Don't make accusations without basis, Dr Wee tells Armizan

KUALA LUMPUR: Amendments to the Control of Supplies (Amendment) Act 2021 (Act 122) was never about regulating the use of subsidised liquefied petroleum gas (LPG), says Datuk Seri Dr Wee Ka Siong.
The MCA President, who referred to the 2021 parliamentary Hansards, said the amendments only gave wider enforcement powers to Domestic Trade and Cost of Living Ministry officers.
He said the amendments were debated by numerous MPs before it was passed in Parliament in 2021.
"Not a single MP mentioned the permit for three subsidised LPG gas cylinders and the use of commercial LPG for restaurants," Dr Wee said in a video posted on social media on Sunday (June 8).
He said when then-domestic trade and cost of living minister Datuk Seri Alexander Nanta Linggi gave a Parliament reply in March 2022, he never mentioned regulations about subsidised gas cylinders.
"Datuk Armizan Mohd Ali, you were not at the Dewan Rakyat then but you could have checked the Hansard – do your homework before accusing me," he said.
Armizan, who is Domestic Trade and Cost of Living Minister, had claimed that the law where eateries are required to use 14kg commercial LPG cylinders, was passed when Dr Wee was part of the Cabinet in 2021.
"Maybe the regulations on the use of gas in subsidised gas cylinders not exceeding 42kg was an internal ministerial order, or it could be an instruction from the administration," he said.
Dr Wee added that the law was never enforced until the first Pakatan Harapan government in 2019.
"During early 2019, the domestic trade and consumer affairs minister issued orders making it compulsory for restaurants, coffee shops and hawkers to use commercial LPG.
"But Chong Chieng Jen, who was the deputy minister then, announced a postponement of that policy following concerns food prices may go up.
"And now, they are trying to enforce it again under the Madani government in 2025," he said.
Dr Wee also demanded an apology from Armizan.
"You should apologise to me for your carelessness," he said, adding he was acting as "the spokesman of the people".
On Thursday (June 5), Armizan said small and micro-scale food and beverage operators would be exempt from enforcement under the Ops Gasak.
Ops Gasak, which began on May 1 until Oct 31, is meant to curb illegal activities such as decanting (transferring gas from subsidised LPG cylinders to non-subsidised ones), smuggling and the misuse of subsidised LPG by medium and large-scale industrial sectors.
Dr Wee said Ops Gasak should have focused on large-scale operations and at borders – not petty traders and hawkers.
The Ayer Hitam MP also said consumers would ultimately bear the cost of eateries using LPG for commercial use, which costs 170% more than subsidised gas for domestic purposes.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

The Star

7 hours ago

• The Star

Tax, transport and juice: Triple blow could spike imported fruit prices, traders warn

KUALA LUMPUR: Consumers may soon be paying significantly more for imported fruits following a series of cost increases from July 1, traders say. Kuala Lumpur Fruits Wholesalers Association president Chin Nyuk Moy said importers were bracing to get hit on three fronts: a 5% sales and service tax (SST) on imported fruits, a 30% increase in freight charges at Port Klang, and higher electricity tariffs in Peninsular Malaysia. "Port Klang will implement increased container handling and storage fees. "Along with the SST and rising base electricity tariffs in Peninsular Malaysia on July 1, these changes are set to escalate operating expenses," she told a press conference on Monday (June 23). ALSO READ: Food for thought on revised SST Chin added that many imported fruits are also subject to import duties of between 5% and 30%, depending on their origin and type. 'Fruits from countries such as Thailand, South Africa and the United States still incur import taxes. With everything added up, we can't imagine how much apples, oranges, pears and grapes will cost after July 1,' she said. Electricity costs are a major concern for cold storage operators, with Chin citing her own facility's monthly bill of around RM60,000. 'That's a significant burden. SST also applies to transport and electricity,' she said. Fruit sales typically peak on the 1st and 15th of the lunar calendar months, but she warned that rising costs could dampen demand. 'We're under immense pressure. Fruits aren't luxury items, they're daily necessities. Vegetables are exempt from SST, and we believe fruits should be too. You can't replace apples with cucumbers,' she said. ALSO READ: MCA urges government to drop 5% tax on imported fruits, calls for stakeholder consultation Chin pointed out that fruits such as avocados, once considered premium, are now commonplace in supermarkets. 'Fruits are vital for people of all ages. They promote good health. It's unjust to treat them as luxury goods,' she said. She also expressed uncertainty over how consumers will respond from July. "If people begin cutting back, we will be forced to reduce imports. Our profit margins are already razor-thin, and we still have to cover labour and operating costs," she said. Chin said importers try to source from more affordable countries, but even then, supply is shrinking with Australia producing less, the United States reducing imports, and exchange rates against importers. 'Chinese apples have also gone up. A box that used to cost RM50 or RM60 now costs RM100. For oranges, we've turned to Egypt and the Middle East for better value,' she added. ALSO READ: Basic needs exempted from revised SST to protect vulnerable households, says Treasury sec-gen Northern Kuala Lumpur Traders Association president Ong Mok Hooi said small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) are already under pressure and cannot shoulder more costs. 'SMEs are the backbone of the economy. Expanding the SST to cover imported fruits at a time of economic uncertainty only adds to our burdens. "If business keeps declining, why are we hiring so many workers? 'If the government truly wants to support SMEs, it should focus on that, not waste money on white elephant projects,' Ong said. Wholesaler Khiew Yoon Chin said consumers used to be able to buy 3kg of fruit for RM10, but after last year's diesel hike, that now only gets them 2kg – and with the expansion of the SST, it may soon be even less. ALSO READ: PMO: Tax expansion vital to ensure fiscal sustainability He noted that fruits were not taxed under the previous goods and services tax (GST) regime but now are, under the expanded SST. 'Businesses are already grappling with income tax, PERKESO contributions, rising transport costs and new e-invoicing rules. "The government should consider the needs of the people. Fruits are rich in vitamins and essential for health – even GST didn't tax them,' he said. Under the expanded SST, a 5% tax will be imposed on all imported fruits, while locally grown produce will remain exempt. For example, strawberries from Cameron Highlands will remain tax-free, but imported varieties will be subject to SST.

