‘New evidence' — stalled R1bn Malusi Booi and Ralph Stanfield tender fraud case still on track

The DA's former Cape Town mayoral committee member Malusi Booi is not necessarily in the clear. This comes after the provisional dropping of charges linked to allegations of unlawfully awarded R1bn in contracts, against him and suspected 28s gang boss Ralph Stanfield.
Former City of Cape Town DA human settlements mayoral committee member Malusi Booi took to social media a few days ago and thanked several people for believing in his 'innocence' after commercial crime charges against him were provisionally withdrawn.
But Booi and his co-accused, including suspected 28s gang boss Ralph Stanfield, have not been acquitted or officially cleared of the charges.
The National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) and the South African Police Service (SAPS) have made it clear that new evidence, which is being investigated, necessitated the provisional withdrawal.
This means that the charges can still be reinstated and that the new evidence may produce more criminal accusations or a bolstered case.
Politics and policing
Investigations into issues linked to Booi and Stanfield have become highly controversial – and political – and have led to accusations about what has been motivating police to act.
The City of Cape Town is DA-run while the SAPS is viewed as an ANC remit, so the overall situation creates the impression that tensions between the two parties are at play.
This weekend, Booi took to social media and effectively said he was the target of a smear campaign, much like Mayoral Committee Member for Safety and Security JP Smith's insistence after a raid on his office earlier this year that has been linked to issues involving Stanfield.
While there have been smear campaign insinuations and while no one in the matter has been found guilty in a court, City of Cape Town officials have acknowledged dodgy dealings relating to its human settlements arena.
Carl Pophaim, who replaced Booi as Cape Town Mayco member for human settlements, previously told journalists that various investigations were focused on 'part of this one singular thing, an attempt to capture human settlements and construction in Cape Town'.
Merged, then provisionally dropped
Booi and nine others were accused of being involved in a tenders-for-cash enterprise, which the State has alleged was headed by Stanfield and his wife, Nicole Johnson.
The tenders flagged in the case were allegedly worth more than R1-billion.
Booi faced allegations that he accepted gratification from Stanfield and, in exchange, used his influence over tenders.
Aside from those commercial crime charges, Stanfield, Johnson and several others also face other criminal accusations.
Stanfield, for example, faces accusations that he was involved in the 2019 assassination of then Hard Livings gang boss Rashied Staggie.
Other charges against Stanfield and Johnson's co-accused in this case relate to the 2023 murder of City of Cape Town staff member Wendy Kloppers, who was shot at a housing development site in Delft.
She was killed, apparently because she had refused to give in to gangsters demanding contractors' work.
The commercial crime case, in which Booi was the main accused, had been merged with the criminal case in which Stanfield and Johnson were the key accused.
But on Friday, 23 May 2025, the tender-related commercial crime charges were provisionally withdrawn against Booi, Stanfield, Johnson and nine others.
While Stanfield, Johnson and several others remain in custody because of the criminal charges they face in the case set to resume in July, Booi, who was previously released on bail, no longer faces formal accusations.
'Purpose was to destroy me'
After the charges were provisionally dropped on Friday, Booi left the Cape Town Magistrates' Court and told journalists he was 'relieved' and was headed home 'to start a new life'.
Booi also took to the social media platform X that day to further express himself.
NEWS JUST IN
[WATCH]
Fraud related charges against former City of Cape Town Human Settlements MMC Malusi Booi and nine others have been withdrawn. They relate to a billion rand housing tender fraud within the city's human settlements directorate @NtuthuzeloNene pic.twitter.com/7YyTGJrvaO
— EWN Reporter (@ewnreporter) May 23, 2025
He posted: 'I would like to take this opportunity to thank my 84-year-old mother, my ancestors, my partner, my entire family, friends, Nitta & crew, Manxasana & crew for their unwavering support & belief in my innocence!
'Thanks to the Nkomo Foundation. I maintain my innocence.'
Days later, on Sunday, 25 May, Booi took to X again, implying that he was the victim of a smear campaign.
'Just for the record! There was never a R1bn tender fraud City of Cape Town never lost a cent,' Booi's post said.
'There is no site or awarded tenders Why AG never picked it up or internal audit The purpose was to destroy me and tarnish my reputation! I pray a living God.'
Just for the record!
There was never a R1bn tender fraud
