Chris Selley: Alberta NDP's divorce from the federal party trainwreck is better for everyone
Article content
Mark Carney cuts the ultimate Laurentian-elite figure, but he did grow up in Edmonton, which is a bit risqué from a Liberal standpoint. Before Carney, the party's leaders had grown up (in this order) in Montreal, Toronto, Quebec City, Ottawa, Shawinigan, Ottawa, Montreal, Hamilton … you get the picture.
Article content
The federal NDP have been stuck in Central Canada mode for nearly as long: Jagmeet Singh is from Toronto; his predecessor Tom Mulcair is from Montreal, and for all his perspicacity never really made much sense as party leader; Layton before that cut his political teeth in Toronto, yet somehow his upbringing in the arch-anglophone Montreal suburb of Hudson played to his advantage in francophone Quebec. That's not something the party will ever be able to replicate. No one is quite sure how it happened the first time.
Article content
It's an interesting fact that only one person, the little-remembered John Thompson, has ever served both as a provincial premier (Nova Scotia) and as prime minister (he was Canada's fourth, dying in office quite spectacularly of a heart attack at Windsor Castle in 1894). But there's no reason a premier couldn't or shouldn't become PM, and the NDP — more than any other nationwide party, probably — should want to break that streak.
Article content
Article content
Say what you will about British Columbia NDP premier David Eby, or former Alberta NDP premier Rachel Notley or her successor Naheed Nenshi, or Saskatchewan opposition leader Carla Beck (whose NDP hold 27 seats to the Saskatchewan Party's 34), or Manitoba NDP Premier Wab Kinew, but they're all heavy hitters compared to the low-energy types that find themselves leading the Ontario and federal parties.
Article content
There is clearly an expectation of winning in certain provincial capitals that does not exist among New Democrats at Queen's Park or on Parliament Hill — which is especially odd considering the provincial and federal parties so freely trade strategists and staffers. To pick just one prominent example: Montreal-born-and-bred Brian Topp, who ran for the party leadership against Mulcair after Layton's death, was Notley's chief of staff in Edmonton, and had previously been Saskatchewan NDP Premier Roy Romanow's deputy chief of staff in Regina.
Article content
Article content
Lately he has been reduced to crowing about how great the federal NDP's supply-and-confidence deal was with the Trudeau Liberals. It's just weird. Maybe what the party needs is a proper, public civil war.
Article content
In any event, if federal New Democrats want to be relevant again other than mathematically — never mind want to govern — they would do well to stop pretending they have anything much in common with their successful provincial comrades in Victoria, Edmonton, Regina and Winnipeg. And their comrades in those provincial capitals would do well to separate themselves from decades of wretched failure by the federal party — even if only symbolically. They're just not playing in the same league. In practice, they simply aren't the single party they claim to be.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
2 hours ago
- CBC
Conservatives to hold national convention Jan. 29-31 in Calgary
The Conservative Party of Canada's next national convention will be held in Calgary from Jan. 29 to 31, the party announced Friday. Stephen Barber, president of the party's national council, said in a statement that he was "thrilled" to host Conservatives from across the country in what he said was "a dynamic, entrepreneurial and growing city that reflects this Conservative Party." The party said Prime Minister Mark Carney is on the "same destructive Liberal path" of overspending, over-taxing and over-regulating the lives of Canadians — and that the convention will be an opportunity to address that. Conservatives across the country will use the convention to "identify areas of growth and opportunity to continue the incredible momentum we've gained over the last few years," the party said in a statement. While Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre did manage to increase his party's seat count on election night, boosting his caucus to 144 MPs, he blew a 25-point lead in the polls in the months before the election, and lost his own Ottawa riding of Carleton. Despite that result, Poilievre announced he would stay on as leader. When a Conservative leader does not resign following an election loss, the party's constitution requires party members to vote on whether that leader should keep their job at the next national convention. Having lost his seat to Liberal MP Bruce Fanjoy, Poilievre must win in a byelection in order to re-enter the House and assume the role of Opposition leader. Poilievre remains leader of the party, but former leader Andrew Scheer is currently filling the role of Opposition leader in the House. In May, Battle River-Crowfoot MP Damien Kurek said he would step aside to allow Poilievre to run in his Alberta riding, which is considered one of the safest Conservative seats in the country. Kurek first won the seat of Battle River-Crowfoot in 2019 and was re-elected this year with almost 82 per cent of the vote. Kurek officially resigned on Tuesday, after the mandatory waiting period following the election had passed. A byelection can now be called as early as this month, and must be called within 180 days. While Carney could delay Poilievre's return to the House, the prime minister said following his election victory that he'd call the race to bring the Conservative leader back to the House swiftly. "I will ensure that it happens as soon as possible. No games, nothing," he said.
