BBC did not mention Adams allegation, Donaldson family's former solicitor says
Gerry Adams was not mentioned in interactions between the solicitor representing the family of a man who was killed and a BBC team making a documentary on the matter, a libel trial relating to the programme has heard.
Mr Adams is suing the BBC over accusations contained in a broadcast of the Spotlight documentary series and an accompanying online article which alleged he had sanctioned the killing of Denis Donaldson.
Mr Donaldson was shot dead in 2006, months after admitting his role as a police and MI5 agent for 20 years.
In 2009 the Real IRA admitted killing Mr Donaldson, and the Spotlight programme was broadcast in September 2016.
At the High Court in Dublin on Thursday, Mr Adams' barrister Tom Hogan brought the family's solicitor from the time of the programme as a witness.
Ciaran Shiels, a solicitor and partner at Madden and Finucane Solicitors, told the court that the BBC was not only 'barking up the wrong tree' but was in the 'wrong orchard' over the claims against Mr Adams.
Mr Shiels said he represented Mr Donaldson and his family from a period before his death until a period after the broadcast.
He said he came to act as a spokesperson for the family after Mr Donaldson's death but said he no longer does so.
Mr Shiels, who works mainly in criminal defence work, told the jury about his interactions with the BBC team in the months up to the broadcast – including journalist Jennifer O'Leary.
He said he did not represent Mr Adams and said his concern was about the relatives of Mr Donaldson.
Asked if there was any mention of Mr Adams in any of his interactions with the BBC, Mr Shiels said: 'I don't think his name was even suggested.
'Nowhere, and I would have remembered if it had.'
Asked by Mr Hogan what he would have said to Ms O'Leary if she had put forward the allegations against Mr Adams, Mr Shiels said: 'I would have said to her that not only was she barking up the wrong tree, she wasn't even in the right orchard.'
He said the idea that Mr Adams somehow authorised the murder or that it was the Provisional IRA that carried it out 'did not marry' in any way with the lines of inquiry being followed by police, the understanding of the family, or 'common sense'.
Mr Shiels said it was a 'pretty perverse statement and depiction as to what happened'.
He added that the family did not accept or believe in any way that Mr Adams had anything to do with it.
Mr Shiels added: 'Mr Adams was seen as a family friend, he was trusted by the family, the family would have felt that he had integrity, the family would be streetwise enough to know that the persons who the guards had identified as people who would be – they believed to be involved in the murder would have no truck with Mr Adams and Mr Adams would have no truck with them.'
Earlier in the proceedings, Mr Shiels said he had been contacted by Ms O'Leary from the BBC on April 4 2016 – the 10th anniversary of Mr Donaldson's death.
He said they wanted to speak to him about a number of issues, including the 'Stormontgate' affair which involved an allegation that Sinn Fein was operating a spy ring in which Mr Donaldson was arrested, how that resulted in the collapse of powersharing institutions, and the circumstances under which he had outed himself as an informant.
Mr Shiels said he was also 'concerned' after being asked if he knew why Mr Donaldson had become a British agent and there were discussions about indiscretion in his private life – that there may have been an affair or that he may have been a homosexual.
He said the family had a right to privacy and that there had been a previous 'quite sensationalist and gory' documentary which featured a reconstruction of the murder that 'hurt the family'.
Mr Shiels said that Mr Donaldson's location had been front page news in a newspaper three weeks prior to his killing, and added that the family were 'concerned about further irresponsible journalism taking place'.
He said: 'People were still grieving, people were still trying to get on with their lives.
'It was very difficult to see what possible good could come from this.'
Mr Shiels added: 'Previously when this subject was looked at in the media, this ended in disaster.'
At the same time, he said the family were demoralised that an inquest into Mr Donaldson's death was not commencing substantively.
Under questioning from Mr Hogan, Mr Shiels outlined a series of correspondence and interactions between him and the BBC about the upcoming programme.
He said it was made clear that the family did not want to take part in the documentary but it was put forward that he would be interviewed on their behalf.
