Book Of The Week: The Benefactors by Wendy Erskine
When John William De Forest coined the expression 'Great American Novel' in 1868, he anticipated a work which had the ability communicate the tableau of contemporary living through "the ordinary emotions and manners of American existence". Mark Twain was touted as an early contender, as was Henry James, who internalised the concept so enthusiastically that by the time he reached the later stages of his career, he wrote obsessive tracts of self-criticism that ended up pummelling his sentences into meta-commentaries on their own construction.
The term had barely been born before authors started missing the point. The 'Great American Novel' was meant to simplify as well as elucidate; to mirror American society back on itself so that the spirit of the nation could be recognised more easily.
Given the evident impossibility of the task, it's as well that Irish literature has not developed some lofty equivalent. Contenders for greatness are by this point so innumerable that anybody caught striving is rightfully scorned for having 'notions'. We have texts comprising a national body of work which seeks to add to the whole rather than trying to encapsulate it fully. We have great novels about Dublin, great novels about Cork, great novels about Limerick and of course, great novels about Belfast.
Listen: Oliver Callan talks to Wendy Erskine
The Benefactors by Wendy Erskine is one such great novel. Written in a mixture of third-person present tense and first-person past, the polyphonic narrative of the book belies its relatively short length. At just over 320 pages, The Benefactors has the lush feel of a Dickensian epic; one in which the city of Belfast fulfils its role as hidden protagonist of a tale spanning everything from gender politics and class to intergenerational trauma and the legacy of the Troubles.
Which isn't to say that the book is without wit. Erskine has one of the keenest ears for dialogue in the business meaning that, even under the most horrendous circumstances, her characters can still be disarmingly funny. "Most people are stupid and do stuff without too much consideration or forethought," one character considers. "Read too deeply into individuals' actions and you end up crediting them with too much intelligence. Way too much intelligence."
The Benefactors has the lush feel of a Dickensian epic
At its core, The Benefactors is a novel about three mothers and three sons – each from varyingly affluent backgrounds – as they use their power and influence to try and defuse the potential fallout from a sexual assault allegation. In lesser hands, such explosive material might come across as polemical or, worse, heightened to the point where its hard-won realism comes across as frenzied. Yet Erskine navigates the subject with compassion; emphasising the frailty of human endeavour such that we can't help but be moved by the mothers' plight even as we are disgusted by their conduct and behaviour.
If I have one quibble, it's that the sheer volume of characters and voices at times threatens to overwhelm the integrity of the narrative. One can't help but wonder whether Erskine's training as a short story writer motivated the story's fragmentary construction, littered as it is with asides separate from the main thread. Thankfully it all comes together. Erskine is a skilled medium and while The Benefactors is not the all-encompassing 'Great Irish Novel' that elucidates everything in the national character, it is a vital puzzle piece; one that confirms Belfast as an important site for the imagination, holding no less than the world within its sagging redbrick walls.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
30 minutes ago
- The Irish Sun
‘Get her out' rant Love Island fans as they call for star to be kicked off show for ‘bullying'
LOVE Island fans were left fuming during last night's explosive episode - with many demanding one islander be booted from the villa after accusing her of 'bullying' behaviour. Viewers vent their frustration with some even calling on ITV bosses to step in after islander constantly "digs out other girls." 5 Helena is slammed of bringing "mean girl energy" Credit: Eroteme 5 Helena accused Toni of marking her territory with Harrison Credit: Eroteme Viewers previously His confession Since then, Helena has failed to strike up a spark with any of the other boys in the villa. read more love island But she hasn't stayed out of the spotlight - instead, Helena's found herself caught up in the girls' drama. Sitting down with the newest boy Harrison, 22, to chat and flirt, Helena was talking about his other love interest, Toni, 24. Helena explained how she thought Toni was "marking her territory" with Harrison. She also said that it sometimes felt like Toni didn't like her talking to Harrison. Most read in Love Island Harrison was stunned and intrigued as Helena spoke about the American bombshell. Fans are flooding online forums with the same message: 'Get Helena out!' Love Island feud exposed as fans spot girl 'making faces' behind rival's back One wrote: "I feel as though she has such mean girl energy and can't hold a conversation without digging another girl out. "She has flashes of being funny and witty and I think her probably humiliating experience with