On Allahabad High Court Judge's Impeachment, Congress Sends 'Reminder'
New Delhi:
The Congress on Friday 'reminded' Rajya Sabha Chair Jagdeep Dhankhar to act on a six-month-old notice to impeach an Allahabad High Court judge accused of making communal remarks.
The opposition party's nudge follows strong remarks by Rajya Sabha MP Kapil Sibal about Mr Dhankhar's lack of action in this matter. He also accused the government of trying to 'shield' the judge.
Justice Shekhar Kumar Yadav is staring down the barrel of an impeachment process after 55 MPs - five over the threshold to begin his removal - sent that notice to the House Chairperson.
At least 50 Rajya Sabha MPs must sign a motion - a record of the intention to impeach - for the matter to proceed further. In the Lok Sabha that number is 100.
NDTV Explains | How To Remove Sitting Supreme Court Or High Court Judge
Once that threshold is reached, the Chair of the former or the Speaker of the latter, depending on which House first admits the motion, will decide whether or not to carry the issue forward.
In this case the motion to impeach was submitted on December 13, 2024.
The file has been pending since, prompting Mr Sibal's sharp words and Congress' 'reminder'.
Mr Sibal, a senior advocate in the Supreme Court, pointed out swifter action had been taken in the case of Justice Yashwant Varma, the former Delhi High Court judge caught in the cash-at-home row.
Sources told NDTV the delay might be because 19-21 signatures on the motion had yet to be verified. Also, the possibility that one MP signed twice had to be ruled out, sources explained.
A detailed verification of these signatures is ongoing, sources said.
Mr Sibal, though, demanded to know why this process needs to take six months. "I want to ask those sitting in Constitutional posts... their responsibility is to verify if signatures are there... should that take six months? Is this government is trying to protect Shekhar Yadav," he was quoted by news agency PTI.
READ | Plea Against Justice Shekhar Yadav's Impeachment Motion Rejected
In January the Rajya Sabha's pending action on this matter had been challenged in the Allahabad High Court. A PIL demanded the court issue direction to the Rajya Sabha to not act on the proposed impeachment. However, the PIL was rejected because it did not constitue a public interest issue.
What Justice Shekhar Yadav Said
The judge was speaking at an event organised by the legal cell of right-wing Vishwa Hindu Parishad in Prayagraj on December 8, when he said, "I have no hesitation in saying that this is Hindustan... this country would function as per the wishes of the (majority)... This is the law."
READ | High Court Judge Says Law Works Per Majority, A Owaisi Reacts
His remarks (there were more, including comments on Islamic practices such as Halal and polygamy) were condemned by AIMIM MP Asaduddin Owaisi and others who asked how members of any minority community might expect justice from such a judge.
"In a democracy the minority's rights are protected... this speech raises questions... How can a minority expect justice before someone who participates in VHP programs?" he asked.
Supreme Court Acts But...
The Supreme Court took notice and directed the Allahabad High Court to provide details and, on December 17, the Collegium, headed by then Chief Justice Sanjiv Kumar heard from Justice Yadav, who argued the media had selectively quoted him to create 'unnecessary controversy'.
However, the Collegium refused his explanation and reprimanded the judge, reminding him the conduct of a judge is always under scrutiny and that he is expected to maintain a standard.
The Collegium, though, was blocked from taking further action because the MPs' impeachment motion had already been initiated; the letter to the Rajya Sabha was sent December 13.
