Residents of village that inspired Thomas Hardy fight back against expansion
Thomas Hardy described his fictional village of Marlott as being in an 'engirdled and secluded region, for the most part untrodden as yet by tourist or landscape-painter, though within a four hours' journey from London'.
But the Victorian realist would now barely recognise Marnhull, the real-life village in Dorset upon which Marlott was based, and would likely be surprised to know his name is repeatedly invoked in official submissions arguing against its ongoing expansion.
Nestled in the Blackmore Vale, the opening backdrop for Hardy's Tess of the D'Urbervilles, Marnhull is a patchwork of hamlets with a hotchpotch of architectural styles, from Tudor manors and thatched cottages to postwar developments.
In recent months, an acrimonious row has broken out over plans to build up to 120 homes, which residents fear will merely be 'phase one' of an ongoing, wider expansion of the picturesque village. The situation has underlined some of the tensions rising out of the Labour government's drive to build more houses.
Dorset council refused permission for the development in July 2024, but the landowner successfully appealed against this after an inquiry by the national planning inspectorate, which had to take Labour's new housing requirements into account.
The strength of feeling was so forceful in Marnhull that the parish council took the unusual step of taking part in the inquiry as a 'rule 6 party' – an interested group granted the right to actively participate in the inquiry process.
It is striking how many times Hardy is referenced in the parish council's submissions as evidence of the village's important heritage status. Stephen Boyce, a Marnhull resident and heritage consultant, submitted 40 pages of argument with dozens of references to the romantic poet and novelist, known for works including Far from the Madding Crowd and Jude the Obscure.
Boyce, who has held senior roles at the National Lottery Heritage Fund and consulted for the National Trust, says: 'The development demonstrates no awareness of the important cultural value of the site in question, in particular its associations with the work of Dorset's most famous literary figure, Thomas Hardy. These historic connections make a notable contribution to the character, significance and quality of Marnhull's heritage.'
The scheme would also include a commercial plot being developed – provisionally named Tess Square in a nod to the eponymous character of Hardy's renowned novel – as well as a large car park near St Gregory's church – where Tess's baby, Sorrow, was buried.
Boyce says: 'The proposed development particularly impinges on the locations and buildings most closely associated with Tess.' He points out that in addition to the church, the Pure Drop Inn in the novel is based on Marnhull's Crown Inn.
Residents of Butts Close backing on to the field earmarked for development are devastated by the proposals.
Anne Hartley, 59, and her husband, Mike, 61, enjoy an uninterrupted view across the vale from their back garden, which will vanish if and when the development is built.
Anne Hartley says: 'You used to be able to walk quite easily down some of the little country roads and the lanes you've got here, but now you're diving into shrubs to get out of the way of cars.
'If you put another 120 houses you're going to get more and more and more. And you're going to lose that tranquility that so many people have moved here to get.'
Sign up to First Edition
Our morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters
after newsletter promotion
In his decision to allow the appeal, the planning inspector, Jonathan Bore, says that under new requirements introduced by Labour, Dorset council must build 3,219 homes a year – nearly double the 1,739 required under the previous government.
He appears to criticise Dorset council for failing to put in place a policy for housing allocations across the county.
Bore says: 'The position is one of very high identified housing need. There is no up-to-date spatial strategy that responds to this position, no up-to-date policy that establishes the amounts of development to be apportioned to different locations in the light of this need, and no prospect that a new local plan will be adopted until 2027.'
Marnhull parish council said it was 'surprised and clearly disappointed' by the planning inspectorate decision.
It said in a statement: 'We took the unusual step of participating in the inquiry as a rule 6 party as the village was overwhelmingly opposed to what is perceived as a disproportionately large development in a rural village with significant impact on heritage, existing local businesses and highways safety.
'We summarised our case in documents submitted to the inquiry but ultimately our concerns were outweighed by Dorset council's significant shortfall in building housing to meet the new government targets and by the lack of a current Dorset council development plan.'
A spokesperson for Dorset council said it had agreed a supply of housing before the recent government changes, which is valid until the end of October under transitional arrangements. The council said the increased demands for housing under the new framework, coupled with requirements to mitigate potential pollution from new developments meant it was searching for new sites.
