Gavaskar, Sachin, Dravid or Kohli: Who's India's best? Sherlock Holmes investigates

The sun rose over 221B Baker Street, embracing the morning air with warmth. Inside, the faint aroma of burnt toast and strong coffee battled with the smell of tobacco from Sherlock Holmes' pipe.Dr John Watson, bleary-eyed from a late night in a Soho disc, stumbled into the sitting room. He found Sherlock Holmes buried deep in the day's edition of the Times.
Design Credit: ITGD Editorial Design
advertisement'Morning,' Watson muttered, stretching his torso to shake off the stiffness of a night spent chasing whisky and women.
Holmes didn't look up. Watson, curiosity roused, sidled up behind him, peering over his shoulder to catch a glimpse of what held the detective's attention.
'The great Sherlock Holmes,' Watson chuckled, 'reading about the Indian cricket team? Now who would've thought the old chap had a drop of cricket in him?'Holmes set the paper aside and leaned back in his leather lounge chair. Reaching for his violin, he plucked a single, resonant note. It was F-minor, a subtle message.'Come on, mate,' Watson pressed, grinning. You can't duck my questions like a Bumrah bouncer. "What's with the sudden interest in Indian cricket?'advertisementSherlock set the violin beside a polished human skull on the desk. 'Elementary, my dear Watson. I am unravelling the case of the fabulous four.'Watson raised an eyebrow. 'The fab four? What's that, old chap?'Holmes' lips twitched into a smirk. 'The question gripping journalists from Mumbai to Manchester: who is the greatest Indian Test batsman amongst the big four: Gavaskar, Tendulkar, Dravid, or Kohli? I intend to solve this puzzle.'
Watson's eyes lit up. 'Who do you reckon it is?'Holmes reached for his pipe. 'It is a capital mistake to theorise before one has data. You risk twisting facts to suit theories, rather than theories to suit facts. Make a cappuccino, Watson, and we'll examine the evidence.'Watson smiled, heading for the kitchen. 'Tricky business. Fans will cry bias, whatever you conclude.' He paused, scribbling a note for his blog.Holmes' voice was stern. 'There is no 'truth' in cricket, Watson. Only facts. Those who let emotions cloud judgment are fans. Those who weigh facts dispassionately are pundits. No pundit fears a fan's ire.'advertisementWatson's smile froze. Holmes' icy gaze reminded him: when the detective's mind whirred, best not to stir.Placing a cappuccino beside Holmes, Watson settled for a mystery to rival their greatest cases.
SHERLOCK HOLMES INVESTIGATES 'Who do you rank as the best?' Holmes sipped the cappuccino.'Never saw Gavaskar bat. I'm fond of Virat Kohli.''Recency bias,' Holmes smirked. 'A common error of the short-sighted. Look at the data.'Watson chuckled heartily. 'Data is like a bird—it'll sing the tune you fancy''We shall see.' Holmes rose and activated a digital projector. A chart flashed on the sitting room's screen, comparing the fab four's Test batting averages.
'Observe, Watson. Kohli's 46.85 trails Tendulkar's 53.79, Dravid's 52.31, and Gavaskar's 51.12.'Watson's brow creased. "Kohli played the least number of Tests, and was the earliest to retire, despite fitness and modern equipment. He has the lowest average among the fab four.'advertisement'Indeed. Now consider SENA–South Africa, England, New Zealand, and Australia—where pitches favor pace and swing, testing a batsman's mettle.'Another slide appeared, showing SENA averages.
Watson frowned. 'Kohli's lowest outside Asia. News to me.''I omitted the West Indies, Watson. In Kohli's era, their Test side was less formidable than in Gavaskar's day.''Hold on. I'm curious about the Caribbean. Let's see those figures.'The projector shifted, revealing Kohli's average in 11 West Indies Tests. Watson's jaw dropped. 'Kohli's at the bottom again.'
'I am impressed, Watson,' Sherlock clapped slowly. 'There is one more piece of evidence–their batting in the five years before retirement. Guess what?'Watson sighed. 'Bottom again.'
advertisement'Precisely. What does this suggest?' Holmes tapped tobacco into his pipe.'Fading reflexes? Declining motivation, waning drive to succeed?' Watson muttered.'Yes, and a slump. Post-Covid–damn that virus–Kohli faltered, nicked off-stump deliveries, and fell to spinners like Nathan Lyon.''You have a point, Holmes.''The power of facts. Deduction's law,' Holmes smiled. 'Kohli's Test record—low average, lesser longevity, final years' dip—places him fourth. I'd consider Vengsarkar or Sehwag, but let's keep our suspects to four.''So, Kohli isn't the greatest?''Figures don't lie. Eliminate the impossible, and what remains, however improbable, is truth,' Holmes replied, his voice low. 'He is a modern titan, with a hunger for big scores. But not the greatest.''Another cappuccino?' Watson asked, stirring his coffee.'No, a double espresso. This calls for a shot of nostalgia,' Holmes said, lifting his violin.
Watson sipped in silence. The chase for truth had begun. The game was afoot. Holmes was playing his favourite game: deduction by elimination.advertisementThe data placed Kohli below the triumvirate—the saviour (Gavaskar), the destroyer (Tendulkar), and the protector (Dravid).But Watson wasn't done. 'Holmes, let's test the public. I'll post a poll on my blog about Kohli's legacy, then we'll tackle the other three.'Holmes raised an eyebrow. 'A public vote? Sentiment may cloud judgment, but proceed.'Watson posted at once:In a few hours, India's Test cricket will see a generational change.While all eyes are on the future team, Virat Kohli's retirement has ignited a #FabFourDebate.Where would you place Kohli in the list of Gavaskar, Tendulkar, Dravid and himself?Vote here:— India Today Sports (@ITGDsports) June 19, 2025Share your vote! #FabFourDebate and stay tuned for Part 2 of this feature.Sandipan Sharma, our guest author, likes to write on cricket, cinema, music and politics. He believes they are interconnected.Tune InMust Watch

