Busting green card myths: US citizen relatives face long waits too

Being related to a US citizen doesn't always mean a quick path to a green card. While some family members qualify for faster processing, others may wait over 15 years — sometimes decades — depending on the relationship and country of origin.
'If you think your sibling can get a green card quickly just because you're a US citizen, that's a myth,' said Abhisha Parikh, a US-based immigration lawyer. 'The fact is, only immediate relatives — spouses, parents, and children under 21 — get priority. Others, like siblings or married children, might be waiting 15 years or more.'
Under current US immigration law, family members of citizens and lawful permanent residents can apply for green cards, but delays depend heavily on their visa category and country of birth.
Two separate queues
There are two key wait periods that determine how long a green card takes:
1. The visa bulletin queue, which determines when you're eligible to apply
Also Read
2. the USCIS processing time, which starts once your application is submitted
Immediate relatives of US citizens skip the visa bulletin queue entirely. For others, both queues apply — sometimes spanning decades.
'For Indian nationals, the green card backlog is among the worst in the world — especially in categories like F4 (siblings of US citizens) and F1/F3 (adult children of US citizens),' Varun Singh, managing director at XIPHIAS Immigration told Business Standard.
The reason is a country cap that limits green cards for each nation to about 7% of the annual family-based total, regardless of demand.
Singh explains:
Siblings of US citizens: 15 to 20+ years
Adult children of US citizens: Over 10 years
Children under 21: 1 to 2 years
Spouses of US citizens: 12 to 18 months
'Spouses fall under the Immediate Relative category, so there's no quota. That's why their green cards are processed faster and with fewer hurdles,' he said.
Family-based green card waiting times (FY2025)
Here's how long family-based green cards take, based on USCIS data:
Immediate relatives of US citizens (no visa bulletin wait)
Spouses in the US: 9.5 months
Spouses abroad: 14.3 months
Parents: 14.3 months
Unmarried children under 21: 14.3 months
Family preference categories (visa bulletin applies)
Spouses/children of green card holders (F2A): October 2024 | 35 months
Unmarried adult children of US citizens (F1): September 2017 | 9.5 months
Unmarried adult children of green card holders (F2B): January 2017 | 35 months
Married children of US citizens (F3): July 2012 | 9.5 months
Siblings of US citizens (F4):
India: October 2006
Most other countries: April 2008
Mexico: April 2001
Philippines: January 2008
USCIS time: 9.5 months
Family preference categories defined
F1: Unmarried adult sons/daughters of US citizens
F2A: Spouses and under-21 children of green card holders
F2B: Unmarried adult sons/daughters of green card holders
F3: Married sons/daughters of US citizens
F4: Siblings of US citizens
What determines the wait
Two key tools matter when tracking your green card timeline:
< The monthly visa bulletin, which tells you when your priority date becomes eligible
< USCIS processing times, which tell you how long the agency takes once your application is submitted
Immediate relatives can skip the bulletin entirely and apply straight away.
Why Indians wait so long
'It's not about favouritism. It's just maths,' Singh said. 'The volume of Indian applicants is huge, but the law restricts how many green cards can go to each country. That's what causes the bottleneck.'
He added, 'The real cost is human. Families separated for decades, siblings growing old in different countries, and children ageing out before their number comes up.'
What applicants can do if delayed
In some cases, applicants can take legal steps if their application is stuck for too long.
'Couples sponsoring spouses should prepare thoroughly to avoid delays. If the wait becomes unreasonable, filing a writ of mandamus is an option to compel USCIS to act,' said Ketan Mukhija, senior partner at Burgeon Law.
What counts as marriage fraud
Entering into a fake marriage for money or favours
Both parties knowingly entering a sham marriage

