Wine critic in £180,000 court fight with dogsitter after beloved cockapoo hit by car
A top wine critic is suing a dogsitter after his beloved pet cockapoo was hit by a car while in her care.
Writer and renowned wine critic Harry Eyres is blaming Kendra Torgan for serious spinal injuries his dog, Ebony, suffered after being run over by an estate agent's car outside her home in Kensal Rise, London, in 2022.
Mr Eyres, 66, says he was forced to spend thousands on life-saving spinal reconstruction surgery for the dog, which he regards as a "beloved member of his family".
He is now trying to recoup the cost from Ms Torgan, who he blames for letting the cockapoo escape from her garden and into the road.
Mr Eyres is seeking up to £30,000 in damages at Central London County Court, with the case also set to run up more than £150,000 in legal costs.
But Torgan, a former actress who starred as a "beautiful female assassin" in 1998 British crime thriller Killing Time, denies the accident was her fault and blames the dog for its own injury.
Mr Eyres is a renowned wine critic, writing for publications including Country Life magazine. He is also an author and poet, formerly a theatre critic for The Times, wine editor for Harpers and Queen, and has penned columns for the Financial Times and The Spectator.
Ms Torgan acted in a series of films before setting up her pet business, which offers dog walking, puppy training, whispering and behavioural therapy.
Mr Eyres' lawyers say Ebony somehow 'wandered into the road' while being looked after by Ms Torgan at her then home in Ridley Road, Kensal Rise, in October 2022, and was then struck by a car being driven by an employee of estate agents Dexter's London Ltd.
The 66-year-old ex-Etonian claims Ms Torgan 'negligently failed to supervise the dog' and also 'failed to call the dog back once it left her side'.
The Dexter's driver took Ebony and Ms Torgan to an emergency vets' clinic, from where it was transferred to an animal hospital in Marlow for urgent treatment, court documents revealed.
Although Mr Eyres' pet survived the smash, it was found to have suffered a fractured spine which needed repeated reconstructive surgery, with metalwork and screws inserted to hold the broken bones together.
Mr Eyres, who is now suing the dogsitter for damages to cover the costs of Ebony's treatment, says he was left aghast when Ms Torgan allegedly wrote his lawyers an email suggesting "euthanasia" might be a cheaper option to surgery.
'In order to prevent the vertebrae from collapsing, a revision of the original spinal surgery needed to be performed on 30 March 2023, involving removal of the original implant and screws and their replacement with a new larger implant and 13 screws,' his lawyers say in the case papers.
'The dog's treatment remains ongoing.'
Mr Eyres' insurers have confirmed that they will not pay out any sums, he will say that the dog was left with Ms Torgan and she owed him a duty to take care of Ebony.
"She had gone on to suggest that he could have his dog - "prior to the incident healthy, and a beloved member of the family - euthanised rather than seeking treatment," they claim.
The wine critic is also suing the estate agents, but both Ms Torgan and Dexter's are denying blame for the accident.
Ms Torgan claims she should not be sued personally over the incident but rather that Mr Eyres should target her company, despite it having been dissolved in 2023.
Summarising the case, Dexter's barrister Caitlin Corrigan explained: 'Ms Torgan has not filed a defence but in correspondence has said that she should not be being sued as an individual, but rather her dissolved company."
She added that Ms Torgan is also claiming the accident was 'unforeseeable', as the dog took her by surprise when it suddenly wriggled out of her garden, having 'forced the gate open herself'.
Outside court after a brief pre-trial hearing at Central London County Court last week, Ms Torgan added of the incident: 'It was completely out of character as (Ebony) bolted out of the gate'.
For his part, the Dexter's driver insists he was driving with the utmost care and the company's lawyers claim their driver had no chance to avoid hitting the dog which shot out into the street, said their solicitor Elaine Everett.
'Dexter's will aver that (Ms Torgan) failed to control the dog in question, resulting in it suddenly running into the road.
'The driver was unable to safely stop the vehicle and swerving to avoid the dog would have been dangerous,' she added.
The pet payout fight reached court before Judge Daniel Bunting for a case management hearing during which lawyers argued over issues including the extent of the expert medical evidence to be heard.
Ms Torgan was present at court, but not represented by lawyers.
The loser in the fight could face a bill of more than £180,000, with £30,000 damages being sought and Mr Eyres' costs being budgeted at £112,390, while those of Dexter's are budgeted at £40,337.
