An insurance firm is ordered to pay $44M in a lawsuit filed by a man freed from prison in Missouri

A man won $11 million in a lawsuit against police after his conviction for killing a Missouri newspaper's sports editor was overturned, but the city's former insurer resisted paying most of it for almost three years. A Missouri judge this week ordered the company to pay nearly $44 million.
Most of the money would go to Ryan Ferguson, whose legal battle with Minnesota-based St. Paul Fire and Marine Insurance Co. in Missouri's courts started in 2017, about six weeks after he won a federal lawsuit against six Columbia police officers. Ferguson was convicted in 2004 of killing Columbia Daily Tribune sports editor Kent Heitholt but was released from prison in 2013 after a state appeals court panel concluded that he hadn't received a fair trial. Ferguson maintained his innocence.
The city insurer paid Ferguson $2.7 million almost immediately after he won his federal lawsuit, and his attorneys expected St. Paul to pay $8 million under its coverage for the officers from 2006 to 2011. But the company argued that it wasn't on the hook because the actions leading to Ferguson's arrest and imprisonment occurred before its coverage began.
While Ferguson sought to collect, the officers argued that St. Paul was acting in bad faith, shifting the burden to them as individuals and forcing them to face bankruptcy. Ferguson's lawyers took up those claims, and Missouri courts concluded that St. Paul was obligated to pay $5.3 million for the time Ferguson was in prison while it covered the officers. It paid in 2020.
But the payment didn't end the dispute, and in November, a jury concluded that St. Paul had acted in bad faith and engaged in a 'vexatious refusal' to pay. Cole County Circuit Judge S. Cotton Walker upheld that finding in his order Monday as he calculated how much money the company would pay — mostly as punishment — under a Missouri law capping such punitive damages.
'It's a way to send a message to insurance companies that if there's coverage, they need to pay,' said Kathleen Zellner, whose firm represents Ferguson.
She added: 'You can't just pull the rug out from under people when they've paid the premiums.'
The company can appeal the decision. An attorney representing St. Paul did not immediately return a telephone message seeking comment.
Under an agreement between Ferguson and the six officers, they stand to split about $5 million of the $44 million.
The award of nearly $44 million includes $3.2 million to compensate Ferguson and the officers, another $24.2 million in punitive damages, $535,000 million for the 'vexatious refusal' allegation and interest on all of the damages totaling about $16 million.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Daily Mail​

12 minutes ago

• Daily Mail​

Michigan high school coach kills student inside her home before turning gun on himself

A beloved Michigan teenager was gunned down inside her home by her former high school bowling coach, who then turned the gun on himself in a shocking murder-suicide, police said. Bedford High School graduate Gwendolyn Smith, 17, was allegedly shot multiple times by Ryne Leist, 38, a former volunteer coach with the school's bowling club. The horror unfolded inside her stepfather's home in Bedford Township on June 14, Monroe County Sheriff's Office said. Smith's stepfather Matthew Kennerson discovered the unimaginable scene after he returned home around 6 p.m. Monroe County Sheriff Troy Goodnough confirmed Leist died of a self-inflicted gunshot wound. Smith's death was ruled a homicide. Authorities have not said how married father-of-one Leist entered the home, nor have they detailed any possible motive. 'At this time, the point of entry and access remains under investigation,' Goodnough said during a press conference. The sheriff also declined to elaborate on the nature of the relationship between the teen and her former coach but emphasized, 'Gwendolyn did not consider the relation between the two of them to be romantic'. Leist, who had recently resigned from his job at a local bowling alley, had previously worked with the school's bowling club, but was not an official employee of Bedford Public Schools. He had passed all required background checks to volunteer with youth sports in Michigan, Superintendent Carl Shultz told WTOL. In a heartbreaking tribute on Facebook, Shultz remembered Smith as, 'an extraordinary young woman whose presence left an indelible mark on our school community.' 'It is with a heavy heart that I share the tragic and heartbreaking news of the loss of one of our own - Gwendolyn Smith, a 2025 graduate of Bedford School,' he wrote. 'Gwen will be remembered for her kindness, her bright spirit, and the joy she brought to those around her.' The slain teen's stepmother, Heather Smith, expressed the family's devastation in an emotional Facebook post. 'We aren't supposed to outlive our children. Everyone loved Gwen. She was kind, talented and the best kid an evil stepmother could ask for. My middle daughter, my baby, was murdered,' she said. Kennerson had proudly celebrated his stepdaughter's graduation just two weeks earlier, sharing a smiling photo of her in cap and gown. 'Really proud stepdad!' he wrote at the time. Two weeks later, he added a heartbreaking update: 'Love you forever… I'm so sorry I couldn't save you…' Shultz has since launched a GoFundMe to help the family, which has raised over $18,000. 'I was compelled to really help them out and make sure they had the resources necessary to be able to take care of what they needed to due to this horrible tragedy,' he told reporters. 'I'm always a parent first, I'm an educator second. But as a parent, I don't know how you get up the next day,' Shultz added. 'They're extremely strong and they're doing everything they can to hold everything together, but I was just trying to help out as much as I could.' The tragedy has sent shockwaves through the Bedford community, with many struggling to comprehend how such a horrific act could have happened to such a promising and beloved young woman. 'This tragic and unnecessary loss cannot be explained,' Shultz said. 'It has shaken our entire Bedford community, and our hearts and prayers go out to Gwen's family and the many friends whose lives she touched so deeply.'