Global News
3 hours ago
- Global News
Carney calls House Speaker ‘Mr. Prime Minister,' prompting laughs from MPs
In a moment that caused both sides of the House of Commons to erupt into laughter, Prime Minister Mark Carney mistakenly gave his own title to Speaker of the House of Commons Francis Scarpaleggia. Carney, who was answering a question from the opposition during question period in the House of Commons on Tuesday, started his answer by addressing the Speaker, as required by House of Commons rules, which state all questions and responses must be directed through the Speaker. Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy In English, MPs typically refer to a man serving in the role of Speaker as 'Mr. Speaker,' while in French, they direct questions and answers through 'Monsieur le président.' 'Mr. Prime Minister,' Carney began instead. Immediately realizing his gaffe, Carney put his finger up and said, 'Sorry!' Story continues below advertisement A smiling Carney pointed at himself while MPs from both sides of the House erupted in laughter. 'Battlefield promotion there,' Carney said, also laughing. Correcting himself, Carney continued, calling Scarpaleggia 'Mr. Speaker.'
Cision Canada
4 hours ago
- Cision Canada
The Chiefs Steering Committee Denounces Government of Canada's Ongoing Failure to Uphold Treaty Obligations
TREATY 6 TERRITORY, June 20, 2025 /CNW/ - The Chiefs Steering Committee on Technical Services (CSC) expresses profound disappointment in the Government of Canada's persistent failure to uphold its duties and agreements enshrined in Treaty regarding natural resources and water rights. Bill C-5 is being pushed through to fast-track 'nation-building' projects on First Nations lands and endangering Treaty rights. While Prime Minister Mark Carney publicly stated that First Nations input for this legislation is 'critical' to move forward, he failed to meaningfully consult with First Nations Chiefs in the Alberta region on this issue to date, despite multiple invitations. "The Treaties said that we, as Peoples, would live without interference. And yet, Canada has done nothing but interfere," says Chief Vernon Watchmaker from Kehewin Cree Nation and member of the CSC. "Treaties were intended to establish a nation-to-nation relationship, ensuring our Peoples would flourish for as long as the sun shines, the grass grows, and the waters flow. Treaty exists, and it cannot be ignored." Despite generations of First Nations advocacy and explicit promises made by multiple governments, most First Nations continue to live without reliable access to clean, safe drinking water and the infrastructure to support it, a fundamental human right that stands in stark contrast to the abundance enjoyed by the rest of the country. "While the Government of Canada speaks of reconciliation and a renewed relationship with First Nations Peoples, its actions regarding water rights consistently fall short," says Chief Rupert Meneen from Tallcree Tribal Government and member of the CSC. "We demand that Canada honour its binding legal and moral obligations. Our inherent right to govern and protect our waters is not a privilege to be granted, but a right to be recognized and upheld. The health and well-being of our Peoples, our lands, and our future depend on it." "Bill C-5 recognizes the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP) but provides no tangible ways to implement it," says Chief Wilfred Hooka-Nooza from Dene Tha' First Nation. Recent legislative efforts, such as Bill C-61 or the First Nations Clean Water Act, was actively criticized by the CSC for failing to adequately recognize inherent and Treaty rights to water, and potentially offloading Canada's responsibilities—a 'dump-and-run' legislation. "Canada is trying to step over the rights of First Nations, but our inherent right to self-determination comes from us, not from the government," says Chief Watchmaker. "The time for empty promises and incremental progress is over." The CSC calls upon Prime Minister Mark Carney and the Government of Canada to: Support and re-commit to the Treaty Bilateral Table on Water and Related Infrastructure, signed with the Crown's representatives in December 2024, crucial in demonstrating Canada's genuine dedication to upholding Treaty obligations and improving infrastructure for our Peoples. Immediately acknowledge and fully implement First Nations inherent and Treaty rights to water, including jurisdiction over source water protection. Provide immediate, adequate, predictable, and sustainable funding to address the severe infrastructure deficit in First Nations water and wastewater systems. Engage in true nation-to-nation co-development of all legislation and policies impacting First Nations water rights, based on the principle of free, prior, and informed consent. The CSC demands concrete action and accountability to rectify this ongoing human rights crisis and uphold the sacred spirit of the Treaties for all First Nations Peoples. About the Chiefs Steering Committee The Chiefs Steering Committee on Technical Services (CSC) was established to provide oversight and direction to the First Nations Technical Services Advisory Group (TSAG). TSAG is a not-for-profit group to serve First Nations in Treaty 6, 7, and 8 across the Alberta region to support the interests and needs of First Nations, working together with Chiefs and technicians to address water, housing, health, education and infrastructure.
