Ashoka Co-Founder Reacts To Mahmudabad Row: 'Activism, Liberal Arts University Not Joined At The Hip'

Sanjeev Bikhchandani pointed out that while the founders are criticised as "dirty filthy capitalists," they are the ones funding the institution.
Sanjeev Bikhchandani, co-founder and trustee of Ashoka University, has expressed concerns over growing 'activism" within the institution, suggesting it has become a 'headache" and hinting at the possibility of distancing himself from the university. His remarks came in an email response to an alumnus's criticism regarding the university's handling of Professor Ali Khan Mahmudabad's arrest.
In a candid email shared on an internal mailing list, Bikhchandani emphasised that activism is not an inherent component of a liberal arts education. He stated, 'Activism and a Liberal Arts University are not joined at the hip. Ashoka is a Liberal Arts and Sciences University. Whether to be activists or not is a conscious choice people make." He further noted that his previous attempts to question the extent of activism at Ashoka were met with hostility, suggesting that some individuals have 'captured the institution" and resist any challenge to their views.
Bikhchandani also highlighted the financial contributions of the university's founders, pointing out that while they are often criticised as 'dirty filthy capitalists," they are the ones funding the institution. He questioned the assumption that liberal arts education must be synonymous with activism, citing his own experience at a liberal arts and sciences college where activism was minimal, yet students thrived.
'In the past I have questioned the activism at Ashoka—each time, I have been pounced upon by the activists and their supporters, both within and outside Ashoka: students, faculty, activists, etc., saying that 'if you are running a liberal arts university, then activism goes with the territory', that 'I am an arrogant owner', that 'dirty filthy capitalists don't understand how a university runs' (they somehow forget that the same capitalists are paying their salaries)," Bikchandani wrote.
Mentioning how he asked Google AI if all liberal arts universities are activist in nature, he wrote, 'The fundamental point I am making is that activism at Ashoka is a choice and it does not go with the territory. You can be a great liberal arts university and not be activist. Anyone who tells you otherwise is a liar."
Professor Ali Khan Mahmudabad, head of the Political Science Department at Ashoka University, was arrested on May 18, 2025, by Haryana Police over a social media post related to Operation Sindoor, India's percision strike against terrorist bases in Pakistan and PoK. Mahmudabad had in his social media post praised India's strategic doctrine and the outcome of Operation Sindoor, but criticised 'symbolic optics' and the treatment of minorities.
His arrest followed complaints alleging that his post was inflammatory and disrespectful to women in the armed forces. However, colleagues have defended Mahmudabad, asserting that his post supported the Indian government's stance and praised the strategic restraint of the armed forces.
The Supreme Court granted Mahmudabad interim bail, extending it until the third week of July. The court has directed the Special Investigation Team (SIT) to limit its probe to the two FIRs filed in relation to Mahmudabad's Facebook post and has restrained him from posting any content online related to the ongoing case.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Business Standard

12 minutes ago

• Business Standard

Rupee slips 16 paise as West Asia tensions flare up; ends at 86.74/$

The Indian rupee fell after a day of advance as the US strikes at nuclear sites in Iran triggered a risk-off sentiment among investors. The domestic currency depreciated 16 paise to end at 86.74 against the dollar, after closing at 86.59 on Friday, according to Bloomberg. The currency has fallen 1.32 per cent so far this month. Rupee traded weak as the dollar index appreciated toward the 99 mark, indicating broader currency market imbalances, according to Jateen Trivedi, VP research analyst - commodity and currency at LKP Securities. Geopolitical tensions escalated after the US conducted airstrikes on three nuclear-related sites in Iran, raising volatility across global markets, he said. Iran's Parliament has reportedly approved the closure of the Strait of Hormuz after the US struck three nuclear sites over the weekend. US President Donald Trump declared the three facilities 'totally obliterated,' and warned of greater attacks unless Iran makes peace with Israel. Crude oil prices pared gains after it rose as much as 5.7 per cent during the session. Brent crude price was up 0.25 per cent at $77.20 per barrel, while WTI crude prices were higher by 0.28 per cent at 74.05, as of 3:30 PM IST. Despite India's reliance on Iranian oil, it has diversified its sourcing from Russia and the US, reducing its dependence on the Gulf, according to Anil Kumar Bhansali, head of treasury and executive director at Finrex Treasury Advisors LLP. "However, higher oil prices could impact the current account, potentially weakening the rupee slightly. " The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) is likely to intervene to maintain market stability, and its forex reserves have reached $698 billion, nearing the all-time high of $705 billion, providing an ample buffer, Bhansali said. Meanwhile, after depreciating 1.29 per cent against the dollar this financial year, the rupee is expected to weaken more because of West Asian military conflicts, with the expectation that prices of crude oil will rise. According to a Business Standard poll, the majority of the respondents expect the rupee to depreciate to 87 a dollar by the end of July.

