France To Challenge Iran's Hostage Diplomacy Before The UN Top Court
The International Court of Justice (ICJ) in The Hague, Netherlands, on January 11, 2024. (Photo ... More credit: Dursun Aydemir/Anadolu via Getty Images)
On May 16, 2025, France filed an Application instituting proceedings against Iran before the International Court of Justice (ICJ) with regard to a dispute which, according to the Application, concerns 'serious and repeated breaches by Iran of its obligations under the [Vienna]
The Application, as submitted by France, specifically concerns Iran's detention of two French nationals, Ms Cécile Kohler and Mr Jacques Paris. As indicated by France, Ms Cécile Kohler, a modern literature teacher, and her companion, Mr Jacques Paris, a retired mathematics teacher, were on a tourist visa in Iran before they were arrested on May 8, 2022, by Iranian law enforcement. They have been accused of spying - charges which they have denied. They have been imprisoned ever since. It was not until June 18, 2022, that Iran officially informed France about the arrest of two French nationals. Over the last three years of their imprisonment, the two have only been able to speak with the French consular authorities on four occasions, during individual visits lasting an average of around ten minutes, which took place under very close surveillance and in restrictive conditions. Furthermore, France was effectively prevented from providing legal representation for Ms Cécile Kohler and Mr Jacques Paris. Despite its repeated requests, France has never been able to obtain substantial information on the ongoing legal proceedings concerning the two French nationals still detained in Iran.
France alleges that this 'hostage diplomacy' is being implemented with the specific aim of forcing France to perform or refrain from certain acts. This involves, paraphrasing the terms used in the 1979 International Convention against the Taking of Hostages, seeking to obtain a real or supposed counterpart as an 'explicit or implicit condition' for the release of the persons concerned.
With the Application to the ICJ, France seeks to found the Court's jurisdiction on Article 36 of the Statute of the Court, read in conjunction with Article I of the Optional Protocol to the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations concerning the Compulsory Settlement of Disputes of 24 April 1963, to which both France and Iran are parties.
France requests the ICJ to declare that Iran has failed, and continues to fail, to fulfill its obligations under Article 36 of the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations. France also requests the ICJ to order Iran to take all necessary measures without delay to put an end to these violations and to redress all their consequences. France further requests that Iran be ordered to refrain from taking any further measures that would constitute a violation of its obligations and to provide assurances and guarantees of non-repetition of such conduct.
This is an important step taken by France to challenge Iran's hostage diplomacy. Hostage diplomacy refers to the practice of strategic detention of foreign nationals by a state to pressure another government into making political or economic concessions. Over the years, Iran has used hostage diplomacy as a strategic foreign policy tool, toying with the lives of people. However, Iran is not alone in playing such games. Russia, North Korea, and China, among others, are common culprits of this State-level hostage taking. Some experts suggest that State-level hostage takings have increased in recent years. As such, the issue requires further attention. Engaging the ICJ on the issue is an important legal avenue for justice and accountability, and a tool in the toolbox that cannot be underestimated.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Fox News
an hour ago
- Fox News
Trump Keeps His Options Open
President Trump carefully weighs the consequences of a war with Iran as the clock ticks for the Ayatollah to make a deal. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit FOX News Radio
Washington Post
an hour ago
- Washington Post
Diplomatic breakthrough elusive as Israel-Iran war stretches into second week
TEL AVIV, Israel — Hours of talks aimed at de-escalating fighting between Israel and Iran failed to produce a diplomatic breakthrough as the war entered its second week with a fresh round of strikes between the two adversaries. European ministers and Iran's top diplomat met for four hours Friday in Geneva, as President Donald Trump continued to weigh U.S. military involvement and worries rose over potential strikes on nuclear reactors.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
James Carville Calls Out Fox News On Live TV For Playing Into This 'Giant Lie'
James Carville on Friday took on Fox News after host Martha MacCallum tried to push back at his criticism of President Donald Trump as he weighs U.S. military action against Iran amid Israel's war on the country. The longtime Democratic strategist, when asked about Trump's decision-making in a live Fox News appearance, reminded MacCallum of the network's history covering the lead-up to the U.S. invasion of Iraq (and the resulting war). 'I'm old enough to remember 2002 when this network and everybody else was beating war drums as loud as you could beat war drums, that there was every evidence of weapons of mass destruction. Of course, it turned out to be a giant lie,' he said of the Bush administration's pretext for the invasion. MacCallum interjected, 'You think this is like that?' Carville chimed back in, 'I don't know but I do know the government lied to me profoundly 22 years ago, that I do know, why would I trust this government more than I trust —.' MacCallum pointed to a clip she played earlier of David Albright, a nuclear weapons expert, who argued that there's not a sort of 'redux' of the Iraq War claims when it comes to the Iranian nuclear program. Carville jumped back in, 'Again, you are free to beat the war drums as loud as you want to —.' MacCallum replied, 'I'm not beating any war drums, I'm just reporting the facts.' Another panelist, OutKick founder Clay Travis, hopped into the crosstalk before Carville hit back. 'Excuse me for speaking while you're interrupting me,' Carville said. He later continued by noting that Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard testified to the Senate in March that Iran wasn't building a nuclear weapon, a comment that Trump has since dismissed. 'I think that he needs to take his time, they need to assess it and they need to give us a very clear rationale for why this step is necessary to start a war with 92 million people, that's all I'm saying,' added Carville of Trump, who has stressed that Iran is a matter of weeks away from completing a nuclear weapon. 'And that country has 92 million people, half have a college degree, half of those are women and I just don't think it's a good idea to rush headlong into a war. I'm sorry. I was skeptical in 2002 and I'm skeptical in 2025.' Carville: I'm old enough to remember in 2002 when this network was beating war drums as loud as you could beat war drums about WMDs— of course, it turned out to be a giant We just heard from an expert who said there's so much You are free to… — Acyn (@Acyn) June 20, 2025 Trump's Plan To Stop Harvard From Hosting Foreign Students Blocked CNN Data Chief Exposes How Trump Totally Lost This 'Political Battle' Trump Shuts Down Tulsi Gabbard On Iran: 'She's Wrong'
