Entire petroleum resources of the country are vested in Petronas which is given exclusive right to explore and exploit the resources — Hafiz Hassan

MAY 3 — Unbeknown to many, the rights of ownership of the Federal Government and the various States in the Federation of Malaysia to the petroleum resources in onshore land and offshore land have been examined at length by V. K. Moorthy more than 40 years ago in 1982.
The learned writer was a distinguished member of the Kuala Lumpur Bar. He read law at Lincoln's Inn and was called to the English Bar in 1965. He returned to Malaysia and was admitted as an Advocate and Solicitor of the High Court of Malaya in 1966.
He worked first for UMBC Bank and subsequently for Esso Malaysia Bhd from October 1966 as their first Legal Advisor. In January 1978, he moved to Melbourne, Australia where he taught law at Monash University before returning to Malaysia in 1982, setting up his own law firm VK Moorthy & Co.
His article 'Changes in the Federal-State Ownership and Exploitation of Petroleum Resources in Malaysia' (1982) Malaya Law Review 186, written with much aplomb, is now a must read.
The article traced the gradual changes in the ownership of the petroleum resources in favour of the Federal Government, culminating in total or absolute Federal ownership in 1974 with the enactment of the Petroleum Development Act 1974 (PDA).
Two major pieces of federal legislation relevant to the petroleum industry enacted in 1966 – that is, the Petroleum Mining Act 1966 (PMA) and the Continental Shelf Act 1966 (CSA) were also examined, albeit briefly.
V.K. Moorthy wrote:
'The entire legal framework for the petroleum production was completely altered by the [PDA]. Firstly, with the assignment of the entire petroleum resources to Petronas, the Federal Government achieved its ultimate goal of removing the petroleum industry from the control of the States.
Petronas is the only unit of Government that has any involvement in the petroleum industry after the enactment of the Petroleum Development Act, which was moved in Parliament by the then Kota Samarahan MP who later became the fourth Sarawak chief minister, the late Tun Abdul Taib Mahmud who served from 1981 to 2014. — File picture by Hari Anggara
'Secondly, Petronas was vested with the exclusive rights to explore for and exploit petroleum deposits in the country. The only unit of Government that has any involvement in the petroleum industry after the enactment of the [PDA], is the Federal Government through Petronas.
'The role of Petronas is not one of a regulatory nature but of direct participation in the exploration and extraction of petroleum. By this means, the Federal Government has taken absolute charge of the petroleum exploration and exploitation operations which were previously under the control of the Oil Companies.
'The Minister for Primary Industries [who moved the Petroleum Development Bill 1974 in Parliament] has made it clear that the Government expects that [Petronas] shall have and be responsible for the management of petroleum operation....
'The Government has also spelt out the terms upon which Petronas shall engage the Oil Companies for the exploration and mining operations.'
Guess who the Minister was?
He was then MP for Kota Samarahan, who went on to become the fourth Chief Minister of Sarawak (as it was then known).
The learned writer then summarised the effect of PDA as follows:
(1) A National Oil Corporation known as Petronas was established.
(2) The Federation vested its right of ownership to petroleum resources under its control and jurisdiction in Petronas.
(3) Petronas compulsorily acquired the rights to the ownership of petroleum resources of the various States and caused such rights to be vested in it.
(4) All proprietary interests acquired by the oil companies under the production agreements or exploration licences and other forms of title were compulsorily acquired by the Federal Government and vested in Petronas.
(5) The Federation and the States ceased to have the usual regulatory role in the petroleum industry. The PMA became a dead letter.
(6) The Federation, through Petronas, entered the commercial arena of petroleum exploration, production and marketing and plans shortly to manufacture and distribute petroleum and petro-chemical products.
(7) All proprietary concepts, such as leasehold interests, licences and profit a prendre are no longer applicable to the Malaysian petroleum industry because the entire petroleum resources of the country are vested in Petronas which is given the exclusive right to explore and exploit these resources.
(8) The Federal Government approved the use of oil companies as contractors to assist Petronas in the exploration and exploitation of petroleum and adopted the Indonesian Production Sharing Contract system. The oil companies accepted this arrangement in lieu of monetary compensation.
So, why the reported legal notice by Sarawak's utility and telecommunications ministry alleging that Petronas subsidiary, Petronas Carigali Sdn Bhd has violated Section 7(e) of the state's Distribution of Gas Ordinance 2016 (DGO)?
* This is the personal opinion of the writer or publication and does not necessarily represent the views of Malay Mail.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Barnama

3 hours ago

• Barnama

Melaka Thanks Federal Government For RM660 Mln WTE Project

MELAKA, June 22 (Bernama) -- The Melaka government has expressed its appreciation to the Federal Government for approving the RM660 million Waste-To-Energy (WTE) plant project in Sungai Udang, expected to be completed by 2029. State Housing, Local Government, Drainage, Climate Change and Disaster Management Committee chairman Datuk Rais Yasin said a groundbreaking ceremony will be held soon and officiated by Chief Minister Datuk Seri Ab Rauf Yusoh. "This project enhances the efficiency of solid waste management and supports the state's green agenda," he said during the Elected Representative for the People (WRUR) programme for the Bemban state constituency.

