India must be ‘circumspect', rules-based order has collapsed—Manish Tewari on Iran conflict

What complicates the situation for India, he said, is unlike during the Cold War era, New Delhi has no Soviet Union to fall back upon, while Chinese influence has grown over the past decade, especially since Xi Jinping took over as president of the neighbouring country.
In an interview to ThePrint, Tewari, who serves as general secretary of the Congress party's foreign affairs department, said India must also tread carefully due to what he called a 'new dynamic' developing between the US, Pakistan and China. 'I think we need to be extremely careful. We should feel the stones as we go along, because only fools rush in where wise men fear to tread,' Tewari said, pointing to the new dynamic 'at play again'.
New Delhi: Congress Lok Sabha MP Manish Tewari Sunday said that India should approach the conflict in the Middle East, which has escalated with the United States joining Israel's war with Iran, with 'extreme circumspection' and a 'degree of exceptionalism' given that the rules-based liberal democratic international order has 'collapsed'.
'Under those circumstances, India must approach the situation with a degree of exceptionalism, whereby we engage with situations and problems on our own and not really try to play 'vishwa guru'. Not that we have tried to mediate in any of these conflicts which have very complex historical and geopolitical roots. However, after this latest escalation. You know, circumspection and extreme circumspection should be the order of the day,' Tewari said.
While the Congress, the principal opposition party, is yet to issue a statement on the US bombing of Iranian nuclear sites, it had on 15 June accused Israel of violating Iran's sovereignty and encroaching on its rights.
Tewari said the Congress's position was correct from the public international law perspective.
'Because there has been a violation of Iranian sovereignty. And albeit unprovoked because there is no empirical evidence to substantiate that Iran was close to actually acquiring a nuclear bomb for a nuclear weapon. In fact, the only nuclear weapon state in the de facto nuclear weapon state in the Middle East is Israel, which purportedly has 90 warheads,' said the Chandigarh MP and former Union minister who recently travelled to Egypt, Qatar, South Africa, and Ethiopia as the member of a multi-party delegation formed by the Centre after Operation Sindoor.
In an opinion piece on the Middle East crisis published in The Hindu Saturday, Congress parliamentary party chairperson Sonia Gandhi criticised the Modi government's 'silence on the devastation in Gaza and now on the unprovoked escalation against Iran,' saying it reflects a disturbing departure from 'our moral and diplomatic traditions,' and amounts to a 'surrender of values'.
Tewari endorsed that line, underlining India's historic position with regard to the two-state solution as Israel and Palestine was concerned and also with regard to respecting the sovereignty of independent countries.
'These are templates or postulates of Indian foreign policy which stretch back into time, and we have repeatedly called out such transgressions and invasions … this has been a consistent position. So is New Delhi really going to be taking a revisionist view on this position?'
'Also there is a domestic imperative. We have a large, diverse, heterogeneous population—a population which, notwithstanding their religious affiliations, does believe in a semblance of equity and fair play and so under those circumstances, even people would be very close to watching the positions which India would take,' Tewari, a three-term MP, said.
Sharing his assessment of the geopolitical situation, Tewari said the world order and frames of an international rule of law stand completely and absolutely upended with concurrent conflicts playing out across the globe.
'In Europe, it is Russia versus Ukraine. In the Middle East, it is Israel versus Hamas versus Hezbollah versus Iran, and then you have the India-Pakistan standoff, which may have lasted a few days, but has lingering implications. And then you have the continuous militarization of the East China and South China sea as a consequence of the not too peaceful rise of China.
'What you are really witnessing is that the liberal democratic international order, built post World War II undergirded by the principles of public international law, has completely collapsed. The irrelevance of the United Nations and even the United Nations Security Council could not be more stark in what we are seeing today.'
(Edited by Amrtansh Arora)
Also Read: Iran has fewer options & more risks than before. Its choices will affect all of Middle East

