WA Budget 2025: GST win coming for the west as fight looms over lucrative deal
WA will see its GST share lift above the legislated 75 cent floor for the first time the Budget has predicted, as the Government prepares to argue for the 2018 deal which has proven an economic boon for the State.
Ahead of a Productivity Commission-lead review next year, Treasury has made concerns clear over the Commonwealth Grants Commission's process for calculating the annual handouts to the States, including outdated references to the pandemic.
Under the fair share deal, which mandates WA receives 75 cents for every dollar, from 2026-27 the State's GST will be weighted to NSW's share, putting WA's slice of the national fund at 82 cents in the dollar — the highest point in more than a decade.
Without the deal, WA's share would have fallen to as low as 18 cents in the coming financial year.
The Budget made the argument that the cost of maintaining WA's share above the floor — a constant gripe for other State Governments — was clearly outweighed by the value of the State's iron ore industry.
'Every State, not just Western Australia, has benefited from high iron ore prices,' the Budget states
'The other States can now expect to receive about $30 billion extra GST over 2020-21 to 2028-29, because of the higher than expected iron ore prices to date.
'The three largest iron ore miners paid $17 billion to the Commonwealth in company tax in 2023-24 on its Western Australian operations, while the cost of the no-worse-off guarantee was only $5 billion that year.'
But a recent review of the calculations used by the Commission drew criticism from the State Government, for failing to consider
'For example, the CGC's decision to include COVID-19 business support and health expenses resulted in States that recorded higher expenses receiving higher GST grants,' the budget read.
'This method change does not acknowledge the different policy approaches of States when responding to COVID-19, and penalises States that took actions that prevented the spread of COVID-19 in the community.'
In her Budget speech, Treasurer Rita Saffioti stood by the deal, saying the global uncertainties were a 'constant reminder' the agreement needed to be protected.
'It is again important to point out that despite the irrational and absurd commentary from many over east, WA will still only receive 75 per cent of our population share of GST this year,' she said.
'In fact Members, our Treasury officials have estimated that Western Australia's net contribution to the other States last financial year was $39 billion. That is, $13,000 that every Western Australian is contributing to the rest of the nation.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
7 hours ago
- ABC News
As Iran and Israel fighting rages, many people face a difficult choice
For some people in Iran and Israel, the past week of fighting between their two countries has posed a difficult question: stay, or leave? Choosing the former usually means living with an ever-present risk of serious injury or death. At best? Survival and constant anxiety. Seeking to leave your home to find safer areas — elsewhere in the country or abroad — may seem an obvious option, but there are multiple reasons why it's not one available to everyone. It often represents a logistical nightmare that comes at enormous financial cost (just ask the Israelis who chartered yachts to take them on a 20-hour journey to the safety of Cyprus this week). Some residents of Tel Aviv are determined to stay in the city. However, they are moving underground to stay safe. Three generations of the Papirany family are currently living underneath one of the city's largest malls, the Dizengoff Centre. Their home is still standing. But a missile strike a few days ago hit buildings a couple of hundred metres away and they are worried about being caught short in future. "I've never heard anything like it before, there were like several jets up ahead, like a dog fight was going on, and we heard lots of booms," Tracey Papirany said. "And then next minute, such a loud boom that everyone yelled and grabbed each other." When the ABC visited the car park, people's mobile phones started chirping with advance warning of a missile strike, which comes from an official Israeli government app. "We put on a show, just for you," Mali, Tracey's daughter, quipped. "This is our everyday life, it's the reality here and that's what we accept when we come here. "We know what we're coming into and we live with it each day now." Maya Papirany, Mali's sister, said she had copped abuse from her friends for moving to Israel. She had been living in New Zealand with her two young children while her parents were in Australia. When they moved to Israel, she followed. "I made that decision knowing that there was a war, but I knew that I had no choice, there was nothing else I could do, it was my sanity, my mental health and doing what I thought was best for the children at the time," she said. "And since moving over, people have been messaging me saying, how could you bring your children to this war? How could you do this to them?" While the Papiranys brought their own bedding, the shopping centre's management is also sourcing supplies. "We're also bringing them tents and mattresses, so people will come here every night, just for the night, from 6pm to 9 in the morning after," Dizengoff centre chief executive Dan Pilz said. "And then they can spend the night safely, not be worrying about taking the kids to run during the bombs. "Without tents and mattresses, 4,000 or 5,000 people can stay here, [with tents] we believe we can contain around 100 or 150 families." Almost 1,500 kilometres away, in Iran, Israel's attacks over the past week have sparked a rush at many of the country's land borders as people attempt