Closing arguments in Thomas Hamp's murder trial wrap up Wednesday
Both the defence and the Crown gave their closing arguments on whether Thomas Hamp should be considered not criminally responsible for the death of his girlfriend, Emily Sanche.
The defence's submission was to find Hamp not criminally responsible, while the Crown wants the court to consider all the possibilities for Hamp's violent attack.
Hamp is charged with fatally stabbing Sanche on Feb. 20th, 2022.
Hamp admitted to stabbing her earlier in the trial. We also learned that Sanche deeply documented Hamp's path of psychosis and lobbied for his care.
It was determined Hamp suffered from OCD, cannabis use disorder and was on the realm of schizophrenia spectrum.
Hamp said his delusions ramped up in weeks before the attack.
Story continues below advertisement
He thought the secret police were coming to take him and Sanche away to 'torture and murder them.'
Defence lawyer Brian Pfefferle said Sanche was loved by all, including Hamp.
'There would be absolutely no reason why any sane person would do anything to harm her, and our position is that frankly no sane person would harm her,' said Pfefferle.
Get daily National news
Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy
Pfefferle said the report by psychiatrist Dr. Shabehram Lohrasbe, which found Hamp was acutely psychotic that morning, indicated Hamp's ability to know his actions were wrong was impaired.
He also noted Hamp has an 'undisputable mental disorder' that was a 'longstanding' issue.
'This is a person that has absolutely no record or history of violence, his delusions were getting more and more bizarre,' said Pfefferle.
The Crown says the defence's argument falls on whether he knew it was right or wrong.
Cory Bliss, senior Crown prosecutor, points to Hamp's diagnosis of cannabis use disorder, noting a cannabis-induced psychosis is different from a mental health one.
We know Hamp stopped taking weed days before the incident, but not the exact date.
The Crown also pointing to the fact that even Lohrasbe was concerned about Hamp's initial attempt to claim someone broke into their house and stabbed them both, which he later retracted.
Story continues below advertisement
'It's very unusual that someone would commit a crime while deluded and then immediately suggest that someone else committed the crime,' said Bliss.
Bliss said it's unusual for someone who was having delusions that the secret police was after them would calm down at the sight of police following the incident.
Hamp didn't bring up his delusions about the secret police or torture at the scene or hospital.
Bliss questions why Hamp, who was thinking of committing a murder suicide, didn't go through with killing himself.
He also wants the court to consider if there were triggers leading to Hamp's violence.
Hamp had heard a phone call between Sanche and his parents about taking him to the hospital. There was also a notebook found where Sanche had written out steps for getting help.
'That he was angered by her decision to basically take the choice out of his hands and force him to receive psychiatric help,' said Bliss.
Bliss wondered why Sanche had never written about the secret police delusions Hamp claimed to have.
Due to the complex case, the court is not able to make a decision this week.
Story continues below advertisement
The verdict is set to come down in July.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Global News
2 hours ago
- Global News
Police investigating homicide at Ajax GO parking lot
See more sharing options Send this page to someone via email Share this item on Twitter Share this item via WhatsApp Share this item on Facebook Durham Regional Police say they are investigating the region's fourth homicide at a GO station. Police said on Monday the homicide happened at Ajax GO station parking lot. Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy Service at the GO station is not impacted but police said commuters should expect delays and limitation on parking availability. There is no word on suspects.
Global News
11 hours ago
- Global News
Continued cougar sightings keep parts of Whistler Blackcomb closed
Large areas of Whistler Blackcomb will stay closed again on Monday after more cougar encounters over the weekend. The latest sightings were reported Sunday morning on the Blackcomb side of the Whistler Mountain Bike Park. Whistler Blackcomb says the Ascent Trail, Blackcomb bike trails, and both the Creekside and Garbanzo Zones will stay closed Monday. A young family tells Global News they were on a trail just before noon when a woman got caught with a cougar above her and another below. The family says the woman banged her hiking poles together to scare the big cats off before they arrived. Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy 'My dad had pepper spray on him,' explains 11-year-old Carter. 'And he's like, 'yeah it's a cougar' and he just kept screaming 'it's a cougar, it's a cougar.'' Story continues below advertisement Carter and his parents then took the Gondola the rest of the way down. Conservation officers say they have not found the cougars yet but stress the priority is public safety. 'We're still up on the mountain investigating those incidents and we have a number of conservation officers in the area,' says Sgt. Chris Boyle with the BC Conservation Officer Service. 'In both instances no one was injured however the cougars did get quite close to the bikers and in one case, the cougar chased the biker for about 300 metres,' he added. Officers say the animals are not candidates for relocation since they're already in a wild area, they hope the big cats will leave on their own, adding these incidents are believed to be related. 'We had some encounters at Rubble Creek a couple of weeks ago in Garibaldi Park and then again on Whistler Mountain a couple of days ago, and now on Blackcomb mountain, Boyle explains. 'So, it's a series of events similar in nature, which is quite unusual.' Officers say if the cougars remain in the area and threaten the safety of people, they could be destroyed.
