Public Protector uncovers serious procurement irregularities in Lesseyton Sports Facility
Public Protector finds procurement irregularities in the construction of Lesseyton Sports Facility in Enoch Mgijima Municipality.
Image: Supplied
Public Protector Advocate Kholeka Gcaleka has found that there was mismanagement in the construction of the R22.7 million Lesseyton Sports Facility in the Enoch Mgijima Local Municipality.
The investigation was launched after complaints were laid with the Public Protector's office in Bisho, Eastern Cape, to probe the alleged procurement irregularities relating to the construction of the sports field.
The venue, also known as Ndlovukazi Sports Stadium, was unveiled in October 2021.
The stadium sparked outrage, with many questioning its exorbitant price tag.
Pictures posted on social media showed a dry, bumpy field, small metal stands, soccer, and rugby uprights. It also has no working ablution facilities or electricity.
This sparked investigations from the Public Protector and the Department of Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs (Cogta), which also found that the awarding of the tender was irregular.
The Cogta investigation also found that the people involved were able to change the scopes of work without following due process.
The contract was awarded to a Pretoria-based company, Thalami Civils Pty Ltd.
Presenting the report in the Bisho office, Gcaleka said allegations that there were procurement irregularities in the awarding of the tender to Thalami have been substantiated.
She said the awarding of the tender exceeded R18.7m budget, which was approved by Cogta during the 2017/18 financial year, adding that this exceeded the budget by over R4.7m.
'And there is no evidence that the municipality approached the municipal council for additional funding as required by Section 19(1) of the Municipal Finance Management Act (MFMA),' she said.
Enoch Mgijima's spokesperson, Lonwabo Kowa, did not respond at the time of publication.
Gcaleka added that the tender advertisement had two different closing dates and was not placed in three different public platforms as required by regulation 22(1)(a) of the Municipal Supply Chain Management Policy.
She added that the tender advertisement period was shortened from 30 days to 14 days.
'The reason provided was that the construction of the Lesseyton Sports facility was an emergency. The municipality's definition of emergency in this regard is found not to be in line with the definition in terms of Regulation 22 (2) of the Municipal Supply Chain Management Policy,' Gcaleka said.
She said the evidence suggested that two bid evaluation processes took place.
According to her, the first process resulted in a different service provider being the preferred bidder, and the second process utilised a different formula provided by the Bid Evaluation Committee (BEC), and this resulted in the appointment of Thalami Civils, which was the fourth highest bidder to win the tender.
'The reasons advanced by the municipality for awarding the tender to the bidder were that the bidder had recently received the tender for a similar magnitude. The reason provided by the BEC did not amount to a quote objective criterion and was not supported by any legal original authority,' she said, adding that this reason was not part of the evaluation criteria in terms of the specification determined by the BEC.
'Thalami was, therefore, appointed in contravention of Section 2(1)(e) and (f) of the PPPFA, which provides that contracts must be awarded to the tenderer who scores the highest points unless objective criteria justifying the award to another tenderer,' said Gcaleka, adding that the allegation that there were irregularities in the management of the contract and a lack of proper oversight on the sports field construction was also substantiated.
The office also found that after the construction was suspended, Thalami, which was paid R15m, was reappointed and proceeded without a valid contract.
Gcaleka recommended that Cogta should take action officials involved.
The article will be updated when Enoch Mgijima Municipality comments.
[email protected]
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
6 hours ago
- The Citizen
Aserie Ndlovu murder case postponed as fifth suspect joins
The murder case was postponed after the newly-arrested fifth suspect opted to appoint a private lawyer. Pretoria-based journalist Aserie Ndlovu and his partner Zodwa Mdluli were reported missing since February 2025. Picture: Facebook/Sbusiso Aserie Ndlovu The case of the five men charged in connection with the disappearance and murder of journalist Aserie Ndlovu and his partner, Zodwa Mdluli, has been postponed to 4 July. The case was postponed to allow the fifth suspect, Thabang Isaac Hlophe, to secure legal representation after joining the other four. Father Samuel Mogowe, Lucky Sikhosana, David Madisha, and Sello Skhalo Uoane previously abandoned their bail applications. Court appearance for formal joinder The five accused, who appeared in the KwaMhlanga Magistrate's Court in Mpumalanga on Friday, are facing two counts of kidnapping and murder each. National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) regional spokesperson Monica Nyuswa said Friday's court appearance was for the formal joinder of Hlophe to the matter and a possible bail application on his behalf. 'However, the application did not proceed as Hlophe opted to appoint a private attorney to represent him,' Nyuswa said. All suspects have been remanded in custody. 'The [NPA] condemns acts of violent crime and remains resolute in pursuing justice for victims,' Nyuswa said. ALSO READ: Kidnapping victim saved after screaming from moving car on N1 Ndlovu and Mdluli reported missing Ndlovu and Mdluli were last seen on 18 February and were reported missing shortly after their disappearance. The accused were arrested on different occasions during a police intelligence-driven operation. The first suspect arrested was the last to be in the company of the missing couple. 