Daily Mail​

12 minutes ago

• Daily Mail​

Teen soccer star Emerson Colindres speaks out after being deported to Honduras by ICE

A 19-year-old soccer star has spoken out for the first time after being deported from the United States to Honduras. Emerson Colindres, an aspiring professional soccer player, was arrested, detained and eventually deported just weeks after he graduated from high school in Cincinnati. The teen reportedly has no criminal record but was held in the Butler County Jail for a couple of weeks before being flown back to Honduras on Wednesday. According to reports, Colindres was detained in front of his mother on June 4 during a routine check with immigration officials. Ada Bell Baquedano Amador detailed what the ICE agents told her son ahead of his deportation. 'He said: "Mom, you'll never imagine the questions they were asking me. They asked if I knew where I was going. If I had family here, I didn't know what to tell them,' she told FOX19 NOW. Protests were held earlier this month calling on the authorities to release Colindres "'I left Honduras when I was 8. I don't remember anything."' That was her first interaction with him since his detention. Now back in Honduras, Colindres told FOX19 NOW that 'what hurt the most' was being arrested in front of his mother. 'I told myself I would never be in the position to where my mom would have to see me in handcuffs or in jail, and then when she looked at me, she was lost. 'She couldn't speak. But that's one of the most painful things I went through because I've never been separated from my mom ever.' The family arrived in the US in 2014 but their application for asylum was denied. They were given a final removal order in 2023. 'I miss my mom,' Colindres said. 'I miss my sister. I want to see them. When am I going to see them? 'I was just sad, I was really sad. Obviously, I'm going to push through it because I have to, but I was just sad. I just need to see my mom and my sister. I miss them a lot.' His mom and sister are said to be flying back to Honduras on Monday, having also been given a deportation order.

The Guardian

13 minutes ago

• The Guardian

Pope commits to weeding out church sexual abuse, praises role of press in democracy

The Roman Catholic church must 'not tolerate any form of abuse', sexual or otherwise, Pope Leo XIV has said in his first public remarks about the worldwide clerical molestation scandal that has long roiled the church. In a statement read on Friday at the performance of a play which dramatizes the work of a journalist who endured harassment while investigating abuse scandals within a powerful Catholic group, Leo maintained that it was necessary to inculcate 'throughout the church a culture of prevention that does not tolerate any form of abuse: abuse of power or authority, of conscience or spirituality, of sexual abuse'. Leo's statement also exalted the importance of a free, independent press, saying: 'Wherever a journalist is silenced, the democratic soul of a nation is weakened. 'Defending free and ethical journalism is not only an act of justice, but a duty for all who aspire to a strong and participatory democracy.' The comments from the pontiff cut a stark contrast with some other bishops, including from Leo's native US, who have criticized news media reporting on the church clergy molestation and cover-up scandal that has victimized countless children across the world. They also come after clergy-molestation survivors' groups expressed concern over Leo's 8 May election to succeed the late Pope Francis as the leader of the globe's nearly 1.5 billion Catholics. Those concerns stemmed in part from when Robert Prevost – Leo's birth name – was leading the midwestern US chapter of the Augustinian religious order. In that 2000, that chapter stationed an Augustinian priest named James Ray in a friary that was adjacent to an elementary school, nine years after the clergyman had been prohibited from working around children because of accusations that he had molested minors. Then, after he became the bishop of Chiclayo, Peru, beginning in 2015, three women told Prevost directly that they had allegedly been abused as minors by two local priests – but the accusers said they had no evidence any meaningful investigation into their claims ensued. The Vatican has said that Prevost was not the official who authorized Ray's living arrangements at the friary in Chicago, Leo's home town. With respect to the case in Chicalayo, church officials have said Leo handled the case within canonical norms but that the Vatican agency which investigates clerical sexual abuse cases found insufficient evidence to substantiate the accusers' allegations. Leo himself had not discussed Catholic clergy molestation cases until Friday's performance of Proyecto Ugaz in Lima, Peru. The stage production pays tribute to journalist Paola Ugaz, who spent years investigating abuse scandals involving the influential Catholic organization colloquially known as the Sodalitium and was met with litigation as well as death threats. Francis took the extraordinary step of dissolving the Sodalitium in January, about three months before his death. According to the Associated Press, survivors of abuse by the Sodalitium credit Leo with arranging a key meeting with his predecessor that triggered a Vatican investigation leading to the organization's dissolution. As Leo's statement put it, Ugaz and her colleagues carried out their work with 'courage, patience and commitment to the truth'. 'Your fight for justice is also the church's fight,' Leo's statement added. 'A faith that does not touch the wounds of the human body and soul has not yet understood the gospel.' The pope's statement said it was urgent for the church to renew its 'commitment to protect minors and vulnerable adults'. The statement also called on journalists to 'not be afraid'. 'Through your work, you can be builders of peace, unity and social dialogue,' Leo's missive said. 'Be sowers of light in the shadows.'