Owen Doyle: Rugby players seem to think they can interrogate referees. It needs to stop
'If you can meet with triumph and disaster and treat those two imposters just the same . . .'
At some stage in our lives, many of us have found inspiration and comfort in Rudyard Kipling's wondrous poem, If. Maybe Leo Cullen has too.
Leinster
have had their fair measure of disasters over the last few years, with nothing to show on the triumph side of the balance sheet. Losing finals and semi-finals by small margins has been bitter medicine. Not to mention the penalty try that went missing in the
Champions Cup semi-final against Northampton
.
Through all of this, Cullen has remained calm, dignified, not once trying to lay the blame at the door of any match official. Not publicly anyway. It's doubtful I was alone in forecasting that the trophy would be heading south of the equator. Unusually,
it's quite a pleasure to have been proved wrong
.
READ MORE
It wasn't just a win, it was a performance of the highest quality where everything clicked.
The normally powerful Bulls had no answer
. The coach of the San Francisco 49ers, the great Bill Walsh, entitled his leadership book The Score Takes Care of Itself. That's precisely what happened.
Now here's a key question. Can the scrum spoil the
Lions
series? The short answer is yes, but there are a few relevant reasons that might provide a glimmer of hope. We have seen too many top-class matches badly impacted by illegal scrummaging, including the URC final and, for good measure, the English Premiership final.
However, Lions coach Andy Farrell and Australia counterpart Joe Schmidt both favour positive play, with Farrell's men likely having the stronger scrum. So, for example, on the Lions put-in, let's hope the intention will be to play the ball away, not to try and pulverise the opposition to win a penalty.
On Australian ball, legitimate disruptive actions, including pushing straight, should be ordained. World Rugby elite referee manager, Joel Jutge, is bound to have had discussions with the two coaches with a view to working out an agreed scrummaging modus operandi.
Failing that, the appointed referees can help the situation, as well as themselves, by being stronger with scrum decisions.
'This is not what we agreed before the game,' said referee Andrea Piardi as he reset yet another scrum during the URC final. If it isn't what was agreed, by all means tell them, but don't omit a necessary accompanying sanction. Later on, with only eight minutes left, he was still appealing for good behaviour.
Otherwise, Piardi had a good match. None of his decisions affected anything very much, certainly not the clear-cut result. It was not the dog-eat-dog fight that had been widely anticipated.
It was also important that there was no controversy; there has been far too much of it during the season. There have been some poor refereeing performances for long enough and it is a dreadful blot on the URC landscape. The clubs should be up on the rooftops, shouting 'enough'.
Leinster's Jack Conan speaks to referee Andrea Piardi during the URC final against Bulls. Photograph: Ben Brady/Inpho
Piardi is not alone in bringing trouble to his own doorstep by having long conversations with players who are all too keen to disagree with decisions.
Players, not just the captains, are constantly appealing, even though they know perfectly well why the call has been made. It's happening far too much and getting worse. Referees are being subjected to interrogations, with players also pointing to real or imagined offences by their opponents. It will be interesting to see how this stuff is handled in the Lions series.
Piardi will referee the second Lions test – the first Italian to do so. Molte congratulazioni.
He will have an uncomfortable time if he allows players to be consistently in his ear. Piardi must keep his chat to concise, precise explanations and not be drawn into debates. Referees should only deal with the captain. It is clear that match officials have overdone their desire to be seen as the players' understanding friend. That approach is now backfiring.
Then there is the TMO. How will that operate on the Lions tour? The Premiership final saw it reach new levels of interruption. The TMO, Ian Tempest, cooked up a different storm by bringing several, very marginal issues to Karl Dickson's attention. These took an age to conclude and could just as easily have been decided the other way around.
Referee Karl Dickson points towards Dan Cole of Leicester Tigers before issuing a yellow card during the Premiership final. Photograph:One of these was farcical. The question was whether or not Leicester's Nicky Smith, on the ground under his own posts, had deliberately handled the ball. Solomon was needed to apply his wisdom to this one, but not so easy for a mere referee. Dickson took a long time to find in favour of Smith. Tempest also asked the referee to take a look at Dan Cole thumping late into Russell and the resulting yellow card raised another debate. Cole's coach, Michael Cheika, was livid.
The wise referee rule-of-thumb, that only the clear and obvious should be sanctioned, must also apply to TMO intrusions. Otherwise, silence please.
