Judge dismisses juror over protests by lawyers for Sean 'Diddy' Combs

A judge dismissed a juror in the sex trafficking trial of Sean 'Diddy' Combs on Monday after concluding that his conflicting answers about where he lives might indicate he had an agenda or wanted to stay on the jury for a purpose.
Judge Arun Subramanian made the ruling after rejecting arguments by Combs' attorneys that it would disrupt the diversity of the jury to replace the Black man with a white juror.
Subramanian had first announced late Friday that he was dismissing the juror after questions arose over whether he resided in New York or New Jersey most of the time, but multiple defense lawyers protested and the judge waited until Monday to announce his final decision.
The judge said a review of the juror's answers to questions about his residency during jury selection, along with his subsequent responses to similar questions in the robing room, revealed 'clear inconsistencies.'
'Taking these all together, the record raised serious concerns as to the juror's candor and whether he shaded answers to get on and stay on the jury,' he said.
Subramanian said to leave the juror on the panel could threaten the integrity of the judicial process.
'The court should not, indeed cannot, let race factor into the decision of what happens. Here, the answer is clear. Juror No. 6 is excused,' Subramanian said before the jury, minus Juror No. 6, was brought into the courtroom for the resumption of testimony.
The judge expressed disappointment that the defense again raised the racial issue in a letter to the judge over the weekend and tried to accuse prosecutors of misconduct.
'There has been no evidence of prosecutorial misconduct brought to the court's attention. Zero,' he said, rejecting a defense request for a mistrial.
Prosecutors have said they expect to rest sometime this week. The trial is in its sixth week.
Combs, 55, has pleaded not guilty to sex trafficking and racketeering conspiracy charges. He has been active throughout the trial with his lawyers and nodded his head Friday as his lawyers argued outside the presence of the jury against dismissing the juror.
Earlier in the trial, he was warned by the judge that he could be excluded from the courtroom if Subramanian believed he was trying to influence jurors after the judge said he saw him twice nodding his head toward jurors as his lawyer carried out an aggressive cross-examination of a witness.
Last week, prosecutors complained he was continuing to nod and shake his head at times with the jury in the room, although he was no longer looking toward jurors as he did it.
Combs was arrested last September at a New York hotel. He was denied bail multiple times and has remained incarcerated at a federal lockup in Brooklyn ever since.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

The Independent

35 minutes ago

• The Independent

Imprisonment for public protection: Justice experts call for end of ‘cruel experiment'

Leading justice experts, led by Lord John Thomas and convened by the Howard League for Penal Reform, have proposed new measures to finally end the "cruel experiment" of imprisonment for Public protection (IPP) sentences. IPP sentences, abolished in 2012 but not retrospectively, have left 2,614 inmates, some jailed for minor offences, indefinitely incarcerated for up to 20 years longer than their original terms. The expert panel's six recommendations include giving release dates to those still in prison, ending the cycle of recall, enhancing the appeal process, and allowing IPP sentences to become "spent" after an appropriate period. The proposals aim to restore hope to prisoners, prevent further self-inflicted deaths (94 IPP prisoners have died in custody), and could free up prison places while saving taxpayers money. While the government has stated it will "carefully consider" the recommendations, it has previously rejected resentencing, despite the IPP sentence being widely condemned as a "monstrous blot" on the justice system.

Daily Mail​

41 minutes ago

• Daily Mail​

Soccer coach admits drugging and raping young boys... after leaving sick evidence in plain sight

