NCLAT declines to stay CCI order against UFO Moviez, Qube Cinema
Live Events
(You can now subscribe to our
(You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel
The appellate tribunal NCLAT has refused to stay a CCI order, which imposed penalties on UFO Moviez India and Qube Cinema Technologies for indulging in anti-competitive practices A three-member bench said the "balance of convenience" and "prima facie" case lies in favour of the Competition Commission of India (CCI), given concurrent findings in the DG Investigation report."Hence in the circumstances, we are of the considered opinion that the facts do not warrant the grant of stay of the impugned order," said the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT).Earlier on April 16, CCI had imposed a penalty of Rs 1.04 crore on UFO Moviez India and its subsidiary Scrabble Digital and Rs 1.66 crore on Qube Cinema Technologies for indulging in anti-competitive conduct.The matter pertains to the tussle between theatre owners and companies like UFO Moviez and Qube, which supply digital cinema equipment for rent.This was challenged by them before the NCLAT, which is an appellate tribunal for the orders passed by the CCI. The NCLAT directed them to deposit 25 per cent of the penalty amount imposed by CCI within two weeks."We have already passed an order of deposit of 25 per cent of the penalty amount vide a separate order. Be deposited within two weeks," the NCLAT said, adding that "the application for grant of interim stay is though dismissed but we grant four weeks time to file replies by the respondents and two weeks thereafter to file rejoinders".Both petitions are scheduled for a hearing before the appellate tribunal on August 1.CCI, in its order, said UFO Moviez and Qube imposed restrictions on the supply of content in their lease agreements with theatre owners, which created barriers for players engaged in the post-production processing services.In addition, these companies blocked cinema theatre owners (CTOs) with digital cinema initiatives-compliant digital cinema equipment from being served by any other players.Both companies have a market share of 34 per cent and 47 per cent, respectively, in DCI-Compliant DCEs (Digital Cinema Equipment) on lease to Cinema Theatre Owners (CTOs) in India.Due to the advent of technology, the distribution of a cinematograph film to various CTOs has transitioned to digital distribution from distribution through cinematograph film rolls.The digitally distributed cinematograph film can be played by CTOs only through a DCE, and only a digitised version is played.The NCLAT also examined the lease, terms of the agreements and the report of Dthe G of CCI."We find both the DG's report and the impugned order (of CCI) are in line with each other holding inter alia the restrictions imposed relating to content are applicable on the processes subsequent to the mastering process and though as per the agreement, contents of any third party can be run on DCE, but only subject to the payment of Rs 20,000 by the CTOs and also in case where the appellants are unable to provide content," the tribunal said.This clause does not give any choice to the CTOs to procure content from a third party.Moreover, KDM (Key Delivery Message) generated by other PPP (post-production processing) service providers could not be played on the DCE supplied by the appellant on lease, owing to the imposition of restriction on the server; and such practices do not appear to occur internationally and that other competitors, the NCLAT observed."Lastly, the clauses of the agreement(s) make the CTOs refuse to deal with other film producers of a cinematograph film who have not got his cinematograph film's PPP services done by OP2 (Scrabble Digital), hence violative of Section 3(4)(d) of the Act," the NCLAT said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
43 minutes ago
- Time of India
RBI-led initiative to curb digital frauds gains momentum, banks roped in to set up DPIP
In a bid to rein in the increasing incidence of digital payment frauds , major public and private sector banks have been roped to develop Digital Payment Intelligence Platform (DPIP) as a Digital Public Infrastructure (DPI) under the supervision and guidance of the RBI . The proposed platform seeks to bolster fraud risk management by facilitating real-time intelligence sharing and gathering, thereby preventing fraudulent digital transactions, sources said. According to sources, the institutional structure of the proposed entity would be created with the help of both public sector and private sector lenders as fraud is a common monster. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Play War Thunder now for free War Thunder Play Now Earlier this month, a high-level meeting in this regard was convened to finalise the structure of the platform where senior bank officials, RBI officials and other stakeholders were present. Since the issue is one of the top agenda for both the government and the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), sources said the platform should become operational in the next few months. Live Events Once operational, DPIP will collect and analyse data from various sources to identify potential threats and prevent fraudulent activities. By enabling real-time data sharing, the platform will help prevent scams and ensure secure transactions. Reserve Bank Innovation Hub (RBIH) has been assigned for building a prototype of DPIP in consultation with 5-10 banks. It is going to leverage advanced technologies to curb payment-related frauds. RBI, in June last year, formed a committee, chaired by A P Hota, former MD & CEO of NPCI , to examine various aspects of establishing this digital public infrastructure. According to the latest annual report of the RBI, there has been a significant surge in bank frauds, with the amount involved rising nearly three times to Rs 36,014 crore in FY25, compared to Rs 12,230 crore in the previous year. Of this, as much as Rs 25,667 crore worth of frauds were reported by public sector banks as against Rs 9,254 crore a year ago. Frauds have occurred predominantly in the category of digital payments (card/internet) in terms of the number and primarily in the loan portfolio (advances) in terms of value, it said. While card/internet frauds contributed maximum to the number of frauds reported by private sector banks, frauds in public sector banks were mainly in advances, it said.