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

The Hindu

25 minutes ago

• The Hindu

‘Hari Hara Veera Mallu': Pawan Kalyan's film locks a release date

After multiple delays, Pawan Kalyan's movie Hari Hara Veera Mallu has locked its latest release date. The pan-Indian movie, originally shot in Telugu, is directed by Jyothi Krishna and Krish Jagarlamudi. The makers first aimed to release the movie on March 29, 2025. However, the big-budget movie got pushed to May 09, 2025. Owing to delays in the post-production work, Hari Hara Veera Mallu thengot postponed to June 12, 2025. Reports hinted at further delay of the movie due to complex VFX work. On June 21, 2025 (Saturday), the makers announced a fresh release date. The historical film is now set to hit the screens worldwide on July 24, 2025. 'Witness the Battle for truth, faith and freedom in cinemas worldwide on July 24, 2025,' the makers wrote on social media. The movie is produced by A Dayakar Rao under the banner Mega Surya Productions. Veteran producer AM Rathnam will present the movie, which will be dubbed in Hindi, Kannada, Tamil and Malayalam. ALSO READ:Nidhhi Agerwal interview: I felt like Alice in Wonderland on the sets of 'Hari Hara Veera Mallu' The period action drama revolves around the titular character, Veera Mallu, a rebellious outlaw. Bobby Deol, who essays the role of Mughal Emperor Aurangzeb, plays the antagonist in the movie. Niddhi Agerwal is the female lead of the film. Anupam Kher, Jisshu Sengupta, Nargis Fakhri, M Nassar, Sunil, Raghu Babu, Subbaraju and Nora Fatehi are the other actors in the movie. The film will have music from Oscar-award winning composer MM Keeravani, while Manoj Paramahamsa has served as the cinematographer. Veteran Thota Tharani is the art director of the movie.

