Competition Bureau releases final anti-greenwashing guidelines
The Competition Bureau has released its final anti-greenwashing guidelines after considering more than 400 responses to the legislation that took effect about a year ago.
'While a lot of the feedback in the submissions is reflected in the final guidance, some is not,' the bureau said in a backgrounder accompanying Thursday's announcement.
For instance, some suggested the guidelines spell out for businesses exactly what environmental claims they can make in their marketing material and when. But the bureau said amendments to the Competition Act that passed in June 2024 include no such rules.
'Instead, the act allows businesses to make whatever environmental claims they wish, as long as those claims are not false or misleading, and as long as those claims are adequately and properly tested or substantiated where required,' the bureau said.
'This requires an assessment not only of the literal wording of a claim, but also of the general impression created by the advertisement as a whole, including the words, images and layout.'
The agency also received suggestions that it said would mean acting beyond its legal authority. The bureau said some commenters encouraged it to act as gatekeeper for private citizens wanting to launch a challenge, but it said that is the responsibility of the Competition Tribunal. The bureau added it should be left up to the courts to interpret terminology included in the legislation.
Some of those weighing in argued that the bureau's enforcement of greenwashing provisions should mirror that of securities law, but the guidance says there should be a distinction between the two.
'In the bureau's view, the protections afforded to ordinary consumers under the act should not be limited to the protections afforded to people who are seeking to invest in capital markets,' it said.
The new Competition Act provisions dealing with greenwashing require that companies' environmental claims be based on 'adequate and proper testing' and 'proper substantiation in accordance with an internationally recognized methodology.'
When draft guidelines were released in December and put to public consultation, questions were raised about what exactly 'internationally recognized methodology' entails. In the final guidelines, the bureau said it would likely pass muster if it were recognized in two or more countries — but not necessarily by those countries' governments.
The bureau said it has taken enforcement action on two environmental claims over the past two years — against coffee-pod maker Keurig and automaker Volkswagen — under deceptive marketing practices provisions. Violations under those provisions can lead to fines of $10 million or higher.
Energy sector players are among those who have raised concerns about the legislation, with many clamming up on their climate communications in response.
Shortly after the law passed, the Pathways Alliance — a group of oilsands majors planning to capture and store carbon dioxide emissions from their operations — removed virtually all content from its website and social media feeds, citing uncertainty over the rules.
'While Greenpeace would argue the oilsands' greenwashing was always illegal, the new rules make it abundantly clear that the Pathways Alliance's net zero claims do not pass the sniff test, which is likely why the companies so abruptly deleted them and their social media history,' said Keith Stewart, senior energy strategist with Greenpeace Canada.
'The climate change-fuelled wildfires that have driven tens of thousands of Canadians out of their homes again this year are a stark illustration of how making false environmental claims to delay real climate action is not a victimless crime.'
Alberta Premier Danielle Smith has spoken out against the greenwashing rules, among a litany of other federal environmental moves.
A day after the April federal election, the Canadian Association of Energy Contractors laid out its priorities for the Liberal government in Ottawa, including that it 'scrap greenwashing legislation that unfairly silences Canadian companies from showcasing their world-leading environmental performance and economic contributions.'
In April, Canada's largest bank dropped its target of facilitating $500 billion in sustainable financing, in part due to the anti-greenwashing legislation. RBC also decided not to disclose its energy supply ratio, a measure of how its financing of high- and low-carbon energy compare.
At the time, RBC vice-president Jennifer Livingston said no internationally recognized methodologies existed for some of the measurements.
'We are disappointed not to share these metrics externally but will continue to monitor and report them internally to measure our progress,' she said.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 5, 2025.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Wall Street Journal
3 days ago
- Wall Street Journal
Canada's Antitrust Watchdog Calls For Easing of Foreign-Ownership Limits in Airline Sector
OTTAWA-Canada's antitrust watchdog recommends the government ease restrictions on foreign investment in the country's airline sector to stimulate competition – such as allowing nonresidents to own 100% of a domestic-focused carrier. The Competition Bureau issued its findings after a nearly yearlong study about Canada's airline market on ways to stoke fiercer rivalries among operators.
