Paramasivan Fathima Movie Review: This predictable film is ideologically inept and clumsily crafted
Generally, filmmakers find it easy to dish out social issues if their films are set in a fictional world. This helps you stay away from offending any powerful person, organisation or community. It also creates a space for uninhibited discussions. But filmmaker Esakki Karvannan is disingenuous with things he presents as issues and lacks honesty in exploring them fully.
Paramasivan Fathima introduces the fictional world of Subramaniyapuram and the towns split from it, namely Yokobpuram (predominantly Christian) and Sultanpettai (predominantly Muslim). The film begins with the narration that the rampant conversions are the reason for the split, and prospective grooms from both these towns die a day before their D-day. In parallel, we get glimpses of Paramasivan (Vemal) and Fathima/Tamilselvi (Chayadevi), teasing us with what could have happened to them even though the familiar stench of honour killing is discernible from a mile away. However, the film chooses to take a tiring 140 minutes to uninspiringly tell us the relation between the deaths and conversions.
Putting itself on a high pedestal, the film claims to impart some noble message, but is off the target right from the beginning. It reeks of contrivance, especially with no villager in this film having anything to do except be bothered by religion. It could be said that communal flare-ups in Tamil Nadu are few and far in between when compared to cases of caste discrimination. However, the absence of an engaging fictional story cannot be blamed on the social fabric of the state. The film should have ideally explored how bigotry comes in the way of religious harmony in the 21st century rather than creating a fictional world filled with people, who seem to be straight out of the Middle Ages.
The film also trivialises hunger and unemployment through Hindu characters coercing others in their community to not convert for "food and jobs" as though they aren't important enough for sustenance. The question is, what kind of pride should one take in a religion where one follower does not take care of another? Why will anyone not be grateful to someone from some other faith, who has taken it upon themselves to provide sustenance to live a dignified life? Also, it is important to note that the act of service done with an ulterior motive of converting more people to their religion cannot be brought under the umbrella term of 'service.' It is but a transactional relationship.
Can an apathetic person judge when someone from his 'brethren' converts to another religion after receiving certain favours from them? No. Some scenes and dialogues reflect the 'rice-bag convert' condescension in social media, but this anger would have been better justified if it was targeted at those depriving the starving people of their 'rice bag'. 20th-century American psychologist Abraham Maslow would have created a five-tier needs hierarchy that treats physiological and safety needs as having paramount importance for a bare minimum decent life. Food and material requirements aren't nothing. I am duty-bound to remind such self-righteous people that the miracle stories of Lord Krishna filling his impoverished friend Kuselan's house with riches just for a morsel of puffed rice and Lord Jesus multiplying five bread loaves and two fishes to feed 5000 people are being taught to their respective followers even to this day to praise God's glory, generosity and magnanimity.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NDTV
16 minutes ago
- NDTV
Greenpeace Amongst Protestors Against Jeff Bezos-Sanchez's Venice Wedding
Venice: Global environmental lobby Greenpeace added its voice on Monday to protests against this week's celebrity wedding in Venice between American tech billionaire Jeff Bezos and journalist Laura Sanchez. The event, expected to attract some 200 guests including U.S. President Donald Trump's daughter Ivanka and son-in-law Jared Kushner, as well as scores of stars from film, fashion and business, has been dubbed "the wedding of the century". But some locals see the celebration as the latest sign of the brash commodification of a beautiful but fragile city that has long been overrun with tourism while steadily depopulating. Activists from Greenpeace Italy and UK group "Everyone hates Elon" (Musk) unfolded a giant banner in central St Mark's Square with a picture of Bezos laughing and a sign reading: "If you can rent Venice for your wedding you can pay more tax." Local police arrived to talk to activists and check their identification documents, before they rolled up their banner. "The problem is not the wedding, the problem is the system. We think that one big billionaire can't rent a city for his pleasure," Simona Abbate, one of the protesters, told Reuters. Mayor Luigi Brugnaro and regional governor Luca Zaia have defended the wedding, arguing that it will bring an economic windfall to local businesses, including the motor boats and gondolas that