Council considers regulations against abandoning supermarket trolleys

Christchurch councillors say shopping trolleys are being abandoned on footpaths and in rivers, causing a nuisance and costing businesses millions of dollars.
Council staff responded to reports of 6313 abandoned trolleys in the city in the year to last October, more than half of which came from the country's two biggest supermarket chains —2238 from Woolworths New Zealand and 1652 from Foodstuffs-owned Pak'nSave and New World.
RNZ has been told trolleys cost an average of $300 but could cost up to $700 each, with Woolworths spending more than $1.5 million per year on abandoned trolleys nationwide.
Abandoned trolleys were generally reported via the Snap Send Solve app and directed to the retailer who owned the trolley for collection.
On Wednesday, councillors would consider a staff report outlining regulatory and non-regulatory options for addressing the problem by either by adding a clause to an existing waste bylaw or working with Retail NZ on a memorandum of understanding.
Under that approach, they would collaborate on preventive measures and collecting and returning trolleys to stores.
Staff also canvassed distance and time limits around trolley use, including coin deposit locks and wheel locks, although they noted the coin system could easily be circumvented by inserting another item like a key into the slot and people could keep pushing trolleys with locked wheels, breaking them.
Woolworths New Zealand said it had trolley collection services to help keep streets tidy.
"We want to keep our local communities tidy and trolley-free and ensure that we have enough trolleys available in our stores," a spokesperson said.
"We spend over $1.5 million a year on collecting abandoned trolleys, and our contractors collect around 80,000 trolleys and return them to our stores every year."
Foodstuffs said most customers did the right thing and returned trolleys to their designated bays.
"Out of the hundreds used each week, only a small number are taken off-site. We regularly patrol nearby streets to collect abandoned trolleys, and when members of the public report one, we aim to retrieve it as quickly as possible," a spokesperson said.
"However, trolleys do occasionally go missing, and it's always disappointing when they're stolen or dumped. We encourage the public to report any misplaced or stolen trolleys so we can arrange prompt collection.''
Councillor Yani Johanson said he had once seen 10 trolleys in one street, and in one case it took more than a month and 10 complaints for a trolley to be collected.
"The people that own the shopping trolleys have a duty of care to the environment and the community to pick them up and to stop them from being abandoned in the first place," he said.
Johanson had requested the council to take a similar approach to Auckland Council, which had added shopping trolleys as a clause in its waste management and minimisation bylaw in 2019.
Councillor Aaron Keown said supermarkets and other shopping precincts should have areas beyond which trolleys cannot go, otherwise it would be treated as theft.
"I'm not allowed to walk into the store and grab six blocks of chocolate and walk out, trolleys are exactly the same," he said.
"People take this liberty that 'it's a shopping trolley, I'll just use it to get my goods home'. It's not for that, stop doing it."
Councillor Sara Templeton said trolleys were sometimes abandoned because people did not have another way to take their groceries home.
"In Ōtautahi Christchurch we have 13% of adults who don't have a driver's licence. For many of them, being able to transport groceries home in another way is really valuable," she said.
"Yes, they should be taking them back afterwards, but I'm not in favour of stopping people being able to remove trolleys from business premises."
Retail NZ advocacy manager Ann-Marie Johnson said she favoured a solution involving both the council and retailers.
"Then you've got willing partners on both sides to investigate the issue, whereas if it's put into a bylaw, that can be a heavy-hitting approach," she said.
By RNZ's Joe Shaw

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Otago Daily Times

2 days ago

• Otago Daily Times

Councillor denies privacy breach

The West Coast Regional Council is alleging a privacy breach involving its former chairman after correspondence from a mining company ended up in the media. However, Cr Allan Birchfield, who openly admits passing the information on, denies there was any breach. If the council wanted to take issue with it — "bring it on". The council released a statement this week, and although it did not directly refer to Cr Birchfield, it took issue with the release of the correspondence from Chinese-owned Westcoast Mining Ltd shared with "some councillors". The correspondence complained about a two-year delay in their resource consent application, and being ordered by regional council staff to shut down mining operations in the meantime. Council chairman Peter Haddock said in a statement Westcoast Mining Ltd had "confirmed it did not share" its correspondence to the council with anyone else. "Nor did it give permission for any of its information to be shared," Cr Haddock said. Rather, the letter had been shared "confidentially" with some councillors. "It's very disappointing privacy between [the] council and the company has been breached ... We will be taking measures to deal with this transgression." Cr Birchfield said yesterday he took "full credit" for passing on the information because it concerned council activities in the public domain. "They're wrong. That letter was written to all the councillors, and I take full credit for releasing it," he said. "The public should know the mining community do know what is going on [with the council]." He said the correspondence would be otherwise discoverable anyway through the Local Government and Official Information and Meetings Act. The allegations outlined by Westcoast Mining were "symptomatic" of wide disquiet in the West Coast community about the changing council approach to consenting and compliance, Cr Birchfield said. It not only reflected the growing concern within the West Coast mining fraternity but from other industry sectors seeking routine consents and now being presented with new hurdles. Cr Birchfield said the information being sought officially now often reflected no West Coast mining knowledge or local knowledge at all. "I'm being barraged with complaints from the industry and I'm sick of it. "I released that letter because it's not private," Cr Birchfield said. Cr Brett Cummings, who chairs the Resource Management Committee, was surprised at the council stance but preferred not to comment publicly. He was already awaiting further information on "concerns with the consenting process" he had raised. Cr Peter Ewen, who has regularly sparred with Cr Birchfield, described the release of the correspondence as "grandstanding" and "attention seeking". He said Cr Birchfield knew "full well" the rules about information disclosure. Given it was apparently yet to be tabled at the council meeting he was "jumping the gun". "I think attention-seeking councillors are doing it all the time — that's the problem," Cr Ewen said. "There's a right and a wrong way to do it. He knows that ... there's an election coming." Cr Ewen said there was also some irony in that Cr Birchfield, a gold miner, had not always declared his own mining activities at the council table. "He can't even follow the rules himself." Cr Haddock said Westcoast Mining Ltd had been mining without a resource consent when it was shut down on May 31. "It was clear the resource consent was yet to be issued as a company representative visited the WCRC office on May 16 ... to request alterations to their [application]. "We will not be commenting further while the matter is under investigation," Cr Haddock said. — Greymouth Star

