PH, PN leaders play down need for manifesto law
PETALING JAYA: Representatives from both the government and opposition showed little interest in enacting laws to hold political parties accountable for their election manifestos during a BBC debate programme last night.
PKR secretary-general Fuziah Salleh said her coalition, Pakatan Harapan (PH), has come to realise that governing is far more complex than being in opposition — and acknowledged that past manifestos may have overpromised.
"The perspective of how to run the country is different when you are in government as opposed to when you're in the opposition," said Fuziah, who is also deputy minister for domestic trade and cost of living.
"So, we will be more careful with manifestos this time," she added during the BBC's World Questions debate, held on Tuesday night.
The debate, part of the BBC World Service's World Questions series, featured four panellists, including Fuziah and former Bersatu Youth chief Wan Ahmad Fayhsal Wan Ahmad Kamal.
The proposal for a law compelling parties to fulfil their election pledges came from a member of the audience.
Responding to the idea, Wan Fayhsal said such a law was unnecessary, as voters already have the power to remove governments that fail to deliver.
"All political parties in Malaysia have had the experience of governing. We've learned not to overpromise on things we cannot deliver," he said.
Election manifestos in Malaysia are not legally binding.
The debate also touched on issues such as the rising cost of living, national identity and fundamental liberties.
It will be broadcast on the BBC World Service on Saturday, June 14.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Focus Malaysia
2 hours ago
- Focus Malaysia
Critics are now calling Anwar's regime the ‘kuku besi' regime
MALAYSIAN authorities are cracking down on online critics of Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim's administration, with politicians and citizens facing police questioning or charges. Former economy minister Datuk Seri Rafizi Ramli voiced his concerns after a pro-Pakatan Harapan (PH) supporter's wife filed a police report following a visit by officers from both the Malaysian Communications and Multimedia Commission (MCMC) and the police at their home. Rafizi on June 9 highlighted the case of the X user Amer Hamzah, who voiced his views on the PKR elections. Rafizi also identified other social media accounts allegedly targeted for commenting on the recent elections within PKR. The clampdown coincides with controversy over the Mobile Phone Data (MPD) project, which collects mobile data from telcos without an opt-out, raising privacy and surveillance concerns. Despite government assurances, critics remain sceptical. Recently, MCMC blocked two Telegram channels, Edisi Siasat (1.18 million members) and Edisi Khas, for allegedly violating local laws. On June 19, MCMC obtained a court order against Telegram for spreading harmful content, compelling the platform to block the controversial whistleblowing channel Edisi Siasat. This action mirrors the 2015 blocking of Sarawak Report during the 1Malaysia Development Bhd scandal under former premier Datuk Seri Najib Razak's administration. At least six individuals, including Pahang MCA Youth chief Wong Siew Mun, faced police questioning over social media posts criticising the government's MPD project, which collects anonymous mobile data without opt-out until 2026. Critics fear privacy breaches and surveillance, despite assurances of data security. Wong, questioned on June 18 for a TikTok video, called for parliamentary debate. Amid rising discontent and coalition tensions, social media censorship has surged, challenging Anwar's free speech and reform commitments. 'They (the authorities) have to stop the data collection. Why is there a need for large-scale monitoring?' said Wong, whose party is aligned with the Anwar-led unity government. 'This involves public interest and trust. We are trying to foster public discourse on this… We have a role to play in making sure the government is doing the right thing,' she told The Straits Times. On June 18, 2025, Wong was questioned by police over a TikTok video where she criticised the government's MPD project. She questioned whether Malaysia is undergoing genuine reforms or sliding into 'dictatorship', highlighting concerns over the non-consensual collection of mobile data from telcos, raising fears of privacy violations and surveillance. While Madani is taking the same path Najib's regime took, more people are now voicing concerns over the banishment of freedom of expression online. With the Edisi Siasat 2.0 channel now inaccessible, more people are voicing support for the channel. An X user said