Crores down the drain as ‘new' social housing schemes crumble across cities

Vadodara/Surat/Ahmedabad: A criminal waste of public money is being witnessed in key cities of Gujarat, where despite hundreds of crores being spent on their construction, homes in 'new'
affordable housing schemes
for the Economically Weaker Sections (EWS), remain unallocated or uninhabitable for more than a decade, exposing their shoddy quality.
In Vadodara, a Jawaharlal Nehru National Urban Renewal Mission (JNNURM) housing scheme in Sayajipura, comprising 1,196 units has been practically complete since 2019 but remains unoccupied. These homes, meant for the urban poor, lack essential infrastructure like reliable water supply, and have been abandoned. "Even these beneficiaries have not paid their contribution for the houses yet. We got the blocks painted again and some minor work that remains can be done anytime," said an official from the Vadodara Municipal Corporation.
Sources said that the housing scheme had run into difficulties soon after work was allotted to a contractor, who claimed financial difficulties. The work had to be allotted to another contractor. Even after this, it was not completed in the real sense. It was only recently that around 30 beneficiaries were identified through a draw. "Even these beneficiaries have not paid their contribution for the houses yet. We got the blocks painted again and some minor work that remains cane be done anytime," said a VMC official.
An elected representative pointed out that while the housing blocks may seem ready, there were issues related to water supply that still needed to be fixed. "Without basic amenities like water, the houses cannot be handed over," he said.
The rot extends to Ahmedabad where the municipal corporation demolished 1,664 unused houses in Vatva, originally built at a cost of Rs 55.20 crore. These units were part of the 18,928 houses constructed under the Rajiv Gandhi Housing Scheme before 2014 for Rs 500 crore.
"The 1,664 houses, which had been vacant for over a decade, had deteriorated significantly. An influential politician from the area had pressured to stop the allotment process," admits a senior AMC official. The official said, "A structural audit deemed them unsafe, prompting their demolition. Now, AMC has begun inspection of the remaining houses."
Close to 4,000 houses among the 18,928 were never allocated for a long time — largely due to beneficiaries failing to pay the required Rs 65,000, leading to prolonged vacancy and decay.
Alarmingly, nearly half of the total units have shown structural issues over the past 12 years. "The upcoming structural audit will guide AMC's next steps under the Public Housing Redevelopment Policy 2016," said the official.
AMC's standing committee recently approved Rs 81 lakh for SVNIT, Surat, to assess the structural stability of over 8,000 houses across 270 blocks in Vatva and Behrampura. No action has been initiated against the contractors who constructed these dwellings.
"Most of these houses were allocated to families displaced by the Sabarmati Riverfront project," adds the AMC official.
The situation is equally dire in Surat, where a Rs 19 crore housing project for the EWS in Bhestan, developed in 2014-15, crumbled even before its 10th anniversary. This project of 270 apartments was constructed without crucial water and drainage connections.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Indian Express

12 minutes ago

• Indian Express

From building stadiums to hosting international events, how Bihar is trying to turn around its sporting culture

