratchett's single greatest achievement, or simply to come out with the entire series of Discworld books in one go.
Pratchett was always a self-effacing figure and would probably have shrugged at the Classics label
There are many deep-pocketed admirers of the author who would have ordered the entire canon in this new edition, although I can imagine that the effort involved in putting together 40-something painstakingly annotated novels may have been exhausting. This Penguin Classics edition also includes a foreword by Pratchett's PA and biographer Rob Wilkins, and an introduction and annotated notes by two Terry-o-philes, Trinity College Dublin's Dr Darryl Jones and the University of South Australia's Dr David Lloyd.
Despite all that effort in making Night Watch appear to be a classic, even Pratchett would not have claimed that every one of the books was a masterpiece. Yet the nature of Penguin Modern Classics is that when they go all in on an author, they generally have to publish the entire works. Which means, for instance, that Evelyn Waugh's wildly unsuccessful Catholic fantasia Helena must be given the same serious literary treatment as the far more deserving A Handful of Dust.
If Night Watch is successful – and only a fool would think that it won't be – then presumably there will be more Discworld editions over the coming years. Pratchett was always a self-effacing figure and would probably have shrugged at the Classics label (although he was evangelical about the fantasy genre, which he argued was done down by snobbish literary critics).
Yet I can't help thinking that Penguin has done something similar to what the Folio Society has been doing over the past few years, and published a book that they know will cater to a fervent fanbase and sell in considerable quantities thanks to the added material. The question of literary excellence therefore becomes a secondary one. This is understandable – it's fine – but the brand is called Penguin Modern Classics, rather than Penguin Modern Notables. I am unconvinced that this particular instalment in the much-loved series lives up to its grandiose billing it.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Daily Mirror

8 minutes ago

• Daily Mirror

Brit 'devastated' after being kicked out of holiday hotspot for his face tattoos

Jordan Howman, 34, said his £3,000 holiday was ruined when he was pulled aside at Dubai Airport and had his passport confiscated before being sent back to the UK - for having face tattoos A Brit said he was left "devastated" after he was kicked out of Dubai and forced to ditch his dream £3,000 holiday because of his face tattoos. Jordan Howman, 34, landed at Dubai International Airport last Wednesday for a dream week-long holiday with his fiancée Theresa, 38, and daughter Kaic, 16, when immigration officers took him aside and ended up confiscating his passport. The 34-year-old plasterer, from Crewe, said he had "worked his ass off" to save up for the five day trip and had hoped to see the United Arab Emirates, which he called his "favourite country in the world". ‌ ‌ Jordan claimed that his dream holiday ended at the airport as after six hours of being held, immigration officers sent him packing "because of his face tattoos". The 34-year-old got the geometric cubes tattooed on his face around eight or nine years ago alongside words like 'blessed', 'family' and 'crazy life' and said it has never caused problems during his previous two visits to Dubai, he says. Jordan said: "My missus has been crying her eyes out. It has absolutely devastated me. I feel like I've been massively discriminated against. There's no law against face tattoos - there's nothing like that. "I'm a lovely lad, I get on with anyone. It's made me feel absolutely rubbish. I'm not allowed in a country because of the way I look. It's properly, massively affected me. It was my favourite country, but this has absolutely ruined it. Now I'll never go again. I've lost all of my money because of a pattern on my face." The UAE has become a popular spot for wealthy British expats and holidaymakers seeking sunshine but the emirates' strict social rules has proved to be a problem for many foreign visitors. ‌ Jordan's Emirates airline flight landed at Dubai International Airport on Wednesday, June 11, morning at 7.30am. He said: "It was my third trip to Dubai. I'd had no problems all the other times. But this time, as we got in, I scanned my passport and was just about to go through security when an airport worker pulled us aside. "We were about to put our hand luggage on the conveyor belt when the man said: 'Follow me'." After taking Mr Howman aside, the man allegedly asked if he'd had his passport stamped, before taking it from him. Jordan said: "Then he snatched my passport out of my hand. ‌ "There had been nowhere to stamp it - we'd used the electronic gates. It was just an excuse to get the passport out of my hand." After being held in a waiting room for over four hours, the Brit was transferred to immigration at around 12am, he said. By this time, his family had reached their five star Anantara hotel. He called his partner and she got a taxi to the airport but he said "they wouldn't let me see her" and she got a taxi back to the hotel, costing a total of £250. Jordan said he was not given his passport back for some time which was "terrifying". ‌ He said: "A woman came and took me upstairs to immigration, where they said: 'He's not coming in because of his face tattoos - you're not coming in because of the way you look.' One of the staff behind the desk said a more senior immigration officer made the decision, saying I was not to enter Dubai and that I must leave the country immediately." At 2.30pm, Mr Howman was put on another Emirates flight heading back to the UK. He said: "They sent me on a flight back to Manchester. It was only when I landed that I got my passport back. Friday morning was the first time I got to see my daughter, over Facetime." The General Directorate of Residency and Foreigners Affairs Dubai have been approached for comment. Dubai Airports was also contacted for comment.

