How alarmed should we be about Europe's tightening citizenship rules?
In recent months, several countries in Europe have announced plans, or said they are at least considering, new rules on obtaining citizenship.
In Sweden, an inquiry recently proposed
extending the residency requirement
to eight years from the current five, and since April 1st, the Migration Agency has toughened
security checks
on applicants, which led to a
temporary freeze on the processing of applications
. Sweden has also talked of
introducing language and civics tests
for citizenship applicants.
Last year, Finland extended the required residency period for naturalisation from five to eight years and shortened the time limits for allowed absence.
In Germany, the new government has passed a bill to scrap the
fast-track path
to citizenship, which requires only three years of residence for people considered "highly integrated". The bill, which still needs the approval of the Bundestag, reverses part of the citizenship reform adopted in 2024.
In Italy, a
referendum
aiming to reduce the residency requirement to get citizenship didn't receive enough participation to be valid. Separately, the parliament recently adopted new rules that limit to two generations the possibility to obtain citizenship
by ancestry
.
In Denmark authorities hiked the
citizenship fee
by 50 percent on May 1st. Months earlier the country's Immigration Ministry also appointed an expert panel to look into the possibility of
screening
applicants for views considered 'antidemocratic'.
Elsewhere in the Nordics, Norway
will hold a general election in September, and both the Conservative Party and Progress Party, which could form a right-wing coalition, said they want to tighten citizenship requirements.
Advertisement
In France, where the anti-immigration far-right has been growing in popularity in recent years, the country's Interior M
inister
Bruno Retailleau t
alked of his plans to 'toughen up' the citizenship regime
, including the possible addition of a history and civic test.
Nationality reforms were also at the centre of the political agenda in the Netherlands, where the far-right government, which has recently collapsed, wanted to increase the residence requirement from five to ten years. A similar plan to lengthen the residency qualification period has been taken by the Labour government in the UK, as part of proposals to further tighten immigration rules.
Why so many changes?
Professor Maarten Vink, Chair of Citizenship Studies at the Robert Schuman Centre, European University Institute in Florence, suggested citizens around Europe shouldn't be too alarmed at all the tightening and changing of the rules.
'It is quite common that countries change citizenship rules every couple of years," Vink said.
'We are in a democracy, so if in elections the political balance shifts, it is normal that this is reflected in legislation. When migration is a very important topic in politics, issues that are related to migration, such as citizenship, are also part of this dynamic,' he said.
Professor Vink said that citizenship laws in Europe have recently been 'more dynamic than in other parts of the world', although 'changes go in different directions.'
Advertisement
Dual citizenship
The most significant trend that has emerged, and is 'unidirectional', he argued, is the acceptance of dual citizenship.
'Back in the 1960s, most countries around the world restricted dual citizenship because this was seen as a problem of loyalty and allegiance, especially at times of more warfare and military conscription," said Vink.
Although exceptions remain in Austria, the Netherlands, the Baltic countries and several Eastern European states, this is an area that has seen 'a very clear liberalisation trend globally and in Europe'.
Vink said this was partly driven by migration as more people moved and built a life in another country and maintained family ties to the country where they came from, or where their parents and grandparents came from.
Another factor was gender equality.
Advertisement
'In the past, a woman marrying a man from another country would automatically become a citizen of that country, or lose hers, and the children would be only citizen of the father's country. Recognising a woman and a man as both independent in citizenship law, as it happened in all European countries, allowed for the creation of mixed citizenship families,' he explained.
Vink points out that even the new German government, which has proposed a step back on the "modernisation'" of citizenship laws by
removing a fast-track procedure
, has agreed to maintain the main elements of the landmark 2024 reform – the acceptance of dual citizenship and the reduction of the residency requirement from eight to five years.
Developments in family law also affect citizenship, for example with the right to transmit citizenship from the non-biological parent to a child in a same-sex family.
'Scandinavian countries have been very proactive in incorporating these family law elements in citizenship law, while in countries like Italy there are still restrictions,' Vink said.
Crucially most governments in Europe can't just do anything they want when it comes to citizenship laws
In most European countries the area is also regulated via
the European Convention on Nationality
, signed in 1997 under the Council of Europe (not an EU institution). Some 29 European countries signed the Convention, but 8 (Croatia, France, Greece, Italy, Latvia, Malta, Poland and Russia) have not ratified it.
For example under the rules set by the convention, the residence requirement for citizenship cannot exceed 10 years, an upper limit that is met by all European countries, with the most common requirement set at 5 years.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
LeMonde
a day ago
- LeMonde
French police launch nationwide crackdown on undocumented migrants
"Do not come to France. We will tolerate nothing. It's zero tolerance." French Interior Minister Bruno Retailleau delivered these tough words before the microphones of TV and radio media gathered in Paris's Gare du Nord train station on Thursday, June 19, to relay the message of a major nationwide identity check. Spanning June 18 and 19 and redundantly dubbed a "fight against irregular and illegal immigration," the operation reportedly mobilized no fewer than 4,000 police officers, gendarmes, customs officers and soldiers deployed as part of antiterrorist military operation Sentinelle, all with the aim of detaining undocumented migrants aboard trains and in and around train stations. The deployment was not far from the 5,400 personnel mobilized to contain potential disorder during the Champions League soccer final in Paris on May 31. Results of the operation were not available as of Thursday evening. In a document sent to state prefectures on June 12 seen by Le Monde, the interior ministry said some 900 buses had been inspected and 759 undocumented foreigners were detained during a smaller-scale identity check on low-cost international bus lines around the country on May 20 and 21. In the document, Retailleau said these were "significant results." Asked about what happened after the arrests, the ministry said officials had issued 245 deportation orders, 34 placements in detention centers and 72 readmissions.