Bloomberg
3 days ago
- Bloomberg
Watchdog Urges Canada to Open Airline Sector to More Foreign Capital
Canada should loosen investment rules for airlines to allow full foreign ownership of carriers that fly only within the domestic market, according to the country's competition watchdog. The recommendation is one of several released Thursday by the Competition Bureau following a nearly yearlong study. It also suggests raising the ownership limit for Canadian airlines so that a single foreign investor can own as much as 49%, up from the current 25%, and prioritizing competition in merger reviews.
Yahoo
3 days ago
- Yahoo
Watchdog recommends up to 100% foreign airline ownership amid low competition
Canada should allow 100 per cent foreign ownership of domestic-only airlines, the Competition Bureau says in a new report highlighting the country's "highly concentrated" aviation industry. In a market study released Thursday, the watchdog suggested creating a new class of airline that operates only in Canada but could have owners from outside its borders, opening the gate to global expertise — and cash. The current foreign ownership cap sits 49 per cent. In addition, no more than 25 per cent of a carrier can be owned by any one foreign entity, a proportion the Competition Bureau proposed raising to nearly half. "Allowing more foreign investment in Canadian airlines improves access to capital, drives growth and promotes competition," the report said. Low competition in the airline industry remains a big hurdle to lower prices and better service across the country, and remote communities especially, the report found. 'Competition in Canada's airline sector has struggled to take off,' it said, noting consumers' dissatisfaction with fares, flight options and service quality. Air Canada and WestJet together account for between half and three-quarters of all domestic passengers at major airports, according to the study. Though competition improved between 2019 and 2023 with the arrival of Flair Airlines and the expansion of Porter Airlines, market concentration remains 'extremely high' and competition from new entrants fragile, the bureau said, with the field dominated by a few large airlines. 'Many Canadians report that international flights are often cheaper than flights within Canada,' it noted. The report recommended a basket of reforms that include shifting the financial burden of airport maintenance away from passengers, thus lowering ticket prices and allowing more consumers to book flights on budget carriers, as well as expanding market access for new entrants by allowing secondary airports to compete with major hubs. Currently, flight exclusivity clauses often mean only one airport in a local area can host international flights. 'New entrants to the market face aggressive competitive responses,' the study found. The report also called for an end to the transport minister's power to override mergers and acquisitions deemed anticompetitive under a federal review process. It also urged industry-wide publication of data on delays and cancellations to help consumers make informed choices, on par with the United States and United Kingdom. It further stressed the unique challenges faced by remote communities and recommended a working group to ramp up service to the North, where air transportation is an 'essential lifeline, even for residents who never fly' but whose food and medicine arrive by plane. 'New entrants face major barriers because existing carriers control critical assets at the major northern airports,' the report said. It asked the government to "tailor regulations to the northern context" and weed out unnecessary costs. Over the past 20 months, four low-cost carriers have disappeared from the skies, as Lynx Air and Canada Jetlines shut down and WestJet folded subsidiary Swoop and the recently acquired Sunwing Airlines into its main-line service. While the country's biggest cities remain amply served, smaller ones have fewer options, which can also result in higher prices and, when things go awry, stranded passengers. The Calgary-Saskatoon route saw flights fall 39 per cent to 412 last month from 673 in May 2019, now that the airspace between Alberta and Saskatchewan's two biggest cities is served with non-stop flights by WestJet only — Air Canada pulled out over two years ago — according to aviation data firm Cirium. Flight volumes between Ottawa and Fredericton decreased 23 per cent in the same period to 89 trips after Air Canada exited the route, leaving Porter as its sole carrier. Routes served by just one airline tend to be more expensive, the report noted. 'Our research shows that when just one new competitor flies on a route between two cities, airfares go down by nine per cent on average,' the report said. This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 19, 2025. Companies in this story: (TSX: AC) Christopher Reynolds, The Canadian Press Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
