Meta and Shopify urged to act as scale of ‘ghost stores' preying on Australian online shoppers revealed

There have been more than 140 'ghost' stores operating online in Australia falsely marketing themselves as local brands and selling everything from poor quality clothing to counterfeit sports labels – or nothing at all.
Affected customers have told Guardian Australia that if the products they bought from these sites actually arrived, they were of 'rubbish' quality and it was nearly impossible to organise a refund.
The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) is investigating after a surge of complaints about ghost stores, but experts say Shopify and Meta need to take responsibility for enabling these sites and allowing them to run false advertising.
Sign up for the Afternoon Update: Election 2025 email newsletter
Guardian Australia, aided by consumer experts, has tracked more than 140 online ghost stores, all of which pretend to be local businesses and are often accompanied by a fictitious story telling consumers they are closing down and must get rid of stock.
The analysis shows that the number of misleading sites, and threats to Australian consumers, is far more prevalent than previously known.
On 31 March, Guardian Australia bought a blouse for $69.95 from a site called Maison Canberra, which has since been taken down. The store sent an email on 1 April saying the item had been shipped, but it was never delivered.
Experts say the sites should be subject to Australian consumer law because they advertise on social media locally, but it is difficult to enforce any breaches because the exact location of the owners may be difficult to identify.
Many of the websites use very similar copy, sell similar products, and reuse email addresses. For example, one site reviewed by Guardian Australia which has 'Sydney' in its name, lists a contact email for another site with 'Dublin' in its name.
Last November, one online store claimed on its Facebook page that: 'After years of having a physical store only in the heart of Melbourne, we decided to open our webshop!'.
However, on its website, it says it is 'based in Lennik, Belgium'. It lists an address for a house 30 minutes from Brussels but also says 'some of our products are located and shipped from within Australia, while others are shipped from China'.
Another online store claims on its website to be 'based in the heart of Melbourne'. But it lists two addresses, one for an office building in central Amsterdam and another for a townhouse about 20kms away.
The returns form for a third site instructs the customer to pay return postage to address in Zhejiang, China. The same address is listed on five other websites – one uses 'Aussie' in its name, while another uses 'London'.
On third-party review websites, customers have claimed they were instructed to send returns to the same Zhejiang address after purchasing products from sites claiming to be based in Norway, Canada, Germany, and New Zealand.
A 60-year-old Brisbane woman, who asked not to be named, said she spent about $350 on shoes and clothing from the site last year after seeing their advertising on Facebook. She says she received the items, but they were 'rubbish'.
After trying to arrange a refund, she contacted PayPal and her credit card provider.
The woman said the company sent PayPal the details of their refund process, which listed the Zhejiang address and instructed her to make a false customs declaration, stating the value of the goods is under $5.
Sign up to Morning Mail
Our Australian morning briefing breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters
after newsletter promotion
'Anything above $5 will be destroyed immediately, resulting in no possible refund,' the form said.
The customer said she was 'usually a very tenacious person' but 'after four months of backwards and forwards and arguing with people, I thought I'd just cut my losses because it was creating a lot of anxiety'. She was yet to secure a refund.
The majority of the identified ghost stores – based on analysis by Guardian Australia, evidence from customers, and a running list of sites compiled by the Scam Alerts Australia Facebook group – have been built using the Shopify e-commerce platform.
The chief executive of the Consumer Policy Research Centre, Erin Turner, said online platforms must do more to stop 'fraudulent players' from using their services.
'Platforms like Shopify and Instagram are making money as these ghost stores pay for advertising and support,' she said.
'We should call this what it is: digital retail fraud. Without coordinated action from digital platforms and regulators, these fraudsters will keep gaming the system.'
Guardian Australia contacted Meta and Shopify for comment, but the companies did not respond by deadline.
Digital marketing strategist Briony Cullin said she had seen the volume of social media advertising for this type of online store increase over the past six months. She has reported the ads for 13 different businesses to Meta. Each time, she said she has been notified that the ad would not be taken down.
One of the 'support' messages Cullin received from Meta, seen by Guardian Australia, said the company used a 'combination of technology and human reviewers' to process reports.
'There needs to be some balance for consumers here,' Cullin says. 'It's a huge problem that they're not taking any responsibility for and that's terrible.'
Maison Canberra and the other stores referred to in this article were contacted for comment.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Scottish Sun

3 hours ago

• Scottish Sun

Aldi slashes price of ‘garden bar' to just £5 down from £15 – in time for drinks outside in the sunshine this weekend

