'Rock-bottom' fishermen urge government to renegotiate Common Fisheries Policy in wake of EU-UK reset deal

The Government has been urged to begin renegotiating the Commons Fisheries Policy (CFP) in the wake of EU agreement with the UK on a reset trade deal.
British prime minister Keir Starmer met European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen and European Council president Antonio Costa at a summit in Lancaster House, London, yesterday to seal the deal, which covers areas including trade, education, energy, security, and defence partnerships.
The deal will see a 12-year extension of fishing arrangements when the current deal ends, allowing European vessels to operate in UK waters under the same terms until 2038.
"We are turning a page. We are opening a new chapter in our unique relationship,' Ms von der Leyen said.
However the chief executive of the Irish South and West Fish Producers' Organisation, Patrick Murphy warned that without changes to the EU's Common Fisheries Policy, the deal 'doesn't bode well for the future of Ireland's fishing industry'.
Mr Murphy said that Irish fishermen sacrificed 40% of fishing opportunities to the UK as part of the original Brexit deal. 'This devastated our fleet to the tune of 25% of our income in key stocks in mackerel and nephrops (Dublin Bay prawns). The solution we were offered was to scrap a quarter of our fleet in response, and the fishing rights went with the boats. We have gone from 400 vessels to 140 in the past two decades and are struggling to survive, with no new entrants coming into the industry.
"Our prediction is if there is no rebalancing of the overpayment that Ireland made, we could see our fleet further reduced. The only benefit we see in this deal is there are 12 years of stability - once we reach rock bottom, it can't get worse.'
Mr Murphy said the Common Fisheries Policy, first set up 50 years ago, is no longer fit for purpose, leaving the industry 'frozen', while some traditional fish stocks are reducing due to climate change, with no alternatives being made available.
He said minister of state at the department of agriculture, food and the marine with special responsibility for fisheries, Timmy Dooley, has engaged positively with sector representatives and urged Government to now push Europe to renegotiate to save the industry in Ireland.
Fisheries cover just one element of the deal signed in London on Monday. Other measures covered in the UK-EU deal include:
- An open-ended new sanitary and phytosanitary (SPS) agreement to slash red tape on food and drink exports and imports between the UK and EU.
- Some routine checks on plant and animal products will be removed completely.
- Linking UK and EU emissions-trading schemes which will mean British firms will not be hit by Brussels' carbon tax next year.
- A security and defence partnership will pave the way for UK arms firms to bid for work under the EU's proposed new €178bn security action for Europe (Safe) fund.
- The UK and EU have agreed to co-operate on a "youth experience scheme", while there is also a commitment to work towards the UK associating with the Erasmus+ student exchange programme.
- British steel exports will be protected from new EU rules and restrictive tariffs.
The deal requires "dynamic alignment" - the UK following rules set by Brussels - in areas covering the SPS deal, emissions trading and potential cooperation in the electricity market.
Additional reporting by PA

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Irish Independent

an hour ago

• Irish Independent

Why Wexford villages will be ‘dead in 15 years' unless a way to provide wastewater treatment services in rural areas can be found

And with Uisce Éireann opting to focus its attention on urban areas there is a genuine fear that the county's villages will slowly empty as people search for viable housing options elsewhere. At the June meeting of the New Ross Municipal District (NRMD) Councillor Marty Murphy asked what WCC could do to prevent these villages from dying. 'What is our policy on cluster developments in villages?' he asked. 'Uisce Éireann (UE) is clearly not going to service them so we need to have a plan as a council to allow developments to go ahead with their own wastewater treatment services.' Cllr Murphy received support from Cllr Michael Sheehan. 'My understanding is we can supply wastewater for once-off and linear projects,' he said. 'But places like Ramsgrange are literally going to be dead in 15 years because of the demographics there; people are moving on, there's no houses being built, the schools will end up having to close or amalgamate. We need to try and build 8-10 housing developments in our villages, if we're waiting on UE to do it those villages will be dead.' After the meeting executive planner Eoghan Nolan circulated a section of the County Development Plan (CDP) which went some way towards explaining the council's policy on cluster developments in rural areas. 'There is no specific policy that details the requirements of cluster developments, but these would not be considered in rural areas and only generally only in a designated town, village or rural node.' According to the CDP, the rural nodes in the NRMD include Cushinstown, Poulpeasty, and Horeswood – Ramsgrange is listed as a large village. Broken down into categories the CDP lists Campile, Clonroche, Wellingtonbridge, and Taghmon as 'settlements', and states, 'there are no public wastewater services nor will there be in most of our settlements'. "It is contrary to the plan to provide private shared treatment plants for residential development. Therefore, the houses need to have individual treatment systems at a density acceptable to environment,' the CDP reads.