India.com
43 minutes ago
- India.com
Bad news for employees of THIS company as these workers may be sacked due to…, Not Ratan Tata's TCS, Azim Premji's Wipro or Narayana Murthy's Infosys
Narayana Murthy, Late Ratan Tata, Azim Premji (Left to right) Massive layoff at Amazon: In a significant bad news for the employees of Amazon, Amazon CEO Andy Jassy has confirmed that the company will gradually reduce its corporate workforce over the next few years. As per the company, key roles like customer service, software development, HR, and middle management can possibly be phased out due to extensive implementation of generative AI and automation tools. Here are all the details you need to know about the possible massive layoff at Amazon. Massive layoff at Amazon The company added that over 1,000 internal AI agents in inventory forecasting to automated seller listing tools are already streamlining operations and the resulting layoffs are expected to occur through natural attrition rather than large-scale cuts. Media reports note that around 14,000 manager-level roles have already been eliminated this year and more layoffs are expected to follow. Amazon India to invest over Rs 2,000 crore in 2025 In another related event, Amazon announced that it will invest over Rs 2,000 crore ($233 million) in 2025 to expand and upgrade operations infrastructure, improve associate safety and well-being programmes, along with developing new tools and technology for its fulfillment network. As per a report by IANS news agency, the new investment builds on top of Amazon's investments in creating an operations network that helps the company deliver to all serviceable pin-codes across the country. 'For over a decade now in India, we have been focused on building the best-in-class logistics infrastructure — designed to deliver with safety, speed, scale, and reliability for our customers across the country,' said Abhinav Singh, VP-Operations, Amazon India and Australia. 'By strengthening our infrastructure capabilities, enhancing processing capacity, and implementing state-of-the-art technology, we're positioning Amazon to better serve customers throughout India while supporting our employees, associates and partners who are the heart of it all,' Singh mentioned. (With inputs from agencies)
India Today
44 minutes ago
- India Today
Sitaare Zameen Par box office Day 2: Aamir's film outshines itself, earns Rs 30 crore
The stars seem to be aligning for Aamir Khan, quite literally. His latest release, 'Sitaare Zameen Par' - a spiritual successor to the beloved 'Taare Zameen Par' - has opened on a strong note at the domestic box office, showing a solid hold through its first just two days of its release, the film has raked in Rs 32.20 crore nett in India. As per industry tracker the heartwarming sports drama witnessed a massive jump on Day 2, earning an estimated Rs 21.50 crore - nearly double its opening day collection of Rs 10.70 by positive word of mouth, the film's sharp upward trajectory at the box office is being seen as a major win for Khan, especially in comparison to his last outing, 'Laal Singh Chaddha', which earned Rs 18.96 crore over its first two days. Watch the trailer of the film here: 'Sitaare Zameen Par' features Aamir Khan alongside Genelia Deshmukh and introduces a team of young debutants including Aroush Datta, Gopi Krishna Varma, Samvit Desai, Vedant Sharma, and others. The film is directed by RS Prasanna and produced under the Aamir Khan Productions on June 20, the film is not only drawing in audiences with its emotional depth and uplifting themes but also emerging as a promising theatrical Watch
