Australia's teen social media ban faces a new wildcard: teenagers

HighlightsThirteen-year-old Jasmine Elkin expressed skepticism about the effectiveness of age-checking software designed to restrict social media access for users under 16, stating that individuals will find ways to bypass such measures. From December, social media platforms like Meta's Facebook and Instagram, Snapchat, and TikTok could face substantial fines for failing to implement reasonable steps to block younger users, amidst growing global scrutiny of child protection efforts online. The trial of photo-based age estimation products revealed that while many young testers had their ages guessed correctly, the reliability of the software remains uncertain, with the need for the government to establish acceptable effectiveness standards.
When 13-year-old Jasmine Elkin tried out the age-checking software Australia might use to ban children and teenagers from social media, she was surprised some products could identify a person's age to the month - but she still doubts it will work.
"People are always going to find a way to get past it," said the Perth schoolgirl who trialled five photo-based age estimation products with about 30 other students in May. "They can get their brother or sister to take a photo. There's nothing really that you can do about it."
Elkin's view echoes one of the main concerns of child protection advocates, tech firms and even the trial organisers about the technology Australia hopes will enable the world's first national social media ban for under-16s: the software works, they say, but young people will find a way around it.
From December, social media companies like Meta's Facebook and Instagram, Snapchat and TikTok will face a fine of as much as A$49.5 million ($32.17 million) if they fail to take what the law calls "reasonable steps" to block younger users in an effort to protect their mental and physical health.
The platforms say users need to be at least 13 years old to sign up for an account.
How well the ban works could reverberate across some of the world's largest companies and the governments seeking to contain them: already Britain, France and Singapore are making efforts to keep children and teens off social media, while U.S. states including Florida are challenging free speech laws by pushing for a ban.
Even the law's opponents are likely to be watching closely: X owner Elon Musk, who has been advising U.S. President Donald Trump and is a vocal opponent of platform moderation and regulation, has criticised the measure and called the regulator overseeing it a "censorship commissar".
"Everybody is looking at Australia," said Colm Gannon, CEO of the International Centre for Missing and Exploited Children Australia, a member of the trial's stakeholder adviser group. "Australia should be really focusing on robust technology, robust testing and making sure the scope of the actual project is in line with the needs that they're trying to address."
The organisers of the trial, which ended this month, say it was designed to determine whether the software worked as promised, and that nearly 60 products were pitched.
But it also underlined the teenagers' tech skills - testers were so fast completing their assignments, organisers doubled the number of products they tested and halved session times as the project progressed.
"It hasn't been our intention to pull apart the software, rip the guts out and work out every different way that you could circumvent it," said Andrew Hammond, general manager at tech contractor KJR, which ran the trial.
They will present an overview of the findings on June 20 and deliver a detailed report to the government by the end of next month.
That will inform the eSafety Commissioner's advice to the government, which cited risks from cyberbullying, harmful depictions of body image and misogynist content in pushing forward with the legislation.
"We know that social media age restrictions will not be the end-all be-all solution for harms experienced by young people online, but it's a step in the right direction to keep our kids safer," said a spokesperson for Communications Minister Anika Wells.
What about the teens?
For some of the young Australians who participated, the trial was a glimpse into a world six months in the future where, according to the law, they will no longer be allowed to use a platform they have come to rely on for daily communication.
"I use it a lot, but I can still live without it," said Canberra school student Charlie Price, 14, who trialled four software options in a room with about 60 peers and had his age guessed accurately (someone in his testing group was wrongly assessed at over 20).
"I know people that will get really shocked and upset," added Price, who uses Snapchat, Instagram and messaging platform Discord and plans to collect phone numbers of his online associates before December. Like Elkin, he said he thought some teenagers might try to get around the block.
Emanuel Casa, 15, who was in the same group, said the test subjects tried to check the products for ease and accuracy, but "no one tried to challenge it necessarily, like no one tried to trick it."
Hammond said software that revolved around a user submitting a selfie - sometimes with different facial expressions - proved the fastest and most accurate way to identify teenagers.
Products involving credit card details proved impractical since few young teens had their own cards, while those that required a person to hold up their hand in various positions gave too broad an age estimate for people near the 16 cutoff, he added.
No further trials have been scheduled, but Hammond said the government would need to decide on the level of software reliability it was prepared to accept. Most of the young testers had their ages guessed correctly most of the time, but a peer of Elkin, the 13-year-old, was placed at 42 by one product, she said.
"There is no measure at the moment as to what 'good' is. Do they need to be 70% effective or 80% effective or 100% effective?" said Hammond. "The government so far hasn't indicated that they're going to mandate a particular solution."
Nathanael Edwards, principal of Radiant Life College, a Queensland high school where 35 students along with a few parents and teachers participated, said his group tested a basic age-gating product where a person typed in their birthday.
Some did as asked, while others faked a birthday to age themselves up - although not always successfully.
"I think the mathematics caught a couple of kids out," he said.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