Metro

35 minutes ago

• Metro

Amazon Prime quietly drops all episodes of 'brutal' drama with Game of Thrones s

Amazon Prime viewers can now watch a 'riotously fun' British dark comedy about survivalists. Released in 2020 on Sky One, Two Weeks to Live stars Maisie Williams, best known for playing Arya Stark in Game of Thrones from 2011 until 2019. In the six-part series she played 'strange young misfit' Kim, who was just a small child when her father died in mysterious circumstances. Soon after her mum Kim – played by Fleabag's Sian Clifford – whisked her away to a remote rural life of seclusion and bizarre survival techniques. After years cut off from the world, Kim decides to set back out and carry out a secret mission to honour her father's memory. But after meeting the socially awkward Nicky (Mawaan Rizwan) in a pub, the pair then face 'a chaotic series of events that puts their lives in danger' as they go on the run from murderous gangsters and the police with a massive bag of stolen cash. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video This week the series dropped on Amazon Prime, giving more people a chance to tune in. When the show was released, critics praised it as 'one of the best shows of the year' despite it largely going under the radar. 'One of 2020's best new shows, Two Weeks to Live leans into the witty humour of classic British comedies like Hot Fuzz and Brassic,' NME wrote in its review. 'With each episode gleefully upping the stakes, it's as if that doomsday clock actually is tock-ticking down to midnight. You'll be hooked into Two Weeks to Live like tinned tuna crammed into a nuclear bunker's storeroom,' SBS wrote. 'Two Weeks to Live is riotous fun, with a ton of heart and soul to boot, and after the year we've all had, it couldn't have arrived at a better time,' Digital Spy added. Fans said it was 'gripping', 'action packed with splashes of comedy', and an 'absolute gem of a show'. Speaking to Sky ahead of the show's initial release, Maisie explained the evolution of her character throughout the story. More Trending 'She's always felt really independent and very capable but emotionally, she's realising that being alone is going to be a big step for her and although she can probably handle herself physically, mentally she's facing huge battles every day,' she said. 'I knew it was always going to be very funny and the characters were very interesting, but we were very keen to make them real. I think you can write very funny people but not necessarily relate to that character in your own life so between myself, Taheen, Mawaan, and Sian we were very keen to route it back to something that is relatable,' she added. Two Weeks to Live also stars Taheen Modak, Jason Flemyng, Michael Begley, Thalissa Teixeira, Kerry Howard and Sean Knopp. View More » Two Weeks to Live is streaming on Amazon Prime Video. Got a story? If you've got a celebrity story, video or pictures get in touch with the entertainment team by emailing us celebtips@ calling 020 3615 2145 or by visiting our Submit Stuff page – we'd love to hear from you. MORE: All Neighbours spoilers for next week as legend resigns MORE: Where to stream Jaws in the UK for the iconic film's 50th anniversary MORE: 'One of the best horror films' is finally coming to Amazon Prime next week

