Police did not properly probe killer's assaults before attacks, report says

Police failed to properly investigate an assault on warehouse workers by Nottingham killer Valdo Calocane which could have stopped his murder spree a month later, a report by the police watchdog has found.
The Independent Office for Police Conduct's (IOPC) report which probed the actions of three Leicestershire Police officers, seen by the PA news agency, resulted in a misconduct meeting rather than a more serious misconduct hearing, meaning the officers will receive a maximum of a final written warning.
Calocane was reported to have punched a man in the face and pushed a woman over at a warehouse in Kegworth on May 5 2023 – a month before he killed 19-year-old students Barnaby Webber and Grace O'Malley-Kumar and 65-year-old caretaker Ian Coates.
The officer assigned to the investigation, known only as Officer A, failed to check his details on the police national computer (PNC), which would have identified an outstanding arrest warrant, acts of violence and his detention under the Mental Health Act, the report said.
She also told the IOPC that had she run a PNC check on Calocane, she would have prioritised his arrest.
The two alleged victims in the case, who were both Romanian, were contacted by the officer with the use of Google Translate because she was unaware that she could 'use an interpreter over the phone'.
CCTV footage of the alleged assault was also not exhibited by Officer A, meaning it was permanently wiped from the force's systems.
The officer was only 12 days into the job when the incident occurred, the report said.
Her tutor, known as Officer B, said he had accrued a 'crime queue' as he had not tutored for six months prior to Officer A joining the force, and accepted he should have satisfied himself that PNC checks were carried out, and apologised.
The supervising officer, known as Sergeant C, agreed his review of the crime report into Calocane 'fell short of expected standards', but told the IOPC he was not 'lazy or slacking', but 'simply overworked'.
Despite the failings outlined in the report, the IOPC concluded no lessons could be learned from the errors.
The families of the three murder victims said they have been 'excluded' from the 'secret' misconduct meeting – describing both Leicestershire Police and the IOPC as 'not fit for purpose'.
In a statement, the families said they were 'deeply unhappy' and believed the report to be of 'very poor quality'.
We question why we are excluded from yet another secret meeting
Families of the Nottingham attack victims
It read: 'Once more we have been let down.
'We are limited in what we can say by the terms of an NDA (non disclosure agreement) that we were made to sign months ago.
'What we can say is that we are aware of the details contained within the IOPC investigation.
'We can confirm we are deeply unhappy and believe it to be of very poor quality.'
The families continued: 'The IOPC and Leicestershire (Police) Force have been made aware in detail on numerous occasions of our concerns and thus far have failed to address them.
'Additionally we have very recently been advised that our attendance at the disciplinary meeting may be restricted to remote viewing and the identity of officers under disciplinary action withheld.
'We question why we are excluded from yet another secret meeting.
'Especially when we consider the manner in which an officer in Nottingham was publicly named at a full disciplinary hearing in January 2024 for sharing (and not authoring) an inappropriate WhatsApp message following the murders.
'Thank god that the statutory public inquiry has been confirmed. We put our trust in the truth finally being found out.
'The police force in question and watchdog supposed to hold them to account are not fit for purpose.'
Officer A told the IOPC she 'recognised and accepted that she did not complete police national computer (PNC) or police national database (PND) checks on the suspect' but said she 'did not know that this needed to be done', the report said.
IOPC investigators obtained information from the PNC that would have been available at the time of the alleged assaults – which included an outstanding arrest warrant for assaulting an emergency worker from September 2022, following an incident in 2021.
Other incidents involving Calocane available on the PNC were:
– Stalking of a former housemate in July 2022 which resulted in no complaint;
– Assault of another resident in student housing in January 2022 which resulted in no complaint;
– Punching an officer in the face and headbutting him while being sectioned under the Mental Health Act;
– Assault of a flatmate in July 2021 which resulted in no complaint;
– His detention under the Mental Health Act in July 2020;
– And a female being injured after jumping out of an upstairs window after Calocane was kicking her front door in May 2020 which resulted in no further action as he was sectioned.
Officer A also recognised that she 'made a mistake' after CCTV footage of the alleged assault was not exhibited after it was recorded on her colleague's body-worn video.
The report read: 'Officer A stated she could have made more attempts to contact the victims, contact witnesses, and obtained the CCTV in an evidential format. She said 'I'm really sorry I didn't do any of that'.'
A person known in the report only as Witness X called 999 to report the alleged assaults and in a statement in March 2024, she said she informed the officers who attended that her colleague thought Calocane was bending down to 'take hold of a safety knife' and that it was 'kicked away from him' when he went to pick it up.
Officer A told the IOPC she recalled a witness mentioning a safety knife that may have been dropped but it was unclear who it belonged to.
She added: 'There was no mention that (Calocane) had tried to reach for the knife. I contest I was told about this.'
She stated this was not malicious on her part - it was because she was brand new and she had 'no idea'
IOPC report
Concluding its analysis of the officer, the report said: 'Officer A stated that she was very new and she accepted she had made mistakes with the way she handled things.
'She stated this was not malicious on her part – it was because she was brand new and she had 'no idea'.'
Officer B told the IOPC he discussed prioritisation of cases with Officer A but 'unfortunately, this one might have fell further down the queue because we didn't have any details for him at the point'.
He said he assumed the failure to exhibit the CCTV footage must have been 'human error' and accepted he could have checked that had been completed.
The officer told the watchdog there was 'no hiding' from the fact that intelligence checks on the suspect were not done quickly enough and said they could have been 'more robust in seeking arrest attempts'.
An IOPC spokesperson said: 'We concluded our investigation in September last year into Leicestershire Police's handling of assault allegations made against Valdo Calocane in May 2023.
'As a result, three officers will face misconduct meetings being arranged by the force.
'Our report and findings were shared with all of the interested parties including the families of Ian Coates, Grace O'Malley-Kumar and Barnaby Webber.
'Our thoughts and sympathies remain with them.
'We have advised the families and the force that we intend to publish our investigation report and findings following the conclusion of proceedings.
'We are unable to comment further at present.'

