HCSTSI President spells out ‘core' reason behind narrow tax base
HYDERABAD: President Hyderabad Chamber of Small Traders & Small Industry (HCSTSI), Muhammad Saleem Memon, has said in a statement that the core reason behind Pakistan's narrow tax net and limited number of taxpayers is the lack of public and business community's trust in the government's utilization of tax revenues.
He emphasized that unless people are assured of transparent and effective use of their paid taxes, there can be no significant improvement in voluntary tax compliance.
He highlighted that despite billions of rupees being collected in taxes annually by various departments, the public and business sectors continue to suffer from a lack of basic civic amenities. Roads remain in poor condition, hospitals and schools are dilapidated, and municipal services are constantly declining. He pointed out that numerous reports, including those from the Auditor General of Pakistan, have consistently revealed massive financial irregularities and mismanagement in public funds, but no meaningful accountability has been ensured.
HCSTSI President stressed that it is impossible to strengthen the tax system without restoring the confidence of the business community. Currently, traders feel that they are being forcefully taxed, yet their issues remain unresolved. He urged the federal and provincial governments to publish detailed annual expenditure reports alongside tax collection data, so that citizens can clearly see how and where their money is being spent.
He said that if the government ensures the transparent use of public money, it would not only boost the confidence of current taxpayers but also motivate non-taxpayers to become part of the formal economy. He noted that Pakistan's tax-to-GDP ratio is lower than other regional countries such as Bangladesh and Sri Lanka, which reflects the public's deep mistrust in how tax revenues are managed.
Drawing comparisons with developed nations, Memon stated that one of the key reasons behind their success is the public's trust in their tax systems. For instance, in Canada, each taxpayer receives an annual breakdown of where their taxes were spent. In Norway, citizens have access to detailed expenditures of any public project. South Korea's 'Taxpayer Bill of Rights' gives people full awareness and holds the government accountable. As a result, people in these countries willingly and confidently pay taxes.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
21 hours ago
- Business Recorder
‘Sudden ban on plastic bags to harm traders, industrialists'
HYDERABAD: A delegation of the Hyderabad Plastic Bags Association Market Road Hyderabad, led by Patron Yousuf Dada and President Nadeem Nizamani, met with Ahmed Idrees Chohan, Acting President of Hyderabad Chamber of Small Traders & Small Industry (HCSTSI). Delegation expressed strong concerns regarding the Sindh Government notification dated 30-04-2025, which imposes a blanket ban on all types, sizes and weights of non-degradable and oxo-degradable plastic carrier bags across the province effective from June 15, 2025. Delegation stated that while they fully support the government environmental protection initiatives and are willing to comply with the 2014 regulations, the sudden and unplanned enforcement of the ban without adequate preparation or consultation will prove devastating for small businesses, factory owners and thousands of labourers dependent on the industry. HCSTSI Acting President Idrees Chohan assured the delegation of Chamber's full support and noted that while the use of plastic bags is indeed harmful to the environment, the government must first establish a viable system for alternatives. He emphasized the need for awareness campaigns and capacity building programs to enable local industries to transition toward environmentally friendly products. An abrupt ban, he warned, would lead to increased unemployment, factory closures and inflation. The government's role should not be limited to imposing bans. It must also provide practical alternatives. HCSTSI demands that any such policy be implemented in phases, in consultation with the industry, and accompanied by public awareness efforts. Otherwise, instead of improving the environment, the move could result in serious economic consequences. The delegation concluded by affirming their commitment to supporting eco-friendly regulations, provided the government treats the trader and industrialist community with fairness and cooperation. On this occasion, Sikandar Ali Rajput, Kishor Kumar Bhatia, Abdullah Memon, Noman, Aqil Naeem, Saeed Gulshan, Jameel Naseer and Taimoor were also present. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
3 days ago
- Business Recorder
Govt launches National Electric Vehicle Policy 2025-30
The federal government has officially launched the National Electric Vehicle (NEV) Policy 2025-30, the Ministry of Industries and Production said on Thursday. Speaking at the launch, Special Assistant to the Prime Minister on Industries and Production Haroon Akhtar Khan called the policy a 'historic and transformative step' in Pakistan's journey towards industrial, environmental, and energy reforms. Haroon Akhtar Khan stated that the new EV policy is aligned with the Prime Minister's vision of promoting clean, sustainable, and affordable transportation while encouraging local industry and protecting the environment. He emphasised that the transport sector is a major contributor to carbon emissions in Pakistan, and reform in this area is imperative. National Electric Vehicle policy expected in one month He said that one of the major targets under the policy is to ensure that 30% of all new vehicles sold in Pakistan by 2030 are electric. This transition is projected to save 2.07 billion litres of fuel annually, amounting