He said at some point relationships between the BBC and the family 'went south'.
Mr Shiels said the family had five years prior put out a press statement outlining frustrations that Irish police, An Garda Siochana, were primarily focused on who had pulled the trigger to kill Mr Donaldson rather than the circumstances around him being 'burned as an agent'.
He said this involved him being notified there was a threat to his life, and interactions with his handler known as 'Lenny'.
Mr Shiels said the family were 'credulous' that gardai could not see a linkage between the two and that that was where the inquiry should be starting.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Graziadaily
2 hours ago
- Graziadaily
Naga Munchetty Workplace Bullying Allegations: Everything To Know
BBC Breakfast presenter Naga Munchetty is facing scrutiny after being accused of inappropriate behaviour and bullying incidents on both BBC Breakfast studio and Radio 5 Live. According to a report in The Sun, Naga has been reprimanded for two allegations in three years – one that she bullied a junior staffer and another that she made a sex jibe off air on Radio 5 Live. These claims have emerged after the BBC announced that Richard Frediani, the editor of Breakfast and News at One, had taken some 'extended leave' amid claims of bullying against him. This came after 'unhappy' employees made a formal complaint against 'tyrannical' Richard, according to The Sun. The BBC has enlisted the help of a consultant to review the culture of its breakfast show. Sources also say that the BBC's HR team have seconded a lawyer from PwC to sort out the ongoing problem. According to deadline, staff have been approached about sharing their experience of working on the programme, according to the industry website Deadline. Naga has been a staple of the BBC breakfast show since 2010 and became part of the presenting lineup in 2014. The exact comment Naga is under fire for hasn't been reported. But according to reports, it was thought to be a crude slang term for a sex act, before directing the question at a colleague. The incident, which happened in 2022, was said to have left the audience stunned. Naga was reprimanded by a senior producer, but no formal action was taken. One source described the incident as 'Crass, inappropriate and wildly unprofessional. The person felt embarrassed.' According to The Sun, Naga was allegedly involved in the bullying of a younger member of staff last year, who was the most junior staffer. She reportedly accused the staffer of stealing without presenting any evidence. The confrontation led to a closed-door exchange, with Naga not issuing an apology after. 'It was humiliating. There was no evidence, no apology. The woman left not long after, completely demoralised,' said a source. Another insider explained the episode as part of a larger issue. 'That wasn't an isolated incident. It really is the tip of the iceberg,' they said. Alice Hall is the Staff Writer at Grazia UK. At Grazia, she writes news and features about pop culture, health, politics and interiors.
Edinburgh Live
4 hours ago
- Edinburgh Live
Abandoned Edinburgh restaurant of 'disappearing Armenian cook' joins the market
Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info An abandoned Edinburgh restaurant that is 'shrouded in mystery' has been put up for sale. The historic building at 55 Abbeyhill dates back to 1896, when it was designed for use as a police station. It closed in 1932, and was owned by a church until the '80s. The derelict structure had a second (or third) life as an Armenian restaurant. An elusive eatery, entry was 'notoriously gaurded' - and the spot was found only by rumour or word of mouth. The owner, and cook, was a man who liked to be known simply as Peter. His restaurant, however, had a more extensive honorific - Aghtamar Lake Van Monastery in Exile - though locals labelled it simply 'The Armenian Restaurant'. Edinburgh resident Jo Spiller ate at the restaurant in 2010. She told the BBC: "I heard about it from friends, who heard about it from friends, and it was so difficult to book. My friend thinks he was calling a public phone box to make a reservation." Sign up for Edinburgh Live newsletters for more headlines straight to your inbox Out of nowhere, Peter disappeared in 2012. The restaurant, which has sat empty for over a decade, closed down. Having become a well-known figure in Edinburgh, residents were left perplexed. This was until 2021, when a segment on BBC's The Nine set out to find him - and it didn't take long. They found Peter had owned an Armenian rug shop, which was also in a derelict state. They ended up leaving a note for Peter, who agreed to meet them. Speaking to The Nine, he said: "People were so keen, I couldn't control the numbers. "Some nights we had guests in the three figures, people would bring chairs from home for more seating." As it turns out, Peter had been in Edinburgh the whole time. A robbery at the restaurant had seen all of his priceless Armenian antiques stolen. Join Edinburgh Live's Whatsapp Community here and get the latest news sent straight to your messages. Peter was distraught, and simply shut the eatery down and retreated from the public eye. Allied Surveyors Scotland's head of commercial agency Iain Mercer said: "'For years people have driven past these properties and often wondered about their past and, indeed, their availability. "As such, we anticipate they will pique the interest of domestic and international buyers such is their rich and colourful history. Whilst preserving their historic interest, the buildings would now lend themselves to a range of potential uses such as residential, gallery, museum, brewing or restaurant." Now, the B listed property is on the market. offers over £500,000 are being sought.