Daily Express

10 hours ago

• Daily Express

Options on honouring 40pc entitlement

Published on: Sunday, June 22, 2025 Published on: Sun, Jun 22, 2025 By: Datuk Roger Chin Text Size: SABAH's 40% entitlement under the Malaysia Agreement 1963 (MA63) has long been a point of contention, with the Federal Government often citing financial constraints as the reason for not fulfilling this obligation. However, the argument of 'inability to pay' is not an absolute financial limitation but rather a matter of budgetary prioritisation. The Federal Government has consistently funded large-scale infrastructure projects in Peninsular Malaysia—such as public transportation systems, skyscrapers, and highways—while similar investments in Sabah have been minimal. This demonstrates that fulfilling Sabah's 40% entitlement is more about political will and resource allocation than an actual lack of financial capacity. It is essential to emphasise that the 40% entitlement is distinct from the Federal Government's other obligations to Sabah under the Federal Constitution, such as development funds. These are separate commitments, and the entitlement under MA63 should not be mixed with broader Federal allocations. A range of innovative mechanisms can be employed to fulfil this legal obligation while ensuring equitable development across Malaysia. Advertisement 1. Phased Instalment Payments A structured instalment plan would allow the Federal Government to meet its obligation to Sabah while mitigating any immediate financial burden. This approach could mirror how large-scale infrastructure projects in Peninsular Malaysia are prioritised. Key features: Gradual Payment Structure - Payments could be spread over 10 to 20 years, starting with smaller instalments and gradually increasing over time, allowing the Federal Government to manage its fiscal obligations more effectively. Interest on Delays - Should payments be delayed, interest could accrue, ensuring Sabah is not unfairly penalised by any Federal fiscal management issues. 2. Interest-Free Development Loans or Grants In lieu of direct payments, the Federal Government could offer Sabah interest-free loans or grants earmarked for critical development projects, such as infrastructure, healthcare, and education. Considerations: Targeted Development Funding - These funds could be directed towards sectors where Sabah is underdeveloped, providing an immediate boost to the state's growth. Offset Against Entitlement - The value of these loans or grants could be deducted from the total entitlement, allowing for progress towards fulfilling the obligation while directly benefiting Sabah's development. 3. Transfer of Oil and Gas Fields Transferring ownership and control of oil and gas fields within Sabah's territorial waters would provide the state with a direct revenue stream from its natural resources, fostering long-term economic autonomy. Key aspects: Full Ownership - By gaining full control of its oil and gas fields, Sabah could generate significant revenue from resource extraction, with the profits offsetting the Federal Government's 40% obligation. New Resource Exploration - The right to explore and develop new fields could ensure sustainable future revenue for the state, reducing dependence on Federal transfers. 4. Transfer of Federal-Owned Land A feasible option to reduce the Federal Government's financial burden would be the transfer of Federal-owned land in Sabah, particularly those with high economic potential, to the state government. Advantages: Strategic Land Transfers - Economically valuable land could be surrendered to Sabah, enabling the state to generate revenue through development or other uses. Offsetting the Amount Owed - The value of the transferred land would be credited against the 40% entitlement, providing an immediate means of fulfilling part of the obligation without direct cash payments. 5. Revenue-Sharing from Federal Investments Revenue-sharing arrangements for Federal projects in Sabah would ensure that the state benefits from economic activities generated within its borders, particularly in key sectors such as tourism and agriculture. Key considerations: Profit-Sharing Models - Federal enterprises operating in Sabah, such as airports, and tourism developments, could share a portion of their profits with the state. Sector-Specific Revenue - Industries crucial to Sabah's economy could be prioritised for revenue-sharing, ensuring that local resources and projects directly benefit the state. 6. Enhanced Tax Autonomy Granting Sabah greater autonomy in tax collection, particularly in sectors such as tourism and natural resources, would reduce its dependence on Federal transfers and ensure that the state benefits more directly from its own economic activities. Considerations: Exclusive Taxing Authority - Sabah could be given exclusive rights to tax specific industries, ensuring that revenue generated within the state remains in the state. Increased Royalties - The Federal Government could increase Sabah's share of oil and gas royalties from the current 5% to a more equitable level, providing an additional revenue stream. 7. Issuance of Federal Bonds or Sukuk The Federal Government could issue bonds or sukuk (Islamic bonds) specifically designed to fulfil Sabah's entitlement. This would provide immediate funds for development while allowing the Federal Government to spread the repayment over time. Mechanics: Entitlement-Backed Bonds - Bonds linked to Sabah's 40% entitlement would provide upfront financing, allowing for immediate development projects, while the Federal Government repays bondholders over a set period. Sukuk Option - Bonds backed by Federal assets in Sabah could comply with Islamic finance principles, offering an ethical and sustainable method of financing the entitlement. 8. Equity Participation in Government-Linked Companies Sabah could be granted equity stakes in Federal Government-linked companies (GLCs) such as Petronas or Tenaga Nasional Berhad (TNB). These stakes would provide the state with a recurring revenue stream through dividends. Key features: Equity Stakes - Shares in key GLCs would enable Sabah to receive regular dividend payments, which could then be deducted from the overall entitlement. Dividend-Based Fulfilment - Regular dividend payments would serve as an alternative to direct cash transfers, offering a sustainable source of income. 9. Performance-Based Entitlement Adjustments A portion of the entitlement could be linked to Sabah's economic performance, incentivising both the Federal and Sabah state governments to focus on growth-oriented policies. Benefits: Development Incentives - Tying part of the entitlement to key performance indicators, such as GDP growth or infrastructure improvements, would promote long-term development in Sabah. Joint Investment Projects - Federal and State Governments could collaborate on large-scale projects, with profits reinvested into fulfilling Sabah's entitlement. 10. Dedicated Federal Development Funds A one-off, dedicated allocation of Federal development funds to Sabah would provide long-term stability for critical infrastructure projects, separate from the annual budget allocations, and ensure continuity in development initiatives. Key elements: Fully Allocated Funds - Unlike regular budgetary allocations, these development funds would be transferred entirely to Sabah, providing the state with full control over long-term infrastructure projects. Priority Sectors - The funds could be earmarked for essential sectors such as transport, rural electrification, and industrial growth, ensuring that Sabah's development progresses at a comparable rate to Peninsular Malaysia. Concluding Remarks The Federal Government's claim of financial incapacity to meet Sabah's 40% entitlement is more about prioritisation than genuine fiscal limitations. By adopting innovative mechanisms—such as phased instalments, land transfers, or equity stakes—the Government can fulfil its legal obligation while simultaneously supporting Sabah's development. Crucially, these solutions must remain distinct from the Federal Government's other obligations, ensuring that Sabah receives both its rightful entitlement under MA63 and its fair share of Federal development resources. This balanced approach would foster not only fairness for Sabah but also sustainable growth for Malaysia as a whole. The views expressed here are the views of the writer and do not necessarily reflect those of the Daily Express. If you have something to share, write to us at: [email protected]