The case will return for a full trial at a later date.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
32 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
Brit rising star becomes unexpected new frontrunner to play James Bond as race to be new 007 heats up
Industry insiders and bookmakers are taking serious notice of the new contender RACE GEARS UP Brit rising star becomes unexpected new frontrunner to play James Bond as race to be new 007 heats up A BRITISH rising star has become an unexpected new frontrunner to play James Bond as the race to be the new 007 heats up. Speculation over who will replace Daniel Craig in the iconic role has been heating up, and fans all have their own theories. 5 A British rising star has become an unexpected new frontrunner to play James Bond as the race to be the new 007 heats up Credit: Alamy 5 Aaron Pierre is emerging as a front runner for the iconic Bond role Credit: Shutterstock Editorial 5 The star is best known for his performances in The Underground Railroad and Rebel Ridge Credit: YouTube British actor Aaron Pierre, 31, is now emerging as a frontrunner for the iconic role. And industry insiders and bookmakers are taking serious notice of the new contender. Following a leak by industry insider Daniel Ritchman, it has been revealed Aaron is in talks for the role reported GBNews. Aaron is best known for his performances in The Underground Railroad, Rebel Ridge, and Disney's upcoming Mufasa: The Lion King. And rising betting odds are putting the young actor firmly in the frame for the coveted spot. Bookmakers now have Aaron gaining ground, as his odds narrow to place him alongside all the familiar contenders. Currently, Theo James leads the pack with odds of 5/2 followed by Henry Cavill at 3/1 and Jack Lowden at 4/1. While, Aaron Taylor‑Johnson, a huge favourite, has fallen to 5/1. Aaron, 34, fuelled rumours he'd bagged the role after signing a deal with Omega - the brand of watch the 007 spy wears. Omega has been supplying timepieces to the iconic literary and movie character since the release of 1995 flick, Golden Eye. For Your Eyes Only, Official Trailer The Sun told last year how Aaron had been offered the job - with insiders saying at the time Eon Productions were keen to snap him up. Despite that, still at the top is fellow Brit hunk Theo who fans are convinced will lead the race to victory. Meanwhile, Peaky Blinders actor Cillian Murphy is a current favourite to be named as the next 007 baddie. It's also been confirmed that Bond will still be a British man despite being sold to 'woke' Hollywood streaming site Amazon. Timeline of James Bond actors Over the years there have been seven actors who have played 007. The first ever James Bond film was in 1962, and this is who has played the lead role over the years: Sean Connery - The late star was the first ever actor to play Bond, and reprised the role for seven movies. George Lazenby - The star only played Bond once, but was the youngest actor to ever play the spy. Roger Moore - The late movie star spent 12 years making seven films in the famous franchise. Timothy Dalton - The smooth actor took over from Roger Moore and appeared in The Living Daylights and Licence to Kill. Pierce Brosnan - The handsome star played Bond for four movies from 1995 to 2002. Daniel Craig - The British star was the first blonde James Bond and the sixth actor to win the role in 2005. Before giving up ownership of the popular film franchise, 007's stewards Barbara Broccoli and Michael G Wilson insisted the spy would retain his nationality and gender. Barbara, who took over the Bond brand from company Eon Productions alongside Mr Wilson in 1995, made the arrangement before she agreed to sell the rights to Amazon in a £770million deal. Insiders have hit back at fears the streaming giant - owned by Jeff Bezos - will turn Bond 'woke'. An insider told the Mail on Sunday: 'Amazon is committed to keeping the spirit of Bond alive and that means he has to be British or from the Commonwealth - and he has to be male.' 5 Aaron Taylor-Johnson is thought to already have agreed to the Bond role Credit: Getty
Scottish Sun
an hour ago
- Scottish Sun
Tensions in Middle East ramp up as B-2 stealth bombers leave US for possible strike on Iranian targets
British and US warjets have previously helped shoot down Iranian missiles fired at Israel BOMBER THREAT Tensions in Middle East ramp up as B-2 stealth bombers leave US for possible strike on Iranian targets TENSIONS in the Middle East ramped up further yesterday as B-2 stealth bombers left the US for a possible strike on Iran. US president Donald Trump is believed to have signed off on a hit on the rogue state's underground atomic plant at Fordow. Advertisement 4 Middle East tensions rise as B-2 stealth bombers left the US for a possible strike on Iran Credit: Alamy 4 Missiles fired from Iran in retaliation for Israeli attacks Credit: Getty It came after a British national suspected of spying for Iran was arrested near an RAF base on Cyprus. Trump, who said on Thursday he would decide whether to join the offensive 'within two weeks', yesterday gave Israel free rein to continue attacking its enemy Iran. Meanwhile, B-2 bombers took off from the US and were thought to be heading to the Andersen Air Force Base on the Pacific island of Guam. The powerful B-2 Spirit is the only aircraft capable of delivering the GBU-57 Massive Ordnance Penetrator bombs needed to smash Iran's atomic site at Fordow, south of Tehran. Advertisement READ MORE ON IRAN IRON WILL Israel will keep bombing Iran even without Trump, says Netanyahu's ex-advisor Waves of attacks would be needed to destroy the plant, which is encased in steel under a mountain. Iran's 86-year-old Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei is also said to be sheltering in a bunker as Israel targets military leaders and nuclear facilities in his country. US officials last night said no orders had yet been given to move the B-2s beyond Guam. But it ramped up more pressure on Khamenei to cut a deal — with Trump demanding Iran scrap its nuclear and ballistic missile plans. Advertisement Meanwhile, a suspected spy linked to Iran was