Metro
9 hours ago
- Metro
'I beat the system and proved I didn't need a TV licence'
A man who thought he 'beat the system' by getting his TV licence cancelled after proving he only watches streaming services still ended up being threatened with a criminal conviction. Lee Stuart applied for one when he moved into a new home in Kirkby, Merseyside, but later decided to scrap it because he preferred bingeing Netflix and Amazon Prime. He was visited by an inspection officer last September and says they agreed he did not watch any live TV or use the BBC iPlayer. But in January this year, a letter came through saying he was being prosecuted under the controversial single justice procedure (SJP). The SJP was set up in 2015 to allow magistrates to decide on minor offences, such as using a television without a licence or driving without car insurance, without defendants going to court. Wake up to find news on your TV shows in your inbox every morning with Metro's TV Newsletter. Sign up to our newsletter and then select your show in the link we'll send you so we can get TV news tailored to you. Around 25,000 people were convicted of not paying their TV licence in the year ending June 2024, the Standard reports. There have been calls to reform the system after it was revealed sick pensioners, people with mental health problems and bereaved families were being given criminal convictions for failing to pay. Lee said of his inspection: 'I told him I didn't pay for a TV licence because I didn't think I needed one because I don't watch live TV. I don't even have an aerial installed in my TV.' He said he 'just watches Netflix and Amazon Prime through the PlayStation', which the inspector agreed. 'To be honest, I was really made up with myself, thinking I'd beaten the system and proved I didn't need a licence,' he added. But that relief was wiped out when the SJP notice came through the letter box in January. Speaking to the Echo, he said: 'It said if I pleaded not guilty, the fine would be larger, and I may have to pay court costs. So, I'm not sure what's going on at this point.' He said the inspector's statement was included in the paperwork but the question 'May I come in to inspect the TV receiver?' was marked 'No'. It also stated he had admitted to watching the news days earlier. More Trending Lee decided to contest the case in court – despite warnings he faced a large fine as well as prosecution costs – and ended up proving his case a second time. 'I can see why people just accept it, but I knew I was innocent, and I wasn't paying for a TV licence that I didn't need so I fought it,' he said. Magistrates threw out the case due to insufficient evidence. A TV Licensing spokesperson said: 'This was reviewed by TV Licensing following the court hearing in April 2025 as is standard practice, and no failings were highlighted.' A TV licence covers you for: All TV channels – like BBC, ITV, Channel 4, U&Dave and international channels – like BBC, ITV, Channel 4, U&Dave and international channels Pay TV services – like Sky, Virgin Media and EE TV – like Sky, Virgin Media and EE TV Live TV on streaming services – like YouTube, Netflix, and Amazon Prime Video – like YouTube, Netflix, and Amazon Prime Video Everything on BBC iPlayer This includes watching, recording and downloading. On any device. The full list of rules can be found here. Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@ For more stories like this, check our news page. MORE: BBC star Naga Munchetty facing bullying allegations and inappropriate 'sex jibe' claims MORE: Netflix's rudely axed Mindhunter could be returning with a twist MORE: More schedule changes confirmed as EastEnders is pulled from BBC One