A Tennessee youth soccer coach admitted to drugging and raping young boys after disturbing sexually explicit content involving minors was discovered on his cell phone after he left it behind at a restaurant. Camilo Campos-Hurtado, 65, pleaded guilty to four counts of sexual exploitation of a minor and one count of receiving visual depictions of minors engaged in sexually explicit conduct on Tuesday, according to the US Attorney's Office for the Middle District of Tennessee. The egregious content came to light in 2023 when Campos-Hurtado lost his phone. While trying to identify the owner, staff members discovered 'dozens of unconscionable videos and pictures of children,' and immediately called police, McClatchy News reported. Investigators discovered a cell phone and several other electronic devices, belonging to Campos-Hurtado, which had hundreds of images of child sexual abuse material that he received, downloaded and produced between 2017 and 2021. The countless photos and videos showed the Franklin-native sexually assaulting unconscious boys ranging from 9 to 17 years old, according to the Department of Justice. Investigators later learned that Campos-Hurtado would recruit players from school playgrounds to play for his soccer team. 'After gaining their trust, Campos invited many of the kids to his home where he drugged and then raped them,' police stated, adding that some victims may not even be aware of what transpired. While investigators identified at least 10 victims, Campos-Hurtado pleaded guilty to the aforementioned five counts. According to an indictment, Campos-Hurtado's abuse dates back to 2013. In addition to the sexual exploitation charges, search warrants revealed fake IDs and immigration documents, including three counterfeit social security cards, two fake legal permanent resident cards and a fraudulent resident alien card. Campos-Hurtado, who prosecutors say lacks legal status in the US, was also charged with using or possessing fraudulent immigration documents and possessing a stolen or unlawfully produced identification document. 'Campos preyed on children in our community for years, using his position to gain the trust of his victims only to betray them by sexually abusing them,' Robert McGuire, Acting United States Attorney for the Middle District of Tennessee, said. 'Protecting children in our community and holding child sex offenders to maximum accountability is among the highest priorities of our office and of the Department of Justice. At sentencing, we will seek to guarantee that Campos does not have any chance to hurt another child.' Campos-Hurtado pleaded guilty to all seven charges he was indicted on and is scheduled for sentencing on October 29. He faces a mandatory minimum of 15 years in prison, after which he will be deported to Mexico, according to the US Attorney's Office. Campos-Hurtado's hometown of Franklin is about a 20-mile drive south from downtown Nashville.

Daily Mail​

an hour ago

• Daily Mail​

Scott Wolf's estranged wife Kelley claims she's 'trying to locate' their kids following her shocking arrest

Kelley Wolf, the estranged wife of Scott Wolf, has returned to Instagram following her arrest and hospitalization. Kelley made several surprising allegations amid her ongoing divorce from the Party of Five star, 57. 'There's only one thing I want right now: Peace,' Kelley, 48, wrote on Instagram on June 20. 'I'm currently in my car, parked at my home. I am not in a hospital. I was discharged with zero substances in my system, no diagnosis [and] no family history of mental illness.' Kelley claimed she was forcibly detained by local Utah law enforcement officials earlier this month and then taken to a hospital. 'I was handcuffed, bruised, and offered strong medications like lithium and Seroquel —against my will,' she alleged on Friday. 'Let that sink in.' Scott has not commented on his estranged wife's arrest or hospitalization. He was spotted with the children he shares with Kelley – Jackson, 16, Miller, 12; and Lucy, 11, at an airport. 'On the road with my forever squad,' Scott wrote on a photo of his kids on an escalator in an airport on his Instagram Stories on Friday. The post also featured Rusted Root's 'Send Me On My Way' playing in the background. Scott and Kelley were married for 21 years before he filed for divorce last month. has not received a response to its request for comment from Scott Wolf. Kelley wrote that Scott 'filed for divorce this past week, even though I've been trying to file for a legal separation for 9 LONG months, appears to have taken our three children to Boston. 'Without informing me. I'm currently trying to locate them so I can meet them there. I've barely seen my kids,' she heartbreakingly wrote. Kelley continued: 'Getting divorced is hard enough without the public weighing in on my every move. Enough is enough. 'If you're a real friend — or even someone who's known me for a while — You probably have my number. … I'm consistent. I'm a good friend. If you know, you know.' She added, 'Unless I've worked with you for many years or you're already a paid partnership OR a true friend, I would kindly request you stop viewing my IG.' Her post continued, bizarrely blaming Billy Bush, writing, 'And yes—Billy Bush has been going on television claiming he spoke to me while I was in the hospital.' 'That's simply not true. He did not speak to me. Billy, please stop.' And then she went back to blaming Billy Bush, 'And to a certain someone whose name ends in 'Y'… 'It's time to stand down, sir. You're the godfather to my son Miller. We've been friends for over 20 years. Please stop speaking publicly in ways that feel cruel,' she wrote. 'And maybe—just maybe—it's time for you to take care of yourself, too.' On June 13, a friend of Kelley's called 911 to ask them to send a team of mental health professionals to the Sundance Resort where Kelley had been living since she and Scott split. Describing the author and public speaker as 'very skittish' and 'very anti getting help,' the caller noted that she thought 'a team needs to go and insist that she get help.' 'I do not think she will cooperate,' the friend added. 'I mean we've been trying to get her to get some help for weeks to months.' Later Kelley shared a photo to her Instagram Stories over which she had written: 'I have been taken against my will. Please check on my kids. Also… I am happy!! Happier than I have ever been.'