It said: 'Dorset council is preparing a new local plan, and consultation will be taking place on site options this summer, taking account of the latest housing and mitigation requirements. In the meantime the council continues to work positively to support the delivery of sustainable development.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Is Netflix actually pulling the strings of Meghan's business As Ever? The subtle clue she let slip
When Meghan Markle first stepped into the world of the Royal Family, she liked to portray herself as a UN ambassador and do-gooder environmentalist. But for the past few months, the Duchess of Sussex has been reinventing herself yet again.
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
Fuming Love Island viewers calling Ofcom as show is hit by fresh bullying row after explosive fight
FUMING Love Island viewers are calling Ofcom as the show is hit by a fresh bullying row, after an explosive fight. It comes after fans watched on as Yasmin snogged two of the boys in the villa, during a game of beer pong. 5 5 5 Yasmin's first snog occurred with Dejon, who is coupled up with Meg, but he was tasked with snogging the Islander he found most attractive, aside from his partner. He went straight over to Yasmin as Meg watched on, and snogged her. Later on in the game, Yasmin ended up snogging Harry too, despite being coupled up with Shea. And some of the girls questioned Yasmin's motives after the villa snogs, including Meg who was shocked to see love interest Dejon's kiss with her. After a tense exchange between Meg and Yasmin, some fans have threatened to call Ofcom, accusing the girls of 'ganging up.' One person wrote: 'Can the girls stop going at Yasmin… OFCOM! #LoveIsland.' A second penned: 'Ofcom complaint being filed for the witches coven bullying Yasmin #LoveIsland.' A third echoed: 'Those OFCOM lines will be busy #LoveIsland,' and a fourth said: 'I wanna write to ofcom that was awful tv #LoveIsland.' The threats of Ofcom come as Meg said to Yasmin in front of the group: 'Wait, how can you still be happy in your couple if you're snogging everyone but the man you're coupled up with?' Love Island fans convinced star is AI bot in bizarre conspiracy theory Yasmin fired back: 'It's just a game,' to which Meg responded: 'But you're saying you're happy in your couple.' Things were obviously tense between the ladies, as Yasmin backed her reasoning, responding: 'Everyone's playing the games way too safe and you're here to explore connections and to take risks.' Not backing down, Meg added: 'I know it's a game, but you got asked if you're happy in your couple and you said yes, and you've not once kissed your man. Don't think you're happy in your couple.' Yasmin ended the chat by saying: 'That's your opinion,' as the other Islanders watched on. Love Island 2025 full lineup Harry Cooksley: A 30-year-old footballer with charm to spare. Shakira Khan: A 22-year-old Manchester-based model, ready to turn heads. Megan Moore: A payroll specialist from Southampton, looking for someone tall and stylish. Alima Gagigo: International business graduate with brains and ambition. Tommy Bradley: A gym enthusiast with a big heart. Helena Ford: A Londoner with celebrity connections, aiming to find someone funny or Northern. Ben Holbrough: A model ready to make waves. Megan Clarke: An Irish actress already drawing comparisons to Maura Higgins. Dejon Noel-Williams: A personal trainer and semi-pro footballer, following in his footballer father's footsteps. Aaron Buckett: A towering 6'5' personal trainer. Conor Phillips: A 25-year-old Irish rugby pro. Antonia Laites: Love Island's first bombshell revealed as sexy Las Vegas pool party waitress. Yasmin Pettet: The 24-year-old bombshell hails from London and works as a commercial banking executive. Malisha Jordan: A teaching assistant from Broxbourne, Hertfordshire, who entered Love Island 2025 as a bombshell. Emily Moran: Bombshell Welsh brunette from the same town as Love Island 2024 alumni Nicole Samuel. Shea Mannings: Works as a scaffolder day-to-day and plays semi-pro football on the side. Remell Mullins: Boasts over 18million likes and 500k followers on TikTok thanks to his sizzling body transformation videos. Harrison Solomon: Pro footballer and model entering Love Island 2025 as a bombshell. Departures: Kyle Ashman: Axed after an arrest over a machete attack emerged. He was released with no further action taken and denies any wrongdoing. Sophie Lee: A model and motivational speaker who has overcome adversity after suffering life-changing burns in an accident. Blu Chegini: A boxer with striking model looks, seeking love in the villa. So far Yasmin has asked Dejon for a threesome, propositioned Harry, and talked no stop about sex - despite saying she had only slept with two men. It all kicked off after Yasmin turned to Dejon on Tuesday night's episode, and asked: 'I have a question for you, it's a bit rogue, would you have a threesome with me and Toni?' Dejon laughed - but was soon saved from answering as Meg called out: 'Come here please!" He joked: "You called me at a good