Peter Sullivan: Ministers to prioritise compensation bid by man wrongly jailed for 38 years
The Government has pledged to prioritise any bid for compensation by a man who spent 38 years in prison after wrongly being convicted of murder.
Speaking in Parliament, justice minister Lord Ponsonby of Shulbrede said he would 'encourage' Peter Sullivan, 68, to seek a payout.
The gross miscarriage of justice has again fuelled criticism of the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC), which is already under fire over its handling of the case of Andrew Malkinson, who served 17 years in prison for a rape he did not commit.
Responding to warnings that the independent body which investigates potential miscarriages of justice was 'unravelling quickly', Lord Ponsonby said an interim chair had been identified with an announcement to be made 'imminently'.
The previous chairwoman Helen Pitcher resigned in January over the controversy sparked by Mr Malkinson's case, claiming she had been scapegoated.
Mr Sullivan, who to date has spent more of his life in prison than free, finally had his name cleared last week after decades protesting his innocence.
Crucial DNA evidence was finally unearthed due to scientific advances last year, showing it was another unknown man who raped and murdered 21-year-old Diane Sindall in 1986.
Victims of miscarriages of justice can apply to a government compensation scheme.
Mr Malkinson was given a six-figure payment in February this year after delays left him struggling to survive financially and turning to food banks.
Independent crossbencher Baroness Deech, a former chairwoman of the Bar Standards Board and a member of the Law Commission, said: 'Does it not add insult to injury that after a person has wasted the whole of their life in jail, that they don't get immediate compensation as soon as they are released?'
Responding, Lord Ponsonby said: 'We would encourage Mr Sullivan to make an application to the miscarriages of justice application service, and we will prioritise his application because of the length of the prison sentence.'
Tory peer Lord Garnier, who previously served as solicitor general, stressed the urgent need to appoint a chair of the CCRC 'not in the near future, but today'.
He said: 'It's unravelling. It's unravelling quickly and there will be more Malkinsons, there will be more cases of that hideous nature, unless the Government really grabs hold of this thing and takes charge.'
Lord Ponsonby said: 'The objective is to have an interim chair for 18 months to review the operations of the CCRC.
'What I can say is an individual has been identified and is going through the approvals process, so the announcement will be made imminently.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Powys County Times
39 minutes ago
- Powys County Times
Windrush campaigners urge the Government to save Notting Hill Carnival
Campaigners have urged the Government to step in to protect the future of Notting Hill Carnival as they mark Windrush Day. The west London carnival is in jeopardy, its chairman Ian Comfort said in a letter on Wednesday, when he asked Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy to provide urgent funding to save the event. Jacqueline McKenzie, a campaigner and human rights lawyer who helped victims of the Windrush scandal, said the carnival holds 'huge national and international significance'. 'The Government needs to recognise this and act urgently to protect it,' Ms McKenzie said. In the late 1950s, Notting Hill became home to many people from the Caribbean who arrived in Britain on Windrush and accompanying ships, and the carnival was founded by pioneers of that generation. Ms McKenzie said the carnival being at risk 'adds insult to injury' for victims of the Windrush scandal. 'It should not be lost on us that these funding concerns coincide with Windrush Day on Sunday,' she said. 'To see this celebration in jeopardy whilst so many of the Windrush generation continue to fight for justice following the Home Office scandal only adds insult to injury. 'Carnival embodies the fundamental role of Black and Caribbean communities in Britain, and the Government should be upholding the Windrush legacy instead of undermining it.' The carnival attracts around two million people over the August bank holiday, and Susan Hall, leader of the Conservatives on the London Assembly, previously said the event was a 'victim of its own success' and a 'disaster waiting to happen' because of the large number of attendees. City Hall said it has been working with partners to ensure the safety of carnival-goers, which it described as 'paramount'. Professor Patrick Vernon, a cultural historian and Windrush campaigner, said: 'Notting Hill Carnival is far more than a street event — it is a vital cultural institution with both national and international significance. 'As the second-largest carnival in the world, second only to Rio de Janeiro, it underscores London's position as a leading global capital of diversity, creativity and cultural exchange.' Professor Vernon campaigned for a national Windrush Day following the 2018 scandal when it was revealed thousands of British people, mainly of Caribbean origin, were wrongly classed as illegal immigrants – with many deported while others faced difficulty securing work, accessing healthcare or housing. 'The injustice faced by the Windrush Generation in recent years makes the threat to Notting Hill Carnival all the more painful,' Professor Vernon said. 'It is a celebration born of resistance, resilience, and unity – a legacy that should be upheld, not undermined. To allow this cornerstone of Black British identity to fall into jeopardy is to further betray the communities who have already given so much. 'As we approach the 70th anniversary of this extraordinary event, we are reminded that Notting Hill Carnival represents the very best of Britain: unity in diversity, creativity in adversity, and joy in community. Now more than ever, these are values worth defending.' Glenda Caesar, director of the Windrush National Organisation, also urged the Government to step in to save the event, adding: 'In the face of historical and ongoing injustices experienced by people of colour, the carnival stands not only as a celebration of resilience, heritage and identity but also as a powerful symbol of unity and inclusion. 'Supporting this event affirms the UK's commitment to embracing diversity, acknowledging its multicultural roots, and fostering a society where all communities feel seen, valued and empowered.'
Times
2 hours ago
- Times
The wait of the law: justice delayed is an injustice in itself
Eight hundred and ten years ago, the writers of Magna Carta slipped a crucial word into the document they forced King John to sign. The monarch had to promise not to 'deny or delay' justice to his subjects. The law must decide — and, crucially, it must do so promptly. Today we report that the average wait for a case to come to trial at magistrates' courts has reached 346 days. For some people it extends to three years. The price of this indefensible delay is paid by the innocent. First, the victims, who after being traumatised by crime are left in limbo, with that trauma unresolved; second, those who are wrongly accused, living with an unjustified stain on their reputation and a shadow over their future. After eight centuries Magna Carta has no legal force, but its moral authority remains. The government should recognise that, and act accordingly. Justice delayed is not only justice denied: it is an injustice in itself.