City of Cape Town never lost a cent
There is no site or awarded tenders
Why AG never picked it up or internal audit
The purpose was to destroy me and tarnish my reputation!
I pray a living God🙏
— Malusi Booi (@MalusiBooi) May 25, 2025
While Booi is 'relieved' at the withdrawal of charges, the NPA and SAPS have reiterated that it does not mean the case has ended or been derailed.
According to them, key information has been uncovered.
Fresh evidence
The Western Cape's NPA spokesperson Eric Ntabazalila explained that the commercial crime charges had been provisionally withdrawn against Booi, Stanfield, Johnson and nine co-accused 'pending the finalisation of an investigation on newfound evidence against them'.
'Police discovered new evidence during their investigation, and it is apposite at this stage to provisionally withdraw the 16 commercial charges against the accused pending the finalisation of the investigation stemming from the newfound evidence.
'The State will reinstate the charges once the investigation has been finalised.'
Police in the Western Cape released a statement on the saga.
Brigadier Novela Potelwa said the case 'is still on course despite the provisional withdrawal of commercial charges'.
Charges can be reinstated
She said it was not uncommon for the direction of a complex investigation to change, based on new information.'It is envisaged that the commercial charges provisionally withdrawn will be reinstated in due course,' Potelwa said.
'The Western Cape SAPS feels compelled to give assurance that the decision [to provisionally withdraw the commercial charges] is by no means an indication of failure on the part of investigators.'
There is no indication of what the new evidence is.
Booi was arrested in September last year, several months after his City of Cape Town office was raided in March 2023. He has also been fired.
Earlier this year, another raid, which according to police was also linked to the whole Stanfield saga, kicked up even more controversy for the City of Cape Town.
SAPS and the City
On 24 January, police raided JP Smith's office and that of mayoral committee member Xanthea Limberg, who heads the city's energy portfolio.
Unlike what happened to Booi, Smith and Limberg were not suspended. Cape Town Mayor Geordin Hill-Lewis said there was insufficient evidence to warrant suspensions.
Smith has insisted that he is the target of a smear campaign and that the raid had been conducted to tarnish his name.
Earlier this month, Smith announced that he was taking legal action against the SAPS.
He said he had lodged an application in the Western Cape High Court because 'immediately after the searches I was advised that the warrants which contain numerous falsehoods, errors and critical omissions are unlawful and should be legally challenged'.
Smith said: 'The media frenzy and reputational harm resulting from the search on my office should never have been permitted.
'The allegations against me are false and there is abundant evidence in the public domain of my continued actions to do the exact opposite of which I am accused by SAPS, including the continuous taking action to remove compromised and corrupt individuals from the city'.
As if underscoring what Smith said about action against staffers, the SAPS announced last week that two City of Cape Town law enforcement officers had been arrested on charges of kidnapping and extortion.
Smith had issued a statement saying the city's Safety and Security Investigations Unit had launched an internal investigation, which led to the arrests.
Beyond smear claims – murder and red flags
In the Stanfield-linked saga, both Booi and Smith's official offices were raided, and both have since separately said they are the targets of smear campaigns.
On Sunday, a part of Booi's post on X said: 'The purpose was to destroy me and tarnish my reputation!'
As for Smith, earlier this month, in the statement on the legal action he launched against the SAPS, he said that he had been told the purpose of the campaign against him was to 'destroy my reputation'.
There are highly concerning aspects of the now provisionally withdrawn commercial crime charges and to the city's human settlement remit.
City manager Lungelo Mbandazayo previously told IOL that an investigation 'saw some of the officials from the human settlements department being suspended and others are attending disciplinary hearings.
'They were even tailor-making tenders before they went out, so those same companies could easily apply and be granted those tenders. They (the gangsters) don't operate in isolation.
'They exist because internally, there are people helping them. When you look at any criminal activity that is thriving, it's because people are conniving.'
Serious dangers are associated with this arena.
One of Booi's co-accused, who previously faced charges alongside him, was Abdul Kader Davids.
On 20 September 2024, two days after being released from custody on R250,000 bail in that case, Davids was fatally shot in the Cape Town suburb of Mitchells Plain. DM