According to Mr Sibal this was because the Rajya Sabha Secretariat wrote to then Chief Justice directing him to not take action against Justice Yadav becase of the pending impeachment notice.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
20 minutes ago
- India Today
Himanta Sarma claims 5,000 accounts from countries like Pak backing Congress
Assam Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma has alleged that around 5,000 Facebook accounts, mostly operated from Islamic countries like Pakistan and Bangladesh, have become active in the past one month and were posting content in favour of the said such foreign involvement ahead of the elections was concerning, and he had informed the Centre about to the media, Sarma said these accounts originated from countries like Pakistan, Bangladesh, Afghanistan, and were interacting with content related to the Assam Congress and one of its While Sarma did not name the Congress leader, he appeared to be referring to Gaurav Gogoi. Gogoi was appointed the Assam Congress president in from Islamic fundamentalist content, Sarma said pro-Palestine posts and remarks supporting Bangladesh's interim head Muhammad Yunus were being put out by these accounts."These accounts are not just politically aligned but are also propagating hardline Islamic content that does not resonate with the sentiments of indigenous Muslims in Assam," the Chief Minister further claimed that the Congress was highlighting interactions from these accounts to portray increased public support. He called this approach misleading and warned that such activity from foreign sources could harm India's democratic process, especially during also said there was information that some people from outside the state had rented houses in Guwahati and have connected with social media influencers for this Congress has not yet responded to the allegations, the Chief Minister called on national agencies to investigate what he described as "foreign involvement" in Assam Watch
News18
an hour ago
- News18
Pakistan, Bangladesh-based Social Media Accounts Boosting Assam Congress' Online, Says Himanta
Last Updated: Assam CM alleges over 5,000 foreign-run social media accounts are backing state Congress. Assam chief minister Himanta Biswa Sarma on Friday alleged that over 5,000 social media accounts run from Pakistan and Bangladesh and other Islamic nations are boosting the online presence of the state Congress unit. 'It is surprising that they do not comment on or like posts by Rahul Gandhi or even the Indian National Congress. They are only focused on a particular leader and the Assam Congress," Sarma was quoted as saying by news agency PTI. Himanta Biswa Sarma did not name the Assam Congress leader in question, but it appeared he was referring to Gaurav Gogoi, who took charge as the Assam Pradesh Congress Committee president in the last week of May. The Assam CM claimed that social media accounts from 47 countries, mostly from Pakistan and Bangladesh, have been unusually focused on Gogoi's activities and the state Congress unit's recent moves. He said this is the first time he saw 'so much foreign involvement in Assam politics". 'We are not concerned with the change in the party's leadership in the state, but this development has taken place in the last month and there must be some link. For the first time, there is so much foreign involvement in Assam politics in the run-up to the 2026 assembly elections," Sarma said. He said the issue is related to 'national security" and added that the government is not ruling out that 'some of the accounts may be from within the state". Sarma then revealed that he has 'ordered a forensic audit" of the accounts while pointing out that some of the 5,000 accounts are being run with their location marked as Guwahati. He also said these social media accounts, apart from posting about Assam politics, are also reportedly sharing content linked to Islamic fundamentalist causes, including pro-Palestine messaging, Iranian narratives and statements by Bangladesh's chief advisor Mohammad Yunus. He said a forensic audit revealed that 700 of the accounts originated from Bangladesh, 350 from Pakistan, 246 from Saudi Arabia, 86 from Kuwait and 35 from Afghanistan. First Published:
New Indian Express
an hour ago
- New Indian Express
5000 foreign social media accounts taking interest in Assam Congress: CM Himanta
GUWAHATI: Over 5,000 Facebook and other social media accounts, operated mostly from abroad, have suddenly become active around the activities of the Assam Congress and a particular political leader, Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma said on Friday. 'They have hard contents – pro-Palestine, pro-Iran, pro-Muhammad Yunus. These people are hardcore Islamic fundamentalists,' Sarma said, addressing a press conference. 'Interestingly, they do not follow Rahul Gandhi or the Indian National Congress. They like the pages concerning the activities of the political leader and the Assam Congress,' he said. Stating that the account holders are from a particular community, he said they were propagating the political party in the context of Assam. He added that the state government conducted a study on 2,092 accounts and the investigation is ongoing. According to him, the accounts are being operated from 47 countries, including Bangladesh and Pakistan. 'Apart from the posts on Assam, their contents are mainly on fundamentalist Islamic ideology. These include annihilation of Israel and anti-India contents,' the Chief Minister said.
