Denley: Ottawa's flawed transit system built on what people once wanted
Frustration with Ottawa's public transit system is understandable, but the root cause is not a large number of people who made remarkably stupid decisions over a long period of time, as it is now popular to conclude.
Article content
Article content
In fact, it's almost the opposite. The light-rail decisions that are mocked today were both popular and rational when they were made.
Article content
Ottawans wanted the same kind of rail service that other cities had already had for years. To accomplish that, they kept electing and re-electing politicians who promised to make the dream a reality.
Article content
Article content
People look back now and lament the loss of what they remember as a much better bus system, but there was a good reason why it had to change. It's hard to imagine now, but 25 years ago, buses clogged downtown streets at rush hours, particularly on Albert and Slater streets.
Article content
At the time, OC Transpo was moving about 10,000 people an hour in each direction downtown at rush hours. The streets were near capacity and transit ridership was growing rapidly. Light rail in a downtown tunnel was ultimately seen as the most viable solution to that problem. It would enable OC Transpo to move up to 24,000 passengers an hour each way.
Article content
It's fair to say that the city's first train decision wasn't the best. Then-mayor Bob Chiarelli wanted light rail that would run from downtown to Barrhaven, but with no tunnel. It was a short-term solution, and one that went north-south when Ottawa's main commute was east and west to downtown. The federal government refused to support the plan.
Article content
Article content
In 2006, Ottawa voters rejected Chiarelli's plan and elected as mayor Larry O'Brien, who became a champion of a downtown tunnel and an east-west route. It was a plan that was more costly but also more rational. O'Brien argued that trains in a tunnel would be faster and more reliable. It seemed plausible.
Article content
Article content
The decision to go with rail was widely regarded as the big-city thing to do. Skeptics, including me, questioned the high capital cost, but enthusiasm won the day. The first stage of the LRT was under way.
Article content
In 2010, voters elected Jim Watson as mayor. He'd been critical of the train plan, but quickly changed his mind when he figured out that others liked it. In the end, Watson became an enthusiastic supporter of light rail.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Ottawa Citizen
5 days ago
- Ottawa Citizen
Hersh: Ottawa Council must take a risk and ban fossil fuel ads
Recently, Ottawa was filled with smoke due to wildfires in Western Canada. In the past couple of years our city has experienced tornadoes, massive flooding and intense storms, all of which can be attributed in part to climate change. Article content Yet, despite declaring a climate emergency in 2019, city council has taken little action in respect to our climate priorities. Since approving its flagship Energy Evolution program in 2020, it has spent a paltry $2.6 million on the program, which calls for around $600 million annually. Article content Article content Article content Today, however, councillors have a chance to take real action when it comes to tackling 'greenwashing' and climate misinformation. Article content In February 2024, 15 civil society groups launched a campaign to get the City of Ottawa to ban fossil fuel ads from city property such as community centres, sports arenas and OC Transpo buses and shelters. Article content In essence, the groups are asking councillors to take the same leadership the city took 20 years ago when it banned tobacco advertising despite a strong backlash from the industry. Just like Big Tobacco, oil and gas have harmful effects on public health. Continuing to allow advertising that promotes fossil fuels as 'clean energy' is not in line with the city's priorities. Article content Now, city staff have come forward with a report that will be debated at committee, saying it would be too legally risky to implement a ban, as that would limit the content of ads and would therefore 'constitute a limit on the right to freedom of expression.' Instead, the report suggests Ottawa can instead follow new 'greenwashing' guidelines from the Competition Act. Article content Article content While this is arguably a step forward, this puts the onus on residents to submit individual complaints about particular ads when it is the city that should be taking leadership. Article content Article content One only needs to look to The Hague to see that it is possible to challenge the fossil fuel industry on this and win. Article content The Hague voted to approve a ban on fossil fuels ads in 2024, coming into effect in January 2025. The municipal bylaw had since been challenged in court by the industry. Article content On April 25, the court ruled in favour of the municipality, arguing that commercial advertising is not protected under freedom of expression and that The Hague is allowed to enact laws it deems in the public interest. Article content The Hague took bold action and have since been vindicated — but it was not without legal risk, as Ottawa's city staff note.
Ottawa Citizen
11-06-2025
- Ottawa Citizen
What new OC Transpo funding means for special constables
Article content OC Transpo's special constables are counting on recent provincial funding to bolster their frontline numbers, increase officer visibility at transit stations and allow for 'more proactive, less reactive' enforcement. Article content 'The province recognized there could be improvements in public safety on transit and specifically in the downtown core,' said OC Transpo chief special constable Peter Scislowski. Article content Article content Article content The so-called 'New Deal for Ottawa' announced by the province last year includes $48 million in funding over three years to improve safety and security on transit and in the city's downtown core. Article content Article content That parcel of funding, announced in November 2024, followed the approval of the city's public safety plan and will increase the number of uniformed OC Transpo special constables on the transit system, along with funds for outreach and alternative mental health supports and the police neighbourhood operations centre near the ByWard Market. Article content OC Transpo currently has 56 frontline special constables and will be using the provincial funding to hire eight more officers in August and September. Article content 'The biggest focus for us is adding staff,' Scislowski said during a recent tour of the city's Transit Operations Control Centre (TOCC) on Belfast Road. The tour included a ridealong through some of the city's transit hotspots, from Tunney's Pasture to Rideau Station at the edge of the ByWard Market, and a look inside the police neighbourhood operations centre on Rideau Street. Article content Article content 'We're adequately staffed to respond to calls we receive right now, but it will improve that visibility for us at the stations. Our special constables are responding to calls from one end of the city to another and north to south… We want to have resources dedicated that are more proactive visibility on the system, and less reactive. Article content Article content The city received funding with the launch of Line 1 to improve its monitoring and response with eyes on more than 5,000 CCTV cameras across the transit network. Special constables and transit staff monitor thousands of cameras in the bustling open-space room, with wall-to-wall screens and a central map of all vehicles and their real-time locations on the road.
Ottawa Citizen
05-06-2025
- Ottawa Citizen
Pellerin: What if OC Transpo had a strong, capable leader?
OC Transpo general manager Renée Amilcar is leaving next month, to become head of a new Quebec government transportation agency, Mobilité Infra Québec. It must be nice to be mobile. Unlike, say, Ottawans who rely (if that's the word) on transit for their everyday transportation needs. Article content I'm sure Amilcar thinks she did a great job in the last four years running our beleaguered system. And in fairness, it's not immediately clear whether she did any worse than her predecessor. Now that we've set the bar suitably low, let's turn our attention to the next person who'll occupy that chair. I thought I'd get the process started by outlining a few key elements of the job description. Article content Article content Article content The first qualification is to be an excellent driver who lives anywhere in the city that doesn't have a quick, reliable and direct bus route to work. That way, they'll be certain to never use the transit system they are nominally in charge of. Leave that to other people, you know? Article content A proven ability to demonstrate a strong allergy to success is also required. The good people of Ottawa have been training for a long time in how to react to one bitter transportation disappointment after another. It is not at all obvious to me they would survive sudden efficiency during their commute. Article content I don't just mean that we got used to hundreds of cancelled buses and trains that only run sporadically. It's also roads crawling with drivers who have abandoned the bus. And construction projects that are apparently designed to inflict maximum pain in the slowest, most drawn-out way possible. Your drive is made worse by the number of people who would prefer riding the proletarian chariot but gave up on it and are driving in front of you instead. Article content Article content Like the frog that's slowly getting used to warming water, Ottawa commuters have gotten used to a slow worsening of their transportation options. They know things aren't good. Article content Article content Imagine what would happen if we had the option of walking out of our home in the morning and hopping on a train or bus that goes to where we're going and shows up often enough that we don't even need to think about looking at the schedule. Mass apoplexy is what. Article content And then what if we could get to a hockey game or a show at Lansdowne or the Canadian Tire Centre from anywhere in the city in half an hour without having to bother with traffic, parking or the worry of drinking and driving? And the ride was comfortable, clean and fare-free?
