Stalin targets Centre over Presidential reference, calls for united legal fight to defend Constitution

Tamil Nadu Chief Minister M K Stalin on Thursday sharply criticised the Union government over the Presidential reference seeking the Supreme Court's opinion on the Governors' powers over state Bills, calling it a 'desperate attempt to weaken democratically elected state Governments'.
Left parties, too, have criticised the move.
In a strongly worded statement, Stalin described the Presidential Reference under Article 143 as an assault on the Constitution and a direct challenge to the Supreme Court's authority.
'I strongly condemn the Union Government's Presidential reference, which attempts to subvert the Constitutional position already settled by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the Tamil Nadu Governor's case and other precedents,' he said in a post on X.
The DMK, which has been locked in multiple tussles with Governor R N Ravi over pending Bills, had earlier hailed the top court's ruling on deadlines for Governors as a landmark victory for states' rights. Stalin's latest statement appears to reopen that battle.
'This attempt clearly exposes the fact that the Tamil Nadu Governor acted at the BJP's behest to undermine the people's mandate,' Stalin said, accusing the Centre of seeking to paralyse Opposition-led legislatures through gubernatorial overreach.
The Presidential Reference comes weeks after the top court held that Governors must act within a reasonable time when a Bill is presented. The President has now sought the court's opinion on whether Governors and President are justiciable and whether timelines can be imposed on them in the absence of any such provision in the Constitution.
In a post on X, CPI(M) general secretary M A Baby quoted Stalin's post and said his party is opposed to the move. 'The governors are acting at the behest of the ruling party BJP and obstructing the functioning of opposition-led state govts. They are violating the federal principles enshrined in our Constitution. All the non-BJP state govts should condemn this move and join together in the fight against centralisation of powers at the cost of states' rights,' he said.
CPI general secretary D Raja too criticised the Presidential reference, posting on X: 'The judgment came in response to repeated, undemocratic delays by governors in opposition-ruled states like Tamil Nadu and Kerala — where the British Raj relic of governor's office is being weaponised to block the will of the people.'
Stalin, meanwhile, warned of broader implications for federalism, saying: 'This directly challenges the majesty of law and the authority of the Supreme Court as the final interpreter of the Constitution.'
He posed pointed questions to the Centre: 'Why should there be any objection to prescribing time limits for Governors to act? Is the BJP seeking to legitimise its Governors' obstruction by allowing indefinite delays in Bill assent? Does the Union Government intend to paralyse non-BJP State Legislatures?'
Calling the development a 'grave circumstance,' Stalin asserted that the move revealed 'the BJP-led Union Government's sinister intent to distort the Constitution's basic distribution of powers and incapacitate the State Legislatures dominated by opposition parties.' He said this posed 'a clear exigent threat to State autonomy.'
Stalin urged leaders of all non-BJP ruled states to stand united in a legal battle to uphold the federal spirit of the Constitution. 'In these grave circumstances, I urge all non-BJP states and party leaders to join this legal struggle to defend the #Constitution,' he said. 'We will fight this battle with all our might. Tamil Nadu will fight — and #TamilNadu will win!'

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Hindustan Times

12 minutes ago

• Hindustan Times

Kerala to include lesson on Governor's powers in school syllabus

Amid growing friction between the Kerala government and Raj Bhavan, state general education minister V Sivankutty said a lesson on the constitutional powers and duties of Governors would soon be a part of the school curriculum. In Kerala, the office of Governor Rajendra Arlekar, who took charge in January and who was seen to initially enjoy cordial relations with chief minister Pinarayi Vijayan(PTI) The announcement came just a day after Sivankutty walked out of an event at the Raj Bhavan in Thiruvananthapuram protesting against the display of a portrait of 'Bharat Mata', associated with the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), on the dais. Speaking to reporters on Friday, Sivankutty said that the lesson explaining the constitutional rights and duties of Governors in India would be included in the second volume of social science textbooks for class 10 students this year. The chapter will be added to textbooks for students of classes 11 and 12 as part of curriculum revision as well, he added. 'Schools are the ideal place to learn the values of democracy. School curriculum is being revised while upholding constitutional values. In the country today, efforts to destabilise elected state governments through governors are rising. The Supreme Court has recently made it clear what the constitutional rights of governors are,' the minister said. His reference was to the Supreme Court's ruling on April 8 that set a timeline for Governors to clear state bills or refer them to the President. It also set a timeline for the President to clear them. The President has sought a Presidential Reference on the judgement. The court's ruling came after the state of Tamil Nadu approached it citing the alleged obstructionist behaviour of Governor R N Ravi. Several states governed by parties opposed to the Bharatiya Janata Party have seen clashes between the elected government and the Governor, whose powers are limited under the Constitution. When asked if the decision had anything to do with the ongoing row with the Raj Bhavan over the use of the 'Bharat Mata' portrait, the minister replied, 'I strongly feel students must learn and understand the duties of governors. That's why we have decided to include the chapter. It is a part of constitution. It is true that governors are interfering a lot. Students must be taught the right things.' In Kerala, the office of Governor Rajendra Arlekar, who took charge in January and who was seen to initially enjoy cordial relations with chief minister Pinarayi Vijayan -- especially when compared to the former Governor Arif Mohammed Khan -- has been locked in a tussle with the LDF government over the usage of a portrait of 'Bharat Mata' , showing a woman holding a saffron flag astride a lion at official events. The CM and ministers of the state government have argued that the portrait is associated with the RSS, the ideological fount of the BJP, and its display at official government events is inappropriate and violative of secular values. On Thursday, Sivankutty walked out in the middle of an event at the Raj Bhavan to honour scouts and guides after objecting to the display of the portrait. Later, he argued that Indian nationalism draws its strength from its diversity of languages, religions, regions, cultures etc. None of these can be contained within a narrow or unified image, he said. 'Calling the image of a woman carrying a saffron flag the sole symbol of Indian patriotism ignores this basic reality,' he added. Raj Bhavan issued a statement claiming that the minister's 'staged walkout' was a 'gross violation of protocol and a grave insult to the office of the Governor'. The Governor also said that there was 'no question of doing away with Bharat Mata as we draw our idea of patriotism and nationhood' from it. The office of the Governor said the minister's actions set a wrong precedent and that it viewed the developments with utmost concern. The row also spilled out onto the streets of Thiruvananthapuram with the SFI, student wing of CPI(M), taking a protest march to Raj Bhavan. In response, ABVP, the student wing of the RSS, displayed black flags as a convoy of the general education minister passed by.

