Man who killed Michael Barr in feud says court was wrong to dismiss eyewitness evidence
RIGHTS BREACHED |
Counsel for David Hunter (46) also argued that Hunter's privacy rights had been breached by the introduction of mobile phone evidence during his trial.
Michael Barr
Counsel for David Hunter (46) also argued that Hunter's privacy rights had been breached by the introduction of mobile phone evidence during his trial, in which he was found guilty by the Special Criminal Court in September 2020.
Liverpool native Hunter, with an address at Du Cane Road, White City, London, had denied the Kinahan Cartel murder of 35-year-old Michael Barr at the Sunset House pub in Dublin's north inner city on the night of April 25, 2016.
At his trial before the non-jury, three-judge Special Criminal Court, Mr Justice Alexander Owens, presiding, sitting with Judge Gerard Griffin and Judge David McHugh, said that the evidence had been heard in a "compelling way" that Hunter was one of the two gunmen who entered the Summerhill pub and murdered Mr Barr by shooting him. Hunter's involvement in the murder had been "fully proved" and the court was "sure of his guilt", remarked Mr Justice Owens.
The judge noted that the murderers had failed to burn out the getaway car, which had been abandoned at Walsh Road in Drumcondra a few minutes after the killing, and they had also dropped a burner phone at the getaway scene. He said the major part of a DNA profile taken from a ski mask recovered from the car during the investigation into the shooting of Mr Barr matched the profile of Hunter.
Michael Barr
News in 90 Seconds - May 29th
In a voluntary statement to gardaí, Hunter said that the ski mask was his but that he had dropped it in a car driven by another man when he visited Ireland two months before the murder on a car-stealing exercise. Hunter also claimed he had used the mask on various ski trips with his children to Norway, France, Spain, Scotland, Austria and Switzerland.
Mr Justice Owens said that the circumstantial evidence in the case "pointed inextricably" to Hunter's guilt and the facts taken together had established the father-of-five's guilt beyond a reasonable doubt and no other rational explanation could be drawn.
At the Court of Appeal today, Hunter's legal team argued that the trial court erred in rejecting the evidence of witnesses present in the Sunset House that said there was a difference in height between the two assailants who entered the pub and killed Mr Barr.
Michael Bowman SC said that the trial court had set out that Hunter was being convicted because someone dropped a mobile phone at the scene and the car used by the gunmen failed to burn out, meaning that latex masks were not destroyed by the fire.
Counsel said that a witness in the pub was very clear in the physical description he gave, identifying a distinction in height between the two men. This witness had said the gunman was wearing a ski mask under a latex mask, but Mr Bowman said the trial court had refused to acknowledge what the witness had seen. He said that this witness identified the gunman as being six feet one or two, while Hunter is five feet ten.
Concerning the ski mask from which a DNA profile of Hunter was obtained, Mr Bowman said that in February 2016, Hunter 'on the spur of the moment' came to Ireland for a two-day period to steal cars, bringing the ski mask with him for this purpose.
'It's a very careless criminal who would leave his ski mask behind in a car that was stolen,' remarked Mr Justice John Edwards.
Mr Bowman said that the ski mask was correctly observed by the witness in the pub, adding that Hunter does not conform with the height of the assailant given, which meant that there was potentially another individual who wore that mask. Read more
Mr Justice Patrick McCarthy remarked that this would make Hunter 'a victim of coincidence' if he had left the mask in a car six weeks before, only for it then to turn up in a car used in a murder.
'Life is a series of unfortunate coincidences,' said Mr Bowman.
Hunter's legal team also raised a ground of appeal concerning the mobile phones in the case, arguing that even if the appellant accepted or refused ownership of one of the phones, he was entitled to challenge the phone evidence on the basis of a breach of his privacy rights.
It was submitted that the trial court erred in finding that the mere fact that the material in question may pertain to criminal activity meant it could not attract privacy rights.
On behalf of the State, Dominic McGinn SC said that at the time of the trial, only two of those involved in the shooting were apprehended, while a third man had not been identified. He said that Hunter and co-accused Eamonn Cumberton were of the same height.
Mr McGinn said that of the latex masks found in the car, each had a dominant DNA profile, with one that matched Hunter, one that matched Cumberton, and the last that matched the third man involved, Christopher Slator. He said that each DNA profile from these masks was paired to different items in the car, with Hunter's profile also found on the ski mask.