Time of India

29 minutes ago

• Time of India

Meet Dr Dhaval Bhanusali, the Indian dermatologist behind Hailey Bieber's $1 billion skincare brand

Hailey Bieber's skincare brand, Rhode, has been acquired by e.l.f. Beauty for $1 billion. But behind the glamour and headlines lies a story you haven't heard: that of Indian-American dermatologist Dr. Dhaval Bhanusali. A founding team member, formulator, and early believer in Rhode, Dr. Bhanusali played a pivotal role in turning a skincare startup into a billion-dollar brand. In this episode of ET Conversation, Nisha Poddar speaks with Dr. Bhanusali about building Rhode from scratch, the science behind its products, the rising influence of Indian beauty traditions like turmeric and hair oiling, and his personal journey as an immigrant son balancing medicine, entrepreneurship, and global ambition. Show more Show less

Mint

39 minutes ago

• Mint

‘Bollywood and India inspire me': French designer Mossi Traoré

Mossi Traoré, the famous French fashion designer, believes in the idea of 'everyday couture". Each of his ready-to-wear creations, whether a blouse or a dress, come sublimated with couture detailing, be it the draping, the embroidery or the fabric. It's an idea that the designer, who launched his Mossi label in 2017, is promoting through his fashion school, Les Ateliers d'Alix, as well. Traoré opened the school in 2015 as a way to empower the underprivileged, enabling students to master rarefied haute couture skills. It's located in Hautes-Noues, an impoverished Parisian suburb where Traoré grew up. He was recently in India as part of the Ashoka University's Lodha Genius Programme, an initiative that brings global changemakers to the campus to inspire young minds. Also read: How to elevate your office look with the necktie In an interview with Lounge, Traoré talks about how India inspires his work, following eco-friendly practices while designing and the future of fashion. Edited excerpts: At the Parisian school Mod'Art International, you learnt how to make clothes with an Indian seamstress and an African maker. How did the experience shape? These experiences have been very formative and have been part of my apprenticeship. They have reinforced my determination and my choice to be a designer open to the world and to the diversity of cultures. India and Africa are among the cultures that are very dear to my heart. In 2015, you founded your own school, Les Ateliers d'Alix, a name that pays homage to French couturier Madame Grès… Madame Grès and Yohji Yamamoto are my two greatest sources of inspiration in fashion. Madame Grès made me love couture excellence. Fashion is an art, and Madame Grès is its mirror. Rigour, passion, the quest for eternal perfection—that's what Madame Grès inspires in me. ⁠You launched your own eponymous brand Mossi, in 2017. Do you see fashion as an applied art form? Art is a tree with many branches, and I've grabbed the fashion one while having fun with the others. My work revolves around four words: fashion, art, crafts and the world. Your school signed a partnership with Chanel last year. Would you consider it a key milestone? Yes, this is a very important step, because it shows today that one of the biggest haute couture houses was sensitive to the quality of our training, but above all to the technical skills of our students to meet their needs and those of the industry. You won the Pierre Bergé Prize in 2020, and you presented your collection as an artistic performance with dancers, one of your biggest inspirations… I love movement, which translates into many artistic currents and forms, including dance, which is one of my favorite artistic mediums. Which artists inspire you the most? Korean artist Lee Bul is my fountain of inspiration. I'm also fond of the Korean artist Lee Bae for his world and his artistic expression. Calligrapher Hassan Massoudy and his art of movement. The textile sculptor Simone Pheulpin, the talented Ibrahim Ballo fascinate me. And above all, Bollywood actors. Has India ever inspired your moodboard? India has always inspired me and will always inspire me. Your advice to young designers? Not to be afraid to be curious, and to encourage collaborations that unite people around values they can relate to themselves. How challenging is it for a young creative to start a label in today's challenging times? The context is not the most favourable: competition is fierce and the sector is less dynamic. Without substantial resources, it's very difficult to survive in this industry. However, the fashion sector has its doubts, and needs to reinvent itself in certain areas—and that's an excellent opportunity for the new generation to come up with new ideas. You've always rooted for social justice and sustainability through your work… I believe that fashion can contribute to providing solutions to make our world a better place. I want to embody fashion that has a positive social impact on the public and on local areas. Two great social entrepreneurs, Ali Benat and Leila Janah, who are of Indian origin, have confirmed me on this path. Can fashion ever be sustainable? It must try to be. Manish Mishra is a Delhi-based writer and content creator. Also read: Why nude dressing is trending on the red carpet