US newspaper recommends books that don't exist through AI-generated reading list
An AI-generated reading list in the Sun-Times and Inquirer featured fake titles by real authors; both have apologised. – LYNDON FRENCH/The New York Times
The summer reading list tucked into a special section of the Chicago Sun-Times and The Philadelphia Inquirer seemed innocuous enough.
There were books by beloved authors such as Isabel Allende and Min Jin Lee; novels by bestsellers including Delia Owens, Taylor Jenkins Reid and Brit Bennett; and a novel by Percival Everett, a recent Pulitzer Prize winner.
There was just one issue: none of the book titles attributed to the above authors were real. They had been created by generative artificial intelligence.
It's the latest case of bad AI making its way into the news. While generative AI has improved, there is still no way to ensure the systems produce accurate information. AI chatbots cannot distinguish between what is true and what is false, and they often make things up. The chatbots can spit out information and expert names with an air of authority.
Most of the book descriptions were fairly believable. It didn't seem out of reach that Bennett would 'explore family bonds tested by natural disasters,' or that Allende would pen another 'multigenerational saga.'
The technology publication 404 Media reported earlier on the reading list. In addition to nonexistent book titles, the section included quotes from unidentifiable experts.
Both the Sun-Times and the Inquirer issued statements condemning the use of AI and in part blamed King Features, a Hearst syndicate that licenses content nationally. The syndicate produced the 56-page supplement to the newspaper called 'Heat Index: Your Guide To The Best Of Summer', which also included things like summer food trends and activity recommendations.
While the list did not have a byline, a freelancer named Marco Buscaglia took responsibility for the piece. He confirmed that the list was partially generated by artificial intelligence, most likely Claude.
'It was just a really bad error on my part and I feel bad that it has affected the Sun-Times and King Features, and that they are taking the shrapnel for it,' Buscaglia said in an interview.
It's fairly common for media organisations, especially resource-strapped local newsrooms, to rely on syndicates to supplement coverage.
Just two months ago, 20% of staff at the Sun-Times resigned as part of a buyout offer.
On the newspaper's homepage on Wednesday, there were two banners atop the website. One linked to the statement on the May 18 special section, and the other linked to a piece on how federal cuts threaten local journalism.
Felix M. Simon, a research fellow in AI and digital news at the Reuters Institute at Oxford University, said the technology was not entirely at fault. There are responsible and irresponsible ways to use AI for news gathering, he said.
'We need better education for everyone from the freelancer level to the executive level,' said Simon, calling on people to look 'at the structures that ultimately allowed this factually false article to appear in a reputable news outlet.'
The special section was removed from the Inquirer's website when it was discovered, according to Lisa Hughes, the publisher and CEO of the paper. The section was also removed from the Sun-Times' e-paper version, according to a statement, and subscribers would not be charged for the premium edition.
King Features did not respond to requests for comment, but in a statement provided to the Sun-Times said it had 'a strict policy with our staff, cartoonists, columnists, and freelance writers against the use of AI to create content.'
In their statement, the Sun-Times said that the incident should be a 'learning moment.'
'Our work is valued — and valuable — because of the humanity behind it,' the statement read. – By TALYA MINSBERG/ ©2025 The New York Times Company
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Straits Times
6 days ago
- New Straits Times
#SHOWBIZ: Taiwanese actress Michelle Chen weeps at Stefanie Sun's Beijing concert
TAIPEI: Taiwanese actress Michelle Chen wept during Singapore pop star Stefanie Sun's concert at Beijing's National Stadium recently. The 42-year-old was among the 50,000 guests who turned up for Sun's concert on June 13. "She is my favourite Chinese-language female singer and I have waited for this concert for a long time," said Chen on Chinese social media platform Weibo on June 14. "I had a chance to watch it more than 10 years ago, but missed it due to work," she said. "I didn't expect that it would be many years later before I got to watch her." Sun, 46, kicked off her first world tour in a decade, titled Aut Nihilo, in April with four concerts in Singapore. She also performed in Shanghai in April and Shenzhen in May. "I wanted to cry the moment you appeared on stage, as you were part of my youth for many years," Chen wrote. "Fortunately, I cried for only half of the show as there were fast songs." The actress, who is best known for the Taiwanese film You Are The Apple Of My Eye (2011), quoted part of the Chinese-language title of the movie in her post. "During those years I listened to your songs, the songs felt like they were carrying one part of innocence, two parts of stubbornness and three parts of freedom," she wrote. "I found myself in the songs and pursued my dreams." Sun's concert in Beijing was her first at the stadium since her debut in 2000. She became the fourth Chinese-language female singer to hold a concert there after Hong Kong's Karen Mok and G.E.M., as well as Taiwan's A-Mei.
