Tarar for avoiding conflict of interests
Listen to article
Law Minister Azam Nazir Tarar has advised the newly appointed members of appellate tribunals dealing with billions of rupees worth of tax matters to recuse themselves from hearing cases where the conflict of interests arises because of their past professional affiliations.
The minister spoke to The Express Tribune after questions were posed about the conflict of interests in the case of some of the appellate tribunal members. "When the question of conflict of interests arises, the newly appointed members will choose the option of 'not before me'," Tarar said.
Instead of appointing new members of the Inland Revenue appellate tribunal through the Federal Public Service Commission (FPSC), the government in January this year constituted a three-member selection committee.
Among the committee members were Justice (Retired) Mushir Alam, Major General (Retired) Naveed Ahmad, who is a member of the FPSC, and Asim Zulfiqar, a senior partner of AF Ferguson chartered accountancy firm.
On the recommendation of the committee, the federal cabinet has so far appointed 15 members from March to May this year.
The newly appointed members have been given salaries equal to judges but they are not independent like the judges, said Dr Ikramul Haq, a senior lawyer at the Supreme Court of Pakistan. He also questioned the selection process, saying there were questions about some of the members' competency and conflict of interests.
The members should either work under high courts or the Supreme Court instead of working under the executive branch, he suggested.
To a question about bypassing the FPSC, the law minister said the selection process had been outsourced to management consulting firm AT Kearney "for ensuring independence" in the process.
To another question how to ensure transparency and objectivity in deciding the cases if some of the tribunal members have worked with tax advisory firms, Tarar replied "we believe that these are mature people and will take care of the conflict of interests".
The minister said that whenever such a situation arises, the members should exercise the "not before me" right to avoid hearing cases being pleaded by tax firms where they have worked in the past. The Ministry of Law has made these appointments under Section 130 of the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001.
The law states that a person shall be eligible to be appointed as a member of the Appellate Tribunal, if he is an advocate of a High Court for not less than 15 years and possesses such other qualifications as may be prescribed by rules under this section; has for a period not less than 10 years practiced professionally as a chartered accountant and has for a period not less than 10 years practiced professionally as a cost and management accountant.
An officer of the Inland Revenue in BS-21 or above; or an officer of the Inland Revenue in BS-20, having served in such a grade for three years or more, is also eligible for these appointments.
The prime minister decided to appoint all these members from the private sector to address the issue of conflict of interests. There had also been incidents in the past where the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) used to influence the outcome of cases, although the members were working under the administrative control of the law ministry.
About Rs4 trillion in revenues are stuck at various levels – most of which before the commissioners appeal of the FBR and the appellate tribunals. The FBR and the office of the Attorney General of Pakistan had assured the PM to at least recover about Rs400 billion before June. Similar assurances had also been given to the IMF.
However, so far no major breakthrough has been achieved, except in the case of windfall tax.
A recent IMF report stated that the Pakistani authorities were actively pursuing the resolution of outstanding cases. It said efforts were being made to recover Rs367 billion out of a total of Rs770 billion under dispute. These included cases pending before the Supreme Court involving Rs43 billion, high courts in Islamabad, Sindh and Lahore involving Rs217 billion and the Appellate Tribunal Inland Revenue Rs104 billion.
The report disclosed that the IMF had been assured that the Supreme Court had completed its initial hearing, with a final decision expected by mid-April. A favourable ruling could effectively resolve related cases worth an estimated Rs120 billion, according to the report.
The IMF's view was that resolving the cases would help clarify the legality of the disputed claims, thereby supporting future revenue by reducing uncertainty and discouraging future litigation.
The appointments of the new members have already been challenged in courts for the lack of transparency.
According to media reports, the Islamabad High Court (IHC) has issued an interim order on the appointment of members in the Appellate Tribunal Inland Revenue, stating that all appointments would be subject to the final outcome of a writ petition.
Earlier, the IHC issued notices to the Ministry of Law secretary, FPSC chairman and Attorney General of Pakistan following a constitutional petition challenging the appointment process of tribunal members.