Then there is the intolerance of coaches towards match officials' mistakes. If there is a fingertip knock-on in the build up to a vital try, which is only seen afterwards, then the affected team's coach will blow an almighty fuse; we see it often enough. What a pity that rugby's Corinthian spirit has long since left the building.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
43 minutes ago
- The Irish Sun
Joe Schmidt takes cheeky swipe at Lions centre pairing ahead of Australia test series
AUSSIE head coach Joe Schmidt has aimed a subtle dig at the British and Irish Lions. The former Leinster and Ireland boss called Advertisement 2 Wallabies head coach Joe Schmidt aimed a cheeky dig at the Lions centres 2 Joe Schmidt did go on to praise Bundee Aki ahead of the test series later this month Both Aki and Tuipulotu were born in New Zealand and Australia respectively, lined out in midfield for the And speaking ahead of last night's clash, Schmidt appeared to use the moment to highlight the pair's adopted international allegiances. Connacht ace Tuipulotu, meanwhile, represents Scotland through his grandmother who hails from Greenock. Advertisement read more on rugby Wallabies boss said: "A southern-hemisphere centre partnership that will be pretty formidable. 'I coached Bundee for several years and know him really well and respect him massively as a player. He's a great contributor to the team environment. 'I've only had glancing conversations with Sione but again, by all accounts a champion bloke. 'You don't get to be captain of a national team without being a great bloke and really professional in those high-performance environments. Advertisement Most read in Rugby Union "They are real athletes, those two together, so that'll be really interesting.' Debate around the number of overseas-born players in Andy Farrell's Lions squad has intensified in the build-up to the 2025 tour. 'Big weekend' - Peter O'Mahony embarking on hectic gardening project as he aims to add '300 plants' Ireland's Jamison Gibson-Park and James Lowe, along with Scotland's Duhan van der Merwe and Pierre Schoeman, all qualified through residency. Finlay Bealham and Mack Hansen are eligible through family heritage. Advertisement
Irish Examiner
an hour ago
- Irish Examiner
Cork defeat Clare by nine parts after a strong second half performance
Glen Dimplex All-Ireland senior camogie championship: Cork 0-21 Clare 1-9 Cork's winning streak in the Glen Dimplex All-Ireland senior camogie championship continued in SuperValu Páirc Uí Chaoimh on Saturday. A nine-point winning margin was achieved after a strong second-half performance. The victory for Ger Manley's outfit means they head into the final round of fixtures next Saturday against winless Wexford top of Group 1 and in the perfect position to take a semi-final spot. Indication of their squad depth was also highlighted by the unavailability of Hannah Looney and Aoife Healy due to football commitments. However, the hosts didn't get matters entirely their own way having led by three points at the break. Bear in mind too when these teams met in the Munster championship in April Clare lost 2-22 to 0-10. It was evident from the outset the Banner women were up for the challenge and John Carmody's youthful side were competitive. Factor in also, two one-on-one goal opportunities in second-half stoppage time from Róisín Begley and Áine O'Loughlin that were bravely saved by Cork 'keeper Amy Lee. But for now, the visitors will travel home having secured a championship knockout place in Croke Park and that has to be the first box ticked. Their game against Tipperary next weekend will determine whether they finish second or third. They got a tonic start with a green flag inside the opening minute from Jennifer Daly who soloed through from out the field and applied the finishing touches after a mere 45 seconds. The only goal of the day was immediately followed by a Caoimhe Cahill point from play and they were up-and-running. Orlaith Cahalane settled Cork with a fifth minute white flag and they would shoot the next three unanswered points from play. A goal opportunity too came their way but couldn't be taken advantage of. Impressive wing-forward Jennifer Daly raced through for Clare's second point to leave just one between the sides approaching the quarter hour mark, 1-2 to 0-4. Industrious centre-forward Saoirse McCarthy (free) Emma Murphy and Kate Wall stretched the lead. Róisín Begley won a free close to the posts for Aisling Cooney to convert - it remained a single point match with 10 minutes to go to the interval. Sorcha McCartan and Murphy points sent Cork to the dressing-room 0-9 to 1-3 ahead. The defending All-Ireland champions were a different proposition in the second half and reeled off a trio of points from Murphy, McCartan and Amy O'Connor (free) to extend their advantage. Seven-in-a-row points while limiting Clare to a pair of converted frees arrived in a productive 20-minute spell - a Clare team that had emptied the tank in the opening half. Emerging with 10 different scorers, Cork pulled 0-20 to 1-5 clear by the 50th minute despite striking 13 wides to Clare's three overall. Clare did outhit them four-one in the final 10 minutes plus three minutes of stoppage. And had those two late goals been converted the deficit would have been less again. Scorers for Cork: S McCarthy (0-5, 0-1 free), E Murphy and O Cahalane (0-3 each), K Wall, A O'Connor (frees) and S McCartan (0-2 each), L Hayes, A Thompson, K Mackey and C Finn (0-1 each). Scorers for Clare: J Daly (1-1), A Cooney (0-3 frees), Z A Spillane (45s) and C Cahill (0-2) each, N Mulqueen (0-1). CORK: A Lee; M Cahalane (Capt), L Coppinger, P Mackey; R Harty, L Treacy, L Hayes; K Wall, A Thompson; E Murphy, S McCarty, S McCartan; C Finn, K Mackey, O Cahalane. Subs: A O'Connor for C Finn, A O'Neill for R Harty (both half-time), C O'Sullivan for L Coppinger (43). CLARE: D Murphy; S Daly, C Hehir, S O'Keeffe; L Daly, A Walsh, C Queally; N Mulqueen, C Carmody; C Cahill, G Carmody, J Daly; R Begley, A Cooney, A Anderson. Subs: Z Y Spillane for A Anderson (25), D Griffin for C Queally (40), Á O'Loughlin (Capt) for A Cooney (46), C Grogan for G Carmody (50), E Casey for C Carmody (53). Referee: L Dempsey ( Kilkenny).
The Irish Sun
an hour ago
- The Irish Sun
Ian McLauchlan dead at 83: Lions legend dies as tributes pour in for ‘almost indestructible' star
FORMER British and Irish Lions legend Ian McLauchlan has died at the age of 83. The former Scotland captain represented his country 43 times as well as playing for the Lions on eight occasions. 1 Ian McLauchlan has passed away aged 83 Credit: Hulton Archive - Getty Scottish rugby confirmed McLauchlan's passing in a statement that revealed the legend died on Friday. McLauchlan didn't just captain Scotland during his playing days, but also acted as the SRU President from 2010-2012 before stepping away from the board in 2019. The Tarbolton-born prop earned his first cap for Scotland back in 1969 at Twickenham. MORE TO FOLLOW... READ MORE IN RUGBY THIS IS A DEVELOPING STORY.. The Sun is your go to destination for the best football, boxing and MMA news, real-life stories, jaw-dropping pictures and must-see video . Like us on Facebook at
