Developer ‘flatly contradict' claims in row about overheating at €6m Ballsbridge penthouse, court hears
A development company at the centre of a dispute with a businesswoman over alleged overheating in her €6m Ballsbridge, Dublin, penthouse apartment 'flatly contradicts' her claims, the High Court heard.
Aideen O'Byrne claims that due to a failure to maintain or repair the district heating system the temperatures in her Lansdowne Place apartment – thought to be the most expensive in Ireland at the time she bought it – have reached 'unbearable' highs of 33 degrees.
Temperatures in lobby areas have been recorded to reach 29 degrees, she says.
Ms O'Byrne was last week given an interim injunction preventing the developer from transferring its beneficial interest in the buildings and common areas to an owners' management company until problems are resolved.
READ MORE
The case is against the developer, Copper Bridge C 2015 ICAV, and O'Connor Sutton Cronin and Associates Ltd.
That interim injunction application was made ex parte, with only the O'Byrne side represented.
The case came back before Mr Justice Brian Cregan on Thursday when Hugh O'Keeffe SC, for Copper Bridge, said his client had a full defence to the merits of this case and had experts who 'flatly contradict' Ms Byrne's claims.
'We spent three years trying to address them without any progress', he said. He was seeking an early trial as his side wanted the matter determined as quickly as possible.
Mr O'Keeffe said it was also their case in relation to the substance of the injunction preventing a transfer of interests that the transfer had already happened. It was in accordance with required standards upon the making of a statutory declaration of completion of the development under the Multi Unit Development (MUD) Act, the court heard.
The legal interest had previously been transferred and the transfer in accordance with MUD takes place upon completion of the statutory declaration, he said.
Gavin Mooney SC, for Ms O'Byrne, said it was curious that the statutory declaration took place on April 3 when his side had already been on inquiry into the matter.
Mr Mooney said if he now has to seek to change his application to one of setting aside that transfer of beneficial interest 'then so be it'.
He also said he was also seeking to join the Lansdowne Place Owners' Management Company (OMC) as a defendant in the proceedings.
While the first application was only against the developer, after 'we did not get very far' his side approached the OMC to see if they would assist, he said.
'But it was not forthcoming and the OMC has now targeted us because we seem to have annoyed them,' he said.
Siobhán Gaffney, for the OMC, said her clients first wanted to set out on affidavit their position in relation to Mr Mooney's application, but it was their case that the OMC was now 'being dragged into the proceedings' when it was only responsible for the common areas and the issue in relation to overheating was a structural and engineering matter.
Deirdre Ní Fhloinn, for the co-defendant, said they supported the developer's request for an early trial.
Mr Justice Cregan said that given the overheating also allegedly affected the common areas and that excess heat was alleged to be coming from pipes and fittings, he was satisfied to join the OMC to the case. Ms O'Byrne would have to amend her papers, he said.
Mr Mooney asked he be allowed to do so after a forensic engineer's report was completed.
The judge, who continued the terms of the interim injunction, gave directions for exchange of papers and adjourned the matter to next month.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Rathmines locals protest over An Post move to sell ‘cultural icon' later this year
Protesters gathered outside Rathmines post office on Saturday morning in a demonstration against its relocation and planned sale of the building. The protest came after An Post this week confirmed its plans to move the Rathmines branch by September, paving the way for the sale of one of the most prominent buildings in the south Dublin suburb. Labour leader and local TD Ivana Bacik organised Saturday's demonstration, alongside local councillors Fiona Connelly and Dermot Lacey. Speaking at the protest, she said the building should be kept 'in community usage', adding that 'our priority is to keep the postal service in the retail hall'. Labour leader Ivana Bacik at the protest in Rathmines on Saturday. Photograph: Ella Sloane The imposing 1934 art deco building will be sold with two other Dublin post offices – Phibsborough and Tallaght – as well as a further three across the State, as part of the 'transformation of the national post office network,' An Post said previously. READ MORE At present, 95 per cent of the country's post offices are already contracted out to independent business owners, who often run post office services as part of a local shop. It is understood the Rathmines post office will move to a Centra store in the locality. Ms Bacik described the demonstration as 'a last-ditch appeal' to Minister for Communications Patrick O'Donovan and Minister for Expenditure Jack Chambers to not sign off on the property's divestment. 'The post office is a very well loved, much-used building. This is very much from the heart.' Ms Connelly stressed the importance of public buildings such as the post office 'as a community asset and a community resource'. Cllr Fiona Connelly at the protest. Photograph: Ella Sloane 'It's really sad to see a resource like the post office, that's in such demand and so heavily used, closing.' Enid O'Dowd, a local and regular user of the postal service, said the decision to sell the building was 'just ridiculous', expressing concern at the pressure the branch's relocation would place on the post office in Ranelagh. Speaking of the branch's speculated move to a nearby Centra, she said the shop 'is going to be a very crushed place with queues spilling out on to the pavement'. 'What's going to happen is people are going to start using the one in Ranelagh but that isn't big enough for the demand. They've only two cashiers there.' Enid O'Dowd at the protest. Photograph: Ella Sloane Cliona Buckley, who grew up on Leinster Road said: 'The last thing they [An Post] should be doing is shutting down memorable, protected, built for purpose buildings. What they should be doing is spending money cleaning up the front of it or they could have lovely potted plants or flower baskets and make it a feature.' She said the post office's planned closure and sale showed a failure by An Post 'to serve the Irish citizens'. Andrew Folan, Mary Freehill and Cliona Buckley at the protest. Photograph: Ella Sloane Another local demonstrator, Andrew Folan, said he felt 'absolutely outraged' by An Post's decision, adding that it was indicative of 'the digitalisation of our culture'. 'The analogue thing of writing letters, posting letters, distributing parcels and meeting the community while you do it is an essential part of our life. I think that the gradual shutting down of post offices is a very negative thing.' Mr Folan pointed to the need for 'a spacious building' due to demand for the service. 'This is a fantastic cultural icon, beautiful design and art deco, well built and a landmark for Rathmines. I think we should celebrate what we've got and show a bit more regard for our culture and our heritage,' he said. Former Labour councillor Mary Freehill, from Rathmines, said the recent loss of the suburb's citizen's information centre in 2022 had already taken a toll on the community. 'There isn't a place for people to come together.' 'Rathmines has very few publicly owned buildings,' said Ms Freehill, adding 'this is the only thing built by the Irish State in Rathmines. All of our other public buildings were built by the British.'