The stylish garden bar has had its price slashed just in time for summer DRINK UP Aldi slashes price of 'garden bar' to just £5 down from £15 – in time for drinks outside in the sunshine this weekend SHOPPERS are racing to grab an Aldi "garden bar" after the budget retailer slashed its price to just £5 just in time in time for summer. With summer beginning to hit the UK Brits will no doubt be looking to chill outside in the sunshine. Advertisement 4 The garden bar has had its price reduced by a whopping £10 Credit: Facebook/Extreme Couponing and B 4 The stylish garden item is perfect for outdoor parties Credit: Facebook/Extreme Couponing and B The garden bar offers the perfect item to make enjoying an outdoor tipple easier and cheaper. The stylish black cart has two levels, offering plenty of room to store glassware and drinks. It boasts a built in bottle and glass holder to save you from taking trips back and forth to the kitchen. Shoppers will have to assemble the bar themselves but Aldi says that this should be easy to do. Advertisement With a set of wheels propping it up the garden bar can easily be moved around the patio and the house. Normally retailing for £14.99 Aldi have reduced the price of the item by an impressive £10. Shoppers spotted the discounted price in their local Aldi store and shared the news to social media. Retailing now at just £4.99 the garden bar has had its price slashed at the perfect time as warm summer weather begins to roll in. Advertisement The 44 x 40 x 75cm cart is available now in store at a discounted price. It appears to only be on offer at a few select locations however so shoppers will need to go to their local store to check if they can bag the bargain. The exact date Aldi's sell out wooden garden day bed returns to stores Aldi said about the bar: "Get ready to host the best garden party of the year. "This Bar Cart will ensure you have everything you need to keep the drinks flowing." Advertisement It measures in at 44 x 40 x 75cm and can be found in some Aldi stores now. A post touting the discounted garden bar was shared on social media by one shopper who snapped up the deal. 4 The garden bar is perfect for BBQs Credit: Getty 4 Aldi is selling the garden bar at reduced prices in certain stores Credit: Alamy Advertisement Comments began flooding in from others keen to get their hands on one of the bars. One social media user wrote: "How do we fit 24 cans of Stella on it?" Another commented: "New house purchase incoming." A third replied: "We need this for our garden." Advertisement And a fourth said: "This looks good value."

Edinburgh Live

7 hours ago

• Edinburgh Live

Eager Edinburgh customers in huge queue stretching up road as new cafe opens

Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info Hundreds of Edinburgh customers were spotted in a huge queue on a busy street to celebrate the opening of a new bubble tea shop. The team at HeyTea previously announced the opening of their new location in the capital and they officially welcomed customers in on Friday morning. Based at South Bridge, fans of the chain flocked to the new venue to make the most of the 'buy one get one free offer' and hoped to get their hands on the Edinburgh themed magnets - prompting a huge queue. A video taken opposite the road shows the line stretching up South Bridge as customers couldn't wait to get their hands on a drink. A post on Instagram reads: "A fresh sense of taste, awakened by the history tucked in the alleyways. Brew a pot of tea, adding a bit of depth, a bit of layers. "Feel it, gather it, and wait, for another renaissance to unfold. "Grand opening on 20th June. Buy one get one free on our exclusive opening menu. Limited-edition Edinburgh fridge magnets available." An application for HeyTea branded signage was submitted to Edinburgh Council in February of this year and approved in late March. The shop will occupy the premises formerly occupied by another bubble tea shop, HI TEA, now closed. HeyTea is a popular bubble tea brand originating in China. They brand themselves as starting the "new tea style", which innovates traditional tea by adding ingredients like milk, fruit, and various toppings. They sell fruit tea and milk teas, experimenting with unusual ingredients like cheese foam. Join Edinburgh Live's Whatsapp Community here and get the latest news sentstraight to your messages. Their website reads: "As the originator of the New Style Tea, we hav ebeen infusing our teas with eccentric inspiration, giving traditional tea a new life. We want to create a tea brand for young minds who are tired of mediocracy and who dare to drink differently." This will be the franchise's second Scotland store after their first opened in Glasgow. The brand also operates a number of cafes in London and Manchester. They also operate stores across the world in Australian, America, Canada, and Asia.

