AG still concerned about use of consultants in KZN municipalities

The Auditor General South Africa (AGSA) has seen an improvement in some KwaZulu-Natal municipalities including their reliance on consultants which decreased from R240 million to R220 million spent annually.
Image: File
The office of the Auditor General South Africa (AGSA) has seen an improvement in some KwaZulu-Natal municipalities, and while consultants are widely used, there has been a reduction in consultancy fees from R240 million to R220 million in the last financial year.
Irregular expenditure also decreased from R6.2 billion to R5.7 billion. Nomalungelo Mkhize, AGSA Business Unit Leader in KZN, presented the local government audit outcomes of the Municipal Financial Management Act (MFMA) to the KZN Legislature-Standing Committee on Public Accounts (SCOPA) and the Portfolio Committee on Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs(Cogta), on Tuesday.
Mkhize said they made a call to action at the end of the financial cycle in 2022 and 2023, requesting leadership to ensure that the key service delivery indicators are being prioritised with adequate funding to fast track infrastructure projects and to ensure that there is adequate budget for repairs and maintenance.
Mkhize said that the AGSA has seen an increase or a gradual improvement compared to 2022 and 2023 in terms of the audit outcomes. Mkhize said that this demonstrates that the municipalities and the officials are able to present a credible set of financial statements indicating how the monies have been spent.
'Although we have seen a decrease in the use of consultants there are a number of municipalities that do use consultants for financial reporting. We still find misstatements in the work that the consultants are doing and at times the consultants are taking on work where they can see that they may not be able to conclude the work with quality.
"We are also finding that consultants are not being monitored to see whether there is delivery according to what was contracted for."
The AGSA said that municipalities are still struggling with action plans not being implemented and that there was a lack of enforcement being taken against officials that are found to have transgressed previously. Mkhize said that this is the root cause for the continued transgressions and the non-performance in some municipalities.
"It then creates the culture that non-compliance can go on without the necessary consequence management. Officials are not being held accountable," she said.
Mkhize said that poor payment practices are resulting in interest charges and penalties. Mkhize said poor management of electricity and water distribution losses are above the acceptable norms in a number of municipalities.
"There is a concern regarding the credibility of share grants received from national and provincial government. If it was any other business they would actually be at a point where they need to be closed. There is also insufficient funds that are available to complete projects," she said.
The AGSA said that in municipalities that ended the year in deficit, where expenditure was more than revenue, many of them already started eating into the next year's budget.
[email protected]