Irish Times
7 hours ago
- Irish Times
Emergency services carry out multiple coastal rescues over past two days
A number of sea and cliff rescue operations have taken place over the last two days in Donegal , Clare and Dublin as emergency services warn the public to stay back from cliff edges. A multi-agency rescue operation was launched shortly after 7am on Saturday at the West End in Bundoran, Co Donegal, after a person fell from a cliff. The alarm was raised when a member of the public heard cries for help and contacted the emergency services. Malin Head Coast Guard co-ordinated the response, tasking Bundoran RNLI, Donegal Fire Service, the National Ambulance Service and Sligo-based Coast Guard helicopter Rescue 118. Bundoran RNLI volunteers were on scene within minutes. The casualty was located at the base of the cliff having landed on rocks. READ MORE The RNLI crew on scene worked to recover the person to the beach. The person was stabilised and airlifted by Rescue 118 before being transferred to Sligo General hospital for further treatment. A multi-agency search and rescue operation was also launched in Lahinch, Co Clare, on Friday night after a man sustained injuries to his legs after he fell from a cliff. The man, who is believed to be a tourist, fell from a 7m height cliff at the Miltown Malbay Road car park in the town. The alarm was raised at 10.15pm. The Shannon-based Rescue 115 attended the scene along with the Doolin Coast Guard unit. The Coast Guard said it was a difficult rescue as the man had fallen into an inaccessible area. It caused certain difficulties for the fire service in terms of reaching him. A winchman was lowered to the man's location. The man, who is in his 20s, is being treated at Galway University Hospital for non-life-threatening injuries. He arrived on site shortly after midnight. [ Teenager (15) who died while swimming in Laytown, Co Meath is named Opens in new window ] On Friday, a teenager was airlifted to hospital with suspected multiple fractures and lacerations after falling 6m on to rocks in Howth. The teenager had to be winched by helicopter from the White Water Brook, a remote beach below cliffs on the eastern side of the Howth peninsula. The Rescue 116 hospital winching a teenager off the rocks at the Howth peninsula on Friday afternoon Another teenager who went to help him suffered from hypothermia. That boy was transferred to the all-weather lifeboat and taken back to Howth lifeboat station, where he was transferred into the care of an ambulance crew. Both teenagers were taken to Beaumont Hospital in Dublin. In a separate incident, the volunteer crew of the Howth RNLI rescued three children who had been cut off by the tide near Lion's Head – a popular swimming spot on the south side of the Howth peninsula, close to the Bailey lighthouse. The RNLI has reminded anyone visiting the coast to stay well back from cliff edges, take extreme care near the water, and in an emergency dial 999 or 112 and ask for the Coast Guard.
Irish Times
11 hours ago
- Irish Times
Palestine GAA club's planned tour of Ireland ‘under serious threat' due to visa delays
A West Bank GAA club's planned trip to Ireland 'is now under serious threat due to visa delays', representatives have said. At least 33 young Palestinian players are to arrive in Ireland in July to play a series of competitive matches against GAA clubs around the country and to take part in a cultural exchange. GAA Palestine, the organisation behind the tour, said it faced 'new requirements introduced during the [application] process', such as English-language birth certificates for Palestinian players and for coaches born in the West Bank. It further said the Irish embassy in Tel Aviv had closed its public office since Iranian missiles hit the Israeli capital and it was 'not prioritising visa applications ... halting all progress'. READ MORE A total of 46 people, including players, coaches, officials and one doctor, were due to arrive in Dublin on July 18th as part of planned trip by Ramallah-based Moataz Sarsour GAA club. GAA Palestine chairman Stephen Redmond said the new requirements in the visa application process had increased the expected processing time from four weeks to eight after, he said, it was given a 10 week pre-departure time frame to submit all necessary paperwork. It had officially submitted the visa applications on May 19th. Co-founder of GAA Palestine Claire Liddy said 'the embassy responded three weeks later, on Monday, June 9th, with a list of additional required documents'. She said the Irish Representative Office in Ramallah 'refused to accept the original documents' on June 13th. She said as local team members were Palestinian, they were 'banned from travelling to Tel Aviv', so club officials outside the region 'had to scan and send the original documents digitally on Monday, June 16th'. A spokesperson for the Department of Foreign Affairs said: 'The department cannot comment on individual visa applications, but all visa applications are processed in line with established procedures for consideration by the Department of Justice.' The spokesperson said the Irish embassy's public office in Tel Aviv and representative office in Ramallah 'are presently closed due to the security situation and staff are working remotely. The public offices will reopen when circumstances permit'. Mr Redmond criticised what he labelled 'bureaucratic nonsense' and he called 'for common sense to prevail so these young people can step on to a GAA pitch'. He said the group had requested an expedited processing of their application, but that this had not taken place. 'With co-operation from the Department of Foreign Affairs, there is still a chance to issue these visas in time,' he said.