The petition challenges the unadvertised process of "head hunting" and the lack of transparency. It alleges that the appointment process did not follow the established rules and procedures.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
7 hours ago
- Express Tribune
COAS makes pitch for trade with US
Listen to article Field Marshal Syed Asim Munir has said that Pakistan does not seek security assistance or aid from the United States, but rather trade, investment and mutual respect. Speaking at a closed-door session with senior scholars, policy experts, analysts and representatives of leading international media outlets in Washington, the army chief praised President Donald Trump as "one of the greatest and fantastic leaders", a day after their landmark meeting at the White House. "We want to be treated with respect and dignity," Field Marshal Munir was quoted as saying by several participants of the session, who spoke to The Express Tribune on condition of anonymity. According to at least three attendees, the army chief addressed a wide range of issues, including Pakistan-US bilateral ties, counter-terrorism, economic challenges, internal social dynamics, and the country's democratic journey. His candid and confident tone impressed many in the room. "This was a different Asim Munir than the one we saw during his first visit to Washington," said one participant. "He was more composed, self-assured and spoke without notes for over an hour. Last time, he barely made an opening statement." Contrary to narratives often pushed by India, attendees noted that Field Marshal Munir did not display any inclination towards radical or religious extremism. Instead, he referenced a historic speech by Quaid-e-Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah emphasizing equal rights for all citizens, regardless of religion, caste, or creed. On foreign relations, he asserted that Pakistan's ties with China and the United States are not mutually exclusive. "China has never asked us to limit our engagement with the US," he stated, urging Washington to view Pakistan through its own lens and not through the prism of China, India or Afghanistan. The army chief also addressed democratic development in Pakistan, acknowledging that while Pakistan may not have achieved an ideal democracy yet, it aspires to build a democratic system modeled on strong institutions like those in the United States. When asked about his two-hour-long meeting with President Trump, the field marshal declined to share specific details but described the interaction as "fantastic," praising Trump's "global vision" and "strategic clarity." Touching on the volatile Middle East situation, Field Marshal Munir called for diplomacy and peaceful resolution of the Israel-Iran conflict. He also highlighted the destabilizing role India has played in the region, accusing New Delhi of supporting proxy groups to foment unrest inside Pakistan. Overall, observers described the engagement as one of the most candid and strategically focused interactions by a Pakistani military leader in recent memory. Meanwhile, a statement issued by the ISPR said the interaction with prominent US think tanks and representatives of the strategic affairs institutions, provided an opportunity to articulate Pakistan's principled stance on key regional and global issues, and to deepen understanding of Pakistan's strategic outlook. In his remarks, the Chief of Army Staff highlighted Pakistan's unwavering commitment to regional peace and stability, and its constructive role in fostering a rules-based international order. The field marshal eluded to the details and analysis of the Maarka-e-Haq, Operation Bunyanum Marsoos and elaborated on Pakistan's perspective on terrorism, noting the malign influence of certain regional actors in sponsoring and perpetuating terrorism as a tool of hybrid warfare. The COAS emphasised that Pakistan has been on the front lines of the global war against terrorism, having rendered immense sacrifices — both human and economic — in pursuit of a safer and more secure world. Field Marshal Asim Munir shed light on Pakistan's remarkable untapped potential, particularly in the domains of information technology, agriculture, and its vast and underexploited reserves in the mining and mineral sectors. He invited international partners to explore collaborative opportunities in these sectors to unlock shared prosperity. The army chief also provided a detailed exposition of Pakistan's balanced approach to regional and global conflicts, advocating for dialogue, diplomacy, and adherence to international law. He reaffirmed that Pakistan continues to play a responsible and proactive role in mitigating regional tensions and promoting cooperative security frameworks. The discussion further included an evaluation of the long-standing Pakistan-US partnership. The COAS underlined the historical convergences between the two nations, particularly in areas such as counter-terrorism, regional security, and economic development. He underscored the immense potential for a broader, multidimensional relationship built upon mutual respect, shared strategic interests, and economic interdependence. Participants noted the openness and clarity of the COAS's perspectives and appreciated Pakistan's consistent and principled policies. The interaction was marked by a spirit of mutual understanding and was widely regarded as a positive step toward enhancing strategic dialogue between Pakistan and the United States. This engagement reflects Pakistan's commitment to transparent diplomacy, international engagement, and the pursuit of peaceful coexistence through principled and proactive dialogue.