Daily Mail​

38 minutes ago

• Daily Mail​

Relive Lauren Sanchez's shocking transformation from failed journalist to Mrs. Jeff Bezos

was once a budding TV star who was desperate to break into the industry after suffering from an undiagnosed learning disability for years and being turned away from her dream job at The View. Now, she's preparing to marry Amazon founder Jeff Bezos, one of the richest men on the planet, in a luxurious wedding in Venice, Italy, in front of Hollywood's biggest A-listers. So how did go from a struggling reporter to a starlet who mingles with Tinseltown's most elite? While her romance with Jeff certainly cemented her status, Lauren's rise to the top actually started long before they met. New Mexico-based Lauren, now 55, longed to be a successful newscaster from early on, but thanks to her struggle with dyslexia, she decided to give up on that dream and instead pursue a career in aviation after finishing high school. She moved to LA to apply for a job as a stewardess - but was left heartbroken when she was turned away and told she was 'too big' to be a flight attendant, despite only weighing 121 pounds. But a determined Lauren used her devastation as fuel, and when she turned her focus back to journalism after that, she quickly rose through the ranks. She started at a small news outlet in Phoenix, Arizona, before moving to Extra, followed by Fox Sports Net and Good Day LA. Thanks to her vivacious personality and flourishing job in the media, Lauren began slowly integrating herself into the celebrity world. Before meeting Jeff, she was romantically linked to a slew of other stars, including an actor, two famous athletes, and a top CEO of a major talent agency - but it was when her whirlwind affair with Jeff came to light in 2019 that she truly became the subject of the public's interest. It was revealed that they were dating while they were both married to other people, which ultimately led to them leaving their respective partners - and the scandalous start to their romance only propelled Lauren into mega-stardom even more. It's only natural that the world became fiercely fascinated with the woman who stole the heart of one of the richest men on the globe, especially since the couple was ultimately able to overcome the explosive cheating scandal and the accusations of blackmail and extortion that shrouded the start of their romance. After four years of lavish getaways, private jet rides, dinner dates at the most sought-after restaurants in the world, designer shopping trips, yacht rides, and invites to parties amongst the top stars, Jeff and Lauren became engaged in May 2023. As the couple gears up to walk down the aisle together and as Lauren continues to make waves in the media, FEMAIL went ahead and recapped her journey from start to finish - from her roller-coaster quest to find love, which included a failed marriage and multiple failed engagements, to her impressive takeover of Hollywood. Lauren's rise to the spotlight: After being told she was 'too big' to be a stewardess at age 18, she set out on becoming a journalist Lauren grew up in New Mexico, and dreamed of being a journalist from a young age - but because she suffered from undiagnosed dyslexia, she began to believe that she couldn't do it Lauren grew up in Albuquerque, New Mexico, and dreamed of being a journalist from a young age - but because she suffered from undiagnosed dyslexia throughout her childhood, she began to believe that she couldn't do it. Instead, she decided she wanted to become a flight attendant, and at age 18, after finishing high school, she moved to Los Angeles, California, where she applied for a job as a Southwest Airlines stewardess. However, the then-teenager, who weighed just over 120 pounds, told Wall Street Journal last year that she was forced to stand on a scale during the interview process - a standard practice for flight attendants at the time - and she ultimately didn't get the job because she was told she was too big. 'Back then, they weighed you, and I weighed 121 pounds. They said, 'You need to be 115,'' she recalled. Unsure of where to turn, a heartbroken Lauren decided to go to back to school, and enrolled at El Camino College in Torrance, California. It was there that she rediscovered her love for journalism after a teacher encouraged her to get tested for a learning disability and she finally realized that she was suffering from dyslexia. '[The teacher said], 'You're not dumb. You're just dyslexic. Let me give you tools on how to write,'' she explained, adding that the professor gifted her a pocket dictionary to keep with her at all times. 