Daily Express

11 hours ago

• Daily Express

Inclusive and comprehensive development policies: CM

Published on: Sunday, June 22, 2025 Published on: Sun, Jun 22, 2025 Text Size: Hajiji during his speech at the Istiadat Pengurniaan Darjah-Darjah Kebesaran in conjunction with the official 74th birthday celebration of the Head of State, Tun Musa Aman, at Istana Seri Kinabalu, Saturday. THE State Government will continue to strengthen the implementation of inclusive and comprehensive development policies through the Sabah Maju Jaya (SMJ) roadmap in its efforts to ensure sustained progress and the well-being of the people in the state. Chief Minister Datuk Seri Hajiji Noor said that since its introduction, the policy has had a significant impact, particularly in areas such as economic recovery, investment, agriculture, human capital development, and public welfare. 'Alhamdulillah, we are witnessing growing investment activities and increased state revenue collection in recent years. This is proof of the effectiveness of the government's approach,' he said, in his speech during the Istiadat Pengurniaan Darjah-Darjah Kebesaran in conjunction with the official 74th birthday celebration of the Head of State, Tun Musa Aman, at Istana Seri Kinabalu, Saturday. He added that the State Government is also focusing on the development of the agricultural sector, which is a key contributor to ensuring food security in Sabah. Among the initiatives were establishment of the Sabah Rice and Padi Board (LPBS) and the launch of the Paddy Crop Takaful Scheme (STTP) aimed at increasing the state's rice Self-Sufficiency Level (SSL) from 24 per cent in 2025 to sixty per cent by 2030. 'This is a strategic step to ensure Sabah becomes more self-reliant in basic food production, thereby reducing dependence on imports,' he said. Advertisement He added that human capital development, especially among the younger generation, remains a top priority for the government through various youth development programmes such as skills training, education, entrepreneurship, leadership and sports. Hajiji said the State Government has also approved the establishment of the Sabah State TVET Council as a platform to coordinate and monitor technical and vocational education and training to meet current industry needs. 'We want to ensure Sabah's youths are equipped with the knowledge and skills relevant to contribute to the development of the state and the nation.' Hajiji also emphasised that the strong relationship and close cooperation with the Federal Government will continue to be upheld to ensure Sabah is not left behind in the national development agenda. He said the State Government highly values the various forms of assistance and initiatives provided by the Federal Government, including in infrastructure, health, education, and security. He expressed his appreciation to the Prime Minister for the Federal Government's commitment to defending Sabah's rights and sovereignty, including the successful rejection of external claims on the state at the international level. 'Malaysia's success in repelling foreign claims on Sabah proves that the sovereignty of this state remains firm under the Federation of Malaysia, and this gives confidence and reassurance to all Sabahans,' he said. * Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel and Telegram for breaking news alerts and key updates! * Do you have access to the Daily Express e-paper and online exclusive news? Check out subscription plans available. Stay up-to-date by following Daily Express's Telegram channel. Daily Express Malaysia