A market in name only
EDITORIAL: The Power Division's latest invitation for stakeholder comments on the long-touted Competitive Trading Bilateral Contract Market (CTBCM) would be laughable, were the state of Pakistan's power sector not so dire. For years, the same reforms have been announced, reannounced, and endlessly recycled through public consultations and draft directives.
Now, yet again, the country is being told that competitive electricity trading is just around the corner — with a token 800MW to kick-start liberalisation. The irony is staggering. In a sector drowning in circular debt, inefficiencies, and wilful defaulters, this obsession with process over outcome has become a cruel joke.
The National Electricity Plan (NEP) 2023–27 was never going to be a silver bullet. But when some of its key directives, like #87, are being reworded not to enable reform, but to better structure cost recovery for legacy failures, the intent becomes transparent: this isn't liberalisation; it's rearranging the furniture while the house burns. The Power Division's proposed amendment now seeks comments on how to allocate stranded costs — the inevitable fallout of prior bad planning — onto new market participants. This, at a time when the International Monetary Fund is pressing for efficiency in distribution companies, not further bureaucratic entanglements.
Why is this model, already discussed to death, being thrown back into public consultation? What more is there to extract from stakeholders who, in many cases, are the very reason the sector is where it is today? The answer lies in a systemic addiction to appearances. These consultations serve primarily to project the illusion of progress, of inclusion, of reform through consensus. But consensus with whom? Several of these 'stakeholders' are themselves serial defaulters, culprits behind the power sector's financial rot, and habitual opponents of reform whenever it threatens their rent-seeking arrangements.
The circular debt continues to spiral, now breaching Rs2.4 trillion, while technical losses remain high and recovery ratios pitiful. Despite all the planning documents, task forces, and workshops, the fundamentals refuse to improve. This should prompt a reckoning with the assumptions underpinning the CTBCM itself. Instead, we get redrafted directives and a fresh round of comments — this time with a five-year window for liberalisation and complex caveats for cost recovery, hedging, and hybrid sourcing. Meanwhile, the market stays inert, confidence erodes, and industrial consumers remain hostage to poor governance and predatory pricing.
The Power Division's new language emphasises 'balancing financial viability, affordability, and competition.' These are admirable goals, but impossible to achieve in a sector where the price of electricity includes embedded costs for idle capacity contracted under take-or-pay agreements, pilferage, bloated payrolls, and cross-subsidies. Penalising new entrants into the market by saddling them with stranded costs is not liberalization — it's a deterrent. It creates disincentives for investment, distorts price signals, and entrenches the worst aspects of the current system under the guise of reform.
The concerns raised by the Korangi Association of Trade and Industry (KATI) are therefore not incidental. They strike at the core contradiction of the CTBCM process: a competitive market cannot function when its rules are retrofitted to protect incumbents. Making new entrants shoulder the costs of past mismanagement — particularly when they had no hand in creating it — undermines the very purpose of transitioning to open access. It's little surprise that the private sector remains wary of participation, and even less surprising that reform fatigue has set in.
What's even more worrying is the Power Division's willingness to caveat reforms with broad exemptions, conditionalities, and budget-dependent subsidies that render the new model barely distinguishable from the old. If open access is contingent on fiscal space, third-party consultants, and future frameworks yet to be written, then it is neither open nor accessible. It's policy theatre.