'It changed my life. I went from barely a 2.0 student to the dean's list and got a scholarship to USC.' Lauren transferred to University of Southern California in 1992, which she attended for two years while working as a desk assistant at the LA-based news company KCOP-TV. In 1994, she left to school to pursue her career as a reporter full time after she was offered a job at KTVK in Phoenix, Arizona. In the years that followed, she moved around quite a bit - working briefly for Extra before heading to Fox Sports Net. Around that time, she also auditioned for a seat on The View - and when she didn't get the part, she admitted it was one of the 'most devastating days of her life.' She said she had bonded with creator Barbara during the audition process, who personally called her up herself to deliver the sad news herself, which resulted in her crying 'for days.' The position was ultimately given to Lisa Ling. But according to Lauren, the advice that Barbara gave her throughout the process was something that stuck with her for years. 'She really helped me with my career. Not only as someone I looked up to, but really guided me when I was up for The View,' she revealed to WSJ. 'Producers were trying to make me dress extra conservative and she saw me and said, 'What happened?' 'She said, 'They will try and make you ordinary. Don't let them. Then, if you fail, at least you fail as yourself.' I never forgot that.' Around that time, she also auditioned for a seat on The View - and when she didn't get the part, she admitted it was one of the 'most devastating day of her life.' She is seen in 1999 Lauren went on to host Good Day LA for six years before starting her own aerial film and production company called Black Ops Aviation. She is seen on Good Day LA in 2011 Lauren then went on to host Good Day LA for six years before starting her own aerial film and production company called Black Ops Aviation. She also served as the host on the first season of So You Think You Can Dance, and contributed to Larry King Live, The Joy Behar Show, and Showbiz Tonight over the years. As for what she does now, she focuses much of her time on philanthropy, and serves as the vice chair of the Bezos Earth Fund - an organization started by her beau which is dedicated to 'fighting climate change and protecting nature.' She also recently released her first children's book called Flynn, The Fly Who Flew, and launched a production company called Adventure & Fellowship. In addition, she got her helicopter pilot's license in 2016, and has a fierce passion for flying - something she once referred to as her 'calling.' Her roller-coaster journey to finding love: Lauren went through a failed marriage and multiple failed engagements before meeting Jeff Before meeting Jeff, Lauren had a roller-coaster quest to find love, filled with a divorce and multiple failed engagements. And her list of exes has a slew of star-studded names, including an actor, famous athlete, and the head of a massive talent agency. Her first boyfriend was sports broadcaster Rory Markas, who she met when she landed an internship at a Los Angeles TV station during college. The two even got engaged, but according to Page Six, she ultimately dumped Rory after she switched jobs. She then started dating NFL star Anthony Miller, after the two met at the 1996 Super Bowl when he was playing for the Denver Broncos and she was a rising TV reporter. The pair were together for four years and engaged for one and a half before Anthony claimed that Lauren broke things off. He spoke about their romance - as well as their split - exclusively to back in January 2019, and he alleged that Lauren cheated on him. 'I couldn't really trust her,' he claimed. 'She gets around. She was cheating on me with other guys. 'I found out when I looked in her diary, and I found out more after I broke up with her.' He also called Lauren 'frugal' and 'really cheap,' adding: 'She wanted me to pay for everything. 'She was making good money back then, reporting for Extra and on Fox Sports News, but she didn't like paying.' However, sources close to Lauren disputed Anthony's claims, insisting to that it was him who was unfaithful. Those insiders also called the athlete an 'opportunist' for speaking out about the relationship two decades later, right after Lauren's affair with Jeff was revealed. After she and Anthony went their separate ways, Lauren started a relationship with footballer Tony Gonzalez. They welcomed a son, named Nikko Gonzalez, together in 2002 before splitting. After that, she was reportedly linked to actor Henry Simmons, but very little is known about their romance. Lauren then entered into a relationship with Hollywood agent and Endeavor talent agency cofounder Patrick Whitesell. The two walked down the aisle together in 2005, and together, they had a son, named Evan Whitesell, in 2006 and a daughter, named Eleanor Whitesell, in 2008. They were together for more than a decade up until her affair with Jeff was brought to light in early 2019. Lauren and Jeff's whirlwind affair: The couple's romance shrouded in accusations of blackmail and extortion at first While it's unclear when exactly they started dating, Lauren and Jeff's romance was first exposed by the National Enquirer in January 2019, while they were both married to their now-exes. Soon after it was revealed, the billionaire businessman divorced his wife of more than 25 years and the mother of his four children, Mackenzie Scott, while Lauren left her husband, Patrick. At the time, the bombshell report from the Enquirer claimed that Lauren and Jeff had been involved in an eight-month affair, which involved him 'whisking his mistress off to exotic destinations on his $65 million private jet, sending her raunchy messages and erotic selfies, and having secret rendezvous at palatial private estates.' The outlet said that it had tracked them 'across five states and 40,000 miles, tailing them in private jets, swanky limos, helicopter rides, romantic hikes, five-star hotel hideaways, intimate dinner dates and 'quality time' in hidden love nests.' Following the Enquirer's accusations, Jeff fired back by writing a lengthy essay to the publication's CEO, David Pecker, in which the mogul accused the company of blackmailing him. 