HC restores ‘protected forest' status of 120 hectares of Kanjurmarg dumping site
In a setback to Maharashtra government and the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC), the Bombay High Court on Friday restored the status of nearly 120 hectares of Kanjurmarg dumping ground site as a protected forest area under Forest Conservation Act (FCA) and the Forest Act.
It quashed and set aside the 2009 decision that de-notified the 'protected forest' status of the said land for creation of dumping ground.
The court said that any proposal to de-notify the same would need to be complied with the due process prescribed under the FCA. It granted three months' time to BMC, which runs the dumping site, to 'comply with consequences of the HC judgment.'
After the government lawyer sought stay on the operation of the HC verdict, the court said the request need not be considered as a three-month time was given to BMC to comply with the order.
A bench of Justices Girish S Kulkarni and Somasekhar Sundaresan passed a verdict on a plea by NGO Vanashakti filed in 2013 which claimed the Kanjurmarg landfill falls under Coastal Regulation Zone (CRZ) and causes health hazards. The HC order is likely to be challenged in the Supreme Court.
The NGO had challenged the denotification of 119. 91 hectares of land located in Kanjurmarg on the coast of Thane Creek for dumping ground/landfill of nearly 141.77 hectares created by BMC, which was earlier classified as 'protected forest'.
The HC noted that the subject land was salt pan land and over the time witnessed growth of mangroves. It added that the lease for such land for production of salt expired around 2003 and thereafter, under the Coastal Regulation Zone (CRZ) Regulations and the Environment Protection Act, 1986, it was notified and classified as CRZ-1 area.
Senior advocate Gayatri Singh for Vanashakti contended that through impugned notification of December 29, 2009 issued by Divisional Commissioner, Konkan, the status of 'protected forest' has been modified without complying with due process stipulated under the FCA and same should be quashed.
However, Advocate General Birendra Saraf for state government argued that the land in question is only marginally covered by mangroves, which are in two patches and are restricted to 20.76 hectares, as noticed in the report filed by Maharashtra Coastal Zone Management Authority (MCZMA) and nothing in the rest of the area constituted as 'protected forest.'
Saraf added that taking note of the MCZMA report, another bench of HC in May 2013 had directed that no further mangroves must be destroyed and had directed the BMC to ensure compliance with MCZMA recommendations.
The state government said that the two patches in mangroves were excluded from the Kanjurmarg dumping ground. The government and BMC also argued that the impugned decision merely corrected an error in the Forest Notification.
After perusing submissions, the bench observed that 'the subject land was clearly the land covered by the mangroves.'
It noted that the HC in an order on an earlier PIL had explicitly declared a law that 'land covered by mangroves is automatically CRZ-1 land and indeed falls in the category of protected forest,' and 'prohibited dumping of garbage on mangroves.'
'The state had to conduct detailed satellite imaging of actual mangrove growth and coverage before it issued the Forest Notification,' the bench observed.
'The subject land, which indeed is salt pan land, attracts growth of mangroves and it is the violative construction of the wall by MCGM that led to mangroves being stunted and destroyed,' the bench held.
It added that earlier Forest Notification was a 'product of actual verification of facts, satellite imaging and ground truthing and indeed an outcome of due process of law.'
The court further held the impugned decision of 2009 was 'unsustainable' and that the Supreme Court order 'does not give cover to the argument that the Forest Notification was a mistake,' therefore it 'deserved to be quashed and set aside.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
8 hours ago
- Time of India
Find yoga centres on WhatsApp now
Mumbai: The BMC has launched a WhatsApp chatbot service to provide information about yoga centers to Mumbaikars, on the occasion of the International Yoga Day . By sending a message to 8999228999, residents can receive updated and detailed information about nearby Shiva Yoga Centers. tnn
News18
11 hours ago
- News18
Mumbai Water Alert: Andheri, Vile Parle Residents To Be Impacted From Tomorrow Till...