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

The Citizen

3 hours ago

• The Citizen

Poor financial literacy about retirement costing SA and consumers millions

Although most consumers believe they will save enough for a comfortable retirement by the age of 58, research shows it is closer to 80. South Africans' poor financial literacy is costing the country and consumers millions, especially where preparing for retirement is concerned, with nearly half of the respondents in a recent survey saying they need more financial education. According to the 2025 Sanlam Benchmark Survey, the 44th edition of some of the country's most comprehensive research on the retirement fund industry, respondents called for school-level financial education. If you ever said you learnt nothing useful at school, you are probably right: financial education at school level would have made a huge difference in the lives of many consumers and would have lessened the pressure on South Africa's retirement system. ALSO READ: Three financial literacy truths I wish I knew at 20 Financial literacy gap could cost millions Kanyisa Mkhize, chief executive at Sanlam Corporate, says the country's retirement system is under pressure, not only from economic strain but from a widespread lack of access, understanding and early intervention. According to the 2025 Sanlam Benchmark Survey, financial literacy gaps could quietly cost the country millions in lost savings, missed opportunities and poor long-term outcomes. Mkhize says as South Africa's population ages and the pressures of modern work life intensify, the research underscores the urgent need for a holistic approach to employee health and retirement well-being. 'The findings reveal that tackling financial as well as mental stress is critical to ensure long-term health and economic security for South Africans. The 2025 research spanned interviews with over 70 stand-alone funds, 168 participating employers in umbrella funds and over 500 consumers.' ALSO READ: Smart ways to improve your financial literacy Consumers not saving enough for retirement The key findings show that: Only 42% of retirement fund members believe they are on track to save enough for retirement. 43% think they will maintain their current standard of living in retirement. However, six in ten funds say members will not be able to retire comfortably by the age of 64. Fewer than 40% of employer funds allow continued membership after retirement. Nearly half (49%) of members are unaware of the post-retirement options available to them. 92% are aware of the two-pot retirement system, but only 49% feel confident about their knowledge and understanding of the impact of accessing these savings. 44% of those who withdrew from the emergency savings pot used the funds to pay off debt. 64% say regular financial education is very important, yet only 11% had access to a financial adviser through their employer fund when they withdrew from the fund, while nearly 50% rely on Google for financial advice. 68% feel confident about understanding their medical aid benefits, yet only 47% feel the same way about their risk benefits. The number of employer funds offering critical illness benefits increased from 5% in 2019 to 33% in 2025, while umbrella fund participants providing these benefits jumped from 8% in 2019 to 49% in 2025. ALSO READ: Financial literacy at an early age is key for success later Significant cost of what we do not know about financial literacy Mkhize points out that financial stress affects productivity as well as employee health and warns that this has major implications and knock-on consequences for individuals, their families and society and the economy. 'This underscores the need for financial literacy and advice. We see people make life-altering financial decisions without the information, support or advice they need while the right intervention at the right moment can shift outcomes. The opportunity is there – we just need to scale it.' The good news is that amid the less positive survey findings, there are also encouraging signs of progress with engagement increasing, awareness growing and targeted education starting to shift behaviours. 'The challenge now is sustaining this momentum and ensuring it delivers real, measurable improvement,' she says. Mkhize says the cost of what we do not know in financial literacy is significant. Just 42% of pension fund members believe they are saving enough to retire, while only 43% say they are confident they will be able to maintain their standard of living. More than half (51%) worry they will not be able to leave a legacy. She emphasises that the picture is equally troubling system-wide, with six in ten funds saying their members will not retire with enough money by the average retirement age of 64 to maintain their standard of living. ALSO READ: The three phases of retirement and how to maintain your quality of life Financial literacy also needed in retirement Only four in 10 believe that the average retirement age of 64 is still sufficient for financial security, while fewer than 40% of employer funds allow continued membership after retirement, forcing members to navigate a complex financial environment just when they need clarity and support. Only 23% of employer funds offer critical illness benefits and just two in 10 tailor their annuity strategies for different types of members, highlighting a need for more personalised, fit-for-purpose planning, Mkhize says. She points out that the survey data shows that understanding, or the lack of it, drives behaviour, with 49% of members saying they are unaware of their pension options at retirement and one in five saying they have not engaged with their benefits because they 'don't know enough about retirement planning'. 