Pakistan's power sector does not need more discussions. It needs decisions — backed by enforcement. It needs accountability for the billions in capacity payments, theft, and non-recovery. And it needs a clear break from the model of state-managed dysfunction dressed up as market reform. Until that happens, the CTBCM — however well-packaged — will remain a market in name only.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
2 days ago
- Business Recorder
Payment dispute between CPPA-G, KE remains unresolved
ISLAMABAD: The Power Division has reportedly failed to resolve a dispute over an excess payment of Rs 7.43 billion between the Central Power Purchasing Agency – Guaranteed (CPPA-G) and K-Electric (KE), which has been pending for over a year, sources within CPPA-G told Business Recorder. In May 2024, the Power Division released Rs 172.8 billion to CPPA-G on account of Tariff Differential Claims (TDC) for KE. In this regard, KE referred to the Power Purchase Agency Agreement (PPAA) between KE and CPPA-G and the Tariff Differential Subsidy Agreement (TDSA) between KE and the Government of Pakistan, both signed in January 2024. According to KE, since the execution of the PPAA, it has fulfilled its obligations and paid Rs 71.5 billion directly to CPPA-G for power purchases—demonstrating its commitment to enhancing liquidity and sustainability within the power sector. As a result, KE states that there are no outstanding payables to CPPA-G after December 31, 2023. Discos, KE's tariffs: CPPA-G seeks up to Rs1.5 negative adjustment Furthermore, the power utility noted that following the release of the TDC by the Power Division on KE's behalf, all dues to CPPA-G up to December 31, 2023, have been cleared. In fact, KE claims it made an excess payment of Rs 7.43 billion, which it seeks to be adjusted against future invoices under the PPAA. KE has requested CPPA-G to issue a credit note of Rs 7.43 billion, to be made directly to KE rather than CPPA-G, in line with the TDS agreement. The utility has sent multiple letters to the Power Division requesting this credit note and seeking that future TDC disbursements related to the post-December 31, 2023 period be released directly to KE, as per the effective TDSA. Most recently, on June 10, KE sent a letter to Additional Secretary (Power Finance), Mehfooz Bhatti, summarizing previous correspondence and reiterating its demand for a Rs 7.43 billion credit note and direct release of future TDC amounts. Sources reveal that CPPA-G has shown willingness to issue a credit note of Rs 3 billion to KE, suggesting that the remaining amount be discussed with the Power Division. However, a final decision is still pending, and neither the Power Division nor CPPA-G has shared any update on the matter. 'KE contends that since it is paying the full amount against invoices issued by CPPA-G, a credit should be issued to facilitate proper accounting adjustments,' the sources added. KE has also requested that the Power Division release the additional amount before June 30, 2025. For FY 2025-26, the subsidy allocated to KE has been reduced by over 28%—from Rs 174 billion in FY 2024-25 to Rs 125 billion. However, an allocation of Rs 1 billion has been earmarked for agricultural tubewells in Balochistan, up from Rs 500 million in the previous fiscal year. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
3 days ago
- Business Recorder
Power sector: federal cabinet approves Rs1.275trn bank loan to cut circular debt
Pakistan federal cabinet approved on Wednesday Rs1.275 trillion loan from commercial banks at 'the lowest-ever rate' to cut its power sector's circular debt. The decision was taken for a permanent resolution of the circular debt in the power sector, the Ministry of Energy (Power Division) said. The loan aims to offset a portion of the circular debt, which currently stands at approximately Rs2.4 trillion. 'Under the plan, Rs1.275 trillion will be acquired from banks at a historic low interest rate — 0.9% lower than the 3-month KIBOR [Karachi Interbank Offered Rate],' it said. 'For the first time, instead of maintaining the circular debt stock at a certain level through previous methods, it will be gradually eliminated with the help of banks.' Circular debt: Govt in talks with banks to raise Rs1.275trn The loan of Rs1.275 trillion would be used to clear dues of independent power producers (IPPs) and retire Power Holding Company Limited (PHL) debt, the Power Division said. 