Harry has left her feeling insecure and feeling worse but I've had enough of it now! "I also think if she left it would break up the unholy bully alliance of Meg/Megan/Helena (and increasingly Emily)". Another added: "Helena is just a boy follower. In all seriousness, Helena is so male centred it hurts. Love Island 2025 full lineup : A 30-year-old footballer with charm to spare. : A 22-year-old Manchester-based model, ready to turn heads. : A payroll specialist from Southampton, looking for someone tall and stylish. : International business graduate with brains and ambition. : A gym enthusiast with a big heart. : A Londoner with celebrity connections, aiming to find someone funny or Northern. : An Irish actress already drawing comparisons to Maura Higgins. : A personal trainer and semi-pro footballer, following in his footballer father's footsteps. : A towering 6'5' personal trainer. : A 25-year-old Irish rugby pro. : Love Island's first bombshell revealed as sexy Las Vegas pool party waitress. : The 24-year-old bombshell hails from London and works as a commercial banking executive. : A teaching assistant from Broxbourne, Hertfordshire, who entered Love Island 2025 as a bombshell . : Works as a scaffolder day-to-day and plays semi-pro football on the side. : Pro footballer and model entering Love Island 2025 as a bombshell. Departures : : Axed after an arrest over a machete attack emerged. He was released with no further action taken and denies any wrongdoing. : A model and motivational speaker who has overcome adversity after suffering life-changing burns in an accident. : A boxer with striking model looks, seeking love in the villa. "My insides cringe when she puts down another woman herself or tries to get a man to say something negative about a woman. It's really sad how that is what feeds her own ego." In a spoiler for tonight's episode, A video shows him in tears as he sits with Dejon, who said if he could have it his way he would see the pair together. Semi pro footballer Harry, with tears in his eyes, replies: "Yeah. "Like, we just have nothing. "Do you know what I mean?" He then paused to dab his face and added: "Where it's just like, we were good and then it's just like she can't even be around me. "Geez. It's just weird man. "Like it'll never be the same now after the way I've acted, do you know what I mean?" The official Love Island account on X posted the caption: "The consequences of Harry's antics hit home." Yet many thought he was having a taste of his own medicine following his lothario conduct. One fan was quick to write: "Crying as if all of this wasn't his own doing. Men lack accountability fr." A second posted: "If it isn't the consequences of your own actions…." A third noted: "He's realised he's exhausted all his options that man does not want to be with Helena," while one agreed and put: "And tomorrow he'll want Emily we can't predict his next move." One then mused: "Some self reflection is always good." 5 The footballer said of his former partner 'she can't even be around me' Credit: X / @LoveIsland 5 He comes to terms with that his connection with Helena will 'never be the same' Credit: Shutterstock Editorial 5 Tensions rise between two feuding cliques in the villa Credit: Eroteme
Sunday World
an hour ago
- Sunday World
Skateboarder Tony Hawk rolls into Shannon Airport after Ireland getaway
Tony Hawk enjoyed a fruitful spell in Ireland and was spotted tearing up a skatepark in Cork last week Tony Hawk was spotted flying from Shannon Airport after a family holiday in Ireland. Photo: Shannon Airport A legendary skateboarder has been spotted jetting out of Shannon Airport after enjoying a getaway in Ireland. American skateboarder Tony Hawk enjoyed a fruitful spell in Ireland and was spotted tearing up a skatepark in Cork last week. The 57-year-old was holidaying with his family and spent two hours at the skatepark in Mallow before sharing the experience on social media. Staff from Shannon Airport posed with 'Birdman' as they shared a snap with the star on Friday evening. The caption read: 'Boarding pass for a boarding legend please. Our Graduate Management Trainee Adam met Tony Hawk. The absolute pleasures of airport life! Tony Hawk's latest Irish venture is an extension of a storied history in the country over the past decade. He married his wife, Cathy Goodman, at a ceremony at Adare Manor in Limerick on June 27, 2015. The San Diego native has been ranked as one of the most influential skateboarders of all time and is credited with bringing the sport to the mainstream. He won over 70 contests across a 17-year professional career and was known for introducing an array of tricks to the skateboarding world. Most notably, he was the first skateboarder to land a '900' – a trick involving two and a half mid-air rotations on a skateboard. Hawk's star has continued to rise since retiring from professional competition in 1999. Over 20 skateboarding games have been released in his name, including the launch of the best-selling Tony Hawks' Pro Skater series which initially ran from 1999-2002. After the series was credited with inspiring a generation of skateboarders in the early 2000s, an up-to-date remake was commissioned for the legendary Pro Skater 3 and 4 titles and is set to hit the shelves on July 11.