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

The Citizen

26 minutes ago

• The Citizen

SARS disrupts illicit fuel trade with operations across three provinces

SARS disrupts illicit fuel trade with operations across three provinces The South African Revenue Service (SARS) is collaborating with law enforcement agencies to combat the illicit fuel trade, a crime that costs the fiscus billions annually. Over the past four months, the National Joint Operational and Intelligence Structure (Natjoints) has implemented several key interventions to disrupt illegal fuel trade operations. A joint intelligence team made up of SARS and SAPS officials identified 23 targets across Gauteng, Mpumalanga and KwaZulu-Natal. ALSO READ: SARS enhances eFiling for 2025 season In addition, 13 criminal cases were registered with the SAPS, supported by SARS trade investigators, for violations of customs and excise laws and fraud. 'The intelligence-driven joint enforcement operations included search-and-seizure actions at selected fuel storage facilities and depots, along with random sampling of tanker transports to test fuel viscosity and composition,' SARS stated. 'In some instances, diesel analysed during the investigations contained up to 68% paraffin.' Over the past decade, the Maputo Corridor, spanning SA, Eswatini and Mozambique, has become a hotspot for the illicit fuel trade, driven by organised networks that smuggle and illegally adulterate fuel. ALSO READ: Get ready: SARS tax season starts July 7 SARS found that some importers declare fuel quantities of 40 000l or less, while investigations show they actually import up to 60 000l. 'This practice is known as under-declaration and falsified documents are used to conceal this fraudulent activity,' SARS explained. 'SARS has also identified a national trend of fuel-storage and distribution depots adulterating fuel products, particularly by illegally mixing diesel with paraffin.' According to the International Trade Administration Commission, fuel adulteration alone costs the fiscus about R3.6b annually. Faced with this well-planned criminality, government agencies are collaborating closely to detect, prevent and combat fuel adulteration while enforcing the Customs and Excise Act. SARS noted that the illicit economy is a global threat that endangers SA's society, economy and national security. ALSO READ: SARS unveils faster eFiling with enhanced security 'Tax evasion, smuggling, illegal transactions, illicit manufacturing and fraud undermine the rule of law, erode public trust, distort markets, drain government revenue and fuel corruption and organised crime,' SARS said. 'The widespread nature of these illicit activities demands that all enforcement agencies work together to curb their harmful impact. 'The illicit economy is complex and demands a whole-of-government response, involving public entities, the private sector, civil society and international partners.' SARS commissioner Edward Kieswetter thanked the SARS and SAPS teams and other government departments for their efforts to detect and prevent the scourge of the illicit economy. 'The criminal syndicates behind these brazen acts have grown emboldened to act with callous disregard and no restraint in pursuit of their rapacious criminal gains,' the commissioner stated. 'These syndicates underestimate our resolve to eradicate this criminality at their peril. These acts threaten the very foundation of our society. Our message is clear: We will spare no effort to crush them.' Kieswetter affirmed that State agencies would collaborate and operate within the law to confront illicit trade. Among the joint intelligence team's findings: • Some 953 515l of contaminated diesel fuel; • Six fuel depots in contravention of Section 37 of the Customs and Excise Act 91 of 1964, as amended; • Assets and contaminated fuel valued at R367 274 330, leading to further investigation and criminal and civil liabilities; • Two so-called fuel 'washrooms', one a rare mobile 'washroom' fitted on a transport truck, used to remove paraffin markers; • Twelve fuel transport trucks were identified after a suspected false declaration on importation of an average of 15 000l fuel per tanker. At Caxton, we employ humans to generate daily fresh news, not AI intervention. Happy reading!

