India weighs plan to slash Pakistan water supply with new Indus river project
FILE PHOTO: Fishermen clear a fishing net in the water on the partially dried up riverbed of the Indus River in Hyderabad, Pakistan April 25, 2025. REUTERS/Yasir Rajput/File Photo
NEW DELHI/ISLAMABAD - India is considering plans to dramatically increase the water it draws from a major river that feeds Pakistani farms downstream, as part of retaliatory action for a deadly April attack on tourists that New Delhi blames on Islamabad, according to four people familiar with the matter.
Delhi suspended its participation in the Indus Waters Treaty of 1960, which governs usage of the Indus river system, shortly after 26 civilians in Indian Kashmir were killed in what India called an act of terror. Pakistan has denied involvement in the incident, but the accord has not been revived despite the two nuclear-armed neighbours agreeing a ceasefire last week following the worst fighting between them in decades.
After the April 22 attack, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi ordered officials to expedite planning and execution of projects on the Chenab, Jhelum and Indus rivers, three bodies of water in the Indus system that are designated primarily for Pakistan's use, six people told Reuters.
One of the key plans under discussion involves doubling to 120km the length of the Ranbir canal on the Chenab, which runs through India to Pakistan's agricultural powerhouse of Punjab, two of the people said. The canal was built in the 19th century, long before the treaty was signed.
India is permitted to draw a limited amount of water from the Chenab for irrigation, but an expanded canal - which experts said could take years to construct - would allow it to divert 150 cubic meters of water per second, up from about 40 cubic meters currently, the four people said, citing official discussions and documents they had seen.
Details of the Indian government's deliberations on expanding Ranbir have not previously been reported. The discussions started last month and continue even after the ceasefire, one of the people said.
The Indian ministries responsible for water and foreign affairs, as well as Modi's office, did not respond to Reuters' questions. Indian hydropower giant NHPC, which operates many projects in the Indus system, also did not respond to an email seeking comment.
Modi said in a fiery speech this week that "water and blood cannot flow together," though he didn't refer to the treaty. Indian foreign ministry spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal told reporters Tuesday that India "will keep the treaty in abeyance until Pakistan credibly and irrevocably abjures its support for cross-border terrorism".
The water and foreign ministries of Pakistan did not respond to requests for comment. Foreign Minister Ishaq Dar told lawmakers this week that the government had written to India arguing that suspending the treaty was unlawful and that Islamabad regarded it as remaining in force.
Islamabad said after India suspended the treaty in April that it considered "any attempt to stop or divert the flow of water belonging to Pakistan" to be an "act of war."
About 80% of Pakistani farms depend on the Indus system, as do nearly all hydropower projects serving the country of some 250 million.
Any efforts by Delhi to build dams, canals or other infrastructure that would withhold or divert significant amount of flow from the Indus system to India "would take years to realize," said water security expert David Michel of the Washington-based Center for Strategic and International Studies.
But Pakistan has had a preview of the kind of pressure it could face from India: Water at a key receiving point in Pakistan briefly fell by as much as 90% in early May after India started maintenance work on some Indus projects.
SUCCESS THREATENED
The Indus system runs through some of the world's most geopolitically tense areas, originating near Lake Mansarovar in Tibet and snaking through India's north and Pakistan's east and southeast, before emptying into the Arabian Sea.
The treaty is widely seen as one of the world's most successful water-sharing accords, having survived several major wars and longstanding tensions between India and Pakistan.
Islamabad has previously opposed many Indian projects in the Indus system, while Delhi said after the Kashmir attack that it had been trying to renegotiate the treaty since 2023 to account for population increases and its rising need for clean hydroenergy.
The treaty restricts India largely to setting up low-impact hydropower projects on the three rivers allocated to Pakistan. Delhi has freedom to utilize the waters of three other rivers - the Sutlej, Beas and Ravi tributaries - as it sees fit.
Alongside the plans to expand Ranbir canal, India is also considering projects that would likely reduce the flow of water into Pakistan from rivers allocated to that country, according to two government documents seen by Reuters and interviews with five people familiar with the matter.
One document, an undated note prepared by a government company for officials considering irrigation plans, suggests that water from the Indus, Chenab and Jhelum "potentially be distributed into rivers" in three northern Indian states.
One of the people said the document, the details of which haven't been previously reported, was created for discussions with power ministry officials after the April 22 attack.
Delhi has also created a list of hydropower projects in its Jammu and Kashmir territory that it hopes will expand capacity to 12,000 megawatts, up from the current 3,360 MW.
The list, which was created by the power ministry and seen by Reuters, was not dated. A person familiar with the document said it was created before the Kashmir incident but is actively being discussed by government officials.
The prospective projects also include dams that can store large volumes of water, in what would be a first for India in the Indus river system, according to two people familiar with the matter.
India has identified at least five possible storage projects, four of which are on tributaries of the Chenab and Jhelum, according to the power ministry document.
