What the controversial new 'Snow White' can teach Hollywood
'Snow White', Disney's live-action remake of a beloved animated film, had an icy reception before its release in cinemas on March 21st. A trailer posted three months ago has earned just 60,000 likes and over 1m dislikes. 'If I saw this movie on a plane I would still walk out,' grumbled one YouTube user. 'We thankfully have the technology nowadays to make the animation look worse than the original from 1937,' groaned another.
Among the remake's many sins are seven in particular: the dwarves, who have been cheesily rendered with computer-generated imagery (CGI), after a row over whether it was politically correct to have actors with dwarfism in the roles. (In the face of criticism, Disney recast the film's dwarves as 'magical creatures'—whatever that means.) There is also the issue of Rachel Zegler, the actress chosen to play Snow White, who panned the original film as 'extremely dated' and said that the prince 'literally stalks' the princess. It turns out fans do not like it when a remake's heroine villainises the classic film that inspired it.
By respinning familiar tales, remakes can offer studios a surer path towards commercial riches. In the amount of pushback and controversy it has faced, 'Snow White' is unusual. But in another way the film reflects a current trend, which is for studios to reach further back in history for source material. From 2020 to 2024 the average age of the source films that new remakes were based on was 35. That is about 13 years older than from 2011 to 2015, according to our analysis of data from The Numbers, a film website.
What makes for a successful remake? It is a question on the minds of many Hollywood executives, as well as cinephiles. To answer it, The Economist analysed 200 remakes released since 1995; each had a minimum of 5,000 ratings on IMDb, an online movie database. (Our analysis only includes remakes of films, not adaptations of books.) Three lessons stand out.
First, it is not enough to use state-of-the-art special effects; computer-generated imagery needs to be handled carefully. Of the 20 worst remakes (as measured by IMDb audience ratings), half are horror films, in part because of their use of unconvincing special effects. In the fifth-worst-rated, a remake in 2005 of John Carpenter's cult classic 'The Fog' from 1980, a supernatural, vengeful fog descends on an island town off the coast of Oregon. Cheap shocks substitute for tension: viewers have complained that the fog moves too quickly and that ghosts in the fog (never clearly visible in the original) are hokey, a complaint also made by viewers about the dwarves in the new 'Snow White'.
Second, comedies come with grave risks. This is the worst-performing genre for remakes, earning an average IMDb rating 1.5 points (out of ten) lower than the originals. Comedy remakes also tend to make the least at the box office. Not a single one significantly outshines the original film it was based on, according to audience ratings. It may be that viewers of comedies and horrors crave an element of surprise, which is hard to offer in a faithful remake, because audiences already know which gags and gasps to expect.
The best remakes get their inspiration from abroad. Since 1995 about a third of the top remakes have been based on foreign source material, including six of the top ten. So are the only two remakes to have won Academy Awards for Best Picture: 'The Departed' (2006), based on a Hong Kong film, and 'CODA' (2021), based on a French-Belgian one.
Unfamiliarity with the originals may mean that audiences come in with lower expectations and without any attachment to the original. Take 'Bugonia', starring Emma Stone, set to be released in November. It is an English-language remake of a South Korean film; instead of a male chief executive, the new story centres on a female one. However, audiences, lacking knowledge of the original, are unlikely to kick up a fuss about the change. The same cannot be said of the new 'Snow White', which seems destined for an unhappily-ever-after ending.
For more on the latest books, films, TV shows, albums and controversies, sign up to Plot Twist, our weekly subscriber-only newsletter
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Diljit Dosanjh unveils Sardaar Ji 3 trailer featuring Hania Aamir; film to release overseas only amid India-Pakistan tensions
On Sunday evening, launched the much-awaited trailer of his upcoming Punjabi comedy Sardaar Ji 3, putting to rest rumours that Pakistani actress Hania Aamir had been dropped from the film. Her prominent presence in the trailer confirmed her continued role as the female lead, despite growing speculation following the April 22 , which claimed the lives of 26 Indian tourists and escalated tensions between India and Pakistan. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now However, in a surprising move, the film will not be released in India and will instead premiere only in overseas markets. Sharing the trailer on social media, Diljit Dosanjh wrote, 'Sardaar Ji 3 releasing 27th June OVERSEAS Only. FADH LAO BHOOND DIAN LATTAN.' Trailer inaccessible in India Indian viewers were quick to notice that the trailer has been geo-blocked in the country. Attempting to play the video on YouTube triggers the message: 'The uploader has not made this video available in your country.' In contrast, the film's teaser and songs remain accessible to Indian users, suggesting that the trailer's restriction is likely due to Hania Aamir's visible role in the film. Hania Aamir's Instagram account has also reportedly been blocked in India following India's Operation Sindoor, a retaliatory military strike conducted on May 7 targeting terror launchpads in Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Kashmir (PoK). Diljit Dosanjh Joins Forces with Sunny Deol for BORDER 2 | Behind-the-Scenes Fire at NDA Industry backlash and release strategy On June 11, the Federation of Western India Cine Employees (FWICE) issued a statement urging the Central Board of Film Certification (CBFC) to withhold clearance for Sardaar Ji 3, citing the presence of Pakistani actors. In addition to Hania Aamir, the cast also includes Nasir Chinyoti, Daniel Khawar, and Saleem Albela, all Pakistani nationals. To avoid delays, protests, and political backlash, the filmmakers appear to have opted for an overseas-only release strategy. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Sardaar Ji 3 marks the third instalment of Diljit Dosanjh's successful Sardaar Ji franchise, known for its light-hearted humour and fantasy elements. The decision to cast Pakistani actors, particularly Hania Aamir, has placed the film in the centre of a political and cultural storm, with national sentiments running high in the wake of the recent cross-border violence.