Daily Maverick

an hour ago

• Daily Maverick

US joining war on Iran creates major political headache for SA

With the world on tenterhooks following the US bombing of Iranian nuclear sites, South African politicians have been notably cautious in articulating their initial positions. By sunset on Sunday, 22 June, as news of the extraordinary US bombing of Iran's nuclear facilities at Israel's behest continued to ricochet globally, barely a single South African politician seemed willing to come out publicly with a position on the matter. Fikile Mbalula. Gayton McKenzie. Herman Mashaba. These are hardly shrinking violets when it comes to making their views known on forums like X — yet on the matter of the Iranian bombing, at the time of writing, there was a deafening silence from them. Neither was there yet an official statement available from either the DA or the ANC, suggesting that SA's two biggest political parties were to some degree agonising over what, exactly, to say. From Parliament's committee on international relations: niks. The Department of International Relations and Cooperation (Dirco) was mute on Sunday too, and a Daily Maverick query to its spokesperson, Clayson Monyela, went unanswered. Ramaphosa issues mild reprimand of US By mid-afternoon, President Cyril Ramaphosa had grasped the nettle — kind of — and released a statement that said relatively little. 'President Cyril Ramaphosa and the South African government have noted with a great deal of anxiety the entry by the United States of America into the Israel-Iran war,' it read, followed by a weak rebuke of the Trump administration. 'It was South Africa's sincerest hope that President Donald Trump would use his influence and that of the US government to prevail on the parties to pursue a dialogue path in resolving their issues of dispute.' The statement concluded, as is on brand for Ramaphosa, with a call for 'peaceful resolution'. Despite the fact that Tehran and Pretoria enjoy warm diplomatic relations, Ramaphosa's statement revealed the diplomatic egg dance that the situation presents to the South African government. South Africa cannot risk alienating the Trump administration further, with the relationship still on life support from the buildup to the Trump-Ramaphosa Oval Office showdown in late May. The Israel factor is a significant complication The difficulty for Pretoria is that the Iranian strike was overtly carried out at the behest of Israeli President Benjamin Netanyahu. Trump's brief televised announcement, confirming that US fighter jets had targeted multiple nuclear research sites in Iran, ended not only with 'God bless the Middle East' and 'God bless America' but also, specifically, 'God bless Israel' — a closing flourish that left little doubt about whose interests were being prioritised. South Africa has positioned itself internationally as one of the staunchest critics of Israel's conduct, culminating in its landmark International Court of Justice case accusing Israel of genocide in Gaza. Pretoria has also publicly cut diplomatic ties with Israel, formally downgrading the embassy. In the face of this new regional escalation, it must now consider how to balance that principled commitment with its allegiance to Iran, a fellow BRICS member — while simultaneously avoiding direct confrontation with a still-dominant United States. With that in mind, the silence of the political class on Sunday was, frankly, understandable. BRICS buddies band together? South Africa and Iran have shared membership of BRICS since an invitation was issued to the latter at the 2023 Johannesburg summit. Other BRICS states were less hesitant in responding to the bombing. The Chinese foreign ministry issued an unambiguous condemnation: 'China strongly condemns the U.S. attacks on Iran and bombing of nuclear facilities under the safeguards of the IAEA [International Atomic Energy Agency]. The actions of the U.S. seriously violate the purposes and principles of the UN Charter and international law, and have exacerbated tensions in the Middle East. China calls on the parties to the conflict, Israel in particular, to reach a ceasefire as soon as possible, ensure the safety of civilians, and start dialogue and negotiation.' Saudi Arabia, whose new BRICS membership sits awkwardly with its often-fraught relationship with Iran, struck a more guarded tone. Its official English-language X account posted: 'The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia is following with great concern the developments in the sisterly Islamic Republic of Iran, represented by the targeting of Iranian nuclear facilities by the United States of America.' The United States, meanwhile, was vocally backed by a handful of close allies. UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer offered a firm endorsement of the bombing, posting on X: 'Iran's nuclear programme is a grave threat to international security. Iran can never be allowed to develop a nuclear weapon and the US has taken action to alleviate that threat.' But from other corners of the West, the reaction was unease rather than celebration. Carl Bildt, co-chair of the European Council on Foreign Relations, called the bombing a 'clear-cut violation of international law'. UN Secretary-General António Guterres said he was 'gravely alarmed' by the use of force by the US. A massively unpopular war Complicating the picture for South Africa is the fact that this conflict is likely to be widely unpopular across the globe — including among Western populations. Comparisons are already being drawn with the disastrous US invasion of Iraq in 2003, and social media suggests a growing generational divide in how such conflicts are understood as the post-World War 2 political consensus crumbles. Young people in particular are questioning why Israel, which has not signed the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty and possesses undeclared nuclear weapons, is held to a radically different standard than Iran, which remains under international inspections by the International Atomic Energy Agency. This is also a moment when support for Israel is at an all-time low. Tens of thousands of protesters flooded European capitals over the weekend, voicing opposition to the ongoing bombardment of Gaza. In June, a YouGov poll showed support for Israel in Western Europe had sunk to its lowest levels ever recorded. In Germany, France and the UK, only between 13% and 21% of respondents now hold favourable views of Israel, compared to 63% to 70% expressing negative sentiments. As South Africa mulls its response, the stakes are particularly high. The government has sought to portray itself as a champion of the Global South, a defender of international law, and a broker of multipolar diplomacy. The entrance of the United States into open hostilities against Iran, with Israel applauding from the wings, tests every aspect of that narrative. DM