to flee. With airports shuttered, hours-long traffic jams clogged roads out of the capital, Tehran. Some were headed for more isolated areas, particularly in the country's north, while others, like Barry Jahed, 34, and his father, Parvis, wanted out altogether. Both men are British-Iranian and live in London. Parvis had been working on a film in Iran and had been based there for several months at the time of the latest attacks, while Barry had arrived in the country to visit family in May. After several days of moving between various locations — including a particularly distressing night at a relative's home, which was punctuated by "a series of air raids and explosions", according to Barry — the pair decided to head for the country's border with Türkiye. That meant convincing a stranger to drive them north. "We didn't get to say goodbye to family members or anything like that. We made a rush to the border in this car," Barry told the ABC. They relied on connections to beat large queues at petrol stations, and eventually used a border crossing that's typically reserved for freight. Once in Türkiye, Barry and his father combined with a group of around 16 other people in the same position to rent a dilapidated minibus in an attempt to drive towards Istanbul and its major international airport. After multiple mechanical issues, that trip took about 24 hours. "We had a young girl sit up front, and she was the DJ and put on music, and we listened to some songs and tried to make it as enjoyable as possible, as uncomfortable as the journey was," Barry said. After boarding a flight in Istanbul, Barry and Parvis are now back in London. But their concerns about the situation in Iran remain ever-present. "I'm worried about not just the bombings, but also the further consequences of shortages of fuel and therefore food," Barry said. His elderly grandmother is among the many people who cannot leave. "She's not able to move around very much," Barry said. "If there is some kind of shortages, this could very much be bad for her health." While Barry may be safe, his anxiety looks likely to continue as fighting rages into a second week. And if the rhetoric from leaders in both Israel and Iran is anything to go by, the end of hostilities could be a long way off.
News.com.au
8 hours ago
- News.com.au
‘Should not be punished': Queensland decries GST carve up
Cash-strapped state governments are looking west with envy as Western Australia pulls in its large slice of the GST carve up despite the healthiest books in the country. Resource-rich WA posted a $2.5bn operating surplus on Thursday – it's seventh budget surplus in a row. From Friday it is set to receive its share of the GST pool of 75 cents in the dollar, despite its strong revenue stream from its resources sector. State premiers and treasurers have been agitating for changes to the GST distribution, since the final figures were announced in March, and ahead of the funds formally being dished out on Friday. WA is still enjoying the windfalls of a 2018 GST deal struck under previous Coalition government by then-treasurer Scott Morrison and backed in by the Albanese government, where WA is guaranteed 75 cents of every dollar paid in GST. Without this benchmark, WA would have received as little as 18 cents back. The WA Premier and Treasurer credited their economic management for this week's operating surplus and healthy debt forecasts. Iron ore prices are hovering at $US95 while the state government has done its forecasting with an expectation of $US72 a tonne. But every state and territory except WA has been posting deficits since the 75 cent distribution reforms in 2018. The Queensland Treasurer feels short-changed, as strong coal royalties pad the state coffers. Victoria and NSW's slices of the GST pie are set to expand while Queensland's portion gets a trim. 'This money belongs to Queenslanders and we should not be punished because of our support for industries that underpin our national wealth,' state Treasurer David Janetzki said. The impending Queensland state budget, to be delivered on Tuesday, will show the effects of a dip in coal prices after an $8.8bn royalties windfall during the past four years. Despite the Sunshine State's royalty take coming down, Queensland's GST payout this year falls by $1.1bn to $16.5bn. In a speech to the National Press Club on Wednesday, federal Treasurer Jim Chalmers, who has historically opposed raising the GST rate, left the door slightly open to raising it from 10 per cent – the amount the excise has remained for the past 25 years. 'I've, for a decade or more, had a view about the GST,' he told The Conversation. 'I repeated that view at the Press Club because I thought that was the honest thing to do, but what I'm going to genuinely try and do, whether it's in this policy area or in other policy areas, is to not limit what people might bring to the table.' This year, Queensland is the only state or territory getting less than previous years, while every other jurisdiction is getting more. Victoria is set to become a net-recipient of the GST pool for the first time as well. 'It used to be the case that our friends in Victoria would help us shoulder the burden in supporting all the other states,' NSW Treasurer Daniel Mookhey said last month. 'Victoria is now a recipient state, to quite a large degree, $1.07 (per dollar taxed) is what they're getting. 'I'm going to continue to speak out, particularly about the fact that NSW is now carrying the federation when it comes to GST distribution.' The Northern Territory receives $5.15 for every dollar it contributes, far and away the largest return. Despite having the second largest population, Victoria receives the largest portion of the total pool, getting 27.5 per cent; with a $3.6bn year-on-year increase this time around.