Indian Express

40 minutes ago

• Indian Express

English empowering, tool to break chains… should be taught to every child: Rahul Gandhi

Lok Sabha Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi on Friday said the English language is 'not shameful, it's empowering', but the BJP-RSS don't want poor children to learn English because they don't want them to ask questions, move ahead and become equal. 'English is not a dam, it is a bridge. English is not shameful, it is empowering. English is not a chain — it is a tool to break the chains,' said the Congress leader on X. Gandhi was reacting to Union Home Minister Amit Shah's statement that soon a time would come when those speaking English in the country would 'feel ashamed'. On Thursday, Shah, speaking at the launch of Main Boond Swayam, Khud Sagar Hoon, authored by IAS officer Ashutosh Agnihotri, said: 'In our lifetime, we will see a society in which those speaking English will feel ashamed, that day is not far … I believe that the languages of our country are the ornament of our culture. Without them, we would not have been Bharatiya. Our country, its history, its culture, our Dharma, if these have to be understood, it cannot be done in foreign languages.' In his X post, Gandhi said, 'The BJP-RSS don't want poor kids of India to learn English because they don't want you to ask questions, move ahead, and attain equality.' He said in today's world, English is as important as one's mother tongue because it helps in securing employment and boost one's confidence. 'Every language of India has soul, culture, knowledge. We have to cherish them — and at the same time teach English to every child. This is the path to an India that competes with the world, that gives every child an equal opportunity,' said Gandhi. TMC MP Derek O'Brien also weighed in. In a video statement, he said, 'In India, 97% people use one of the 22 constitutionally recognised languages as their mother tongue. 19,500 languages and dialects are used as mother tongues. This is the 'unity in diversity' of our great nation. Amit Shah, PM Narendra Modi and gang will never understand this.' Another TMC Rajya Sabha member, Sagarika Ghose, said Indians should not be ashamed of any language. 'English is a link language across India, it's aspirational, confers a global advantage and knowledge of English is demanded by millions. Indians should not be 'ashamed' of any language,' she said.

Indian Express

40 minutes ago

• Indian Express

Sukanta, doctor who asked question during CM's lecture ‘detained'

STATE BJP president Sukanta Majumdar and a London-based doctor, Rajatshubhra Bandyopadhyay, were both detained by the city police amid a roadside conversation in south Kolkata's Bhabanipur area on Friday. Although they were both released around three hours later, the incident led to protests by BJP workers and a political firestorm. The BJP claimed that around 25 of its workers were also arrested and released nearly hours later. The drama unfolded as Majumdar, who is also a Union minister of state, arrived in Bhabanipur on a motorcycle to observe 'Paschimbanga Dibas' (West Bengal Day), defying police restrictions. After garlanding a statue of Syama Prasad Mookerjee, he went to meet Bandyopadhyay at his residence on Harish Mukherjee Road. Police intercepted Majumdar's convoy, initially claiming that the doctor was not present at home. However, a video later released by the BJP on social media purportedly showed Bandyopadhyay at his residence, prompting protests from party supporters. They accused the police of misleading them and alleged that the state government was 'weaponising the police' to stifle political expression. Amid the standoff, Bandyopadhyay stepped out of the premises of his home to meet Majumdar on the street. The doctor recently garnered attention for publicly questioning Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee during her lecture in London, a video of which had been widely shared online. Their conversation was cut short and both Majumdar and Bandyopadhyay were escorted into police vehicles and taken to the city police headquarters at Lalbazar. 'For what reason have we been detained? I have no clue,' Majumdar told mediapersons as he was led into the van. 'Even a visit to a doctor's house has now become a crime?' a BJP worker questioned. The ruling Trinamool Congress defended the police's actions. 'The BJP is creating provocations. The doctor in question has a track record of inciting controversy. The police acted in accordance with the law to maintain peace in a sensitive locality,' said TMC spokesperson Kunal Ghosh.