Global News
a day ago
- Global News
‘There's no protection': Canadian Sikh leaders face threats, organization says
The World Sikh Organization says multiple Sikh leaders in Canada have received notice from the RCMP that their lives could be in imminent danger. But WSO spokesperson Balpreet Singh told The West Block's Mercedes Stephenson that the national police force shared few details about who was behind the threats — and little in terms of protection or assistance. 'What happens is that you're approached by law enforcement and they give you a piece of paper that says that your life is in imminent risk of being targeted, that you could be killed,' Singh said in an interview. 'They take that paper back and then they ask you, 'Well, where do you think this threat is coming from?' And it's really surreal to think that the police have approached you, and now they're asking you, 'Where do you think the threat is coming from?' You're not provided any real supports.' Story continues below advertisement Singh said some were told to change their routines and think about spending time away from their families and friends, but were otherwise 'left to (their) own devices.' 'It's really an odd situation where you just don't know where to go. And, you know, people that have had to leave their homes, have to leave their families. And there's no end to it,' Singh said. 'Someone approached the police six months after receiving one of these (warnings) and was told, well, there's no foreseeable end because this is a decades-long conflict. So we don't know when this threat will end.' Global News reported earlier this month the RCMP put former NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh under tight security in late 2023 after the national police force assessed the then-NDP leader's life was in imminent danger. Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy Singh and his family were protected by armed police, including at a hospital in December 2023 when Singh's wife was giving birth. His senior staff were also forced to incorporate more stringent security plans for their leader's public appearances. The new revelations come as Prime Minister Mark Carney has attempted to patch up relations with India and Prime Minister Narendra Modi in an effort to diversify Canada's trade partnerships amid tumult with the Trump administration. Canada's relationship with India – the world's fifth largest economy – have been severely strained since former Prime Minister Justin Trudeau publicly said there was 'credible' intelligence linking the Indian government to the assassination of Hardeep Singh Nijjar, a B.C. Sikh leader and Khalistan activist, who was killed on Canadian soil in 2023. Story continues below advertisement The NDP's Singh received a top-secret briefing on the intelligence related to Nijjar's murder, and told reporters there was 'clear evidence' that the Indian government was involved — a claim Indian officials dismissed as 'absurd.' In the months that followed, Singh was to find himself targeted. Citing unnamed sources, Global reported on June 12 that information about Singh's movements, family and travel schedule were being closely watched by an agent suspected of ties to the Lawrence Bishnoi gang, a transnational crime syndicate linked to murders, extortion and drug crimes. The Government of India has been accused of using Bishnoi gang members to commit violence in Canada. Sources said the agent in question has also allegedly been connected to activities directed by the Indian government. India has long accused Canada of not addressing Khalistani activists, some of whom New Delhi considers 'extremists,' living and working in Canada. The Khalistan movement agitates for an independent Sikh state in India's Punjab region. Responding to criticism over inviting Modi to the G7 Summit in Alberta last week, Carney noted that the Indian prime minister has been invited to every G7 since 2018 and called his bilateral meeting with Modi as a 'necessary first step' to rebuilding the relationship between Ottawa and New Delhi. 'I think the meeting today was important, but I would describe it as foundational… An agreement to provide the necessary foundations to begin to rebuild the relationship, based on mutual respect, sovereignty and trust,' Carney told reporters last week. Story continues below advertisement Carney said he and Modi had a 'frank, open exchange,' which included discussions of issues such as law enforcement and transnational repression. The recent federal inquiry into foreign interference named India as the second-most active player in that space, behind only the People's Republic of China. When asked how he would describe Carney's invitation to Modi to join world leaders in Alberta last week, Balpreet Singh with the WSO said 'the word that comes to mind is 'betrayal.'' 'We're not against dialogue, but it's got to be principled,' Singh said. 'But here it was a complete display of appeasement … India has still not acknowledged any role in foreign interference or transnational oppression in Canada.'