New Indian Express

27 minutes ago

• New Indian Express

Pope warns of AI risks to young brains

Vatican City: Pope Leo XIV warned on Friday of the potential consequences of artificial intelligence (AI) on the intellectual development of young people, saying it could damage their grip on reality. Since his election as head of the Catholic Church on May 8, the pope -- a mathematics graduate -- has repeatedly warned of the risks associated with AI but this is the first time he has spoken out exclusively on the subject. "All of us... are concerned for children and young people, and the possible consequences of the use of AI on their intellectual and neurological development," the American pope warned in a written message to participants at the second Rome Conference on AI. "No generation has ever had such quick access to the amount of information now available through AI. "But again, access to data -- however extensive -- must not be confused with intelligence," Leo told business leaders, policymakers and researchers attending the annual conference. While welcoming the use of AI in "enhancing research in healthcare and scientific discovery", the pope said it "raises troubling questions on its possible repercussions" on humanity's "distinctive ability to grasp and process reality". Pope Leo himself has been the target of deep fake videos and audio messages published on social media in recent weeks. An AFP investigation earlier this month identified dozens of YouTube and TikTok pages broadcasting AI-generated messages masquerading as genuine comments from the pope in English or Spanish. A survey from the Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism this week found significant numbers of young people in particular were using chatbots to get headlines and updates. The Catholic Church has attempted to influence ethical thinking surrounding the use of new technologies in recent years under Leo's predecessor Francis. In 2020, the Vatican initiated the Rome Call for AI Ethics -- signed by Microsoft, IBM, the United Nations, Italy and a host of universities -- urging transparency and respect for privacy.

Time of India

41 minutes ago

• Time of India

Friendship with 4 women costs Mumbai bizman Rs 80 lakh in two weeks

Mumbai: A city businessman's friendship with four women in two weeks through a social media platform cost him dearly. The four women, who contacted him separately, convinced him to invest in dollar trading for high returns, assuring him they would trade on his behalf. They shared fake profit screenshots with him and duped him of nearly Rs 80 lakh. The businessman, in his 50s, sent money in 36 transactions to various accounts provided by the accused persons. He lodged an FIR with the south cyber crime police station, stating the crime occurred between May 16 and June 1. A team led by senior inspector Nandkumar Gopale is probing the case. The businessman told the police that on May 16, while he was surfing the internet, he saw the profile of one Nitya Agrawal on Facebook. She contacted him and claimed she was from an import-export company. Agrawal began chatting with him and shared her WhatsApp number too. She inquired about his business, and he gave her information about it. She told him that she would give him work in her company's joint venture. She then suggested he invest in dollar trading for high returns. He said he had no knowledge about it. Agrawal sent him a link to download an app. He was given a login ID and a password to access the app. He began investing and could see his investment and profit in the app. She gave him various bank account numbers and asked him to send money, claiming they would do dollar trading for him. She also sent Rs two lakh to his account and gained his trust. She would send him screenshots of the trading and profit they ensured for him. On the same day, he saw the profile of one Dipti Kulkarni, a property dealer. She contacted him, shared her WhatsApp number, and befriended him. She also convinced him to invest in dollar trading, sent him a link, asked him to download an app, and gave account numbers to send money. She said she would do trading for him. He sent her money. Similarly, on May 17, he came across the profile of one Ruchika Bhatt, a property dealer, who began chatting with him and asked him to invest in dollar trading. She also shared her family photo. On May 21, he saw the profile of another woman, Aniya Roy, who contacted him and suggested he invest in dollar trading. He invested. When he asked for his money, the women told him to pay more. The businessman then asked his son to check it. After examining the apps, the son told his father he was cheated. The businessman then lodged an FIR, saying he was duped of Rs 79.14 lakh.

Mint

an hour ago

• Mint

Meta rolls out ‘Passkey' login for Facebook users on mobile devices: How the safety feature works

Meta has announced the introduction of passkeys as a new method of login for Facebook users on mobile devices. The feature is being rolled out for both iOS and Android platforms, with plans to extend support to Messenger in the near future. Passkeys are digital credentials that replace traditional passwords, allowing users to authenticate their identity using biometric methods such as fingerprint or facial recognition, or a device PIN. Developed by the FIDO Alliance, an industry group focused on improving digital security, passkeys are designed to provide a more secure and convenient way to access online accounts. According to Meta, passkeys offer a higher level of protection against common cyber threats such as phishing and credential theft. Unlike passwords, passkeys cannot be guessed or stolen via malicious websites, and they are resistant to techniques like password spraying. Users can set up a passkey through the Accounts Center located in Facebook's settings. In some cases, they may be prompted to create one during the login process. Once set up, the passkey will enable quicker and more secure access to Facebook on mobile devices that support the feature. The same passkey will also function for Messenger when support is introduced. Meta plans to extend the use of passkeys to other services, including autofilling payment details via Meta Pay and securing encrypted message backups. While the passkey becomes the default method on supported devices, users will retain the ability to log in using their password on devices that do not yet support passkey functionality. Meta has confirmed that the biometric data used to generate the passkey remains on the user's device and is neither visible to nor stored by the company. In other news, Oakley has teamed up with Meta to launch a new line of AI-powered smart glasses aimed at athletes and sports fans. The Oakley Meta HSTN (pronounced 'HOW-stuhn') blends Oakley's signature design with Meta's wearable tech, offering hands-free camera use, open-ear audio, and integrated AI assistance.