The Journal

2 hours ago

• The Journal

Political parties scramble to introduce policies around AI use after Swedish House Mafia-gate

IRISH POLITICAL PARTIES are beginning to develop policies around the use of artificial intelligence (AI) after MEP Ciaran Mullooly revealed he used it to write a letter to the President of the European Commission. In the letter, which urged the EU to deliver more aid to Gaza, the Independent Ireland MEP inadvertently quoted the house music group Swedish House Mafia and recounted a fictional story of a girl in Rafah without indicating that she was not real. Following this, The Journal contacted all political parties represented in Dáil Éireann to see if they have policies or guidelines in place around the use of AI for public representatives. No party currently does. While the Labour Party said it has been working on guidelines since earlier this year, other parties were left scrambling after Mullooly's AI-assisted letter made headlines. The Social Democrats, Fine Gael and Independent Ireland all said they are currently working on developing policies, while the Green Party is also examining the idea as part of a strategic plan. A Sinn Féin source admitted that the Mullooly story was sent around to TDs as a 'cautionary tale' but said the party does not currently have any guidelines around the use of AI. Despite the slow uptake from political HQs on the issue, many TDs were more vocal about their feelings on the use of the technology in public life. When asked if they use AI to assist their work as a TD, just four current members of the Dáil admitted that they do. Independent TD Barry Heneghan used AI to create a song as part of his election campaign and said he uses a mix of programmes now as a TD, such as ChatGPT and Microsoft 365 Co-pilot, depending on the work he wants to streamline. Fianna Fáil's Paul McAuliffe, Fine Gael's John Paul O'Shea and Labour's Conor Sheehan all said they use programmes like ChatGPT and Co-pilot on occasion to help with admin tasks, but all were of the view that it shouldn't be used for drafting speeches or public statements. Advertisement 'I think transparency is important in this job. It's still up to TDs to stand over what they say and do, and AI can make mistakes and add things in that you would never say,' Heneghan said. He added: 'If you trusted it for your whole speech, it doesn't sound human in my opinion.' Independent Ireland TD Ken O'Flynn compared AI to the printing press and said his party supports the 'responsible use' of the emerging technology. 'Whether to improve communication or streamline workflows, like the printing press or the personal computer, artificial intelligence may face scepticism in its early stages but if history has shown us anything, it is that new tools often begin with controversy and end with positive transformation.' Most other TDs we contacted said they do not use AI to assist with their work, although many parties said staff sometimes use it for research purposes or admin. When asked if politicians should have to disclose when they have used AI to draft a speech or statement, most TDs we contacted said yes. A spokesperson for Independent Ireland said it 'would not be a bad idea in the interests of transparency', while Green Party leader Roderic O'Gorman went further and said it should also be disclosed when politicians use it to alter images of themselves. A number of TDs said it came down to being honest with constituents, while others, like People Before Profit TD Paul Murphy, said he was against its use on environmental grounds. Labour TD Duncan Smith argued that it is lazy for TDs to use AI. The Dublin Fingal East TD said he doesn't use it because he has 'no interest in selling my constituents short'. 'When people elect you to represent them, it should actually be you and the team you put together to work with you, representing your constituents. 'I think TDs using AI are displaying laziness at best and I think it shows a lack of respect to the people who have elected you to the Dáil, who rightfully expect you to be putting in the work,' he said. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal

Irish Examiner

3 hours ago

• Irish Examiner

Infrastructure taskforce to be updated on project delays

The Government's recently-formed infrastructure taskforce is to be briefed on the delays besetting key projects across the country. Public expenditure minister Jack Chambers is to chair the second meeting of the 'accelerating infrastructure taskforce', which is focusing on removing barriers to delivery. At the meeting, it is expected that members will be briefed on specific projects that have been subject to different types of delay. This will include the M28 Ringaskiddy-to-Cork road, alongside water and energy projects across the country. One government source said taskforce members will examine what changes to current processes and project requirements could be made to 'strike the appropriate balance between the controls and procedures governing the delivery of major capital projects'. It is understood the taskforce will submit a report that identifies the specific barriers to infrastructure delivery to the Government by the end of July. It comes after one member of the taskforce, Economic and Social Research Institute chairman Sean O'Driscoll, told the Irish Examiner there were 'catastrophic consequences' facing Ireland's water, energy, and transport networks if 'radical and brave decisions are not taken to ensure projects get completed quicker'. Mr O'Driscoll said the Government needed to accept that there is a 'national crisis' in Irish infrastructure, while adding that public servants are more 'scared' of the public accounts committee than the economy declining. Meanwhile, Taoiseach Micheál Martin is to bring an update on the Government's expert group on conveyancing and probate, with the group set to be extended for a further six months. The group is recommending a more permanent structure to take over dealing with issues surrounding probate and conveyancing in December. Conveyancing and probate are the legal processes for transferring a property from one person to another, or for when an individual dies. The Government's aim through the group is to speed up the conveyancing and probate processes, to avoid houses being left empty due to being stuck in lengthy processes. There is a target of an eight-week turnaround time for solicitors to complete conveyancing, from the acceptance of an offer to its close. A new e-probate system is expected to be launched later this year, which the Government believes will significantly reduce processing times and delays. The group is continuing to develop proposals around the establishment of an e-conveyancing system over the coming six months. Cabinet will also be briefed around the implementation of the Dublin City taskforce report. It is understood that proposals within the implementation plan include the establishment of a development body for regeneration projects in the city. This would include the future use of the GPO on O'Connell Street, but would also look at regenerating shops, apartments, and offices within the city. Elsewhere, a meeting between transport minister Darragh O'Brien and justice minister Jim O'Callaghan took place last week to discuss options for the establishment of a new transport police. It is understood that any such force would operate outside An Garda Síochána and would not be under the remit of the Department of Justice. Government sources indicated that the current preferred model would see the transport police led by the National Transport Authority, with powers similar to that of the airport police.