Argonaut Algorithm: Lithium stocks are getting cheaper, so you don't need to skimp on quality
Argonaut Funds Management's David Franklyn joins Stockhead to share investing secrets from the high-conviction resource sector investing fund, including his junior stock pick of the month.
Lithium prices have tumbled to a fresh four year low of late.
After numerous dead cat bounces in the US$800/t range last year, 6% Li2O spodumene – the kind of lithium produced by WA's hard rock miners – is trading at US$620/t according to Fastmarkets.
Those are levels that only Greenbushes in WA's South West, the highest grade hard rock lithium mine in the world, is really making money on.
Prices last bottomed out at US$375/t in March 2020, before the EV boom that temporarily sent them as high as US$8000/t on the spot market in late 2022.
It's impossible to predict if and when that could happen again.
But fund manager David Franklyn has an important message. With lithium stocks all off the boil, it's the right time to trade out marginal players for true quality.
It's like heading to a McDonalds only to find out the place next door is selling a porterhouse for only a couple bucks extra.
"I think the advantage you have where you're looking at a sector where it's near the bottom of the cycle rather than near the top of the cycle, is you don't need to compromise on quality," he said.
"What we tend to do is go, do we think we can double our money in the next three years?
"You don't really know when that turn in the market is going to happen, whether it happens in the first three months that you own it or whether it happens in two years and nine months.
"We're here for a medium-term investment and we're happy to wait and see when that return actually pays off."
The turn
It's impossible to really say where the top or bottom of any market is.
Despite the hype around the battery metal, lithium remains small and immature, with price-setting opaque and futures markets in their infancy.
It can make it hard to truly assess the role supply and demand plays in setting prices, especially with two of the market's biggest end users – dominant Chinese battery producer CATL and EV maker BYD stepping upstream into the raw materials space to secure their own supply chains.
They operate higher cost lepidolite mines, a lower grade, lower quality form of hard rock lithium, that counts as a major swing factor for lithium supply – a market otherwise dominated by Australian and African spodumene and South American brines.
"The industry is dominated by CATL and BYD. They produce about over 55% of global batteries. And therefore they're the biggest buyer of lithium," Franklyn said.
"You could argue they're bringing on high cost lepidolite a time the market's slightly oversupplied to force the price down, because ultimately they're a big buyer of lithium and by doing that they're reducing their purchase price.
"It reflects the fact that lithium is still a small market, it's dominated by a small number of major players and therefore it is open to some form of manipulation."
Yet feedback from lithium suppliers suggests demand remains strong.
"You've got a doubling of (demand in) the industry in the next five years and you have prices that are going down," Franklyn said. "I think we're getting near the bottom of the market and the question is do you start to chip away at some of these good quality lithium stocks."
There are four serious players in the lithium mining space – Pilbara Minerals (ASX:PLS), IGO (ASX:IGO), which owns ~25% of Greenbushes, Mineral Resources (ASX:MIN) and Liontown Resources (ASX:LTR).
MinRes and Liontown are "very good businesses" but still have debt concerns to address.
"At this point in the cycle, do you want to take on the additional risk? And our view is, I don't think you need to," Franklyn said.
With IGO saddled by two troublesome lithium refining plants and a nickel business that's winding down, that makes the cashed up Pilbara the standout option for Argonaut.
"The benefit of Pilbara is it's got net cash of about $700m and it's very well positioned," Franklyn said. "I'd probably put Pilbara slightly ahead of IGO."
PLS shares rose a heady 5.6% on Wednesday to $1.425 after a 23% increase in lithium resources at its flagship Pilgangoora mine in WA's North West to 446Mt at 1.28% Li2O.
It remains some way of its $5.31 boom time highs.
Junior stock of the month
Patriot Battery Metals (ASX:PMT)
For Franklyn, the Canadian developer led by former PLS MD Ken Brinsden remains the standout junior stock in the lithium market.
"At the developer level the benefit you've got is you can focus on quality," Franklynsaid.