Business Standard

12 minutes ago

• Business Standard

Hormuz blockade may shrink Russian crude discounts for Indian refiners

Indian refiners may end up paying higher prices for Russian oil delivered in August due to escalating tensions in the Strait of Hormuz—a key transit route for around 40 per cent of India's crude imports and more than half of its LNG supplies—industry sources said. The threat of an Iranian blockade has added pressure to shipping costs and tightened the global supply of Middle Eastern oil, prompting refiners to brace for reduced discounts on Russian crude. August negotiations underway Indian refiners began negotiations this week with Russian suppliers for August-loading crude, typically done 45 days ahead of delivery, a trader at a state-owned refiner said. While volumes may remain stable or decline, demand from countries like Turkey is intensifying. Over 70 per cent of India's Russian oil consists of the medium, sour Urals grade—also preferred by Turkish refiners, particularly amid disrupted Middle East flows. Discounts fall as freight and demand rise Russian oil discounts may fall to their lowest levels in months due to higher shipping costs and increased competition, two refinery traders told Business Standard. Russia currently supplies four out of every ten barrels of oil imported by India. 'We may have to pay more for Russian oil because the discounts on the grades may shrink,' said a senior trader at a state-run oil company. Discounts could narrow by 20–40 cents per barrel, potentially falling below $2 per barrel, refining sources said. For context, discounts stood at $10–$15 per barrel in 2023 and $5–$8 earlier this year. Tighter margins could impact the gross refining margins of Indian refiners, they added. Reliance, PSUs face squeeze on discounts At present, Indian state-run refiners secure discounts of about $2.50 per barrel on Russian crude, priced against the European Dated Brent benchmark on a delivered basis. Reliance Industries, the country's top Russian oil importer, obtains a higher $3-per-barrel discount under a 500,000 barrels-per-day term deal signed with Rosneft in December. Most Russian supplies to India, however, are purchased on the spot market. Espo demand from China may rise India may also face stiffer competition from China for the East Siberia–Pacific Ocean (Espo) grade in August, particularly as Chinese refiners lose access to Iranian crude due to ongoing conflict, an Indian refining executive said. China does not typically purchase Urals but prefers Espo, a lighter crude. India's purchases of Espo have increased this year amid China's declining demand. But with Iranian supply constraints, China's dependence on Espo may rise again. This month, Espo was India's second-largest imported Russian grade, at 162,000 barrels per day, according to ship-tracking data. Russia remains top supplier Russian crude made up a record 45 per cent of India's total crude imports during the first 23 days of June, exceeding 2.2 million barrels per day, according to Paris-based intelligence firm Kpler. Urals inflows reached an all-time high of 1.6 million bpd. Reliance Industries accounted for 722,000 bpd—roughly a third of total Russian imports. State-run refiners, led by Indian Oil Corporation and Bharat Petroleum Corporation, together imported about 52 per cent. The remainder comprised lighter grades such as CPC Russia, Espo, and Arco.

Time of India

13 minutes ago

• Time of India

‘Make your social media profiles public immediately', US tells all student visa applicants

The US Embassy in India has announced stricter visa screening measures for applicants under the F, M, and J non immigrant visa categories, with immediate effect. The embassy has directed all student and exchange visitor applicants to set their social media profiles to 'public' to support identity verification and admissibility checks. The directive is part of enhanced vetting procedures being implemented across US consular services globally. 'Effective immediately, all individuals applying for an F, M, or J non immigrant visa are requested to adjust the privacy settings on all of their social media accounts to public to facilitate vetting necessary to establish their identity and admissibility to the United States,' the US Embassy in India said on X. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Bank Owned Properties For Sale In Sidi Larbi (Prices May Surprise You) Foreclosed Homes | Search ads Search Now — USAndIndia (@USAndIndia) (Join our ETNRI WhatsApp channel for all the latest updates) The announcement comes two days after the US Department of Homeland Security (DHS) posted a broader clarification regarding the nature of visas. The department had stated: 'A US visa is a privilege, not a right. The screening does not stop after it is issued.' Live Events MORE STORIES FOR YOU ✕ How Trump has targeted Harvard's international students - and what the latest court ruling means Want to study in the U.S.? The government might scroll your Instagram first — here's what the new 2025 visa rule means for foreign students « Back to recommendation stories I don't want to see these stories because They are not relevant to me They disrupt the reading flow Others SUBMIT — StateDept (@StateDept) As per the latest US State Department guidelines, every student visa adjudication is treated as a national security decision. Officials have been instructed to thoroughly examine applicants' intentions, especially regarding compliance with visa terms and potential national security risks. Under the new protocol, US posts abroad, including those in India, will soon resume scheduling appointments for F, M, and J visa applications. Applicants have been advised to monitor embassy and consulate websites for updated availability. The United States had restarted its student visa processing after a brief suspension, but new rules require foreign applicants to provide open access to their social media accounts. The US State Department made the announcement on June 19, linking the policy to national security concerns. The expanded screening is expected to impact thousands of Indian students planning to travel to the US for the fall semester. With social media becoming a key part of the vetting process, immigration attorneys have urged students to review their online activity and ensure it aligns with their declared visa purpose.