to nearly USD 1 billion in foreign exchange savings. Additionally, the policy is expected to reduce carbon emissions by 4.5 million tons and cut healthcare-related costs by USD 405 million per year. Akhtar announced that an initial subsidy of Rs. 9 billion has been allocated for the fiscal year 2025-26, under which 116,053 electric bikes and 3,171 electric rickshaws will be facilitated. Importantly, 25% of this subsidy is reserved for women to provide them with safe, affordable, and eco-friendly mobility. He said a fully digital platform has also been introduced to ensure transparent online application, verification, and disbursement of subsidies. Furthermore, the policy outlines the installation of 40 new EV charging stations on motorways, with an average distance of 105 kilometres between them. Electric Vehicle policy to be announced by end of November: Tanveer The policy also includes the introduction of battery swapping systems, vehicle-to-grid (V2G) schemes, and mandatory integration of EV charging points in new building codes to facilitate wider adoption in urban areas. To encourage local manufacturing, incentives are being provided to domestic producers. Currently, over 90% of parts for two- and three-wheelers are already manufactured locally. The government will also introduce special support packages for small and medium enterprises (SMEs) to further boost localisation. The AIDEP tariff facility will continue until 2026 and be phased out gradually by 2030. The Special Assistant noted that the policy was developed through consultations with over 60 experts, institutions, and industry stakeholders, guided by a steering committee under the Ministry of Industries and Production since September 2024. The steering committee will hold monthly and quarterly review meetings, while the Auditor General of Pakistan will conduct a performance audit every six months. He stressed that the NEV Policy 2025-30 is not only an environmental revolution but also a foundation for industrial growth, local employment, energy efficiency, and technological self-reliance in Pakistan. He expressed hope that federal and provincial governments, the private sector, and citizens will work together to realise this vision of a clean, modern, and sustainable transport system. Akhtar stated that the policy is a decisive move toward clean energy, sustainable transportation, and industrial development. It presents a comprehensive and results-driven strategy that aims to lead Pakistan toward a cleaner and more resilient future. He also highlighted that locally produced goods are 30-40% cheaper than imported alternatives. In the two-wheeler segment alone, more than 90% of parts are now produced locally. Given Pakistan's vulnerability to climate change, the EV policy will significantly contribute to achieving global carbon reduction targets. The policy is expected to yield savings of approximately Rs. 800 billion over the next 24-25 years through reduced fuel imports, the use of cheap electricity, and revenue from carbon credits. Charging vehicles with electricity will also reduce capacity payments from Rs174 billion to Rs105 billion, and carbon credits could generate around Rs15 billion in revenue. The country's total energy demand for EVs over the next five years is projected at 126 terawatt-hours, which can be met using the existing surplus in the national grid. An electric rickshaw or bike user is expected to recover their initial investment within 1 year and 10 months due to the low cost of charging compared to petrol. For instance, if the additional cost of an electric bike is Rs. 150,000, this can be recouped within less than two years through fuel savings. He concluded by saying that the government has also provided exemptions on customs duties and sales tax on EV parts to support the local industry. 'This policy should be embraced wholeheartedly by Pakistan, as it is a game-changer for our economy, environment, and industrial landscape,' Akhtar affirmed.
Express Tribune
5 days ago
- Express Tribune
HCSTSI slams FBR arrest powers in budget
Listen to article Hyderabad Chamber of Small Traders & Small Industry (HCSTSI) Acting President Ahmed Idrees Chohan has strongly condemned the inclusion of a new Section 37AA in the Sales Tax Act under the Federal Budget 2025-26. He called the amendment draconian and unconstitutional, saying it allows Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) officers to arrest any businessman, industrialist, CEO, or director merely on suspicion, without a warrant. He termed it the most dangerous legal provision in Pakistan's history. Chohan said the section empowers FBR officers to arrest and detain individuals for up to 14 days without court approval or a judicial warrant. "This violates justice and assaults constitutional rights and damages business freedom. What kind of financial reform instills fear among investors by allowing tax officials to arrest people?" he asked. "Is being an industrialist now a crime in Pakistan?" He questioned whether the government wants to promote business or drive investors abroad to business-friendly countries like Bangladesh, Vietnam, Malaysia, or the United Arab Emirates (UAE), where no such arrest clauses exist. While the world promotes ease of doing business, Pakistan appears to treat entrepreneurs like criminals, he said. The HCSTSI leader said such arbitrary arrest powers don't exist in any developed or developing country. "If someone is evading taxes, a judicial system already exists. The FBR isn't a judicial body or law enforcement agency. It has no authority to arrest," he added. Chohan labelled Section 37AA as "economic terrorism" and a deliberate act of "capital destruction". He warned that if the clause remains, Pakistan's business community will feel unsafe and foreign investment will stay away.