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Indian Express

31 minutes ago

• Indian Express

Teenager killed by ‘crude bomb hurled during TMC victory rally' in Kaliganj

A 13-year-old girl was killed in an explosion in West Bengal's Kaliganj on Monday, allegedly after a crude bomb was hurled during a Trinamool Congress (TMC) victory rally following the party's bypoll win. The student was found with an injury on her neck on the verandah of her home in Barochandgar village, an area known to be a Congress-CPM stronghold. She later succumbed. Residents allege that the bomb was thrown from a TMC victory procession targeting a CPM supporter's house. Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee expressed shock and grief over the incident. In a statement, she said: 'I am shocked and deeply saddened at the death of a young girl in an explosion at Barochandgar in Krishnanagar police district. My prayers and thoughts are with the family in their hour of grief. Police shall take strong and decisive legal action against the culprits at the earliest.' Superintendent of Police, Krishnanagar, K Amarnath, told The Indian Express, 'One person has been detained and an investigation is underway. The body was found on the verandah and has been sent for autopsy.' A senior police official, on condition of anonymity, said prima facie it appeared to be a crude bomb. 'No splinters were recovered from the site. While it happened during a victory rally, all angles are being investigated,' the official added. The Election Commission has sought a report on the incident. The girl's mother blamed the TMC for the attack. 'They had been hurling bombs since morning. Those who did this are from the TMC. We are CPM supporters. My whole family votes for CPM,' she said. The West Bengal Police, in a statement on social media, said: 'Today, a 13-year-old girl succumbed to her injuries sustained from an explosion in Kaliganj PS area of Krishnanagar police district. We shall spare no effort to nab the culprits behind this extremely unfortunate death. Raids are on in full swing. Our thoughts are with the family.' The incident has triggered a political row. CPM state secretary Mohammad Selim hit out at the ruling party, questioning the TMC's oft-quoted slogan 'Badla noi, badal chai' (No revenge, we want change), and demanded accountability from its leadership. 'Not speeches, not sweets – bombs were thrown in the name of 'victory' in a bypoll! A minor girl was blown to death even before counting ended in Kaliganj. Only in (Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee)'s Bengal can an election celebration look like a terrorist attack! How brutal, how sick, how inhuman do you have to be to throw bombs while kids are on the street?' BJP state president Sukanta Majumdar posted on X. The by-election in Kaliganj was held following the death of the sitting MLA. TMC candidate Alifa Ahmed won the seat with a substantial margin, results for which were declared earlier in the day.

Time of India

33 minutes ago

• Time of India

Iran-Israel war: Iran's Fordo nuclear site hit again in Israeli strike; Israel says attack aimed to block access routes to enrichment facility

This satellite image provided by Maxar Technologies shows the Fordo enrichment facility in Iran before US strike. (AP) Iran's underground nuclear enrichment site at Fordo was struck again on Monday, Iranian state television reported, a day after the United States bombed the facility using heavy bunker-buster bombs in a major escalation of the ongoing conflict. Israel confirms Monday strike, says aim was to block access The Israeli military confirmed on Monday that it launched air raids to 'obstruct access routes' to the Fordo facility, stating that the strike was intended to cut off movement around the enrichment site. 'Israeli forces struck in order to obstruct access routes to the Fordo enrichment site,' the military said. US President Donald Trump had earlier said the Fordo site had been 'totally obliterated' in Sunday's US strike. IAEA: 'Very significant damage' likely at Fordo In Vienna, Rafael Grossi, head of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), said Sunday's attack likely caused heavy destruction at the sensitive facility. 'Given the explosive payload utilized and the extreme vibration-sensitive nature of centrifuges, very significant damage is expected to have occurred,' Grossi noted. He added that the IAEA has yet to fully assess the underground impact. US describes strike as one-off; Iran warns of retaliation The US described its Sunday strike on Fordo, Natanz, and Isfahan as a one-time operation to damage Iran's nuclear infrastructure. However, President Trump warned that more strikes could follow if Iran retaliates. Iran condemned the attack as a violation of its sovereignty and likened it to an invasion. Iran fires back with Operation 'True Promise 3' On Monday, Iran responded by launching missiles and drones toward Israel, targeting cities such as Haifa and Tel Aviv. Explosions were also heard in Jerusalem. Iranian state television said the barrage was part of a new wave under 'Operation True Promise 3.' Israel activated its defence systems and advised residents in northern and central areas to take shelter. Iranian general warns US of consequences Iranian General Abdolrahim Mousavi, chief of the joint staff, warned that the US airstrikes had given Iranian forces a 'free hand' to act against American interests and forces in the region. Tens of thousands of US troops are stationed across the Middle East, many within range of Iran's short-range missiles. Global leaders urge de-escalation Amid rising tensions, global calls for restraint have grown. European Union foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas urged a return to diplomacy and warned that Iran's potential closure of the Strait of Hormuz, a key oil shipping route, would be 'extremely dangerous.' The EU said Iran must be ready to return to direct talks with the US to help resolve the crisis. Iran's nuclear program in focus after 2015 deal collapse The conflict comes against the backdrop of the collapse of the 2015 nuclear agreement. After the US withdrew from the deal during Trump's first term, Iran began enriching uranium up to 60% purity and restricted access to international inspectors. On Monday, Iran's Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi held talks in Moscow with Russian President Vladimir Putin, a key Iranian ally.