The Star
6 days ago
- The Star
Michelle Chen weeps at Stefanie Sun's 1st concert at Beijing National Stadium
Michelle Chen (right) was among the 50,000 spectators who turned up for Stefanie Sun's concert in Beijing on June 13. Photos: Handout, Michelle Chen/Weibo Taiwanese actress Michelle Chen wept during Singapore pop star Stefanie Sun's concert at Beijing's National Stadium. The 42-year-old was among the 50,000 spectators who turned up for the Beijing leg of Sun's concert tour on June 13. 'She is my favourite Chinese-language female singer and I have waited for this concert for a very long time,' Chen wrote on Chinese social media platform Weibo on the morning of June 14. 'I had a chance to watch it more than 10 years ago, but missed it due to work,' she wrote in Chinese. 'I didn't expect that it would be many years later before I got to watch her in concert.' Sun, 46, kicked off her first world tour in a decade, titled Aut Nihilo, in April with four concerts in Singapore. She also performed in Shanghai later in April and in Shenzhen in May. 'I wanted to cry the moment you appeared on stage, as you were part of my youth for many years,' Chen wrote. 'Fortunately, I cried for only half of the show as there were fast songs.' The actress, who is best known for the Taiwanese coming-of-age romance film You Are The Apple Of My Eye (2011), then quoted part of the Chinese-language title of the movie in her post. 'During those years I listened to your songs, the songs felt like they were carrying one part of innocence, two parts of stubbornness and three parts of freedom,' she wrote. 'I found myself in the songs and pursued my dreams.' The actress posted photos of her concert ticket and herself at the event, as well as two short videos of Sun performing. Sun's concert at Beijing's National Stadium, which is nicknamed the Bird's Nest, was her first at the venue since her debut in 2000. Sun will be holding a second show there on June 15. She became the fourth Chinese-language female singer to hold a concert at the stadium after Hong Kong's Karen Mok and G.E.M., as well as Taiwan's A-mei. – The Straits Times/Asia News Network
The Sun
10-06-2025
- The Sun
US judge dismisses actor Baldoni's lawsuit against Lively, NYT
NEW YORK: A US judge on Monday rejected a $400 million lawsuit that actor Justin Baldoni filed against former co-star Blake Lively and The New York Times after she accused him of sexual harassment and other misbehavior. Back in December the Times reported that Lively had filed a complaint against Baldoni and producer Jamey Heath for allegedly inappropriate behavior and comments during the shooting of the movie 'It Ends with Us.' The complaint said Baldoni -- who also directed the film -- had spoken inappropriately about his sex life and sought to alter the film to include sex scenes that were not in the script and had not been agreed to. It also said Heath had watched Lively while she was topless, despite having been asked to turn away. It further said Baldoni waged a PR campaign to wreck Lively's reputation. A lawyer for Wayfarer, the studio behind the film, said in a statement released to the New York Times at the time that neither the studio, its executives, nor its PR team did anything to retaliate against Lively. 'These claims are completely false, outrageous and intentionally salacious with an intent to publicly hurt and rehash a narrative in the media,' lawyer Bryan Freedman wrote in December. Baldoni filed suit in January against the actress, her husband Ryan Reynolds and the Times, arguing that an article the paper ran in December defamed him. On Monday, Judge Lewis Liman of the US District Court in Manhattan dismissed the lawsuit filed by Baldoni. The judge said the Times had simply reported on Lively's original legal filing alleging harassment on set and a retaliatory smear campaign, and that it had taken the trouble to seek a reaction from Baldoni to the actress's allegations. The judge also rejected allegations by Baldoni that Lively, whose Instagram account has more than 43 million followers, had tried to seize control of the film and its promotion. Baldoni accused her husband, Reynolds, of wrongly describing him as a sexual predator. In a statement carried by US media, Lively's lawyers celebrated what they called a 'total victory' over Baldoni's 'retaliatory lawsuit.' Baldoni's lawyer did not immediately respond to an AFP request for comment. Based on a best-selling novel by the US writer Colleen Hoover, 'It Ends with Us' is a romantic drama that made more than $350 million at the box office in 2024, making it one of the biggest hits of the year.