Business Recorder
8 hours ago
- Business Recorder
PARTLY FACETIOUS: There is a need for structural changes in taxation system
'Chairman FBR urged the Senate body to abolish the Seventh Schedule of the Income Tax Ordinance…' 'Which incidentally dates back to 2001.' 'Hey, that ordinance has been amended from time to time and like other countries remains largely valid…' 'Excuse me, but there is a need for structural change in our taxes – our reliance on withholding taxes that are levied in the sales tax mode, which you must know is an indirect tax whose incidence on the poor is greater than on the rich, but credited dishonestly by the FBR under direct tax collections…' 'They are kinda easy to collect – you appoint withholding agents from the private sector, increase their work load don't pay them a penny, and they collect it…' 'Look at the glass as half full: you collect more while you don't burden your staff and…' 'The private sector is reeling, let me cite the Finance Division's data on large scale manufacturing sector: negative 1.4 percent in the outgoing year, negative under 0.5 percent last year and this negativity…' 'The glass is half full, my friend.' 'Right besides the Chairman has claimed that enforcement measures have generated a close to 380 billion rupees and…' 'But the successful enforcements he mentioned were from indirect taxes, excise duty on….on was it sugar or cigarettes? And that tax is passed onto the consumers anyway, so…' 'Anyway one question, if the seventh schedule is abolished would the banks be as amenable to lending around 1.2 trillion rupees to the poorly performing power sector - money borrowed to retire the circular debt?' 'If you recall, the head of our premier intelligence agency did, how can I put it, convince the Independent Power Producers to agree to the renegotiations and….' 'I am aware of that, my question is if the banks do not get special treatment then would they agree to lending to a sector where they are over exposed and…' 'I am not sure, but why doesn't the Chairman consider generating revenue from some other source. India for example, generates huge amounts from its stock market activities…' 'Hey, our stock markets are used as a yardstick to assess government performance.' 'But the bulk of our population, the poor, the lower middle and middle income earners do not invest in the stock market…' 'Shut up silly. You don't know the macro picture.' 'I stand corrected.' Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
8 hours ago
- Business Recorder
FBR officials: OICCI says concerned at proposed arrest powers
KARACHI: The Overseas Investors Chamber of Commerce and Industry (OICCI) has expressed serious concerns over the proposed powers of arrest granted to Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) officials under the Finance Bill 2025-26, warning that the move has significantly undermined investor confidence, particularly among foreign stakeholders. In a letter addressed to Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb, the OICCI expressed deep concern over proposed amendments in the Finance Bill 2025-26, relating to Section 37 AA of the Sales Tax Act, 1990, seeking to extend wide powers to the Inland Revenue officials relating to arrest/prosecution without necessary check and balance. The chamber criticized the provision for granting sweeping powers of arrest and prosecution to Inland Revenue officials without adequate checks and balances, which it believes could lead to misuse and harassment of businesses. Tax laws: PM directs formation of arrest powers review panel 'Local business leadership has also reacted very negatively to the proposed measure; however, this move has dented the confidence of the leadership of our 200-plus members belonging to over 30 countries,' Abdul Aleem Chief Executive and Secretary General OICCI said in the letter. He said that such arbitrary measures, without thorough consultation with key stakeholders or due consideration of its potential impact on the business environment, add to the negative perception of the country as a business-friendly destination for local and foreign investors. OICCI has also appreciated the timely intervention from Prime Minister, Mian Shehbaz Sharif, Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb and senior members of Parliament in ensuring that such far-reaching and potentially disruptive proposals are not enacted without rigorous oversight and due diligence. He said there should be any consideration to retain this clause for exceptional circumstances, the OICCI looks forward to reviewing the specific safeguards proposed to prevent misuse. In the Chamber's view, at a minimum, explicit prior approval from the FBR Chairman should be mandated in any such extraordinary case involving the arrest of an alleged defaulter. The OICCI further emphasized its trust that the government leadership and relevant authorities including the FBR fully recognize the potential reputational damage that such unnecessary and excessive measures could cause to Pakistan's image as a welcoming and dependable destination for both foreign and domestic investors. The OICCI has also conveyed its concerns to FBR Chairman Rashid Mahmood Langrial and urged a reconsideration of the proposed clause. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