'Yet most consumers also believe they will have saved enough to retire comfortably by the age of 58. Conversely, Sanlam Corporate's internal data shows the age at which most South Africans can afford to retire comfortably is closer to 80. 'This shows the critical need for financial literacy to empower people with the right information to make informed decisions.' ALSO READ: South Africa's real retirement age? 80! People only seek financial literacy for retirement when it is too late The survey shows that most people only seek advice within nine years of retirement and for many there is not enough time to make adjustments that will have a significant effect on their retirement outcomes. 'You cannot act on what you do not understand and right now, the cost of that lack of understanding is carried by individuals, families and the economy,' Nzwa Shoniwa, managing executive at Sanlam Umbrella Solutions, says. The segments of society most at risk from making bad financial decisions due to poor financial literacy are young people and women. Shoniwa says the financial literacy gap does not affect all consumers equally, with some groups falling behind in ways that could affect their long-term health and retirement outcomes. 'Women are particularly vulnerable, with only 38% believing they will maintain their lifestyle in retirement, compared to 62% of men. Women are generally less confident about their understanding of retirement benefits, with only 39% reporting confidence about their benefits compared to 61% of men. 'This gap extends to other areas including risk benefits, financial advice, value-added benefits like rewards, medical aid, gap cover, primary health insurance, employee assistance programmes and even understanding the financial impact of withdrawing from the emergency savings pot.' Shoniwa adds that young adults are also at risk. 'For many starting their careers, typically between ages 24 and 30, joining a medical aid is often a condition of employment. Just 17% of those under 30 are covered by an employer medical scheme, while 18% receive cash as part of their salary to purchase their own product. ALSO READ: 50 and still haven't saved? Here's how to kickstart your retirement plan today Appetite for financial literacy about retirement is strong 'However, the complexity and cost of available products can lead to underinsurance, opting out or delayed long-term planning. This group, especially those between the ages of 31 and 40, is also the most likely to cite rising living costs as a barrier to long-term planning. Compounding these decisions, many only start saving for the long term in their 40s.' That is why it is good news that the survey shows the appetite for better financial guidance is strong, with 64% of members saying regular financial education is very important and nearly half of employer funds supporting retirement planning in schools, while 49% of employer funds believe targeted communication could improve outcomes. Shoniwa says there is momentum, with nearly 60% of members reviewing their benefits in the past year, probably prompted by the introduction of the two-pot retirement system. 'As a result, 66% know the value of their savings and 59% understand how their investments are allocated. 'We see growing engagement but to truly close the gap, we must embed education more consistently, from the classroom to the payslip.' In addition, Shoniwa points out that no single player can fix the system. 'It requires aligned action from government, employers, advisers and administrators. Employers are uniquely placed to support members early. Guidance from the first payslip – particularly around group risk and preservation – can make a lasting difference. ALSO READ: We are living longer – how to plan for a long retirement Better communication needed He says retirement fund administrators must do more than communicate. 'They must deliver seamless advice, access and behaviour-linked incentives. Funds must also outperform and align with members' long-term goals. 'The 2025 Sanlam Benchmark data is more than a call to action – it is a roadmap. South Africans want better outcomes and they are ready to engage. What they need now is consistent education, clearer communication and simpler systems. 'What we do not know is already costing us but what we choose to teach and how we teach it together could change everything. Financial literacy is the foundation for a system that delivers not just outcomes, but dignity,' Mkhize says.