Time of India
3 hours ago
- Time of India
Indian-origin Canadian rapper Tommy Genesis faces backlash for dressing as Goddess Kali: 'Deliberately chose to mock Hinduism'
Indian-origin Canadian rapper Tommy Genesis slammed for mocking Hinduism and Christianity in her latest album. Canadian rapper Tommy Genesis's Indian-origin was dragged as she received a massive backlash for her music video True Blue in which she dressed as Goddess Kali. Both Hindus and Christians slammed the music video as dressed as Goddess Kali, the singer provocatively posed with a Christian cross. Indian rapper Raftaar publicly condemned the video on Instagram, calling it a 'mockery of my religion' and urging fans to report it on YouTube. Tommy Genesis, also known as Genesis Yasmine Mohanraj, was born in Canada to a Malayali-Tamil-Swedish family. Her father, Mohanraj, is a Tamil-Malayali Christian who emigrated from India to Canada when he was young. His parents, Tommy Genesis's grandparents, were a scientist and a nurse who moved to Canada in response to a newspaper ad seeking professionals in their fields. Tommy Genesis' mother is of Swedish descent. Tommy is known for her provocative, genre-defying music that explores themes of gender, identity, and sexuality, often describing herself as a 'fetish rapper.' She gained prominence in the underground rap scene, with Dazed magazine labeling her 'the internet's most rebellious underground rap queen' in 2016 "Tommy Genesis, from a Tamil-Malayali Christian background, mocks Hindu symbols in her 'True Blue' video for shock value. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Run Your Business Like a Pro - Top Trending Accounting Software (Check Now) Accounting ERP Click Here Undo This isn't art, it's cultural insult, plain and shameless," a social media comment said. "bro i'm not even a hindu or a christian but this was so uncomfortable to watch like it just feels so off. what's with the mindset of mocking other religions culture and beliefs for clout? the insane part is that tommy genesis is an indian plus the song and music is just AWFUL," another wrote. "Her character in the latest track TRUE BLUE is described as 'Freak Of India' on the posters as you can see on the top of the poster below. Her ancestors were priests. Her father is a converted Christian. So she is apparently angry on hindus for the way they treated her father and then she is also angry on christians as they did not allower her in the church because she is a queer. And she made this video mocking both the religion," one wrote.
News18
7 hours ago
- News18
Samay Raina's India's Got Latent Makes Comeback On YouTube After Ranveer Allahbadia Controversy
Samay Raina's India's Got Latent returns to YouTube months after controversy involving Ranveer Allahbadia. Fans hail it as the 'best comeback ever.' Four months after being embroiled in a major controversy, India's Got Latent — the YouTube talent show hosted by comedian Samay Raina — has quietly made a return, albeit on a different channel. The show was pulled down earlier this year after YouTuber Ranveer Allahbadia faced widespread backlash for making an inappropriate comment to a contestant involving their parents. The controversial remark led to public outrage and legal repercussions, with multiple FIRs filed against Ranveer, Samay, Apoorva Mukhija, and Ashish Chanchlani. Following the incident, Samay Raina took down all episodes from his official channel and issued a public statement expressing his distress. 'Everything that is happening has been too much for me to handle. I have removed all India's Got Latent videos from my channel. My only objective was to make people laugh and have a good time," he wrote. He also confirmed his full cooperation with authorities investigating the matter. Now, months later, the show's segments have reappeared online — not on the original channel but on a newly active page titled India's Got Latent Clips. The revived clips include content from public and members-only episodes, with over 500 videos currently available for viewing. Fans of the show have welcomed its digital return with open arms. Comments like '2025 is the year of comeback," 'Best comeback everrr," and 'Finallyyyyyyyy… comeback ho hi gaya Latent ka" have flooded the clips, suggesting that the core audience has remained loyal despite the controversy. Meanwhile, Samay Raina is currently touring internationally, performing across Europe, the UK, Australia, and New Zealand. His tour, which began on June 5, will conclude in Sydney on July 20. Whether this quiet return marks a full revival for the show or merely serves as a nostalgic archive remains to be seen — but for now, India's Got Latent seems to be back in the algorithm. First Published:
