‘He just looks like a happy, cheeky boy': Palestinian child refugees pick up the camera
A boy pulling a funny face, a sleeping pet, a grandfather in his chair – all ordinary scenes from life that many of us would take for granted. What makes these images special is they were taken by Palestinian children, refugees displaced to Egypt since Israel's war in Gaza, making sense of their new, if hopefully temporary, home and what they have escaped from.
'It's familial life, relationships, and although they've seen so much, you're not seeing trauma, you're not seeing the faces of people that have given up,' says the photographer Misan Harriman, an ambassador for Save the Children. 'Even though none of these kids know what the future brings and there's huge uncertainty, they are living in the moment. They're doing their best to thrive and learn.' The camera, he adds, is 'a seemingly inanimate object that can help you find answers to a world that is confusing, and even more confusing for some of these children.'
Harriman led a photography workshop in Cairo, run by Save the Children and the charity Choose Love, in which 10 Palestinian children from Gaza, between the ages of 11 and 13, were given a camera and taught how to use it. Over several weeks, they created their own images. It was fun and an outlet for creativity, but it was also about much more, says Harriman. These are children forced to leave their homeland. 'They understand what bearing witness means,' he says. 'They understand what preserving memories means, and hopefully taking pictures of friends, loved ones, possessions they love, it's just a beautiful, maybe even cathartic experience for them.'
Misan Harriman, centre, with some of the children involved in the project. Photograph: Anna Sass/Save the Children
The children who took part in the project are the lucky few, he acknowledges. In Egypt, temporarily home to 100,000 Palestinians since October 2023, more than 2,000 children are on a waiting list to access Save the Children's support services. In Gaza, aid agencies warn of almost total famine as Israel maintained its blockade, only recently and scantly eased. Harriman says: 'More than 93% of all the children in Gaza are at critical risk of famine – that means 930,000 children are at risk of famine, disease and death, if nothing's done.'
Their images, and the portraits taken by Harriman, are about showing 'the humanity of Palestinian families. I want us to re-transmit their right to thrive and learn and laugh and grow, and have siblings and parents in their lives to look after them. Those are basic rights, that the children of the occupied territories do not have.'
Harriman started late in photography – he went on to document protests including those by Black Lives Matter and Extinction Rebellion, shoot for British Vogue, and photograph Harry and Meghan, and was nominated for an Oscar for his short film The After – and he says he learned from the children, too. He saw how they didn't tend to doubt themselves. 'They press the shutter because they want to take that image, they want to freeze that decisive moment. I think that's something that's core to the essence of photography, and children have that inbuilt. We lose it as we get older.'
He taught them about practicalities such as composition and light, which they picked up quickly, but he says his job was to 'plant seeds for these kids to see that with a camera, there are limitless possibilities in how they can tell stories. And all of them have stories that deserve to be heard and seen.' Here, Harriman chooses some of his favourite images from the project.
Portrait of her mother, by Rawan. All photographs: Save the Children
It's an extraordinary image, by someone who has never been formally trained in photography to understand composition and light. There are many people that have far more time and resources who wouldn't necessarily be able to come out with a picture that is this honest, well-composed and a really good representation of what portraiture at its best should be. Palestinian mothers, to me, are deities – they have a strength that few mothers on this planet are forced to have. I see a daughter allowed to capture her love for her mother for eternity. Apart from it just being a good picture, you have a young Palestinian showing respect and recognising the sacrifice and the fortitude of what it means to be a Palestinian mother today.
Rawan says: 'This project enabled me to document my memories and enrich my skills. I was able to show what I hope to achieve one day. It meant a lot to me. My mother is my first supporter and witnessed my first steps. I was excited when I took a photo of her.'
Portrait of his cat, by Shadi
It's subversive in many ways. We have all these gender presumptions of boys, but he says his cat is his favourite thing, and I love the tenderness of that. His pet is what he loves and wants to look after, and it probably makes him feel safe and cosy, with the consideration of what he has been through. Pets are a big part of Palestinian culture and there are many stories of children, with what little food they have, feeding their pets first. The people of Palestine have always looked after the land and their animals. It's nicely composed, with soft light falling on the cat. It's a lovely picture.
Shadi says: 'All my photographs are special to me and each photo has its own significance. My favourite photo is the one of my cat, because she's the most precious thing I own and I feel a great deal of responsibility towards her.'
Portrait of his grandfather, by Shadi
It's hard not to get emotional when you think of the generations that have been taken from Palestinian kids. What I love about this image is the grandfather's hands. You think of the life those hands have seen – this is a man that's probably old enough to have been a child during the Nakba in 1948 and he's still with us, and lucky enough to be able to look down to his beautiful grandson. It's a hopeful picture, but it's also a picture to remind us of the generation of the Nakba who have had so much taken from them.
Shadi says: 'Owning a camera impacted my life positively. It made me notice and value all the things that I own. It made me see beauty in everything, and I hope I can continue my journey in photography.'
Portrait of his sister, and family portrait, by Ayman
The background – the hanging lanterns, the patterned rugs – gives a rich sense of place and the square of light frames her beautifully. This photo captures a sense of the trust and familiarity between the two siblings. The image of Ayman with his family is special simply because it's sadly so rare to see a Palestinian family all together in one photograph in such a normal setting. They are still together, in spite of everything.
Self-portrait, by Ayman
He's being exactly what an 11-year-old boy is. That could be an image taken on any street or apartment in Britain. He just looks like a happy, cheeky boy. I think that's what makes it a great portrait.
High-rise building and self-portrait, by Toleen
The high-rise building with pure blue skies and Ramadan bunting gives a sense of her everyday life and place, but also a feeling of warmth and optimism, and shows how the month of Ramadan is one of real celebration. I love the selfie of Toleen in the mirror. She took this on the day of the workshop, possibly when she got back home and was playing around with the camera. She looks a little shy, but also happy, and it was heartwarming to see her growing in confidence.
Toleen says: 'I felt happy and excited during the project, because I was going through new experiences and learning how to see things from a different perspective. It really had an impact on me. I see life now in a different, more beautiful way. Having a camera has become a part of my life and taught me to pay attention to the small details of the world around me.'
Self-portrait reading the Qur'an, and self-portrait, by Taleen
There's a lovely contrast between the two images which demonstrate Taleen's connection to her faith – the quiet, contemplative moment as she read the Qur'an at home with beautiful soft lighting pouring down on her from a window above, versus the portrait of her in front of a glittery Ramadan decoration outside, which gives a real sense of the celebratory mood of that month. That spirituality, I think, has been increased in these kids because of what they've seen. Judging by the sense of strength that many of the young people have, I think their faith has been central to it, so it's not surprising that many of them photographed prayer mats and beads, and Qur'ans.
Taleen says: 'My favourite photograph is the one of me while reading the Holy Qur'an because it makes me feel happiness, serenity and safety.'
Self-portrait, by Masa
This image of Masa in her keffiyeh is powerful as it shows her pride in her nationality and identity, and she stands resolutely in the middle of the frame. It feels quiet but strong – and giving the peace sign adds a powerful layer of meaning. The keffiyeh in particular is really meaningful in terms of identity. Many chose to photograph the keffiyeh, pictures of the Qur'an and breaking the fast at Ramadan, because these are all memories. They're saying you cannot erase these images, and let that be the truth that the rest of the world sees, which I think is a really powerful thing.
Masa says: 'The keffiyeh is our national symbol. This project was a new, enjoyable experience for me. I learned a lot from it. Photography helps me to express my feelings in a beautiful way.'
Portrait of teacher, by Adam
This image is of one of the teachers at Save the Children's child-friendly space in Cairo. Many of the teachers and volunteers who run the programme are Palestinian. It gives a sense of the environment in which the group spends their days, and the responsibility she bears as teacher, bringing displaced Palestinian families together and providing them with a sense of belonging and unity in a new city and country.
Names have been changed. Visit savethechildren.org.uk to find out more
Do you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article? If you would like to submit a response of up to 300 words by email to be considered for publication in our letters section, please click here.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Grandmother, 86, who dumped her 37-year-old Egyptian toyboy after boasting about their wild romps vows to never have sex again
An 86-year-old grandmother who dumped her Egyptian toyboy lover less than half her age has vowed never to have sex again after their bitter split. Iris Jones defied critics and tied the knot with Mohamed Ibrahim, 37, in June 2020 -later boasting about their wild romps that left her 'saddle-sore'. The pair met on social media in 2019, and after getting married in Cairo, they spent almost two years apart before Mohamed was granted a visa which allowed him to move into Iris's bungalow in Weston-super-Mare. However, in 2023 Iris revealed she had split up with Mohamed and accused him of being a 'selfish money-grabber'. Bank statements show Iris transferred Mohamed thousands of pounds in loans, which she claims were not repaid- but he disputes. Iris, a former legal secretary, has now revealed her experience with the 37-year-old Egyptian has put her off relationships for good. She told The Mirror: 'The idea of sex now makes my stomach turn. I'm not interested in men at all, not in companionship with them and certainly not sex with them. 'My experience with Mohamed has put me off relationships for life. I wish I'd never met him.' The pair met on social media in 2019, and after getting married in Cairo, they spent almost two years apart before Mohamed was granted a visa to move to the UK Iris added: 'Mohamed was only with me for my money. I can see that now, and I look back and think, 'How could I have been so stupid?'.' She said decided to kick Mohamed out of her house after they started arguing about 'anything and everything'. Iris, who has two sons, Stephen, 59, and Darren, 58, said she also became fed up of 'having to clean up after him'. She revealed, however, that despite the acrimonious split, her and Mohamed are still married as she 'doesn't want to have to pay out for a divorce'. Iris first stunned audiences on This Morning in early 2020 when she detailed her first night of passion with Mohamed after she travelled to Egypt to meet him. She now, however, sees herself as an 'agony aunt' to other women who have had their hearts broken by much younger men. Writing on Facebook last year, Iris said 'A warning to all vulnerable women on-line, chatting to scammers and con-artists, thinking they are messaging genuine males on legitimate dating sites. 'Be aware that these criminals are only interested in getting their filthy paws on your money, and will sweet-talk you for weeks or even months in order to achieve their goal. 'I, myself have been targeted by four scammers in the last few months and regard myself now as a competent scam hunter!' It comes after she revealed the 'full story' of what happened with Mohamed on social media in September 2023. Iris said: 'On June 25, 2019, I received a message from Mohamed, and we became friends on messenger. 'He seemed a nice bloke and right from the start that he was forced into a marriage and that as a result four children were born. 'He was going through a divorce and felt that I was the person who could understand and that he could talk to. 'He sent me photos of himself and I told him:' You will soon find someone else, a good looking chap like yourself.' 'I told him about myself, an old biddy pushing 79 years with two grown up sons, older than him, both married and living not far from me. 'Our messages to one another continued and I began to realise he was getting to be more loving and on July 10 2019, he proposed marriage! 'He'd never seen what I looked like and my first reaction was 'You are bloody mad!' 'But the love bombing continued and in November 2019 I flew to Cairo and met him. In early 2020, Iris raised eyebrows when she appeared with Holly and Phil on This Morning – reducing them to hysterics – as she opened up about their first night of passion 'I had taken several thousand pounds with me, and I paid all his debts as he had ben borrowing on his credit card. 'We had a wonderful time and I stayed for a month. We tried to get married, but we didn't have the correct documents.' Iris then went on to describe how an official at the British Embassy in Cairo, called john Neil, warned her: 'Don't give him any money.' Sadly, Iris failed to listen to his advice and wrote how the next time she went to visit Mohammed she took £15,000 and handed it to him. By this time Covid had hit and attempts to get married were thwarted by the pandemic but on her third trip in 2020 they did tie the knot. Iris said: 'I had £40,000 in my bank account and I handed over my bank card to Mohamed every day and we were drawing 1000 Egyptian pounds daily. 'This was to pay for living expenses, eating out, a honeymoon in Sharm-El-Shiek and generally enjoying the high life.' After three months in Egypt Irish returned to the UK and as she left Cairo, she wrote how Mohammed had told her: 'Check your bank account when you get back to Heathrow. 'I think you will have about nine grand in there.' Furious Iris stormed: 'He was absolutely correct. £9,000 left of the £40,000. Mohamed has never had a job and has never had any money. 'I used to say to people that we shared expenses, but my money paid for everything.' Iris added how even when back in the UK, Mohammed would ask for money, and she sent him another £14,000. In November 2021, Mohammed obtained a spousal visa and was able to travel to the UK where he was allowed to stay for two years, pending a review in two months' time. To satisfy the Home Office, Iris paid money into his account so that it wouldn't look as if he was 'sponging off state'. But even after getting a job at a local supermarket, Irish wrote how he would still 'keep asking for many' so much so that she gave him another £26,000. Iris said: 'I told him: 'no more money. If I dropped dead tomorrow, I wouldn't have enough to bury me.' She went on: 'He did say at that stage that he needed another £40,000. Well, you will have to whistle for it because I haven't got it.' Iris added the relationship then started to deteriorate, with numerous rows, especially after Mohamed learned he would not be inheriting her seaside bungalow. Mohamed offered to give Iris the names of women who were 'coming onto him' if she changed her will and tellingly on her post she wrote: 'This occurred to me that maybe that's why he married me.' Iris ended her lengthy post by saying: 'There is much more I can say at this juncture, but it could involve legal issues. 'From Mohamed's behaviour, I learned that he was displaying many of the traits of narcissism. 'I researched the condition thoroughly, as I wanted to save my marriage, but Mohamed wouldn't listen. 'He was always right, I was always wrong. On June 13 of this year, after another vitriolic row, I told him to go. 'It was one of the hardest decisions I have ever had to make, as my love for Mohamed was genuine but it was no good pretending that things would improve. 'I let my head rule my heart. There is so much more I could say at this point but that will be for another post.'
Daily Mail
a day ago
- Daily Mail
BBC scraps plans to show documentary about medics in Gaza after new bias concerns
The BBC has decided to scrap plans to show a documentary about medics in Gaza over concerns it 'risked creating a perception of partiality' of its coverage of the conflict. Gaza: Doctors Under Attack was commissioned by the corporation more than a year ago from an independent production company called Basement Films. However, its production was paused in April after an investigation was launched into the making of another controversial documentary, Gaza: How to Survive a War Zone. That programme was taken off the iPlayer earlier this year, and the corporation was forced to apologise after it was revealed that the documentary featured a 13-year-old narrator who is the son of a Hamas government minister and grandson of one of Hamas' s founding members. In the latest controversy over the BBC's coverage of the war, the broadcaster has confirmed discussions over the documentary showing the plight of medics in Gaza had 'reached the end of the road'. The corporation will now transfer ownership of the project to the independent production company that produced it. 'We wanted the doctors' voices to be heard,' the BBC said in a statement. 'Our aim was to find a way to air some of the material in our news programmes, in line with our impartiality standards, before the review was published. 'For some weeks, the BBC has been working with Basement Films to find a way to tell the stories of these doctors on our platforms.' But, the corporation added: 'Yesterday it became apparent that we have reached the end of the road with these discussions. 'We have come to the conclusion that broadcasting this material risked creating a perception of partiality that would not meet the high standards that the public rightly expect of the BBC. 'Impartiality is a core principle of BBC News. It is one of the reasons that we are the world's most trusted broadcaster. 'Therefore, we are transferring ownership of the film material to Basement Films.' It went on to say that since the pause in production of Gaza: Doctors Under Attack, 'it has not undergone the BBC's final pre-broadcast sign-off processes' and 'any film broadcast will not be a BBC film'. Critics were also enraged by the Beeb's failure to disclose who the film's narrator was, leading former director of BBC Television Danny Cohen to say: 'The BBC appears to have given an hour of prime-time coverage to the son of a senior member of the Hamas terrorist group. 'Either they were not aware of the terrorist links because they did not carry out the most basic journalistic checks or the BBC did know and misled audiences about the family's deep involvement with terrorism.' The BBC documentary, Gaza: How to Survive a Warzone, was broadcast on BBC Two with the aim of showing a 'vivid and unflinching view of life' in the enclave Since the allegations were made, the BBC has apologised and added new text to the film which explains who Abdullah and his father are. In an email exchange via the BBC, Abdullah reportedly said he wanted to be part of the documentary, which was made by Hoyo Films, 'to explain the suffering that people here in Gaza witness with the language that the world understands, English.' He is said to have asked to be involved to help viewers learn about the situation on the ground without being 'blurred by misinformation'. The BBC documentary, Gaza: How to Survive a Warzone, was broadcast on February 17 on BBC Two with the aim of showing a 'vivid and unflinching view of life' in the strip. It was made by two producers based in London who remotely directed two cameramen on the ground over nine months. Independent investigative journalist David Collier claimed one of the child narrators, Abdullah, is the son of a Hamas government minister and grandson of one of Hamas's founding members. Using Facebook and publicly available data online, Mr Collier claimed the show's young star is the son of Gaza's deputy minister of agriculture Dr Ayman Al-Yazouri. This would mean his grandfather would be the Hamas founder Ibrahim al-Yazouri, who has previously been jailed by Egypt and Israel for involvement in proscribed groups. The Daily Mail has not been able to independently verify Mr Collier's claims. The BBC apologised for the inclusion of the documentary's young star, with a spokesperson for the corporation saying: 'Since the transmission of our documentary on Gaza, the BBC has become aware of the family connections of the film's narrator, a child called Abdullah. 'We've promised our audiences the highest standards of transparency, so it is only right that as a result of this new information, we add some more detail to the film before its retransmission. We apologise for the omission of that detail from the original film.' The BBC said the new text attached to the film: 'The narrator of this film is 13 year old Abdullah. His father has worked as a deputy agriculture minister for the Hamas-run government in Gaza. The production team had full editorial control of filming with Abdullah.' 'We followed all of our usual compliance procedures in the making of this film, but we had not been informed of this information by the independent producers when we complied and then broadcast the finished film,' the statement added. 'The film remains a powerful child's eye view of the devastating consequences of the war in Gaza which we believe is an invaluable testament to their experiences, and we must meet our commitment to transparency.'
BBC News
a day ago
- BBC News
Brother raising money in memory of teen photographer Liz Hatton
The brother of a teenage photographer who inspired Catherine, Princess of Wales, during her fight against a rare cancer has started a fundraising challenge in her Hatton, 17, from Harrogate, died in November from a desmoplastic small round cell tumour after becoming known for her photography bucket Mateo is raising money with a 24-hour swimming and knitting challenge for research into palliative care for young people with similar terminal thinks his sister would be "really proud of me for raising money for not just her, but for her cancer". Money is being raised through the charity Capture, set up by Liz's family to fund research into desmoplastic small round cell tumours and the care given to young and Mateo's mother Vicky Robayna said: "For those young people it is really important that they make the most out of each and every day because the future is really uncertain but there's currently no research out there on young people's views of palliative care."She said Liz's consultant, Dr Bob Phillips, gave her "real choices about how to live the rest of her life"."She knew that he would go all-out to find a solution that didn't involve her having to spend ages in hospital, so she would definitely approve of us trying to give that gift to other young people," she added. Mateo said the idea for the "Splash and Stitch" event came from combining both of his hobbies."I didn't know how to knit until a year ago when one of my favourite teachers at school taught me how to knit and crochet," he said. "I guess it just relaxes me."Swimming is special to Mateo, his mum added, as Liz watched his first session with Harrogate District swimming squad the night before she died."Unlike Mateo, she was not a fan of swimming, so she was so so proud of him for being such a good swimmer," Vicky said."She was just truly amazing - what she did with her camera, her supportiveness." Friends from the knitting club at Mateo's school are lending their support and visited for the first two hours of the challenge which was due to last from 14:00 on Friday until 14:00 on Saturday."I think if Liz was here she would really like what we're doing and she would be really proud of Mateo and everyone who supported her, because she was a very nice person," schoolfriend Paloma said. Listen to highlights from North Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North.