The National
2 hours ago
- The National
Inside an asylum hotel – the experiences of those left waiting
The so-called 'asylum hotels' have been the site of anti-immigration protests in recent years, and hit the headlines last summer when they became the target of far-right riots in England, but so often missing from the coverage are the voices of those living inside. The Sunday National met three men staying in a hotel to find out more about their experience in Scotland. Kawa KAWA* has been in asylum accommodation for 10 months, first in Aberdeen and then more recently in South Lanarkshire. In his home country of Iran, speaking out against the regime's human rights abuses can have grave consequences. When his activities were reported to the authorities, he was forced to flee his home in the middle of the night to avoid capture. 'There were no preparations, it happened all of a sudden,' Kawa said. 'I was just thinking about not falling into the hands of the government because they easily burn lives. If I was arrested, a dark fate awaited me.' He paid a smuggler for safe passage from Iran into Europe – a dangerous journey he 'would not even wish on his enemies'. The 35-year-old wears a black cap every day, which he explained was to cover his newly greying hair. READ MORE: BBC officially axes documentary on Gaza doctors over 'impartiality' concerns 'During this time all my hair turned white … being away from my family cost me a lot. Now I hide myself when I talk to them so they won't be upset.' Kawa left behind his wife in Tehran and has been suffering from depression since he arrived in Scotland. Unable to speak English, he explained through a translator that he has struggled to get the support he needs for his mental health. Furthermore, issues with his ASPEN card – a prepaid card which allows people seeking asylum to get their weekly subsistence allowance – means he has yet to receive any financial support. While their claim for refugee status is assessed, people seeking asylum are not allowed to work or claim benefits. The hotel provides a room and three basic meals a day, and the Government issues a weekly allowance of £8.86. With no income and nothing to do all day, frustration and boredom set in quickly with residents, many of whom face lengthy waits for their applications to be processed. Mohammad MOHAMMAD* stayed in the hotel for 15 months. He left Sudan on the back of a sheep lorry, the only means of transport he could find, to escape war in 2023. 'There's nothing to plan for with nine pounds,' said Mohammad. 'You just sleep, get up, sleep – there's a lot of time to think. The time in the hotel is very difficult for mental health, with anxiety and depression. 'If allowed to study during asylum time it would be very helpful. Instead of letting people stay and waiting, let them work and do something to support themselves and the community.' People like Kawa and Mohammad rely on charities to provide clothes and other basic amenities. With a long history of accommodating asylum seekers, Glasgow has many organisations that provide support, but even a trip into the city is often out of reach for those accommodated in other towns across Scotland. 'When I arrived, there were no organisations in this area,' Mohammad said. 'People were talking about stopping asylum and sending people to Rwanda; I was scared about this. 'Maybe because there is a lot of fake news about people coming here, inside you feel strange; it's a big barrier most people are struggling with. You don't feel it's your real country. We are very thankful for everything, but there's still this kind of sense.' Dismayed by the lack of services in South Lanarkshire, a group of local residents formed East Kilbride Integration Network (EKin) at the end of 2023 to help address the basic needs of those in the hotel. They hold monthly conversation cafes, where people can meet for a hot drink, practise their English and even get a haircut. Mohammad took up the opportunity to attend English classes and play football with a local team. He has since started volunteering at the organisation, alongside fellow refugee Ahmed* who also fled the war in Sudan. Ahmed AHMED travelled to the UK alone, in a journey across North Africa and into Europe that spanned five months. A huge football fan, he said his knowledge of England was mostly from supporting Liverpool FC, but the 25-year-old knew nothing of Scotland before he was placed here. 'When I came here, I was really nervous,' he said. 'I'm in a different country with new people – are they going to be friendly with us or not? I asked myself many questions. I didn't go out in my first three weeks.' READ MORE: Labour blasted as 'deeply authoritarian' over plans to proscribe Palestine Action Ahmed was unable to speak English when he arrived in 2023, and 'felt ashamed' that he could not converse with people due to the language barrier. Armed with a notepad and pen, he spent his time in the library with the aim of learning 10 new words every day. He added: 'I have to learn quickly to understand people and the system, or there are so many doors closed on your face in the future.' The asylum system not only dictates where you live while you await the outcome of your application, but it also strips away the daily autonomy most take for granted – such as what food to eat and when. 'Sometimes the food is bad, sometimes it's nice,' Ahmed said. 'You don't have any choice, you have to eat at the same time, if you didn't eat at that time, there is no food for you.' With no friends or family around, everyone we spoke to told us life in the asylum system can be very isolating. More than 100 refugee charities across the UK recently signed an open letter urging the UK Government to end the use of hotels and instead accommodate people in community housing which supports 'better integration into society'. In the current circumstances, local organisations that offer events and support are often the only way for people to make new connections in the area. 'In EKin community I made friends, they help us so much,' said Ahmed. 'There are a lot of activities, I play football, sometimes the gym, and badminton – I didn't have any idea about this. Last year we went on some trips to Edinburgh, to Kelvingrove Museum, it was fantastic. I feel like I'm in the middle of my family.' Mohammad and Ahmed recently received their refugee status, and are planning to further their education in software development and electrical engineering respectively. They both want to remain in Scotland to build their new lives. Kawa's initial asylum claim was rejected by the Home Office, and now he is awaiting the outcome of his appeal. *Names have been changed