The Irish Sun
an hour ago
- The Irish Sun
Love Island feud exposed as fans spot girl ‘making faces' behind rival's back
LOVE Island fans have become convinced that there's a new feud brewing between two islanders – after a girl was caught 'making faces' at another. As the ITV2 dating series continues, tensions are beginning to flare between the islanders as they try and find their match, with Shakira having more than one clash over the series. 5 Emily has been spotted 'making faces' at another girl Credit: Eroteme 5 A game of spin the bottle brought out some awkward results Credit: Eroteme 5 Emily was seen pulling faces as Tommy picked Shakira during some of his answers Credit: Eroteme However, while Shakira and Toni After Sunday night's episode, one fan took to Reddit and said: "Quite a few people have clocked this and I'm seeing it now after today's episode but Irish Megan has some sort of weird one-sided beef with Shakira too, it isn't just Helena. "Whenever the boys pick Shakira in a challenge or if they compliment her she's always making a face," they add. "I think along with the other girls that she's also threatened by Shakira. READ MORE LOVE ISLAND "They're both the hot brunettes of the Island and Shakira is Megan's only competition when it comes to boys in the villa, most the guys want either of them. It doesn't help that the two of them are in different cliques that clash too." Others were quick to agree, with one saying: "Yeah, I noticed that too. Megan seriously irritated me in this episode with that face pulling when Tommy picked Shakira. "Her double standards are INSANE. So it's okay for her to flirt with Connor? Do a sex position with Connor, but it's not okay for Tommy to say he was attracted to both her and Shakira initially in the villa???? "And then what Megan said later to someone, about having sexual feelings for Connor. But only likes Tommy for his relationship qualities." Most read in Love Island "I'm not a megan fan but I think it's more that Shakira is the only other girl that is Tommy's "type" which means megan is more threatened by her than the other girls," defended a third. "If you look at the unseen bits she seems closest to Shakira out of all of the girls that aren't the trio so I doubt it's personal." Love Island's 'secret romance' exposed as two islanders seen in deep chat Since arriving on day one of the show, Megan has been coupled up with Tommy Bradley, with the pair hitting it off straight away. However, other boys have shown an interest in Megan, particularly Conor Phillips. While she chose to continue her romance with Tommy, a game of spin the bottle resulted in question marks being raised. During the game, which also was a game of truth or date, Megan was asked how she felt about Conor - prompting her to admit: "Me and Conor got on from the start and that got cut short so I feel like there's unfinished business there." However, things got even more heated when during the game, Tommy paid attention to Shakira during some of his answers – leaving her pulling the supposed faces. Is there trouble in paradise? Love Island continues weekdays at 9pm on ITV2. 5 Shakira has found herself clashing with a number of the girls Credit: Eroteme 5 Fans weren't happy with Megan's behaviour after the game, saying it wasn't the first time she'd made faces at Shakira Credit: Eroteme
