Harry Brook's strokeplay is pure box office... but the hook shot could be his downfall, writes NASSER HUSSAIN
Harry Brook's innings on his home ground of Headingley on Sunday was absolutely box office - a spectacular exhibition of stroke play.
Brook is such a positive player, with all the shots, and one of his most profitable over recent years has been to run at seam bowlers.
It took people by surprise when he did this to India 's premier bowler Jasprit Bumrah at the start of the morning session and banged the ball away for four. Doing so, not in a chaotic, frenetic way, but in a controlled manner.
You have to show intent against whoever you face. You need to put good bowlers under pressure.
The issue for Brook, though, and Australia will be watching with their bigger grounds in mind, is the short ball.
Teams might try one set of tactics against him first up, but if he gets in what will he do if they bounce him? Is he taking it on? Or not?
How would he have been out on the second evening, if Bumrah hadn't reprieved him by overstepping? Hooking. He's got to work out going forward what he is going to do when challenged to play that shot, because there will be more coming.
That will be his challenge and if I was a coach, I would be asking: is the shot getting you runs? Is it one of your shots? Is it getting you out?
The charge down the pitch isn't resulting in dismissals for him. Ask the same question to the hook shot, though, and it is not as clear cut. Is it getting him runs? Yes. Is it getting him out? Yes.
So, there is a risk-reward dilemma. As a batsman, are you going to put the shot away? Continue playing it? What are you going to do?
Brook will know it's going to come now in this series, and that it will come in Australia. Previously, he's tried to take that short ball on and hit it for six, but because he was on 99, I think he tried to almost keep it down. He may have been walking off wishing he'd tried to hit it all the way.
As a batsman you must have a plan. On the bigger grounds in Australia later this year, it will be high risk, and risk factor is something you are always weighing up.
As my old Essex captain Keith Fletcher once said to me, if you don't play any shots, you don't get any runs. Virtually every cricket shot has some kind of risk element. You can't put them all away.
And the beauty of a five-match Test series is that patterns develop. Get out in a certain fashion and your opponents will try to repeat it.
In response, you've got to try to put it to bed somehow and the only way to do that is to work hard, think about your own game, and find the balance that's right for you.
Take Jamie Smith here. If he hits the ball out of the ground, everyone goes 'wow.' But when there are four men out there, you find one. So, as we go through the series, we're going to see that ploy to him quite a bit, I would imagine.
There were three soft dismissals in England's innings: Joe Root, Ollie Pope and Ben Stokes all edging outside off stump.
That is why Stokes chucked his bat up in the air: he was cross with himself.
Stokes had actually been lining up very well. I liked his triggers, and it looked like he'd gone back to his old 2019 movements: composed, right in behind the ball, and then from nowhere, he just feathered one behind.
He now knows that Mohammad Siraj and Bumrah will be coming around the wicket to him, trying to get the ball going away, with a full slip cordon over these next few matches.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
33 minutes ago
- BBC News
Lee claims third major with PGA Championship victory
Women's PGA Championship final round leaderboard-4 M Lee (Aus); -1 A Kim (US) C Wannasaen (Tha); +1 C Iwai (Jpn) +1 J Thitikul (Tha)Selected others: +5 C Hull (Eng); +6 N Korda (US), L Maguire (Ire)Full leaderboard Australia's Minjee Lee claimed the third major title of her career with a three-shot victory at the Women's PGA 29-year-old shot a two-over-par 74 on her final round in Texas to hold off the chasing windy conditions, Lee was one of only three players to finish below par for the weekend after finishing in front of Auston Kim and Chanettee Wannasaen. The average for the field at the Fields Ranch East was just over 75 - the highest for any LPGA Tour major in a decade. Lee initially struggled with the conditions, hitting three bogeys in her opening six Kim and Wannasaen finished up an hour before Lee with two-under-par rounds of the Australian steadied on the back nine, hitting back-to-back birdies on the 14th and 15th. Lee adds the PGA Championship win to major victories at the 2021 Evian Championship and 2022 Women's US Open.
BBC News
38 minutes ago
- BBC News
Lions will keep 'chests up and crack on'
Tom Curry says the British and Irish Lions must be prepared to have "tough conversations" in the wake of Friday's defeat by Argentina in Dublin. The Lions' hopes for a buoyant send-off before their Australian tour were spoiled by an enterprising Pumas outfit, who deservedly won 28-24 at Aviva Stadium. With the Lions now looking ahead to their tour opener against Western Force on Saturday in Perth (11:00 BST), Curry has called on the squad to "step up" and use Friday's loss as motivation to improve. "I have been in these situations before and we have got to pull tighter, it is the only way," said the 27-year-old England back row."I feel like this group has taken so many steps off the field. I have not got a bad word to say about anyone. "Everyone has been pulling in the right direction, especially the lads who came in this week, so when something goes against us we have got to keep our chests up and crack on with each other. "We have to have the tough conversations. I am not going to say it is going to be a party, we don't need that. But we have got to pull tight and hit the ground running when it comes to training." The Lions scored tries through Bundee Aki and Tadhg Beirne, either side of a penalty try, but Andy Farrell's side lacked a cutting edge when they entered Argentine Curry, who started all three Tests against South Africa in 2021, said the players must take responsibility for their "own performances and how excited" they became on the ball."That is the really annoying thing because on the flip side it's really exciting because we do have our hands on the ball and are in great spots," said the Sale flanker. "But come on, we need to take personal responsibility when we have it."Despite Friday's defeat, Curry described this year's Lions experience so far as "sick" after the Covid-hit series against the Springboks four years ago. "It's nice being in Dublin and people aren't booing you," he said. "I think that's a cool thing. We speak a lot about respect with our own team-mates."We've only got six weeks together. Respect is so hard to earn but so easy to lose and I think it's really important, like I said, that every session and meeting we turn up and push in the right direction."
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
Horse racing tips: Three value picks to bash the bookies including a 14-1 chance miles below last winning mark
Scroll down for the selections FIVER FLUTTER Horse racing tips: Three value picks to bash the bookies including a 14-1 chance miles below last winning mark SUN Racing's Monday picks are below. Back a horse by clicking their odds. Advertisement LONGSHOT FOUR ADAAY (5.17 Windsor) He has dropped to 10lb below his last winning mark and he has plenty of decent form on quirky tracks like this. He wasn't beaten far here in May and is lower in the handicap since then. EACH-WAY THIEF Advertisement DAPPER GEE GEE (2.00 Wolverhampton) He was a game winner at Chepstow last time and goes on the sand too. QUEUE DOS (3.00 Wolverhampton) He went close at Windsor latest and is capable on the all-weather too. Advertisement Commercial content notice: Taking one of the offers featured in this article may result in a payment to The Sun. You should be aware brands pay fees to appear in the highest placements on the page. 18+. T&Cs apply. Remember to gamble responsibly A responsible gambler is someone who: Establishes time and monetary limits before playing Only gambles with money they can afford to lose Never chases their losses Doesn't gamble if they're upset, angry or depressed Gamcare – Gamble Aware – Find our detailed guide on responsible gambling practices here.
