Major projects bill amended to remove cabinet power to sidestep Indian Act

The federal government's major projects legislation was amended by opposition parties on Wednesday to withdraw the power the bill gave cabinet to sidestep the Indian Act, following weeks of criticism from First Nations leaders.
But Assembly of First Nations National Chief Cindy Nepinak Woodhouse said Thursday the 'limited changes' made to the bill don't go far enough. She still wants the government to give members of Parliament more time to study the legislation.
The Liberal government's controversial legislation, which would allow cabinet to quickly grant federal approvals for big industrial projects like mines, ports and pipelines, was introduced on June 6, and sailed through the committee study in about eight hours on Tuesday and Wednesday.
Amendments to the bill made in committee include removing the Indian Act from a list of laws the government can sidestep when determining whether a project should move forward.
Story continues below advertisement
Bloc Québécois MP Xavier Barsalou-Duval said in a media statement the change came from a sub-amendment his party posed, and that the Liberals did not vote in favour of it.
Get breaking National news
For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy
In French, Barsalou-Duval said he regrets that the Liberals didn't vote for the amendment, but he is pleased it passed.
From the moment the bill was first discussed, First Nations leaders warned the bill could violate their constitutionally protected rights.
First Nations leaders also said Ottawa could face legal challenges, and its fast-tracked projects could be slowed down, if Indigenous communities are not meaningfully consulted.
1:54
More pushback for Bill C-5 from Indigenous groups
Some First Nations leaders are warning of a wave protests if the bill doesn't fundamentally change. Prime Minister Mark Carney said respect for section 35 of the Constitution, which recognizes and protects treaty rights is 'at the heart of this legislation.'
Story continues below advertisement
He said it's also important that the bill doesn't approve projects, it just 'creates the possibility of these projects,' which must undergo 'full consultation with Indigenous Peoples to define what is a nation-building project.'
'And then, if something is one of those projects, then what are the conditions in order for that project to move forward, including participation — obviously, I would think, in almost every case, environmental, other conditions — and then only if those conditions are met would the project move forward.'
Woodhouse Nepinak said it appears some other 'constructive suggestions' to amend the bill were voted down.
'These limited changes don't go far enough and were developed without input from rights-holders. We continue to call on Parliament to honour the Crown and have a full discussion with rights-holders before passing the bill, instead of ramming it through in a week,' she said.
'We will continue monitoring the debate closely and will have more to say as the situation develops.'
The legislation, which has support from the opposition Conservatives, is expected to pass Friday.
— With files from Michel Saba

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

CBC

2 hours ago

• CBC

Carney to hold meetings with Indigenous Peoples about major projects bill

Prime Minister Mark Carney says he plans to hold full-day summits with First Nations, Inuit and Métis leadership and experts this summer to make sure the government's major projects bill is implemented 'the right way.' The bill passed the House of Commons on Friday.