"It's got a market cap of $420m, it's the largest hard rock lithium asset in the Americas, it's high grade, simple mineralogy, it's got VW's as a strategic partner, it has got 4.8 million tonnes of contained LCE, so it's huge.
" It kind of ticks all the boxes as a high-quality emerging player in the lithium space. And being in North America also makes some sense as, as you see what's happenin with the US and Canada, where Canada's making projects easy to get up and running, and the US is really pushing for critical minerals supply coming from areas close by."
Argonaut Funds Management is a high conviction resource sector investor managing the Argonaut Natural Resources Fund and the Argonaut Global Gold Fund. David Franklyn is the Fund Manager for the Argonaut Natural Resources Fund.
The views, information, or opinions expressed in this article are solely those of the interviewee and do not represent the views of Stockhead. Stockhead does not provide, endorse or otherwise assume responsibility for any financial product advice contained in this article.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
4 hours ago
- News.com.au
Collingwood: ‘The Lamington' pad's red hot auction result
An ultra-cool Collingwood apartment known as the Lamington has smashed expectations after selling for more than $1m on Saturday. The two-bedroom home at 3F/68 Oxford St with red tiles, metals and glass throughout was advertised with a $900,000-$950,000 asking range. Short-listed for an Australian Institute of Architects' interiors award, the warehouse conversion is located within a factory complex that formerly belonged to one of Australia's first department store chains, Foy & Gibson. The apartment's owner commissioned architectural practice Rexroth Mannasmann Collective to transform its shell into an eclectic abode with a wall of tall windows, 3.6m-high steel-trussed ceilings and polished hardwood floorboards. A horizontal red line features on many of the walls including in the open-plan living and dining area is much like a strip of jam inside a lamington – contributing to the apartment's unofficial name. There's also a central pod within the home containing a laundry and bathroom. One of the pod's walls has a flip-top desk and foldaway bed. The residence has been featured in both Vogue Living and the Architectural Review magazines. Jellis Craig inner north partner Simon Shrimpton said a $900,000 bid started the auction as three bidders competed for the 'very cool' apartment. It was placed on the market at $950,000 and ended up fetching $1.025m. 'The apartment sold a young couple from Fitzroy and the underbidders were a couple downsizing from the eastern suburbs,' Mr Shrimpton said. 'The couple who bought were very excited, they were the first to inquire and the first ones through the door at the first open for inspection,' Mr Shrimpton said. 'They were absolutely in love with the place and all the design aspects and nuances it has.' Mr Shrimpton said that for inner Melbourne apartments, well-designed homes with stylish flair tended to attract a lot of interest. 'Bespoke, architecturally-designed apartments are few and far between and when they are offered to the market, buyers will always line up to compete for them,' he added. Also on Saturday, a double-fronted, Victorian-era house at 1 Peel St, Newport, sold for $1.21m. The three-bedroom house, in need of some work including replastering, had a $1.05m reserve. The Agency property partners Leigh Melbourne and Noah Lautman-Wurt had the listing. Mr Melbourne said that a young couple from the western suburbs purchased the property, out of three bidders. 'The bidding was fast and furious,' Mr Melbourne said. He noted that homes at Peel St's bottom end, near The Strand in Williamstown, did not often come up for sale. 'In my 25 years covering the area, it's the second property I have sold down here,' he said. Mr Lautman-Wurt said the auction started with a $1m bid, with a buyer's advocate and family among the underbidders.