1News

3 days ago

• 1News

Food from fire-damaged New World: Can it be sold or donated?

It is unclear at this stage whether food or drink from an Auckland New World which was damaged in a fire on Tuesday can be sold or donated. The fire broke out shortly after 11am on Tuesday at the store in Freeman's Bay. Damage inside the store has been called "extensive", and Foodstuffs said it will take some time to determine when the store may be able to reopen. But, asked whether items from within the store could be sold or donated, a Foodstuffs person told 1News the "short answer is – too early to know". "Fire and Emergency completed their operations at the site this afternoon and have handed the building back to Foodstuffs," the Foodstuffs spokesperson said. ADVERTISEMENT "At this stage, it's too early to say what will happen to the groceries in the store, but this will be assessed over the coming days. "Food safety will be top of mind when any decision is made." The morning's headlines in 90 seconds including what will happen to food after supermarket blaze, Trump's dithering over the Middle East, and winter car care tips. (Source: 1News) The Ministry for Primary Industries said all food sold in New Zealand was required by law to be safe and suitable for consumption. "Food businesses are regularly verified to make sure these rules are being followed. "Foodstuffs have systems in place to assess potentially affected food products. "We have offered assistance." ADVERTISEMENT As for the building itself, Auckland Council field surveying manager of building consents Jeff Fahrensohn said New World's contractors would assess the damage and then design a remediation plan based on input by specialists such as fire engineers. "The council currently has a live consent for remediation works to New World Victoria Park — lodged prior to the fires — so depending on the level of work needed, the remediation works may be added to the existing building consent as an amendment. Or alternatively, it may need a new building consent and possibly a resource consent as well. "Once consents are approved, the works will commence with inspections by the council and possibly other specialists," Fahrensohn said. "Once work is complete, a Code Compliance Certificate (CCC) would be applied for. The CCC would confirm the fire safety systems are all operating as required. The supermarket cannot open unless the CCC is issued. "An exception would be if there are areas unaffected by the fire, it may be possible to partially open those areas under a certificate of public use (CPU) as long as it is safe to do so."

Scoop

3 days ago

• Scoop

Speirs Finance Group Makes Two Senior Appointments To Drive Growth In Healthcare Finance And Fleet Leasing

Speirs Finance Group has strengthened its team with two senior hires, each tasked with accelerating growth in high-priority sectors of the business. Michelle Herlihy, Chief Executive Officer of Speirs Finance Group, says the appointments come at an exciting time as the company expands what it can offer. "Sean's deep sector knowledge will let us deliver smarter, more flexible funding to healthcare providers nationwide, while Hayley's energy and relationship skills will lift Yoogo Fleet's presence in the North. We're delighted to welcome them both." Sean Coutts becomes Commercial Manager, Healthcare, leading the newly created division within Speirs Finance that funds medical, dental and veterinary equipment. Coutts brings more than two decades of experience working with leading health-technology suppliers and is known for designing tailored capital-equipment solutions that preserve cash flow while keeping practices at the cutting edge of technology. Hayley Holt joins Yoogo Fleet, part of Speirs Finance Group, as Northern Business Development Manager from July, responsible for customer growth from Taupō north. A well-known broadcaster and former TVNZ reporter, Holt recently stepped back from media to study finance. Her remit includes partnering with clients to deliver customised fleet solutions that enhance business productivity through real-time visibility, guaranteed compliance, and optimised asset utilisation. Hayley will support organisations in streamlining their fleet operations, freeing them to focus on driving their core business forward while achieving sustainability objectives. About Speirs Finance Group: Founded in Palmerston North in 1964, Speirs Finance Group is a Kiwi-owned asset-finance specialist that partners with New Zealand businesses to fund equipment, technology and vehicle fleets through simple, flexible solutions. The Group includes Speirs Finance, focused on SME and sector-specific funding including a dedicated healthcare division and Yoogo Fleet, a nationwide vehicle-leasing and fleet-management provider founded in 2013 and recognised for its data-driven, sustainability-led approach. Yoogo Fleet was recently appointed to the All-of-Government panel, reinforcing its position as a trusted partner for both private and public sector fleet solutions.