'The possibility that perhaps someone else picked it up and put it on, that would have required them to leave none of their profile on it,' said Mr McGinn.
Concerning the admissibility of the phone evidence, Mr McGinn said there had been a vast change in the legal position concerning mobile phone data since then, but the investigation team could not be faulted for using the legislation at the time to get the information required.
Mr Justice Edwards said the court would reserve judgement in the case.
Hunter is one of three men to be found guilty of murdering dissident republican Michael Barr. In January 2018, Eamonn Cumberton, of Mountjoy Street, Dublin 7, was convicted of murdering the Tyrone native, while in July 2022, Christopher Slator, of Carnlough Road, Cabra, Dublin 7, was also convicted.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sunday World
2 days ago
- Sunday World
Nine children rescued from water and one in hospital after boat capsizes off Antrim coast
Emergency Services at the scene of the ongoing incident in Carrickfergus Nine children are understood to have been among those rescued from the water off the Co Antrim coast in a major operation this evening. One has been taken to hospital, and police said everyone has been accounted for after a boat capsized in the water shortly after 9pm. The PSNI, Ambulance Service, NI Fire and Rescue and Coastguard were all tasked to the scene near Carrickfergus. Emergency Services at the scene of the ongoing incident in Carrickfergus on June 19th 2025 (Photo by Kevin Scott) The successful operation has been winding down, although eight ambulances were still at the scene late into the evening, with some still being treated. A spokesman for the NI Ambulance Service said they received a call at 9.14pm following reports of a water-related incident near Carrick Marina. "Early reports indicated that the incident involved nine children and one adult,' he said. News in 90 Seconds - June 20th "NIAS despatched multiple resources to the scene, which was also attended by MCA (Maritime and Coastguard Agency), PSNI and NIFRS. "After assessment and initial treatment at the scene, one patient was taken by ambulance to RBHSC (the Royal Belfast Hospital for Sick Children) while the rest were discharged at the scene.'ries at this time and all those on the boat have been accounted for." Emergency Services at the scene of the ongoing incident in Carrickfergus on June 19th 2025 (Photo by Kevin Scott) A police spokesperson said the PSNI received a report of a capsized boat in the water near the Fisherman's Quay area of Carrickfergus shortly after 9.10pm. Inspector Bryan said: "Officers attended, along with colleagues from other emergency services and a number of people were rescued from the water. "There have been no reports of any serious inju
Irish Independent
2 days ago
- Irish Independent
Revenue bill for storing and managing ‘drug ship' now totals €9.11m
That is according to new figures provided by the Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe who said that it is costing the Revenue Commissioners on average €120,000 per week to maintain and store the ship. The MV Matthew was seized on September 26, 2023, in a dramatic drugs operation off the south coast. On board gardaí and Revenue Customs officers found 2.2 tonnes of cocaine worth an estimated €157m. Eight men have pleaded guilty to offences arising from the drugs seizure and are due to be sentenced at the Special Criminal Court on July 4. The ship remains at Cork Harbour and in a written Dáil reply to Séamus McGrath (FF) on the costings, Mr Donohoe provided a breakdown of the €9.11m bill to the Revenue Commissioners from September 26, 2023, to the end of May. Mr Donohoe said: 'In relation to the costs, taking account of all payments made and charges pending, Revenue estimates that the average weekly cost of managing and maintaining the vessel is in the order of €120,000 per week.' He told the Cork South Central TD that the €9.11m bill is made up of €3.43m in crewing, €3.6m in maintenance and €2.07m in berthing, unberthing and movement of the vessel. He added that the maintenance costs included costs such as ship's stores and provisions, bunkering fuel, waste removal, miscellaneous repairs and maintenance, agent and professional fees and insurance. The Finance Minister stated that the bidding process for the sale of the MV Matthew by the Revenue Commissioners was concluded in the first quarter of 2025 and a preferred bidder was identified. He said that the Special Criminal Court on December 2, 2024, authorised the release of the MV Matthew, thereby facilitating its disposal. Mr Donohoe stated that 'I am assured by Revenue that the disposal of this vessel is a key priority and all necessary steps to complete its disposal as expeditiously as possible are being undertaken. 'The regulatory requirements as they apply to the MV Matthew are complex and ensuring compliance with these regulatory requirements is time consuming. Due to the complexities of the regulatory framework, it may be a further number of months before the disposal of the vessel will be completed,' he added.