News.com.au
5 hours ago
- News.com.au
Western United given 14 days to pay overdue wages or run risk of losing players
Western United has again been served with breach notices by a host of the A-League club's players over unpaid wages. It's the second time in two months that United has been issued breach notices by disgruntled players, who were also forced to endure late pay in May. United had 14 days from Friday to make the payments. If the club fails to meet the deadline, players will be entitled to leave to the club, regardless of their contract status. A club spokesman said United was in 'constant communication with all players' and was working 'closely with the PFA (Professional Footballers Australia) and the APL (Australian Professional Leagues) to ensure this is addressed in the coming days'. Earlier in the week, United officials had been confident the club's proposed new majority backers – KAM Melbourne – would have paid the players and staff their overdue wages by Friday. A pitch fit for the European champions 😉🤩 The @FIFACWC is underway with the Rose Bowl in perfect condition for @PSG_inside and @atletienglish yesterday thanks to our groundsman, Justin Lang ðŸ'�ðŸ'š — Western United FC (@wufcofficial) June 17, 2025 However, the money wasn't forthcoming, leading some players issuing breach notices via PFA. KAM Melbourne, a subsidiary of KAM Sports, was last month announced as financially embattled United's new controlling stakeholders. However, the deal is yet to be approved by the APL, which runs the A-League. PFA chief executive officer Beau Busch earlier this week said United's players and staff were 'victims of a governance model that is not fit for purpose, and where FA (Football Australia) and the APL appear unwilling to enforce their own regulations'. 'The professionalism of the Western United players and staff in the most trying conditions is a testament to their character and commitment to Australian football,' Busch said. 'The players (have been) left to fight for their most basic entitlement as employees. We will continue to ensure the players have access to the full resources of the PFA.'
News.com.au
5 hours ago
- News.com.au
Ray White data reveals house-unit price difference in 15 blue chip suburbs
The dream of living in a blue-chip suburb is still in reach for younger Australians if they're willing to trade in a house for a unit, fresh data from real estate titan Ray White has revealed. While house prices remain at astronomical levels across much of the country's prime real estate, the gap in price between houses and units is wide enough in a host of up-market suburbs to make unit living affordable for first-home buyers. In Melbourne's iconic Hawthorn South, characterised by its vast patchwork of cafes, restaurants, heritage-listed buildings and elegant park spaces, median house prices are at $2.48m, but units are priced at $560,368, a massive $1.92m difference in cost. In Sydney's Homebush, which sits adjacent to the iconic Sydney Markets and Bicentennial Park, houses are priced at $2.24m, while units are priced at $677,393, for a $1.56m gap. Brisbane's riverside Hamilton, adorned with swanky Queenslanders and opulent modernist structures, houses go for $2.26m while units are listed at $717,358. Ray White chief economist Nerida Conisbee told NewsWire apartments offered Australians in their 20s and 30s a chance to live in suburbs with 'better amenity' as houses move beyond reach. 'To get an apartment, you might be closer to good retail precincts, better public transport, closer to your work,' she said. 'Also potentially to family and friends. I think this is one of the challenges a lot of younger people have. 'They may have grown up in an area but when they are looking to buy now, it's really expensive, but in some areas, there are definitely apartments available at a much more affordable price.' Ms Conisbee added solving Australia's affordability crisis would entail a greater shift to apartment living, even as builders continue to pump out four-bedroom homes that exceed the size of many emerging families. 'Australia is very unusual globally in that we have incredibly low densities,' she said. 'If you have a look at every other major city and even much smaller cities, they do have very high levels of high densities. 'We can't provide affordable housing in areas that have incredible amenity if we stick to the big homes in the future.' Every major city shows savings of at least $500,000 with an apartment buy over a house. In Adelaide's Walkerville, a tree-lined inner-north suburb, houses sit at $1.6m, while units are going for $604,328, a saving of nearly a million dollars. In Perth's beachside Mosman Park, houses are priced at $2.51m, while units are priced at $551,561, a near $2m difference. In Darwin's Larrakeyah, houses are $1.45m while units are $440,907. In Canberra's Reid, houses are $2.19m, while units are $617,050. Queensland's glittery Gold Coast, however, shows a smaller gap between house and unit prices compared to other major cities. In Southport, houses are $1.05m, while units are $637,051, for a $410,669 gap. Regional cities in popular coastal locations also present substantial gaps between house and unit prices. In the Sunshine Coast's Buderim suburb, which borders the Maroochydore and Mooloolaba beaches north of Brisbane, houses are priced at $1.3m, while units are going for $732,921. In Port Douglas, a Coral Sea town in Queensland's far north that faces out to the Great Barrier Reef, houses are listed at $1.71m, while units are $490,372.