operate its myriad canals. Zaia said the celebrations were expected to cost 20-30 million euros ($23-$34 million). Bezos will also make sizable charity donations, including a million euros for Corila, an academic consortium that studies Venice's lagoon ecosystem, Italy's Corriere della Sera newspaper and the ANSA news agency reported on Sunday. Earlier this month, anti-Bezos banners were hung from St Mark's bell tower and from the famed Rialto bridge, while locals threatened peaceful blockades against the event, saying Venice needed public services and housing, not VIPs and over-tourism. The exact dates and locations of the glitzy nuptials are being kept confidential, but celebrations are expected to play out over three days, most likely around June 26-28.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Tyra Banks opens up about love for Australia; reveals how she wants to encourage women
, the American supermodel, opened up about finding Australia like her dream home. The 51-year-old not only fell in love, but she also moved to the country after visiting the country regularly. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Tyra Banks' love for Australia In an interview with the Daily Mail, Banks revealed that she loves Sydney's charm and relaxed vibe, while unveiling her ice cream shop 'SMiZE & DREAM.' 'I was coming for about a year and a half and just fell in love with it,' she said. 'And I said, should we make this move? And here we are,' she said. 'I love Darling Harbour because of this park. Tumbalong Park is magical,' she said, before adding that even before she opened a shop here, she and her family would spend weekends over there. 'I have friends that live an hour and a half away, and on the weekends. They drive here just to go to the water and put their feet in with the kids,' she further continued, and expressed that there's a playground nearby for older and younger kids. Tyra Banks' favourite ice cream flavour... About Tyra's ice cream brand, she said it feels personal. When asked about her favourite scoop, she said while laughing, 'My favourite flavour is called Tyra's Favourite – very creative, isn't it?' The flavour is salted sweet cream with butter-roasted pecans and a thick, savoury caramel butter swirl. 'It's not your traditional ice cream taste – it has this surprising, rich sensation in the mouth,' she continued. Furthermore, she also dropped the crumbs about a potential collaboration with her fellow Australian friend. The friend is famous, and Banks is excited that she is interested in doing something with her. Tyra Banks wants to encourage women... Tyra hopes to achieve big, beyond her ice cream brand. She said that she wants to encourage women to reinvent themselves irrespective of their age. 'But we have to know our stuff. Unfortunately, women, we have to be better. We have to be smarter. We have to know more,' she said, before adding, 'Just go deep, study hard, walk into that room head held high. You're going to hear 'no's – but one day you're going to get that 'yes'. And you just have to be ready for it.'
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
R. Kelly's fiancée denies all the accusations by her parents; claims to not being a victim or a slave
R. Kelly , the American singer who has been convicted of racketeering, sex trafficking, and child obscenity, was recently sent to the hospital after the prison staff allegedly gave him a copious amount of medicine that would kill him. What did Joycelyn Savage's parents claim? Amid the controversy of his asking for a pardon out of concern of being assassinated in jail, R. Kelly's fiancée's parents accused him of controlling their daughter. According to her parents, the last time they heard from their daughter was in 2019 in a short phone conversation, and they claim that Kelly has a hold of her even after being in custody. The 'Down Low' singer's fiancée, Joycelyn Savage, has denied all the claims and accusations made by her parents. She released a video on Sunday and insisted that she is neither a victim nor a slave. She said that they have been together for 10 years, engaged for three, and want to get married and start a family. Joycelyn Savage gave a statement... Savage asked the audience to believe in any lies her family say. 'I am not held against my will. I am not a sex slave. I am not brainwashed or any of those crazy lies that were told on me,' she said, according to TMZ. She further asked the fans to pray for R. Kelly so that he gets out of prison soon. What happened to R. Kelly? Earlier this month, R. Kelly was rushed to the hospital after he went through a medication overdose. His attorney claimed in the filings that the overdose happened in the prison when the staff 'gave him an amount of medicine that could have killed him" in solitary confinement. However, the prosecutors have firmly denied the claims. Before passing out, the 58-year-old singer allegedly felt 'dizzy' and 'faint,' and saw a couple of black spots in his vision. He spent two days in the Duke University Hospital.