When Bihar played Mumbai at Patna's Moin-ul-Haq stadium in January 2024, it wasn't the game or the cricketing stars that captured media attention. It was the state of the stadium — the broken and muddy stands, the overgrown lawn and the non-functional scoreboard, all telltale signs of government apathy. Since then, Bihar appears to be trying hard to shed that image. From a new multi-crore state-of-the-art sports complexes and a sports university to hosting Khelo India Youth games and a new policy and department exclusively to it, Bihar is doing much in this direction. Bihar's sports push can be gauged from the fact that its sports budget shot up from Rs 30 crore in 2022-23 to Rs 568 crore in 2025-26. According to a senior leader of the ruling Janata Dal (United), the Nitish Kumar government was trying to use such initiatives to tap into a vast vote base – the youth. Youth are estimated to make up about 30 percent of Bihar's population and, according to the leader, such a push holds particular significance since the state has historically lagged behind in sporting achievements. 'Promoting sundry sports ahead of crucial 2025 Assembly polls could come in handy for the government to tap into the vast constituency of youth, which is caste-neutral,' the senior leader, who is close to Bihar Chief Minister Nitish Kumar, said. 'At the heart of this transformation is the belief that sports can empower the youth, promote community well-being, and uplift the state's image on both national and international stages'. A senior government official added: 'If Nitish Kumar's tenure as Bihar CM between 2005 and 2020 is often cited for infrastructure overhaul in the state and providing drinking water to almost all villages, the CM's current tenure between 2020 and 2025 has witnessed a massive push for sports – from upgrading of sports infrastructure to taking Bihar on national map by hosting several national and international sports events in past few years.' A large part of the push is decentralisation of sports and promotion at the village level. This includes constructing outdoor stadiums at block levels to encourage more participation. But it's not only sports infrastructure that the state is upgrading: it's also simultaneously offering incentives for athletes, even announcing a new policy last year for directly recruiting medal-winning athletes into government jobs. Bihar's push for sports also found a mention in Prime Minister Narendra Modi's speech on the opening day of the 7th edition of Khelo India Youth Games, 2025, on May 4. In it, Modi lavished praise at the Bihar government's initiatives to promote sports and said events such Khelo India Youth Games would further 'help Bihar in establishing its presence in the field of sports at national level'. Building sports cities, decentralising sports — Bihar's massive sports push Soon after the January 2024 fiasco, Chief Minister Nitish Kumar announced a revamp of the Moinul Haque stadium. Meanwhile, just ahead of the Khelo India Youth games, Nitish inaugurated sports facilities at the Rajgir Sports Academy-cum-Sports University. Built at a cost of Rs 750 crore, the 90-acre sports complex boasts of having both indoor and outdoor stadiums with facilities to host sports events across 24 disciplines. Also under construction is an international cricket stadium at Rajgir with a capacity of 40,000 spectators, expected to be ready by the end of the year. The stadium is expected to host both domestic and international matches. The Bihar Sports University, meanwhile, is expected to be opened to students from the 2025-26 academic session. The university, which got recognition from the University Grants Commission in January this year, will offer both degree and diploma programmes in various disciplines of sports. Among its programmes are diploma/PG diploma in sports coaching, diploma/PG diploma in Yoga, four years Bachelor of Physical education. It will also offer programmes in sport sciences. Besides this, the government has also begun hosting a variety of national and international sporting events, from the Women's Asian Hockey and the Ranji Trophy Cup matches in 2024 to the Sepak Takraw World Cup 2025 and the Khelo India Youth Games 2025. In January last year, the state government created a standalone sports department, previously part of the art, culture and youth affairs department. This came a year after the state government set up the Bihar State Sports Authority (BSSA) – the body that promotes athletes in the state. The government is also setting up a Rs 100-crore sports complex at Punpun on the outskirts of Patna. The complex would be part of a larger sports city complete with modern facilities such as training centre, gyn, lounges and restaurants. Meanwhile, officials at block and district levels have been asked to have playgrounds ready 'as part of the state government's mega drive to nurture sports talents from grassroot levels', Masaurhi sub-divisional officer Amit Kumar Patel said. Out of Bihar's 534 blocks, 252 already have fully constructed outdoor stadiums while an additional 64 are currently under construction, while 58 are at the active development stage, officials said. 'Proposals for stadiums have been received from 163 more blocks, indicating strong grassroots interest and participation in the program. So far, 25 districts have completed these sports-cum-fitness centres, and another 13 have received official approval for construction,' one district official said. In March this year, the BSSA launched 'Mashal' – a statewide talent search competition for schools. The event saw the participation of students from 38,000 government secondary and higher secondary schools in the state. Students selected under this programme are trained to go to cluster, block, district and state competitions. 'The competition is conducted in two categories — Under 14 and Under 16 for boys and girls. At present, students participate in athletics, kabaddi, badminton, football and volleyball,' one official said, adding that there are plans to add at least half a dozen more sports in the coming three years. In addition, the state is trying to incentivise sports and sportspeople under its 'Medal Lao, Naukri Pao' scheme. 'Under this, medal winners at various sporting competitions will be given Class 1 government jobs without appearing for a written test or interview. So far, 71 national and international award winners have been given government jobs,' one official said. The state government is also offering scholarships for athletes. According to government officials, 123 athletes have been granted scholarships of up to Rs 5 lakh/year. 'This category guarantees that athletes at various levels receive sufficient support to pursue their sporting ambitions. It covers expenses related to training, travel, equipment, and other vital needs,' one official said. Meanwhile, high-performing athletes who have already showcased outstanding skills at national or international competitions are entitled to scholarships of up to Rs 20 lakh/annum. 'The scholarship ensures that elite athletes have access to top-notch training facilities, coaching, nutrition, and medical care. It enables them to compete at the highest levels and achieve recognition for both the state and the nation,' the official said. According to Additional Chief Secretary B Rajender, the initiatives have already begun showing results. 'That Bihar is witnessing a sports revolution is evident in the state's record 36 medals at the 2025 Khelo India Youth Games, a 620 percent jump from last year. A key pillar of this transformation is the rapid expansion of grassroots infrastructure — construction for 6,659 new sports grounds across 5,671 gram panchayats has begun. At the same time, the government is setting up khel clubs and launching talent hunts involving around 60 lakh players from 40,000 schools, ensuring that every corner of Bihar becomes a cradle for sporting excellence.' Athletes too believe these programmes prove how seriously the state is now taking sports. 'Bihar's sports facilities are now at par with Delhi's sports facilities,' Anishka Kumari, an archer, said. 'Bihar hosting some national and international events is a big enough proof of it.' But some experts believe the measures are 'too little, too late'. 'Why had Moin-ul-Haq stadium remained ignored all these years when a small state like Jharkhand has two world-class stadia?' Bihar Players Association president Mrityunjay Tiwari asked. 'The government has to start from basics – we do not have devoted playing hours in schools, and we hardly have sports trainers. Raising boundary walls in villages does not make it a stadium. It is good that the government is finally addressing the neglect of sports but it has to first inculcate sports culture. It can come with good trainers and decentralised sports infrastructure.' Santosh Singh is a Senior Assistant Editor with The Indian Express since June 2008. He covers Bihar with main focus on politics, society and governance. Investigative and explanatory stories are also his forte. Singh has 25 years of experience in print journalism covering Bihar, Delhi, Madhya Pradesh and Karnataka. ... Read More