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

The Hindu

2 hours ago

• The Hindu

Feeding frenzy amid hungry mouths

A distinctive feature of Indian hospitality is the hoary tradition of treating guests with respect and kindness in accordance with the dictum Athithi Devo Bhava. Feeding guests to their satisfaction is considered a privilege and bounden duty of the host. Conservative hosts feel deeply disappointed if their guests declined the food offered. They go to the extent of entreating such guests to have at least some water before they leave. It is not uncommon to see a host insisting on his guest to eat more, even as the guest pleads that he has finished and is full after eating the sumptuous meal. 'Take a little bit more,' the host suggests to the guest, presuming the latter is somewhat shy to ask for more. Talking of shyness in eating, I have often observed in household functions, a person wanting one more laddu would not openly ask for it, but would, with an elfish twinkle in his eyes, direct the server to provide one more laddu to the one sitting next to him with the hope that the server would definitely drop one laddu on his plate also out of courtesy! Shyness, however, does not prevent some of the elders with diet restrictions from asking the serving person to pack the sweets and give them, instead of serving on their plates. During my visits to our ancestral home in the past, my aunt used to serve food as we, family members, sat on the floor in a row, each with a banana leaf before him or her. Due to her deep affection for us, she used to empty the cooked rice she had on her serving plate on everyone's leaf, whether one wanted it or not. Once when she was about to serve excess rice on my leaf despite my protestations, I told her to stop and asked her in mock seriousness whether she understood the meaning of the word 'enough'. It touched her to the quick. From then on, she discontinued her habit of over-serving. To me, importuning a guest to eat more is tantamount to intrusion into privacy. Humongous waste There is no gainsaying the fact that driven by a desire to ensure that every guest eats well and there is no shortage of any food item when entertaining them, more food than what is actually required is prepared at homes that result in food waste. Moreover, in big fat weddings and other grand celebrations, a plethora of dishes is offered in buffet lunch or dinner. In the razzmatazz of such mega events, many guests do not eat every item displayed while there are others who do not finish eating everything taken on their plates; they discard a lot of uneaten food into trash cans. In both the cases, enormous quantities of foods are wasted. Smaller events also contribute to food wastage, albeit on a less scale. It usually occurs due to inaccurate estimation of food needed and the number of guests expected. Thankfully, a thoughtful present-day host, unlike his counterpart of yesteryear, does not consider it inappropriate to ask his guests to indicate the number of people who will attend the marriage, as knowing the exact number of attendees is crucial for bookings and catering. All said and done, wastage of food does take place largely in homes and dining halls. Combined with poor storage and the loss that occurs throughout the supply chain from farm to consumer, food wastage assumes gargantuan proportions at the global level. It is estimated that about one-third of all food produced in the world for human consumption does not make its way to hungry mouths. Food waste and global hunger are therefore mutually connected issues with one exacerbating the other. Wasting food also leads to significant resource depletion and environmental degradation. It is gratifying that several volunteer organisations in our country work to get surplus food from restaurants and wedding halls to the less fortunate sections of our people. Households and housing societies in the cities are also uniting to combat food wastage. By partnering with local food banks, they donate excess food, still in edible condition, to charitable organisations. ramaraon2014@

The Hindu

3 hours ago

• The Hindu

Pickle tales

Pickle is nothing less than a tangy and spicy staple of Indian cuisine. Almost every Indian loves to have it with the main course. Fruits and vegetables are fermented with spices, oil and vinegar to preserve them for a longer duration. Raw mango, jackfruit, garlic, lemon, chilli, tomatoes, the options are endless. Only an Indian can better understand the mouth-watering tanginess of pickle. In the olden days, every home kitchen — mostly women — had a secret recipe for pickles. But with time and modernisation, pickles have emerged as a business option and many brands are selling it with advertisements claiming theirs tastes like grandmother's making. These brands are attempting to deliver the nostalgic taste to urban dwellers who lack the resources to make pickle. Every food item is now available in processed and packed form, and the love for pickle remains strong. But no market-based packed pickles can ever match the taste of the home-made variety of yore. Grandmothers or mothers would preserve pickles in ceramic jars. Among the many memories of summer, one staying brightest is of the pickles. My mother used to prepare pickles on her own. It's an art that needs perfection, patience and right balancing of spicy flavours. Grandmothers and mothers prepare this delicacy every summer with all their fondness to be enjoyed the whole year. The mesmerising taste of pickle, no matter which fruit or vegetable it is of, holds special memories in our life. Every summer story is incomplete without discussing the flavours of taste, and pickle is one such part of it. kirtidimple3007@

Time of India

5 hours ago

• Time of India

Lucknowites get a glimpse of rich cultural history of Delhi

1 2 Lucknow: People came to know about the rich cultural history of Delhi during a talk by Delhi-based historian and activist Sohail Hashmi, hosted by Lucknow Bioscope on Saturday. Hashmi traced Delhi's layered history, beginning with its mythical origins as the Pandavas' Indraprastha. He meticulously explored the rise and shaping of its distinct cities across centuries, focusing particularly on Mehrauli and Shahjahanabad. Central to his narrative was the idea that cities thrive on diversity. "A city needs multi-dimensions to grow, evolve and thrive," Hashmi said, emphasising how continuous influxes of outsiders, bringing varied cultures and languages, have fundamentally moulded Delhi. He painted a vivid picture of this cultural synthesis, with the arrival of Sufi saints, the fascinating journey of Urdu, noting "every single genre of Urdu poetry has developed in Deccan" before maturing in 17th-century Delhi, and the evolution of iconic foods were all threads in Delhi's rich tapestry. Hashmi reminded the audience that modern Delhi, inaugurated as the capital in 1931, is remarkably young, "still less than 100 years old", yet built upon millennia of accumulated history and cultural exchange.