The Irish Sun
2 days ago
- The Irish Sun
Predator who carried ‘rape kit' while posing as Uber driver to attack young women found guilty of kidnap and sex assault
A VILE sex predator carried a "rape kit" while posing as an Uber driver to attack his victims. Graham Head was today found guilty of attempting to rape one woman and sexually assaulting another in attacks around Brighton and Hove. Advertisement 5 Graham Head was found guilty on all counts today Credit: Sussex Police 5 Head was found with a "rape kit" in his car as cops arrested him Credit: Sussex Police 5 The twisted fake taxi driver is set to be sentenced on August 25 In July 2023, the 68-year-old was sentenced to 23 years behind bars for kidnap, attempted rape and assault by penetration relating to two female victims. But the Court of Appeal overturned his conviction in November 2024 after a complaint from the sex predator concerning the Judge who had ruled in the first trial. Head appeared at Lewes Crown Court for his retrial today, where a jury again found him guilty of all counts. The twisted fake taxi driver is set to be sentenced on August 25. Advertisement Read More Jurors at Lewes Crown Court previously heard how a 25-year-old female victim had managed to read his number plate after being attacked. The woman reported waking up in a car, which she thought was a taxi, to find a man sexually assaulting her. She had gotten into the car earlier that night, to travel from Brighton to Hove. Advertisement Most read in The Sun The victim escaped at around 3am and called 999 to report being assaulted by a man in latex gloves and a Covid mask. The court was told Head was a "sexual predator" who "slipped up" the night he was arrested. Chilling moment fake Uber driver who prowled streets for women to rape is arrested after victim memorised number plate In footage shown to jurors, police can be seen talking to the 68-year-old after pulling him over in Brighton. As he is speaking, police decide to search his car where they found latex gloves, viagra, condoms and a balaclava that formed a rape kit. Advertisement When asked why he had the condoms and viagra, Head said: "I'm a normal red blooded male". Police also found business cards advertising him as a "N-Uber driver" that had the slogan "Safe and Reliable - For All Occasions". Head was also found guilty of assaulting a 19-year-old woman he picked up near Hove Park. She was pulled into bushes where the predator attempted to rape her, after the victim initially took a lift from him. Advertisement The two attacks took place in the early hours of August 19 and November 18, 2022. Detective Constable Elliott Lander from the Surrey and Sussex Major Crime Team said: 'Graham Head has twice tried to evade justice for his despicable crimes, and now twice been convicted by separate juries. 'His refusal to accept responsibility for his offending has forced his victims to relive the traumatic attacks carried out by him. The impact on them and their families cannot be overstated, and I commend all involved for their strength and courage in such challenging circumstances. 'Head will remain in prison, as he has throughout this process, as we await resentencing.' Advertisement One of Head's victims, a 25-year-old woman, tragically passed away last year. Her heartbroken mum released the following emotional statement: "Regardless of the outcome of this trial and independently of the jury's verdicts on each of the charges that Graham Head has just faced, I want to say a few words on behalf of my daughter. "My (only) daughter tragically died in late 2024 – a couple days after being informed by the CPS that Graham Head had been successful in appealing his conviction for kidnap of my daughter and for causing serious sexual harm to her and to another even younger female victim. "I feel strongly that I need to protect the anonymity of my own and my daughter's friends and the families and friends of Graham Head's victims. Advertisement "However, I want to recognise and say my own deep thanks for the strong and compassionate support that my daughter, myself, and our family have received from the Police, the CPS, the witness service, and the Courts over the past two years. "This retrial process has been tremendously difficult and a huge strain for all of us; we're glad it is now over. "I'm especially grateful for the attuned support of the Sexual Offences Investigation Team (SOIT) and the Independent Sexual Violence Advocacy (ISVA) service who supported my daughter every step of the way through the challenges of bringing this man to justice on both trials. "Looking to my family's future following my daughter's death, my biggest hope is that other families can now hopefully feel much safer knowing that this dangerous man is no longer able to predate and attack any other vulnerable young local woman thanks to his deserved (re)conviction for these appalling offences. Advertisement "My other hope is that, if there are other young women who feel they may have narrowly escaped or fallen victim to this sexual predator, then they will hopefully be reassured by my daughter's and our family's experience that they will be listened to, supported, and well cared for by the Police and Court systems." 5 Head was also found guilty of assaulting a 19-year-old woman he picked up near Hove Park 5 Police found business cards advertising him as a "N-Uber driver" that had the slogan "Safe and Reliable - For All Occasions" Credit: Sussex Police