Hans India

29 minutes ago

• Hans India

Amid high drama, Kaushik Reddy arrested; gets bail

Hyderabad: Amid high drama, A Railway Court in Warangal that awarded a 14-day remand to BRS' Huzurabad MLA Padi Kaushik Reddy in connection with an extortion case, reversed its decision and granted him conditional bail on Saturday. Earlier, Kaushik Reddy was arrested by the Warangal Subedari police immediately after he landed at the Rajiv Gandhi International Airport at Shamshabad on Saturday early morning. Following his arrest, police transported him to Warangal for further investigation. It's learnt that Kaushik was about to leave the country. According to police, cases have been registered against Kaushik Reddy under BNS Sections 308(2), 308(4), and 352, which pertain to attempted culpable homicide not amounting to murder and assault. The incident reportedly stems from a confrontation between Kaushik Reddy and a quarry owner, during which the MLA allegedly issued threats. It's alleged that the MLA had already extorted Rs 25 lakh and was demanding another Rs 50 lakh from Uma Devi, wife of a granite quarry operator, Manoj Reddy, for running a quarry near Vangapalli village under Kamalapur mandal in Hanumakonda district. A case has been registered under various sections of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS). Subedari Inspector M Ranjith Kumar said that Kaushik demanded money from the quarry operator and produced call records as evidence during court proceedings. Telangana High Court dismissed Kaushik's quash petition earlier this week. The arrest of Kaushik Reddy triggered huge uproar from the BRS leaders. The main opposition party leaders alleged that the chief minister A Revanth Reddy who claims that his government was 'Indiramma Rajyam' was bringing back the Emergency of Indiramma's era.

Time of India

an hour ago

• Time of India

Life term for rapist after girl, 8, testifies

Representative Image AGRA: A Pocso court in Aligarh sentenced a man, in his late 30s, to life imprisonment for raping and physically assaulting an eight-year-old girl on Nov 16, 2020, near a brick kiln, where he worked and the survivor's family lived. Court found Shailesh Manjhi, of Bihar's Nalanda district, guilty under IPC sections 376 (rape), 323 (voluntarily causing hurt) and Pocso Act. It also imposed a fine of Rs 50,000 on him, reports Mohammad Dilshad. The survivor, who was eight at the time, testified that she was playing when Manjhi lured her with a story about burying toffees. He took her under a neem tree, removed her clothes, and "did bad things", she told the court. When she screamed, he punched her in the face, injuring her eyes, and strangled her before fleeing.