IOL News

5 hours ago

• IOL News

Thirst for Justice: Billions wasted as taps run dry

Residents resort to fetching water, pushing buckets home on trolleys due to the ongoing water shortage in their area. With the committee vowing to recall the DWS for a deeper probe into water boards, South Africa's water catastrophe has reached a breaking point. Image: Oupa Mokoena/Independent Newspapers THE water crisis in South Africa is not looming — it's already here, fueled by systemic failures, corruption, and a dangerous blame game between national and local government. This sinking reality dominated the Standing Committee on Public Accounts (Scopa) hearing, where the Department of Water and Sanitation (DWS) faced an intense interrogation over its financial mismanagement, R25 billion in unpaid municipal debts, and the collapse of basic service delivery. Minister Pemmy Majodina, making her debut Scopa appearance under the seventh administration, delivered a rather sobering admission: 'There is no crisis in bulk water supply — but at household level, the system is collapsing.' The root cause? A staggering 105 of the country's 144 municipalities are chronically underperforming, leaving millions without reliable water despite South Africa's dams operating at 98% capacity. The Minister was quick to deflect accountability, citing the constitutional division of powers. 'Whenever there's no water in a village, the DWS is blamed. But reticulation is a local government function,' she said. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Next Stay Close ✕ Yet the data presented by her department painted a damning picture of the consequences: Municipalities owe water boards R25bn, pushing critical entities such as Amatola, Lepelle, and Vaal Central to the brink of insolvency. Meanwhile, the DWS achieved just 70% of its performance targets despite spending 99.8% of its R21.4bn budget — a disparity Deputy Minister David Mahlobo attributed to 'multi-year infrastructure projects'. Corruption remains a festering wound. Over the past five years, the Department investigated 446 misconduct allegations, with 326 substantiated. Cases have been referred to the Directorate for Priority Crime Investigation (DPCI – alias Hawks) and the SA Police Service (SAPS), but convictions remain elusive. The SIU's ongoing probes reveal even darker rot: R4.7bn squandered on the 'War on Leaks' programme, which deployed untrained youth to fix municipal leaks — a function outside the DWS's mandate. Another R17.9 million was paid to a consulting firm with 'no evidence of work performed', while 'water tanker mafias' sabotage infrastructure to profit from emergency contracts. The hearing turned incendiary when MK Party MP Khethukuthula Madlala confronted the DWS over its inertia. 'If the government waits for formal complaints while people are being shot, we've failed,' he said. Minister Majodina conceded the grim reality: communities are too terrified to report extortion and vandalism, fearing violent retaliation. 'We share the frustration, but our hands are tied,' she admitted, highlighting the limitations of a system that requires sworn affidavits to act against criminal networks. The Auditor-General's findings further eroded confidence. The DWS has received three consecutive unqualified audits with 'material misstatements', while 37 procurement deviations, including a water-saving campaign that ballooned to R4.4bn, double its budget, exposed glaring financial controls. The Water Trading Entity (WTE) is owed R18bn, with debtors now taking 573 days to pay, up from 451 days last year. The collapse of water boards emerged as a national security threat. While Rand Water and Umngeni were praised as 'world-class', entities like Amatola and Magalies are buckling under municipal debt and governance chaos. Vaal Central's potential failure would paralyse the Free State and Northern Cape. Court battles rage as defiant municipalities — some owing billions, 'take the DWS to court after receiving debt letters'. The DA's Peter Atkinson delivered a warning: 'At R12bn a year, it will take 40 years to fix water infrastructure.' The DWS's own estimates confirm R400bn is needed just for the worst-performing municipalities, excluding metros. While the Department touted public-private partnerships as a solution, Deputy Minister Mahlobo acknowledged a brutal truth: 'Investors won't touch bankrupt municipalities.' The EFF's Veronica Mente's closing remarks cut to the heart of the crisis. 'Thirty years into democracy, flushing a toilet is still a luxury,' she said, demanding that the DWS take over municipal water functions. 'This isn't just failure — it's betrayal.' As the hearing adjourned, Scopa Chairperson Sizwe Zibi fired a parting shot: 'It's still your problem to solve. I'm sorry.' With the committee vowing to recall the DWS for a deeper probe into water boards, South Africa's water catastrophe has reached a breaking point — and millions are left waiting for a government that cannot, or will not, act. Get the real story on the go: Follow the Sunday Independent on WhatsApp.

The Citizen

a day ago

• The Citizen

Mkhize's luxury cars to go under the hammer

Mkhize's luxury cars to go under the hammer A TOTAL of 13 luxury cars and a tour bus belonging to Shauwn Mkhize will go on auction next week from June 27 to July 2. Mkhize, who was the owner of Royal AM Football Club, was investigated by SARS. Her La Lucia home was searched in August last year, after SARS was granted a preservation order by the Durban High Court. She allegedly owes the revenue services R37m in taxes. Related story: SARS confirms raid of La Lucia businesswoman's home Among the vehicles set to go under the hammer on Bidder's Choice are a 2020 Bentley Continental GTC, five BMWs, four Mercedes-Benz, two Toyota Hilux, a Nissan Hardbody and a Volkswagen Crafter. One of the Mercedes-Benz is a Maybach S680 limited edition – only 100 were made in the world – retailing at about R5m according to The football club is also back on the market after a deal between Global Investments and SARS fell through after the company failed to meet the three-day payment deadline. The reserve is R50 000 and the vehicles can be viewed in Johannesburg. For more from Northglen News, follow us on Facebook , X or Instagram. You can also check out our videos on our YouTube channel or follow us on TikTok. Click to subscribe to our newsletter – here At Caxton, we employ humans to generate daily fresh news, not AI intervention. Happy reading!