Business Standard

33 minutes ago

• Business Standard

Iran's Fordow nuclear site hit again on Monday, says Iranian media

Iran's underground enrichment site at Fordo was hit again Monday while Iran fired a salvo of missiles and drones at Israel and warned the United States that its military now has a free hand to attack American targets in the wake of the Trump administration's massive strikes on Iranian nuclear sites. The Fordo facility was one of those hit in Sunday's attack, and it was struck again on Monday, Iranian state television reported. There was no immediate word on damage nor who launched the attack, though Israel said earlier it was conducting airstrikes on Iran. In Vienna, the head of the United Nations nuclear watchdog said he expected there to be heavy damage at the Fordo facility already following the Sunday's US airstrike there with sophisticated bunker-buster bombs. Given the explosive payload utilized ... very significant damage ... is expected to have occurred, said Rafael Grossi, the head of the International Atomic Energy Agency. With the strikes on Sunday on Iranian nuclear sites, the United States inserted itself into Israel's war, prompting fears of a wider regional conflict. Iran said the US had crossed a very big red line with its risky gambit to strike the three sites with missiles and 30,000-pound bunker-buster bombs. Israel said its defence systems were operating to intercept the latest Iranian threat, which apparently targeted the north and central areas of the country, and told people to head to shelters. Iran described the attack a new wave of its Operation True Promise 3, saying it was targeting the Israeli cities of Haifa and Tel Aviv, according to Iranian state television. Explosions were also heard in Jerusalem. There were no immediate reports of damage. In Iran, witnesses reported Israeli airstrikes hit areas around Iran's capital, Tehran, midday. It wasn't immediately clear what had been targeted. In Vienna, Rafael Mariano Grossi, the head of the International Atomic Energy Agency, said that given the "explosive payload utilized and the extreme vibration sensitive nature of centrifuges, very significant damage is expected to have occurred. He added that at this time, no one, including the IAEA, is in a position to have fully assessed the underground damage at Fordo. Also Monday, Iranian Gen Abdolrahim Mousavi, the chief of joint staff of armed forces, warned Washington its strikes had given Iranian forces a free hand to "act against US interests and its army. Tens of thousands of American troops are based in the Middle East, many in locations within range of short-range Iranian missiles. The U.S. described its Sunday attack on the Fordo and Natanz enrichment facilities, as well as the Isfahan nuclear sit, as a one-off to take out Iran's nuclear programme, but President Donald Trump has warned of additional strikes if Tehran retaliates. Mousavi described the American attack as violating Iran's sovereignty and being tantamount to invading the country, the state-run IRNA news agency reported. In the wake of the American attacks on Iran, calls came from across the globe for de-escalation and the return to diplomacy to try and resolve the conflict. On Monday, the European Union's top diplomat said the bloc remained very much focused on the diplomatic solution. The concerns of retaliation and this war escalating are huge, Kaja Kallas said at the start of a foreign ministers' meeting in Brussels where Iran has jumped to the top of the agenda. Especially closing of the Strait of Hormuz by Iran is something that would be extremely dangerous and not good for anybody, Kallas said, referring to a maritime route crucial for oil transport. After Sunday's attacks, Iranian officials repeated their longtime threats of possibly closing the key shipping lane. Iran, which insists its nuclear programme is for civilian purposes only, previously agreed to limit its uranium enrichment and allow international inspectors access to its nuclear sites under a 2015 deal with the US, France, China, Russia, Britain and Germany in exchange for sanctions relief. But after Trump pulled the US unilaterally out of the deal during his first term, Iran began enriching uranium up to 60% a short, technical step away from weapons-grade levels of 90% and restricting access to its nuclear facilities. As he arrived in Brussels on Monday for a meeting with his EU counterparts, German Foreign Minister renewed calls for Iran to agree again to direct talks with the United States but says Europe still has a role to play. We already made it very clear to the Iranian side that a real precondition for a settlement to the conflict is that Iran be ready to negotiate directly with the US, he said, while adding that the European group known as the E3 will contribute what we can. Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi was meeting on Monday in Moscow with Russian President Vladimir Putin, one of Iran's key allies.