POLITICAL WRANGLING
The Himalayan region of Kashmir is claimed by both India and Pakistan, though each controls only parts of the area.
The region has been ravaged by an anti-India insurgency for decades, which Delhi has accused Islamabad of fuelling and funding. Pakistan denies the charges.
International relations expert Happymon Jacob at Delhi's Jawaharlal Nehru University said that India's new focus on the Indus Waters Treaty reflected an attempt to pressure Pakistan over Kashmir.
"With the latest conflict, Delhi may refuse to discuss Kashmir with Pakistan in any format," he said. "Delhi has not only progressively narrowed the scope of bilateral talks but has also curtailed the agenda, focusing only on specific issues like the IWT."
Pakistan has said that it is preparing legal action in several international forums, including the World Bank, which facilitated the treaty, as well as the Permanent Court of Arbitration or the International Court of Justice in the Hague.
"Water should not be weaponised," Pakistan's Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb told Reuters on Monday. "We don't even want to consider any scenario which ... does not take into account the reinstatement of this treaty."
Michel, the U.S.-based expert, said that concern over the treaty's suspension was not limited to Islamabad.
"As geopolitical competition across the region deepens, more than a few Indian observers fear that Delhi's use of water against Islamabad risks licensing Beijing to adopt the same strategy against India," he said. REUTERS
Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
19 minutes ago
- Straits Times
US urges China to keep Iran from shutting key trade route
US Secretary of State Marco Rubio urged China on June 22 to help deter Iran from shutting down the Strait of Hormuz, a crucial trade route. PHOTO: REUTERS US urges China to keep Iran from shutting key trade route Follow our live coverage here. US Secretary of State Marco Rubio urged China on June 22 to help deter Iran from shutting down the Strait of Hormuz, a crucial trade route, following American strikes on Iranian nuclear sites. 'I encourage the Chinese government in Beijing to call them about that because they heavily depend on the Strait of Hormuz for their oil,' Mr Rubio said on Fox News. Analysts have said Iran may opt to retaliate to Washington's attack earl y on June 22 by shutting the Strait, a waterway through which one-fifth of global oil output passes. 'If they do that, it will be another terrible mistake. It's economic suicide for them if they do it, and we retain options to deal with that,' Mr Rubio added. 'But other countries should be looking at that as well, it would hurt other countries' economies a lot worse than ours. It would be, I think, a massive escalation that would merit a response. Not just by us but from others,' he said. Meanwhile, Iran has threatened bases used by the US military, with an advisor to Iran's supreme leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei saying they will be considered a 'legitimate target for our armed forces'. However, it remains to be seen whether the US strikes will push Tehran to de-escalate the conflict or to widen it further. China has joined Russia and a chorus of Arab states in condemning the US attacks, saying that they 'escalate tensions in the Middle East'. AFP Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
AsiaOne
27 minutes ago
- AsiaOne
Pakistan condemns Trump's bombing of Iran - a day after nominating him for Peace Prize, Asia News
ISLAMABAD — Pakistan condemned on Sunday (June 22) the strikes ordered on its neighbour Iran by Donald Trump, a day after Islamabad had said it would nominate the US President for the Nobel Peace Prize. Pakistan on Sunday said Trump's decision to bomb Iranian nuclear facilities violated international law and that diplomacy was the only way to resolve the Iran crisis. "The unprecedented escalation of tension and violence, owing to ongoing aggression against Iran is deeply disturbing. Any further escalation of tensions will have severely damaging implications for the region and beyond," Pakistan's Ministry of Foreign Affairs said. Also on Sunday, Pakistan's Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif telephoned Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian and "conveyed Pakistan's condemnation of the US attacks," a statement from the Pakistani leader said. Pakistan's information minister and the foreign ministry did not respond to requests for comment on the apparent contradiction in the country's positions over the weekend. In Pakistan's biggest city, Karachi, thousands marched in protest against the US and Israeli strikes on Iran. A large American flag with a picture of Trump on it was placed on the road for demonstrators to walk over. The protesters shouted out chants against America, Israel and Pakistan's regional enemy India. Pakistan on Saturday said it was nominating Trump as "a genuine peacemaker" for his role in bringing a four-day conflict with India to an end last month. It said he had "demonstrated great strategic foresight and stellar statesmanship". [[nid:719377]]
Straits Times
28 minutes ago
- Straits Times
UK aircraft carrier docks at Marina Bay Cruise Centre in first formal port call in the region