The Star

8 hours ago

• The Star

MCA urges government to drop 5% tax on imported fruits, calls for stakeholder consultation

KUALA LUMPUR: The government should withdraw the 5% sales tax on imported fruits and engage stakeholders in consultations to assess the real impact of the tax expansion. MCA vice-president Datuk Lawrence Low said the move to impose tax on imported fruits such as apples, oranges, pears and grapes widely consumed by Malaysians would place an unfair burden on consumers and small traders. 'These are not luxury items. Fruits are part of the daily diet for many families and are used in religious and cultural practices. Taxing them will raise costs at every level and directly impact the rakyat,' he said at a press conference on Monday (June 23). Low said that while the government promotes healthy eating, taxing essential imported fruits sends a contradictory message, particularly as many of these fruits are not produced locally in sufficient quantities. 'We support the consumption of local produce, but Malaysia's climate doesn't allow for large-scale cultivation of temperate fruits. Apples and oranges, for example, remain staples in most households.' Low, who is also the MCA's economic and SME affairs committee chairman, warned that from July 1, small businesses will face increased operational costs, including expansion on SST, a hike in freight charges at Port Klang, and higher electricity tariffs. 'This does not help SMEs. If retailers absorb the added cost, they will face high operating costs; if they pass it on, the consumer pays more. Either way, it adds pressure.' 'Small traders are already struggling to comply with e-invoicing and other regulatory requirements. This tax is like death by a thousand cuts — it's affecting their ability to survive,' he said. Low highlighted that fruits such as apples and grapes are commonly used during festivals and ancestral prayers, while dates (kurma) hold cultural significance for the Malay community. He stressed that such fruits are everyday essentials, not luxuries. 'There's a misconception that imported fruits are only for the wealthy. But they're part of our food culture — found in supermarkets and wet markets alike. Everyone, regardless of income, consumes them.' He said MCA had received many calls from traders and the public expressing concern over rising costs and frustration with what they see as unfair taxation. 'This is not about rejecting taxation — it's about doing it wisely. The government must take a long-term view and avoid policies that erode public trust.' Low reiterated MCA's call for the SST to be replaced with a streamlined Goods and Services Tax (GST) at a lower rate of 3% to 4%, to avoid cascading taxes and improve transparency. 'MCA will continue to be a voice for the people. We stand with those struggling under the rising cost of living and will keep conveying their concerns to the government,' he said. On June 9, the government announced a targeted review of the SST rate, which will take effect from July 1. The sales tax rate will remain the same for essential goods, while a rate of 5% or 10% will be imposed on non-essential or discretionary goods. At the same time, the scope of the service tax has also been expanded to cover six new services, namely rental or leasing, construction, finance, private healthcare, education and beauty.

Daily Express

11 hours ago

• Daily Express

What's happening with ‘BMW-class' smart toilets, Ti asks Nga

Published on: Monday, June 23, 2025 Published on: Mon, Jun 23, 2025 By: Sean Augustin, FMT Text Size: Former MCA vice-president Ti Lian Ker said housing and local government minister Nga Kor Ming owed the public an explanation. PETALING JAYA: Former MCA vice-president Ti Lian Ker has demanded an update from housing and local government minister Nga Kor Ming on the minister's initiative to turn four public toilets into smart toilets. Ti said there had not been any progress report after Nga announced in November that an additional RM4 million had been allocated for the toilets to be built in four locations in Kuala Lumpur and Putrajaya. 'It isn't a paltry sum, which is why the ministry owes the tax-paying public an update,' he said. Ti said the public needed toilets that were clean and functioning. However he questioned the need to spend RM4 million on four toilets at a time when the people were grappling with the increasing cost of living. 'This money could be put into better use by providing low cost housing for the needy. We should not be tone deaf to the plight of the hard-core poor by replacing their needs for shelter with million dollar toilets,' he said. Last year, Nga said funds were allocated to construct two 'BMW-i' or Bersih, Menawan, Wangi (clean, attractive, and fragrant) smart toilets each in Kuala Lumpur and Putrajaya, with such features as built-in automatic bidets, automatic floor-cleaning machines, and automatic doors for people with disabilities. Advertisement Ti said today: 'We don't need no BMW-class toilets. We need functional and easy to maintain toilets instead of high class toilets with higher end maintenance.' He said a recent outcry over a MyKiosk project by Nga's ministry had made it even more urgent for an update on the toilet scheme. In May, Selangor MCA Youth filed a complaint calling for an investigation into the project's funding and execution. In response, Nga dismissed allegations that the initiative was a white elephant. Under the plan, standardised trading spaces will be provided for rent by the B40 group and small traders. * Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel and Telegram for breaking news alerts and key updates! * Do you have access to the Daily Express e-paper and online exclusive news? Check out subscription plans available. Stay up-to-date by following Daily Express's Telegram channel. Daily Express Malaysia