'The second, third and fourth suspects that have been arrested were found with different vehicle parts believed to be those of the missing journalist,' police spokesperson Brigadier Athlenda Mathe said shortly after the arrests. 'One of those arrested is said to be a mechanic who builds and fixes cars in the KwaMhlanga area. Two VW Citi Golfs that were found in possession of the suspects have been seized,' Mathe added. Remains and DNA confirmation Skeletal remains with gunshot wounds, believed to be of the missing couple, were discovered in Rust de Winter along the Limpopo-Gauteng border in May after the suspects identified the location. Earlier this month, police confirmed that DNA analysis positively linked the remains to Ndlovu and Mdluli. 'The human remains were analysed and matched with the reference sample of the biological relatives of the deceased. A positive DNA match thus confirms that the discovered remains are those of the missing couple,' Mathe said at the time. NOW READ: 'Gruesome discovery': Missing teen girl found dead inside shack as stepfather linked to murder
The Citizen
11 hours ago
- The Citizen
Simelane and Dixon to continue careers with the Stormers
Simelane has extended his contract, while Dixon's contractual dispute has also been resolved. Exciting centre prospect Wandisile Simelane has signed a contract extension with the Stormers, while Springbok loose forward Ben-Jason Dixon's contractual dispute with the Western Province Rugby Union has been resolved. Simelane, who joined the Cape-based team from the Lions in the early part of last year, will continue to play for the Stormers for the foreseeable future after impressing in the midfield during this last season's United Rugby Championship campaign. 'Looking forward to seeing where this team can go' Director of Rugby at the Stormers, John Dobson, said he was looking forward to seeing Simelane continue to grow and develop in the Cape. 'Wandi has got incredible natural talent which has marked him as a dangerous player from a young age. What we have been particularly impressed with is his willingness to learn and develop his game,' Dobson said. 'He has an incredibly high ceiling and we are looking forward to seeing what he can do and add to our team going forward.' Simelane said that the decision to extend his contract was an easy one given the unique environment in Cape Town. 'At the Stormers, players are encouraged to express themselves and make the most of their abilities. 'I feel that I have grown as a player since moving here and I'm looking forward to seeing where this team can go,' he said. Ben-Jason Dixon, centre, will continue to play for the Stormers. Picture: Gallo Images Dixon matter resolved Dixon meanwhile will continue to play for the Stormers until the end of the 2027 season following the end of an arbitration process this week. Dixon sought arbitration to resolve a particular clause in his contract, which runs until June 2027. The independent process found Dixon's contract is binding, with no revisions applicable. Dixon said that with the matter now resolved, he is looking forward to making an impact on the field once again. The loose forward made his Springbok debut last season, but has suffered a few setbacks this year due to injuries. 'I'm really grateful that both sides had the chance to bring everything to the table through arbitration and get clarity going forward. With this behind us, I'm looking forward to getting back to doing what I love … giving my best for the Stormers.'
The South African
12 hours ago
- The South African
Hollywoodbets Durban July: And then there were 27
The race for the coveted Hollywoodbets Durban July 2025 title has taken a dramatic turn with the withdrawal of SA Derby winner Legend Of Arthur, leaving only 27 contenders still in the hunt for a spot in the R5 million Grade 1 event at Hollywoodbets Greyville on Saturday, 6 July. The final field will comprise a maximum of 18 runners plus two reserves. Legend Of Arthur, trained by Sean Tarry and previously seen as a strong Durban July hopeful, was scratched due to a medical issue. The three-year-old was set to be the backup ride for champion South African jockey Richard Fourie. This latest development leaves Tarry, a two-time Durban July-winning trainer (with Pomodoro in 2012 and Heavy Metal in 2013), with just one possible runner in the shape of Litigation. All eyes are now on Justin Snaith's highly regarded colt Eight On Eighteen, whose participation remains uncertain. Conflicting reports have circulated in recent days regarding his fitness and intended entry. Monday, 23 June : Final declarations deadline : Final declarations deadline Tuesday, 24 June at 11:00 : Final field announcement and barrier draw live on Gallop TV : Final field announcement and Thursday, 26 June at 07:00 : Public gallops for KwaZulu-Natal-based horses at Hollywoodbets Greyville Gates open at 06:30 Free coffee and pastries available for attendees : for KwaZulu-Natal-based horses at As the excitement builds, racing fans are bracing for what promises to be another thrilling edition of South Africa's most iconic horse race. Horses remaining in contention for Hollywoodbets Durban July Horse MR Trainer Future Swing 117 Justin Snaith Immediate Edge 108 Mike / Mathew de Kock Purple Pitcher 122 Robyn Klaasen Rainbow Lorikeet 111 Candice Bass-Robinson Underworld 109 Justin Snaith Son Of Raj 119 Tony Peter The Equator (IRE) 110 Tony Peter Atticus Finch 121 Alec Laird Madison Valley 115 Frank Robinson Eight On Eighteen 129 Justin Snaith On My Honour 116 Glen Kotzen Magic Verse 113 Justin Snaith Selukwe 111 Andre Nel Confederate 118 Fabian Habib Royal Victory 125 Nathan Kotzen Beating Wings 113 Stuart Pettigrew Okavango 120 Justin Snaith Gladatorian 127 Stuart Ferrie Litigation 113 Sean Tarry Oriental Charm 127 James Crawford Pomodoro's Jet 118 James Crawford Holding Thumbs 107 Glen Kotzen Thunee Playa 104 Mano Pandaram See It Again 127 Michael Roberts Native Ruler 119 Justin Snaith My Best Shot 116 Alan Greeff The Real Prince 120 Dean Kannemeyer Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