ABC News
8 hours ago
- ABC News
Budget reveals WA oil and gas royalties shrinking as North West Shelf earnings drop
When the nation's largest mainland gas project was given provisional approval to keep running until 2070, the West Australian premier heralded it as an economic boost for the state. "It's not just important for our overall economy, it's important for regional WA," Roger Cook told reporters. But the most recent state budget papers show the shared revenue, or royalties, the project is generating for WA is in rapid decline. A royalty is a fee charged for the right to extract a mineral resource. In the 2022-'23 financial year, royalties from the North West Shelf (NWS) gas project on WA's north-west coast, delivered more than $1.3 billion to the state's coffers. That number is now tipped to drop by more than 70 per cent to $365 million in the 2025-'26 financial year. That amounts to 0.7 per cent of the state's $50.2 billion revenue, and just 6 per cent of the $6.6 billion generated by iron ore royalties. The drop in revenue is because the project's original gas fields are depleting. When the NWS began production in 1984, it was required to give 10 per cent of the revenue from each gas well to the Commonwealth. A legal change four years later meant future offshore projects would not pay royalties, but a 40 per cent tax on profits, known as the Petroleum Resource Rent Tax (PRRT). Two-thirds of the revenue from the NWS is redirected to WA. But as those gas fields deplete, so does their revenue, and there have been new gas sources processed at the NWS since 1988 that do not generate royalties. "The North-West Shelf project [is] forecast to process higher volumes of gas sourced from areas outside the revenue-sharing agreement," the 2025-'26 state budget papers read. Principal adviser to progressive think-tank The Australia Institute Mark Ogge said he had not seen any evidence the new gas sources required to extend the NWS would have royalty agreements attached to them. "Australia is being robbed of its resources and our governments are entirely complicit," he said. Mr Ogge said West Australians reading the latest budget should be outraged. Oil and gas analyst and consultant Jeanette Roberts believed it was likely new revenue-sharing agreements would be signed if the NWS extension was finalised. "I think that's the most likely scenario," Ms Roberts said. A spokesperson for Environment Minister Murray Watt would not comment on whether royalties had featured in the negotiations over the NWS extension because the decision was not final yet. Ms Roberts pointed said the oil and gas industry made other contributions to the Australian economy through taxes. "Tax is more than just Petroleum Resource Rent Tax and state royalties, it's also GST, corporate taxes, a whole bunch of contributions gas companies pay," she said. The industry's peak lobby group, Australian Energy Producers, claimed the sector paid $17 billion in taxes and royalties nationally in the 2023-'24 financial year. A spokesperson for Woodside, which manages the NWS, said the project had contributed $40 billion to Australia since beginning production in 1984. "Including more than $18 billion to the WA government," the spokesperson said. They would not comment on any future royalty-sharing agreements. According to the Australian Taxation Office's corporate tax transparency report, the company paid $2.6 billion in income tax in the 2022-'23 financial year. Mr Ogge from the Australia Institute said the public should still expect more from the industry given there were large offshore gas fields near WA where royalties were not being charged. "Vast amounts of gas are processed in Western Australia from offshore fields and exported, making tens of billions of dollars every year for these companies," he said. "I just cannot understand why the federal government doesn't charge royalties on the vast majority of gas being exported from Western Australia." Treasurer Jim Chalmers was approached for comment but did not directly respond to questions. Last year, the federal government made changes to the PRRT, which it claims has brought in more tax revenue from the oil and gas sector.