arrested amid fears he was spearheading a massive attack on UK forces in Cyprus. Sources said he was posing as a British tourist when he was detained near the RAF's Akrotiri base with a large camera with telephoto lenses. US deploys bunker-buster bomb carrying B-2 planes to new military base as Iran tensions grow He was also found to have three mobile phones when armed officers swooped on Friday. Police sources confirmed yesterday he was being held on suspicion of terror-related offences and espionage. Advertisement He is suspected to have links to Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps. Police swooped on him in the Zakaki suburb of Limassol. He has been in the country since April and is feared to have been mapping troops and jets. The Foreign Office confirmed he was a British national who is understood to be of Azerbaijani descent. Advertisement 4 The apparent remains of a ballistic missile lying on the ground in northern Israel Credit: Reuters Akrotiri — where hundreds of British pilots, troops and back-up staff are based — is just 200 miles from Israel and well within range of Iran's ballistic missile arsenal. Britain and the US have been warned by Khamenei that their bases will be hit if their forces join Israel. The suspect appeared before the Limassol District Court on Friday and was remanded in custody for eight days pending inquiries. Advertisement Cypriot sources said he was understood to have had the sprawling UK airbase 'under surveillance' and also watched Cyprus's own Andreas Papandreou Air Base in Paphos. Israel's foreign minister Gideon Sa'ar yesterday also claimed Iran tried to carry out an attack on Israeli citizens in Cyprus. Extra £3k in Persian MI5 jobs By Dominik Lemanski SPYMASTERS are offering £3,000 bonuses to recruit Persian speakers to tackle Iranian terror. Persian Language Specialists at MI5 and MI6 will support investigations to block Tehran-backed assassins and kidnappers. Recruits will be paid up to £44,818 with £3,000 a year extra on qualification. An advert, which is also hiring for GCHQ, reads: 'We're looking for Persian linguists for a role that goes well beyond translation and transcription. 'You will be a significant asset in helping to safeguard the UK.' In April last year, Iranian journalist Pouria Zeraati, 37, was stabbed in South West London, in an attack believed to have been ordered by Tehran. It was not known if it was linked to the Brit's arrest. Cyprus has become a transit point for stranded travellers since Israeli airspace was shut at the start of Operation Rising Lion nine days ago. Advertisement Britain has upped the number of RAF Typhoons at Akrotiri and sent extra Voyager air-to-air refuellers. British and US warjets have previously helped shoot down Iranian missiles fired at Israel. But Sir Keir Starmer's government has so far kept the RAF out of the war amid fears of further escalation. Meanwhile, Israel continued to hammer Iran with air attacks on military and atomic sites — as well as top brass and nuclear scientists. Advertisement Israel Defence Forces' biggest scalp yesterday was terror kingpin Saeed Izadi — the financial mastermind of the October 7 attacks which detonated the Middle East crisis. Izadi, head of the Palestinian Division of Iran's Quds Force, was killed in a strike on a 'safe house' in the Iranian city of Qom. The Israeli military's Chief of General Staff Eyal Zamir said: 'Izadi was one of the key figures involved in planning and executing the October 7 massacre. The blood of thousands of Israelis is on his hands.' 4 Israel's biggest scalp yesterday was terror kingpin Saeed Izadi Credit: @IDF Advertisement The Israeli military later said it killed another commander of the Guards' overseas arm, Benham Shariyari, in western Tehran. He was said to be 'responsible for weapons transfers from the Iranian regime to its proxies across the Middle East'. An 11th nuclear scientist was also assassinated at a safe house located by Israeli intelligence. Iran's foreign minister said he will not negotiate while attacks continued. Advertisement But Trump hit back: 'It's very hard to make that request right now. Israel is doing well, in terms of war, and…Iran is doing less well.' But he added: 'We're ready, willing and able and we've been speaking to Iran.' Iran fired more missiles at Israel overnight which were intercepted amid reports of minimal damage.
Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Mohamed Fayed 'paid spies' to discover ‘truth' about Princess Diana's death
Disgraced former Harrods owner Mohamed Fayed is said to have paid former secret service agents millions in exchange for information about the car accident that killed Princess Diana Mohamed Fayed handed foreign spies millions to try and get details about Princess Diana 's death, it is claimed. Dodi Fayed, the son of the disgraced former Harrods owner, died along with his girlfriend Diana in the Paris car crash in 1997 - and his dad spent years afterwards claiming without evidence that there had been foul play involved in their deaths. Now, new reports show the lengths that Mohamed Fayed allegedly went to try and back up his wild claims, with the tycoon said to have paid large sums to Egyptian secret service agents in exchange for information about the accident. Fayed had told one of the Egyptian operatives that he believed British intelligence services arranged the fatal crash to stop there being "a Muslim brother to the future king", a source told the Telegraph. But he was never able to provide any basis to his claims, and multiple investigations over the years have concluded that Diana and Dodi died in a car accident. The French driver, Henri Paul, was found to be over the legal alcohol limit and speeding, which contributed significantly to the fatal crash. The death of Princess Diana on August 31, 1997, sent shockwaves across the globe. All over the world, millions grieved the loss of the woman they had watched grow from a shy teenaged nursery school teacher to a glamorous celebrity who was at the forefront of the AIDS epidemic. At just 36, Diana died in a car crash in Paris, an event that would go on to change the Royal Family forever.