The BMC announced that the Metro-7A construction work will affect water supply in parts of K-ward from tomorrow till next weekend. Residents in parts of Mumbai's Vile Parle (East) and areas between Andheri station and the Western Express Highway are set to face low water pressure for a week. The affected localities include Old Nagardas Marg, New Nagardas Marg, Mograpada, and Andheri-Kurla Marg, with the disruption scheduled from Sunday, June 22, to Saturday, June 28. The week-long issue is linked to ongoing maintenance work and may impact daily routines in these neighbourhoods. On June 20, the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) issued an advisory about a temporary disruption in water supply. Parts of the K-East Ward will be affected over the coming week due to ongoing construction work for the Metro-7A project. As a result, residents in the affected areas can expect low water pressure during this period. In its advisory, the civic body has advised citizens to store adequate water in advance and to use it sparingly to avoid inconvenience. The BMC, in a statement quoted by Mid-Day, explained that the ongoing work is part of the Mumbai Metro-7A project. The BMC clarified that the ongoing low water pressure in parts of K-East Ward is due to excavation work under the Metro-7A project. As per the statement, a tunnel-boring machine will dig beneath an active 1,800 mm water canal near Bamanwada, Andheri (East). 'Under the Mumbai Metro-7A project, the Mumbai Metropolitan Region Development Authority will be excavating under the operational 1,800-mm diameter corporation canal of Veravali reservoir (24×7), near Bamanwada in Andheri (East), in the K-East Ward through a tunnel-boring machine," BMC said in a statement as quoted by Mid-Day. – In Vile Parle (East), residents will experience low water pressure between 5:00 PM and 8:00 PM daily throughout the affected week. – Meanwhile, areas such as Old Nagardas Marg, New Nagardas Marg, Mograpada, and Andheri-Kurla Marg—specifically the stretch from Andheri Station to the Western Express Highway—will receive water at low pressure between 8:00 PM and 9:30 PM. Residents in these zones are advised to plan their water usage accordingly and store water in advance to avoid disruptions to daily routines. First Published:
Hindustan Times
a day ago
- Hindustan Times
First mangrove parks to come up at Airoli, Ghansoli
NAVI MUMBAI: Eco-tourism will get a boost in Navi Mumbai with the city's first mangrove parks set to come up in Airoli and Ghansoli. The Maharashtra forest department has appointed a consultant for conceptual design and planning services for the development of the parks, following a tender process. Mumbai, India - March 24, 2015: A stretch of mangrooves, fenced and now accolated to builders, now under the new development plan, near Juhu-Versova Link road, at Andheri, in Mumbai, India, on Tuesday, March 24, 2015. (Photo by Vidya Subramanian/ Hindustan Times) (Hindustan Times) Navi Mumbai, located along the creek, has been developed through reclamation of salt lands and the creek area. The vibrant mangroves jungle along its coastline has played a major role in protecting it from flooding, even during the 26/7 deluge. In the past few years, however, the mangrove jungles have faced destruction and threats in the name of development and from encroachments. Hence, for preservation, the Mangrove Division North Konkan under the Mangrove Cell, Mumbai, has started work on developing an eco-sensitive recreational, educational and conservation infrastructure. CoBOL Architects & Planners has been issued the work order for conceptual and detailed architectural design of the mangrove parks. Said a forest official, 'The parks are aimed at promoting mangrove conservation, education, bio diversity awareness and research through community engagement in compliance with all environmental regulations.' Giving details of the project, he said, 'The parks will include elevated boardwalks, nature interpretation centres and educational and research facilities. There will be visitor amenities, pathways, decks, interpretation centres and signages.' Currently, work is being undertaken on site analysis and environmental assessment in coordination with experts. The consultant will prepare a conceptual and detailed architectural design of mangrove parks following which the development of the park will be taken up by an agency. 'The development of the parks will strictly follow CRZ norms with no cutting of mangroves permitted under any circumstance. Any land diversion will require prior approval from the central government, the High Court and Maharashtra Coastal Zone Management Authority (MCZMA),' the official said. Forest minister Ganesh Naik, who plans to have four such mangrove parks in the city said, 'We are planning a world class facility in the Airoli-Ghansoli belt which is rich in mangroves, flamingos and biodiversity. There are plans for two more mangrove walks at Vashi and Belapur once the current pilot project takes off successfully.'