'The acquired loan will also be fully retired over the next six years. This move will not impose any additional financial burden on the national exchequer.' According to the cabinet-approved plan, Rs683 billion of the financing will be used to clear the outstanding dues of the Power Holding Company Limited (PHL) . The loan will be repaid in 24 semi-annual installments, and the interest rate will be 0.9% lower than the 3-month KIBOR. An annual repayment cap of Rs323 billion was set, while a maximum repayment limit of Rs1.938 trillion was set in case of increased interest rates in the future. Business Recorder reported earlier this month that the government had finalised agreements for a historic loan package of Rs1.275 trillion with approximately 18 commercial banks to address the growing circular debt in the power sector. How will govt clear Rs2.4trn circular debt? Pakistan government has committed to the International Monetary Fund (IMF) to clear the circular debt by end of fiscal year 2025, according to the IMF report 'First Review Under the Extended Arrangement Under the Extended Fund Facility, Requests for Modification of Performance Criteria and Request for an Arrangement Under the Resilience and Sustainable Facility' released last month. K-Electric write-offs: NEPRA allows Rs50 billion as 'full and final claim' According to the IMF report, Pakistan government has said that it's on track to achieve net zero circular debt flow for FY25 and will strive for the same in FY26, through 'a combination of timely tariff increases, targeted subsidies, and cost-reducing reforms'. As per the government commitment, the National Electric Power Regulatory Authority (NEPRA) will continue with timely automatic notifications of regular quarterly tariff adjustments (QTAs) and monthly fuel cost adjustments (FCAs) to capture any gaps between the base tariff and actual revenue requirements that arise during the year, to prevent circular debt flow. 'We [Pakistan government] will ensure the full implementation of the July 2025 annual rebasing (new SB, July 1, 2025), QTRs, and FCAs going forward. All provinces agree not to introduce any subsidy for electricity or gas.' Of the existing circular debt stock of Rs2.4 trillion (2.1 percent of GDP), the government committed to clear, by end-FY25, Rs348 billion via renegotiation of arrears with IPPs (Rs127 billion of which will be via already-budgeted subsidy for circular debt stock clearance and Rs221 billion of which will be via CPPA cash flow); Rs387 billion via waived interest fees; and Rs254 billion via additional already-budgeted subsidy for circular debt stock clearance; Rs224 billion in non-interest-bearing liabilities will not be cleared. The remaining Rs1.252 trillion (now Rs1.275 trillion) was committed to be borrowed from banks to repay all PHL loans (PRs 683 billion) and to clear the remaining stock of interest-bearing arrears to power producers (PRs 569 billion), according to the IMF report.
Business Recorder
4 days ago
- Business Recorder
IMF agreed to spare agriculture sector from taxes, says PM Shehbaz
Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif on Wednesday said the government successfully convinced the International Monetary Fund (IMF) to exempt Pakistan's agriculture sector from taxation, despite persistent demands from the global lender. 'We informed the IMF that the government will not impose any tax on the agriculture sector, including fertiliser and pesticide. I am happy to convey that the IMF, despite its insistence, agreed to our terms,' said PM Shehbaz, while addressing the federal cabinet meeting. He said that the agriculture sector is 'already under pressure' in Pakistan, thus protecting it was necessary. The prime minister shared that the salaried class earning between Rs 600,000-1.2 million will pay 1% income tax annually, as compared to 5% imposed in FY25. Whereas, the salaries of government employees have been raised by 10%. However, this contrasts with an earlier announcement by Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb, who, during his budget speech for FY26, stated that the tax rate for this slab will be 2.5% income tax, contrary to 1% mentioned in the Finance Bill 2025. Last week, Pakistan unveiled its federal budget 2025-26 'for a competitive economy', targeting a modest 4.2% growth for the coming fiscal year, compared to 2.7% expected in the outgoing FY25. Numbers speak: Sindh agriculturalists spend more on vehicle registration, pay less in income tax Addressing the cabinet, PM Shehbaz also touched on rising regional tensions, saying that the government increased its fiscal space to meet the country's defence needs amid ongoing tensions with India. 'It is a dire need of the time,' he said. Similarly, the government has allocated Rs1 trillion under the Public Sector Development Programme (PSDP). 'We need to honour commitments made with our partners,' the PM said. He said that Pakistan has successfully averted a sovereign default and is now moving ahead on a sustainable path.