the Anwar regime's iron grip is no joke these days, calling it 'kuku besi'. The Telegram channel Edisi Siasat 2, which just started breathing two days ago and already hit over 100,000 subscribers, got buried yesterday after they managed to drop one post (complete with a phone number) of Communications Minister Fahmi Fadzil. The minister had joined the channel the night before, creating a flurry of comments on the channel. Rejim kuku besi non bukan main lagi ganas sekarang. Channel Telegram Edisi Siasat 2 – yang baru sempat bernafas dua hari lepas & dah cecah lebih 100 ribu subscribers – pun dah kena benam semalam selepas mereka sempat buat satu posting (siap dengan nombor telefon) bahawa Pahmee… — Naratif Rakyat 🇲🇾 (@NaratifRakyat) June 21, 2025 A critic of the Madani regime who is also a whistleblower had this to say: 'Edisi Siasat existed as a critic of government institutions since the Muhyiddin government, and look which kuku besi is trying to silence it.' Edisi Siasat existed as Government institutions' critic since Muhyiddin government and look which kuku besi is trying to silence it. — FreeMalaysian (@FreeMsian) June 19, 2025 Note that in the years before Anwar took power, the words 'kuku besi' were used against the Najib regime. — June 21, 2025
Focus Malaysia
4 hours ago
- Focus Malaysia
Rafizi to speak freely, unbound by ministerial post
FORMER economy minister and PKR MP Rafizi Ramli stated on his podcast 'Yang Berhenti Menteri' that he would rather resign from the Cabinet than remain a 'lame duck' minister unable to voice differing opinions. Now that he is free to voice differing opinions, he took a swipe at the Education Ministry, questioning, 'Where's the major policy framework (from the ministry)? But they're busy talking about someone who resigned.' He said their bickering about his resignation annoyed him, and after two years and a half, the ministry in question has nothing to show. He stepped down after losing the PKR deputy presidency to Nurul Izzah Anwar, Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim's daughter, believing it signalled Anwar's lack of confidence in his leadership. Rafizi argued that staying on as a minister in the Cabinet of Anwar would undermine his legitimacy, hinder economic reforms, and make him complicit in the toxic political culture he opposes. He rejected an offer to be an appointed deputy president, seeing it as a way to silence him while exploiting his supporters. Rafizi emphasised the need for space for dissent within PKR to uphold reform principles and warned against dismissing grassroots members, indirectly criticising PKR figures like Fadhlina Sidek and R Ramanan for overlooking the party's history and supporters. He highlighted achievements in the Economy Ministry but noted the 13th Malaysia Plan and Anti-Rent Seeking Act as unfinished initiatives. While denying plans to form a new party, Rafizi humorously mentioned a gathering to 'celebrate' his loss, focusing on maintaining government stability. — June 21, 2025
Malay Mail
6 hours ago
- Malay Mail
PKR denies new IGP Mohd Khalid is party member, calls out inaccurate report
KUALA LUMPUR, June 21 — PKR has clarified that the newly appointed Inspector-General of Police (IGP), Datuk Seri Mohd Khalid Ismail, has never been a member of PKR, let alone held any position within the party, contrary to claims published on the social media page of a local news outlet yesterday. In a statement today, PKR secretary-general Dr Fuziah Salleh said that the circulation of an inaccurate profile linking the IGP to a political party could undermine his image and credibility, adding that it could also fuel negative perceptions of PKR as the ruling party if members of the public believe that Mohd Khalid's appointment was politically motivated. She emphasised that such an error should never have occurred and urged the news outlet to conduct an internal inquiry. Fuziah also included an attachment listing the names of Kedah State Leadership Council chairpersons according to their respective years of appointment. 1999 — Tan Sri Johari Abdul 1999 - Datuk Sheikh Azmi Ahmad 2000 - Tan Sri Johari Abdul 2004 - Akashah Ismail 2005 - Tan Sri Johari Abdul 2007 - Datuk Zamri Yusuf 2008 - Datuk Ahmad Kasim 2010 - Datuk Wan Salleh Wan Isa 2013 - Tan Sri Johari Abdul 2014 - Dr Azman Ismail 2018 — Tan Sri Johari Abdul 2022 - Nurul Izzah Anwar 2023 - Nurin Aina Abdullah Mohd Khalid, 60, who was appointed as the 15th IGP effective yesterday, has held various important positions in the Royal Malaysia Police Special Branch, including Chief of the Pahang Special Branch from May 25, 2018, before being appointed as the Bukit Aman Special Branch principal assistant director on Sept 6, 2021. — Bernama