People watch as Britain's HMS Prince of Wales aircraft carrier arrives at Marina Bay Cruise Centre on June 23. PHOTO: REUTERS A F-35 aircraft is parked onboard Britain's HMS Prince of Wales aircraft carrier as it arrives at Marina Bay Cruise Centre on June 23. PHOTO: REUTERS A military band performs as Britain's HMS Prince of Wales aircraft carrier arrives at Marina Bay Cruise Centre on June 23. PHOTO: REUTERS UK aircraft carrier docks at Marina Bay Cruise Centre in first formal port call in the region SINGAPORE - British aircraft carrier HMS Prince of Wales, one of the largest warships in the world, has docked at the Marina Bay Cruise Centre. The carrier, whose flight deck is large enough to fit three football pitches, is making its first formal port call in the region at the head of a group of ships on a multi-nation, UK-led deployment. While docked in Singapore, the warship will play host to some 8,000 members of the public who balloted for free tickets earlier in the year, as well as a series of activities. This includes a defence and security industry day, where some 30 UK businesses will hold an expo in the carrier's hanger, as well as a science and technology symposium where experts from both countries will discuss technological developments. The carrier will also host panel discussions on defence and security, and a friendly e-sports tournament between UK and Singapore soldiers. The arrival of the HMS Prince of Wales is a critical demonstration of the UK's commitment to the Indo-Pacific, said British High Commissioner Nikesh Mehta. The visit comes amid a tumultuous global environment, where there is a 'need to demonstrate the importance of stability around the world, stability in the Indo-Pacific, and stability in the Euro-Atlantic', Mr Mehta said at a media briefing on June 19 ahead of the carrier's arrival. Britain's position is that stability in the Indo-Pacific and in the Euro-Atlantic are indivisible, he added. 'You can't have one without the other, and that's why the carrier strike group coming to this part of the world is so important.' The aircraft carrier is the flagship of the UK carrier strike group, which includes several other UK Royal Navy vessels, as well as ships from Canada, Norway and Spain, amongst others. Its visit to Singapore is part of an eight month deployment called Operation Highmast that departed from the UK in April, with the ships sailing from the Atlantic to the Pacific. Its route has included the Mediterranean, and along the way the group has conducted joint exercises, such as with the Indian Navy. The HMS Prince of Wales is one of two aircraft carriers currently operated by UK Navy – two of the largest ever built for the service, with a displacement of 65,000 tonnes and measuring 284m in length. It can carry up to 1,600 soldiers and 36 advanced F-35B fighter jets and four Merlin Helicopters. Its sister ship, the HMS Queen Elizabeth, visited Singapore in 2021, as part of the deployment of the UK's first carrier strike group. A F-35 aircraft is parked onboard Britain's HMS Prince of Wales aircraft carrier as it arrives at Marina Bay Cruise Centre on June 23. PHOTO: REUTERS Visit marks 'momentous' year for Singapore-UK relations: ambassador Besides Singapore, the HMS Prince of Wales is set to visit several other ports in the region including Indonesia, Japan and South Korea, and will take part in several joint exercises, including with the Singapore Armed Forces. In July, the carrier is set to join Exercise Talisman Sabre, an Australia-led exercise involving the US and other regional militaries. On its way back to home waters in September, it will participate in the Five Power Defence Arrangements' (FDPA) signature annual exercise, Bersama Lima. The FPDA consists of the Australia, Malaysia, New Zealand, Singapore, and the UK, and was established in 1971 when the British left the city state. The last time a UK aircraft carrier joined the FPDA's drills was in 1997, when HMS Invincible participated in Exercise Flying Fish, the first time the grouping conducted a combined maritime and air exercise. Head of the British Defence Staff for South-east Asia Colonel Eddie Maskell-Pedersen said HMS Prince of Wales' visit to Marina Bay is the latest in a series of security exchanges between the UK and Singapore this year. There have been reciprocal visits from senior military leadership on both sides, and in May Singapore frigate RSS Formidable docked in London's Canary Wharf, he noted. '(This) provides a clear statement of the importance of the relationship between the UK and Singapore: the partnership we have had, we are moving towards, and hopefully the momentum we would like to continue as partners for the future,' he said on June 19. In response to a question on the carrier's agenda and the UK's security involvement in the region, Col Maskell-Pederson, who is also the UK's defence advisor to Singapore, said Britain is not new to South-east Asia or to exercising in it. 'That's why our contribution, our commitment to FPDA since 1971 for 54 years now, is so important,' he said. 'And that's why the carrier strike group, and elements thereof, will participate in Exercise Bersama Lima because it's an important relationship. It's an important partnership that we are part of, and we want to continue to be committed to that.' A military band performs as Britain's HMS Prince of Wales aircraft carrier arrives at Marina Bay Cruise Centre on June 23. PHOTO: REUTERS At the same briefing, UK Trade Commissioner for Asia Pacific Martin Kent said the visit highlights the UK's commitment to building 'mutual prosperity and security in this region'. The UK is working with partners in the Indo-Pacific to promote and protect the international rules-based order, he added. He said: 'With defense and security exports to the Asia Pacific region worth over 2.1 billion pounds ($3.6 million) in 2023 our commitment to this region is both substantial and enduring.' Mr Mehta, the ambassador, said the carrier's arrival is a 'vital cog' in a 'momentous' year for Singapore-UK relations. The two countries are celebrating 60 years of diplomatic relations, which the visit also commemorates. Join ST's WhatsApp Channel and get the latest news and must-reads.