time! Oh my god! We'll continue that question." However, the flirty tone continued as she followed up with: 'It was in my head, I had to say it. Intrusive thoughts, intrusive thoughts." Yasmin tried to defend the comment as innocent fun, insisting: 'It was just flirty banter. I think all of us talk really openly about sex and what we want to experience.' But Meg wasn't having it, firing back: 'It just seems to be you three all the time.' In the same episode, bombshell Yasmin revealed to some of the Islanders, including Harry and Dejon, that a man had never given her an orgasm before - which came amid another very shocking claim. The Londoner also confessed that she has only ever slept with two men before, despite speaking about sex frequently with guys in the villa. Then, in Wednesday night's instalment, Yasmin spoke to Harry on the terrace when things got very flirty. She spoke about being "bent over" and he said she was "undressing" him with her eyes. 5 5
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
The one small clothing tweak that could entirely change the way people treat you
If someone decides to 'make more of an effort' with their clothes when they go to work, they will likely experience an 'overwhelming' and advantageous difference in the way others treat them, according to a style influencer. UK TikToker Ryan Barton, whose videos help viewers look refined without spending a fortune, published a clip in which he explained exactly why a polished appearance can control other 'people's behaviours'. Ryan, who works in an office where jeans and gymwear are acceptable and typical, told how he swapped casual clothing for 'shirts, tailored trousers [and] loafers - and that 'the difference it made was overwhelming'. The youthful influencer, who was 51,000 followers on TikTok, said: 'Nothing else changed. I still had the same desk, I still had the same job'. But, having embraced a more formal look, Ryan noticed that others started to treat him better. He added: 'People started to say "Hello" when they'd never said "Hello" before. I started to get asked for my input in meetings when I'd never been asked before.' Yet, the 'subtle' but 'noticeable' change that Ryan experienced was not a fluke. Rather, it has been observed by psychologists and even has a name: The Halo Effect. Ryan explained: 'When you look put together, people assume you're more confident, maybe even smarter, before you've even said a word. @ryanjbarton Dressing well isn't just about looking good, it literally changes how people treat you. Here's why your outfit speaks before you do, and what psychology has to do with style, confidence, and first impressions. #mensfashion #mensstyle #mensstyle #menswear #classicmenswear #officeoutfit ♬ original sound - Ryan Barton 'So, by being intentional with the way that you dress, you kind of trick people into thinking that you're a more capable and should be more respected.' But what someone decides to wear doesn't just influence how others perceive and treat them - it also affects their own behaviour. Ryan added: 'There's also something that's called "Enclothed Cognition". That's when what you wear starts to influence how you behave. 'So, the better that you dress, the more assured that you become - and the more that people will naturally reflect that energy back to you.' The influencer summed this up by saying that if you 'dress sharply, then the world will adjust its tone towards you.' He also acknowledged that the way someone dresses is more important than what they say when it comes to earning the respect of others. He concluded: 'If you feel like you're not getting the respect or the recognition that you want within your workplace then try out this trick'. Ryan's video received an amazing 241,500 views in a matter of two days and amassed more than 14,000 comments. Fellow TikTok users were quick to comment on Ryan's video - but not everyone agreed it's worth dressing up for work Many TikTok users were convinced by the influencer's theory - but some were sceptical. One person wrote: 'The older I get, the more I realise dressing well is important. It's about [the] self-discipline [required] to maintain the upkeep every single day'. A second agreed: 'Facts. Dress how you wish to be addressed.' Another shared their experience of 'enclothed cognition', adding: 'I wear a suit working from home, to be honest for same reason. [It] looks smart on meetings and my dog treats me differently'. A fourth person said: 'Gymwear should never be worn in the office, ever.' But a fifth explained that their approach was slightly different. They commented: 'White Ralph Lauren shirt plus Under Armour shorts for Zoom meetings'. Under Armour is a popular gymwear brand. A sixth person, however, shared an entirely different approach: 'I use the Halo Effect for the reverse - going totally casual. It's lovely and peaceful'. While a seventh pointed out: 'I've found from working in corporate for 15 years that the more you earn, the less fancy you dress'. Someone else expressed a more controversial opinion, writing: 'A perfect suit signals narcissism.'