Global News

2 hours ago

• Global News

Welcome to šxʷməθkʷəy̓əmasəm Street: Vancouver unveils Musqueam langauge signs

Musqueam leaders and representatives of the City of Vancouver gathered on the city's west side on Friday to unveil the official signage for a street that has been renamed in the First Nation's language. The road, formerly named Trutch Street, now bears the name šxʷməθkʷəy̓əmasəm Street (pronounced sh-MUS-quee-um-AW-sum), which translates to Musqueamview in English. Signposts bear the English name below the official Musqueam name. 'It's a great feeling to actually see the name being changed, regardless of the political issue, just to see our language out in the public eye where people are living,' Musqueam elder Larry Grant, who manages the band's language and culture department, said. 'It's a really, really heartlifting feeling. Our youth can see it, we can see it, that our language is finally out in the open rather than stifled.' The street was formerly named after Joseph Trutch, B.C.'s first lieutenant governor, whose policies had devastating effects on Indigenous communities. Story continues below advertisement Trutch, who arrived in the province in 1859 and became B.C.'s chief commissioner of land and works in the 1860s, was considered an extreme racist. Vancouver Mayor Ken Sim called the new name an 'important milestone' in the city's ongoing journey towards truth and reconciliation with Indigenous peoples. 'The legacy of Joseph Trutch is one of harm. He was openly racist and actively worked to erase the rights of Indigenous peoples,' Vancouver Mayor Ken Sim said. Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy 'He dismissed the very existence of Indigenous title, stripped communities of their land, reduced the size of reserves, and helped entrance policies that caused lasting harm with effects we feel to this day. That's not a legacy we should commemorate on a street sign.' 1:58 Vandals put 'Truth' in Trutch Street ahead of official name change Trutch Street runs between 18th and 1st Avenues on the city's west side in the unceded traditional territories of the Musqueam people. Story continues below advertisement 'This day has been coming for over 10 years,' Musqueam Chief Wayne Sparrow told the crowd. Vancouver has gone through three mayors since the Musqueam first brought a request for the street's name to be changed. Council voted unanimously in 2021 to change the street's name, and the Musqueam gifted the new name to the city the following year. Sparrow acknowledged the new characters and the Musqueam hən̓q̓əmin̓əm̓ language may be a challenge for some people at first, but said it will be a process of learning together. 'One lady, when we were in a public hearing, they were upset it was in our language, and they were going to have a hard time pronouncing it. And I invited those individuals down to our celebration we are having at our community today, to come down and learn,' Sparrow said. 'Our ancestors were forced to speak English. They were forced to do away without language. And if we are walking reconciliation, we walk together. And we all have a part to learn our language, and we will get there.'' 2:11 B.C. mayors look to change street named after politician Sir Joseph Trutch As a next step, the city will be installing an audio box and an interpretive sign near šxʷməθkʷəy̓əmasəm Street at West Point Grey Road that provide more information about the new name, along with Joseph Trutch and why the name change happened. Story continues below advertisement Neighbour Patrick Purcell said the change will mean a bit of work around updating official documents for people who live on the street, but that the move was 'progress.' 'I think it's beautiful, and I think it's overdue … I am glad it shows the respect to Indigenous people they deserve,' he said. Sim said the city could look at renaming other streets in the future as a part of its efforts towards reconciliation.

Calgary Herald

3 hours ago

• Calgary Herald

Braid: With Bill C-5, some politicians say federal power is a great thing after all

Is that the House of Commons I'm watching, or a hacked broadcast from some other country? Post election realignment in the chamber is a spectacular display of mutating principles. Article content Article content Conservatives back the Liberals on Bill C-5, which gives the federal cabinet more power. Article content They spent the whole Justin Trudeau era complaining about every Liberal power grab. Now they support a significant centralization, because it promises a result they want. Article content Article content The New Democrats and Greens, great lovers of central power, suddenly don't want it at all. Article content Article content The bill is an 'abomination,' said Green Leader Elizabeth May, who once said Ottawa should have full wartime powers to fight climate change. Article content Bill C-5 itself is a vital tool for breaking down the many barriers to development created by Trudeau and his gang of zealots. Article content The Conservatives grit their teeth to support the bill. It's not easy seeing another government implement your policies. Article content For many years, every resource project that came before the Liberals was an environmental problem rather than an economic opportunity. Trudeau set Canada's economy back a full decade Article content The bill gives the federal cabinet extraordinary power to approve and speed up new projects. Prime Minister Mark Carney wants it slammed through before the national will for a new economy begins to fade. Article content Article content Fall could bring an entirely different mood in Canada, especially if he gets a good result on trade from U.S. President Donald Trump. Article content To that end, quick passage of the bill is supported by Alberta Premier Danielle Smith, and Premier Scott Moe in Saskatchewan. Article content Article content Smith brought in the Sovereignty Act. She fought the feds in court at every turn. Moe refused to collect federal tax on home heating fuel — an act branded criminal by Trudeau's crowd. Article content Now, the premiers are ready for more federal power, with some trepidation, because someday it might be used by a federal government even more hostile than Trudeau's.