Daily Maverick

11 hours ago

• Daily Maverick

Manganese carrier truck driver held for allegedly trying to bribe Eastern Cape traffic officer

The driver of a manganese carrier truck was pulled off on the N10 in the Eastern Cape just outside Cookhouse on Friday, after he allegedly offered a traffic officer a bribe when she pulled him over for driving an unroadworthy vehicle. A young Eastern Cape traffic officer refused an alleged bribe of R1,500 by a manganese truck driver after she pulled the vehicle off the road for being in a dangerous condition. Eastern Cape Department of Transport spokesperson, Unathi Binqose, said the woman who arrested the driver was a young traffic officer recruited only in December last year. He said the truck, which was registered in the Northern Cape, was in a dangerous condition. Binqose confirmed that the truck was a manganese carrier. 'It was deemed a moving hazard with various defects ranging from a loose steering rack, loose wiring in the cabin and tyres that were [in poor] condition,' he said. He said the driver had offered the officer a R1,500 bribe, which she refused. She then proceeded to arrest the driver. Eastern Cape Transport MEC Xolile Nqatha applauded the officer for her 'act of bravery and absolute patriotism', putting public safety over personal gain. He said her actions would save lives. History of crashes 'The N10 road has seen a lot of crashes involving trucks with defects like this one, not only claiming lives, but also resulting in lengthy road closures,' Binqose said. In February 2024, a traffic officer, Sisanda Hadi, was knocked over and killed when she tried to pull over a manganese truck at the Kinkelbos weighbridge on the N2. In September 2023, about 17km before Cookhouse, a manganese carrier crashed into the vehicle of Middelburg businessman Calla Perry, killing him. The number of heavy trucks on the N10 passing Cradock has increased from 5,795 in 2021/22 to an estimated 15,000 trucks in the 2023/2024 financial year, according to information provided by Nqatha to the Eastern Cape Legislature. Manganese is transported by truck from mines in the Northern Cape and exported, mainly through the Port of Port Elizabeth in Gqeberha, where Transnet houses its main export facility for manganese in South Africa. In the past month, there have been at least two serious incidents involving heavy trucks on the N10. Two weeks ago, authorities had to struggle for eight hours to clear the wreckage and reopen the route after the N10 between Cookhouse and Nxuba [Cradock] was closed following a head-on collision involving two trucks. Last year, Nqatha said spot checks along the N10 were part of a road safety strategy. 'Corridor operations are conducted every month in collaboration with Northern Cape, focusing on heavy road freight. Multidisciplinary roadblocks are also conducted each quarter, focusing on heavy trucks. 'Traffic officers are deployed on a daily basis to patrol the N9 and N10, routes the heavy trucks are travelling. Speed measuring is conducted in certain spots on the N9 and N10 routes,' Nqatha said in response to a question in the Eastern Cape Legislature. DM