'Rather than capitulate to extortion and blackmail, I've decided to publish exactly what they sent me, despite the personal cost and embarrassment they threaten,' he wrote. '[After] intimate texts messages from me were published in the National Enquirer, I engaged investigators to learn how those texts were obtained, and to determine the motives for the many unusual actions taken by the Enquirer. 'We were then approached with an offer. They said they had more of my text messages and photos that they would publish if we didn't stop our investigation.' He shared alleged emails sent to him by Enquirer staffers, in which they described the racy images they had 'obtained during their newsgathering' in detail. As for how Jeff and Lauren met, it was said that it was Lauren's husband Patrick introduced the two at an Amazon studios party for the movie Manchester By The Sea in 2016 (seen) 'If in my position I can't stand up to this kind of extortion, how many people can?' Jeff continued. 'Of course I don't want personal photos published, but I also won't participate in their well-known practice of blackmail, political favors, political attacks, and corruption. I prefer to stand up, roll this log over, and see what crawls out.' As for how Jeff and Lauren met, it was said that it was Lauren's husband Patrick who was the first to introduce the two at an Amazon studios party for the movie Manchester By the Sea in 2016. Her production team was then hired to film footage for Jeff's rocket company, Blue Origin, in 2018. 'Patrick and Lauren have socialized with Jeff Bezos and his wife for a few years, because both [former] couples have houses in Seattle,' a source told Page Six after their affair was brought to light. 'Then Lauren was hired to work on one of Jeff's projects, Blue Origin, a space-launch company. She has been shooting aerial shots for Jeff.' Cementing herself as a Hollywood star: Lauren has jetted off on a slew of lavish getaways and racked up tons of A-list friends Despite the start of their romance being shrouded in accusations of blackmail and extortion, cheating allegations, and an explosive affair, the couple did not let it defer them. In fact, after splitting from their respective partners, Jeff and Lauren didn't wait long to start flaunting their love all over the globe. They were seen for the first time together publicly in May 2019, when photographers caught them enjoying a romantic date night in New York City, and they made their first official appearance as a couple at Wimbledon that July. Since then, the couple has not tried to hide their romance, and for the last five years, they have continuously jetted off on a slew of lavish getaways together, shared tons of adorable, PDA-filled photos together on social media, gushed over one another nonstop in interviews, and attended a slew of star-studded events side by side. And dating one of the richest men in the world certainly comes with a slew of perks - like dining in top restaurants, hanging out with A-listers, getting VIP treatment wherever they go, and vacationing in some of the most sought after spots on the globe. Lauren has also been expanding her wardrobe since her romance with Jeff began, and the TV personality is now often seen toting around designer handbags and donning exquisite jewelry pieces that are worth hundreds of thousands of dollars. In addition, she's racked up tons of celebrity friends over the course of her and Jeff's five-year romance. Jeff popped the question to Lauren back in May 2023 after a romantic dinner under the stars on his mega-yacht. Lauren opened up about his proposal to Vogue during her and Jeff's joint interview, revealing that she 'blacked out' when she first saw the huge diamond ring. She told the publication that Jeff had concealed the piece of jewelry under her pillow, which she discovered at the end of the evening just before they went to bed. It's believed Lauren and Jeff's Venetian wedding will take place across three days between June 24 and 26. There will be 200 people at the wedding of the year, Mayor of Venice Luigi Brugnaro confirmed in a statement. According to insiders, the couple have snagged Elton John and Lady Gaga to perform and could say their 'I dos' on an island in an open-air theater. The billionaire, his bride and their guests have reportedly already booked rooms at the best hotels, including The Aman Venice, the Belmond Hotel Cipriani, the St. Regis Venice, and the Gritti Palace. Lauren and Jeff reportedly booked a suite that goes for $11,500 a night at The Aman Venice.