Local France
2 days ago
- Local France
France mulls intercepting UK-bound migrant boats at sea
France has long been a launchpad for migrants hoping to cross the Channel and start a better life in Britain. Paying smugglers thousands of dollars, they often board overloaded rubber dinghies to make the dangerous and sometimes deadly journey across one of the world's busiest shipping routes. France and Britain have long vowed to crack down on people smugglers who organise the journey. But until now, French authorities have only intervened on land to prevent boats leaving. But once the vessels are at sea, French authorities have, under international maritime law, so far only intervened if someone's life was in danger. To avoid French authorities stopping them on land, smugglers have in recent years chosen to 'taxi' migrants out to boats waiting in choppy waters just off-shore, rather than depart from the beach. But as more small boats land on English shores, and the UK government comes under mounting pressure from the far right to tackle irregular migration, London has pressed Paris to do more. The French interior ministry on Wednesday told AFP it wanted its rules to 'evolve' so its law enforcement officers could 'intervene in shallow waters and stop 'taxi boats' up to 300 metres from the coast'. It said an inter-ministerial committee had tasked French sea authorities with drawing up an action plan 'by the summer'. The hope, the ministry added, was to have 'shared orientations' in time for a French-British summit that President Emmanuel Macron is expected to attend in England from July 8th to 10th. Advertisement In February, London and Paris agreed to extend a deal under which the United Kingdom funds some of France's border security measures to stop migrants trying to reach British shores. Hardline Interior Minister Bruno Retailleau has already called for a new approach that would allow French forces to intercept boats in the water. Crossings have since only increased. Some 1,194 migrants arrived in the UK after crossing the Channel in small boats on June 1st, a record for this year according to AFP, counting from government data. 'We know more needs to be done with the French to build upon the 10,000 crossing attempts that we have stopped this year, and are strengthening our cooperation to do this,' a UK Home Office official said on Wednesday. Migrants, some travelling with children, have been making the most of the fair weather in recent days to make the sea crossing. On Monday morning, AFP saw dozens of migrants, some from Eritrea, sprint across a northern French beach at sunrise and French police fire teargas in their direction. Wading into the sea up to their waists or higher, some appearing to carry toddlers, they however managed to board a rubber boat. AFP has in the past also seen policemen – who are deployed en masse along northern French beaches – use knives to slash inflatable dinghies on land to prevent departures. Advertisement This is in part why smugglers now prefer the 'taxi boat' system with pickups directly at sea, leading to perilous and often deadly passenger pickups. At least 17 people have died trying to cross the Channel to Britain by boat this year, after a record 78 lost their lives attempting crossing last year. It is not clear how many of them died during departure but an official French report in February noted that the stages of 'boarding and/or return to the beach' were particularly perilous, with an increased risk of drowning or hypothermia. Migrant support organisation Utopia 56 said French authorities intervening at sea would only increase the 'risk of the boat capsizing', and be 'brutal and dangerous'. Thibaut Fleury Graff, an international law professor at Pantheon-Assas University, said any intervention in shallow waters needs legal justification. Under international law, people have 'the right to leave any country' he said. In territorial waters, a state can detain a ship only 'if there is a legal basis' to do so, such as 'the commission of a criminal offence', he said. The alleged offence of 'human trafficking could potentially apply, but it would need to be directed not at the migrants but at the smugglers,' he added.
Local France
3 days ago
- Local France
French interior minister deploys extra 4,000 officers at the border
Interior minister Bruno Retailleau has sent a memo ordering extra police, gendarmes and troops to undertake immigration checks in a two-day operation on Wednesday and Thursday. The operation is targeted at train and bus stations, with officers instructed to check "trains bound for neighbouring countries and major French cities, both arriving and departing". Advertisement It does not affect international arrivals from outside the Schengen zone - such as Eurostar arrivals at Gare de Nord - because these entry points are already policed with border guards. Retailleau, a right-winger with presidential ambitions who has made the fight against immigration his favourite theme, told AFP: "Over the next 48 hours, we'll be mobilising 4,000 gendarmes, police officers, customs officers and troops from Operation Sentinelle to stop illegal immigrants. "Since the beginning of the year, we have stopped 47,000 illegal immigrants. "What I want to say, in the strongest and most definitive way, is that illegal immigrants are not welcome in France." In early May, Retailleau presented another memo, which he described as a "break with the past", aimed at tightening the criteria for naturalising foreigners, in terms of respect for the law, mastery of the French language and integration into the job market. READ ALSO : Explained: France's planned 'tougher' citizenship conditions (including history test)✎