Daily Mirror

8 hours ago

• Daily Mirror

Mirror's Daily Digest - Assisted Dying Bill vote to largest ever data breach

In this Friday's Mirror Daily Digest, we've pulled together the biggest stories of the day from the historic assisted dying Bill vote to the record-breaking data leak Welcome to the Mirror's Daily Digest, where we'll be pulling together all the best stories of the day from our News, Politics, Weather teams and more. This Friday, we're featuring everything from today's historic vote which saw MPs decide whether assisted dying should be legalised, through to a massive data breach which is said to be one of the largest in history. Our Weather team has been closely following the Met Office thunderstorm warning, which could bring with it sudden flooding, with some urged to "consider preparing a flood plan and an emergency flood kit". Meanwhile, our Politics team has covered the Norfolk Tory chief who is facing calls to quit after making a joke about 'poor people'. ‌ Urgent warning for Apple, Facebook & Google users to change passwords now ‌ People who use Apple, Facebook and Google have been urged to change their passwords following the largest ever data breach, which has exposed a staggering 16 billion logins. The data leak, which also affects logins for Instagram, Microsoft, Netflix, PayPal, Roblox, Discord, Telegram, GitHub, has given cybercriminals and hackers "unprecedented access to personal credentials" Government services in more than 29 countries were also targeted in the attack, which were most likely obtained with infostealer malware, which can infiltrate systems and steal sensitive information like login details. CyberNews researchers said that another alternative was that the data was collected by ethical hackers to spot flaws in the system. This breach shows how an astronomical number of people are likely continuing to use compromised accounts, making them more at risk of cybercrime. Criminals use personal information to take over accounts, steal identities, and carry out targeted phishing attacks, CyberNews adds. Researchers said in their report: "This is not just a leak – it's a blueprint for mass exploitation. With over 16billion login records exposed, cybercriminals now have unprecedented access to personal credentials that can be used for account takeover, identity theft, and highly targeted phishing." Assisted dying law passes Commons in historic moment ‌ In a historic moment in the Commons today, MPs voted to back a landmark bill to change the law on assisted dying in England and Wales. They voted by 314 in favour of the legislation to 291 against - a majority of 23 - as supporters of assisted dying jumped and hugged each other outside Parliament. It means the controversial legislation - spearheaded by the Labour MP Kim Leadbeater - will now pass to the House of Lords where it will be debated by peers. The Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill aims to give terminally ill people over the age 18 with just six months left to live the option to end their life early. Their decision must be "clear, settled and informed" at every stage - and free from coercion. ‌ It must also be subject to approval by two doctors and an expert panel featuring a social worker, senior legal figure and psychiatrist. Assisted dying is currently banned and carries a maximum prison sentence of 14 years. Met Office issues thunderstorm warning with 'flash flood' risk despite heatwave ‌ Sun-loving Brits are in for a disappointment, as the Met Office has issued a thunderstorm warning which is set to temporarily break the scorching heatwave. Our Weather team has covered the yellow warning, which is in place from 3pm tomorrow until 4am Sunday morning in the East Midlands, North East England, North West England, Wales, West Midlands and Yorkshire & Humber. The storms could cause sudden flooding that could in turn make the roads difficult to navigate. There could be some road closures as a result, the forecaster added. The flooding could also leave some communities isolated as roads are cut off. The Met Office said that power cuts were also a possibility, with the potential for services to homes and businesses being lost. In the event of lightning strikes, there could be bus and train cancellations in the affected areas. In a statement, it said: "Whilst many places will likely remain dry and unaffected, scattered thunderstorms may develop during Saturday afternoon, lasting through the evening hours, moving northeastwards before eventually clearing to the North Sea by the early hours of Sunday. ‌ "The most intense thunderstorms could produce frequent lightning, large hail and gusty winds, along with some heavy downpours for a time. This may lead to some surface water impacts in places. Consider if your location is at risk of flash flooding. If so, consider preparing a flood plan and an emergency flood kit." Tory council chief sparks outrage with 'poor people' steak dinner joke ‌ In other news, our Politics team has reported on the Tory council chief who is facing calls to quit after posting a picture with the caption: "Wonder what all the poor people are doing?" Norfolk County Council leader Kay Mason Billig posted the photograph of her meal with a £21 bottle of Italian red wine, potatoes in peppercorn sauce and salad to her Facebook friends. But the caption sparked a furious reaction, with tens of thousands of people in Norfolk forced to rely on food banks and her own council runs an £11.8m fund to help people struggling to afford to eat. Mrs Mason Billig, who is entitled to more than £51,000 in allowances from County Hall each year, told the EDP website the sharing of the post beyond her friends was a "personal attack" and a private joke had been misunderstood. However, Steve Morphew, leader of the Labour group at County Hall, said: "People like to have council leaders who show they are in touch, care about the plight of others and show humility and pride in the public positions they hold. This is a nauseating example of the exact opposite. I find nothing amusing here." ‌ Multiple primary school children injured after 'mass casualty incident' Finally, our News team has been closely following a disturbing incident in Berlin, where almost 40 children were injured at a primary school after tear gas was sprayed on site. ‌ Emergency services rushed to Miriam Makeba School in the city of Moabit at around 9am this morning. Multiple kids complained of shortness of breath and eye irritation after the substance was used in the hallway. Police, firefighters and medics attended the scene and treated 37 pupils. Officials evacuated the building in response to the incident. Worried parents raced to the school to check on their children. An investigation has since been launched into the mass casualty. Police said they are investigating the incident under causing bodily harm, reports BZ Berlin. A spokesperson for the fire services said: "We cared for 37 children and provided outpatient care; none of the children required hospital treatment."