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

The Sun

13 hours ago

• The Sun

Man dies after being pulled from inner-city river as cops launch probe over ‘unexplained' death

A MAN has tragically died after being pulled from the River Soar and rushed to hospital. Leicestershire Police said they were called to reports of a man in the water near Castle Gardens, Leicester, on Monday June 16. The man was rushed to hospital to receive medical treatment where he sadly died three days later on Thursday June 19. The mans death is being treated as unexplained by cops who are supporting his family. Officers are asking for anyone with information that may help their investigation to come forward. A report will be prepared for the coroner. Identification of the deceased is being left to HM Coroner. Leicestershire Police's Complex Investigations Team is probing the man's death. Detective Inspector Nathan Paddison, from the Complex Investigation Team (CIT), said: 'Enquiries to establish the circumstances that led to the man entering the water are continuing. 'I'd like to speak to anyone who was on the towpath at Castle Gardens on Monday morning, who has not already contacted police. Anything you can tell us could help our investigation.' Anyone with information has been urged to contact the cops on 101 quoting incident number 172 of June 16. 1

Scottish Sun

13 hours ago

• Scottish Sun

Former reality TV star of Beauty And The Geek is arrested for murder after her partner's body is found in grisly scene

The woman has been detained under the Mental Health Act 'BEAUTY' MURDER ARREST Former reality TV star of Beauty And The Geek is arrested for murder after her partner's body is found in grisly scene Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) A FORMER reality TV star from Beauty and the Geek has been arrested and charged with murder after her partner's body was found in their house. Emergency services were called to the home in Port Lincoln, South Australia, to reports of a fire. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 3 The couple had recently moved in together at the house where the body was found Credit: 9news 3 Forensic and major crime investigators were flown in to assist the local force Credit: 9news 3 Port Lincoln is a small town of just 15,000 people Credit: Google Maps When they investigated, they found a man's body inside. The unnamed 34-year-old was arrested at the scene and later charged with murder. She was once a contestant on reality show Beauty and the Geek, reports The Courier Mail. The social experiment programme brings together attractive women with nerdy men in a mansion. read more in world news TRAM HORROR 7 injured as tram crashes into restaurant after 'taking turn at high speed' The victim and the suspect had been in a relationship together, South Australia Police confirmed. The woman refused bail and remains in custody. Major crime investigators and forensic officers were flown into Port Lincoln to assist local authorities with the investigation. Neighbours were shocked by the news. One told Perth Now the woman is 'really nice, very pleasant, polite.' Ian Parrott, of South Australia Police, said: "I can reassure members of the community that this is not a random incident. Argentina's Lucy Letby' in court after murdering 5 newborns & trying to kill 8 more in chillingly similar case to UK's baby killer "We understand that the female who has been arrested and the deceased male both lived at this address." It is understood the couple had recently moved in together. He continued: "It is still very early stages of this investigation and it's likely that the Major Crime investigators and the forensic response members will be there most of today." Parrot said the cause of death was yet to be determined and that further details could not yet be released as the victim's family hadn't been notified. The woman has been detained under the Mental Health Act and did not seek bail. She is expected to return to court in December. A suppression order is in place preventing the publication of any information that could identify the woman, the victim, or details surrounding the man's death. That order is due for review by the court next week.

Daily Mirror

20 hours ago

• Daily Mirror

Brit knocked unconscious by single punch during row with Benidorm bouncers

The unidentified British tourist and his pals were getting rowdy with bouncers in a Benidorm bar when a local intervened and knocked him unconscious A British tourist was knocked out cold when a Spanish local sucker-punched him during a row with bouncers in Benidorm. A fellow reveller captured the moment the unidentified Brit fell to the floor after the vicious sucker punch at a bar in the Spanish resort town on Sunday night. ‌ Eyewitnesses recalled how another pubgoer had asked him and his pals to leave when a bouncer decided to intervene. The tension racheted up and things became "heated", one person said. ‌ In the footage, the Brit dressed in a white outfit is pushed by a group of men. His friend then steps in before the man is brutally punched in the face and falls to the floor. Shockingly, his leg can also be seen bending unnaturally back towards his hip. A woman with a pink cowboy hat on her head rushes over and crouches over him while the man's friends carry on with their brawl. Another reveller said: "It's always the d***head Brits - it makes you ashamed to be a Brit sometimes. We'd been in there for two hours or so - it seemed a nice bar and all of a sudden we heard a bit of a commotion. "There was a smaller guy who we think was a local and he looked like a bouncer but looked a bit too small to be one. He was asking them to leave, and then the larger bouncer came over and things got a bit heated. It looks like the smaller guy then knocks him out. He was out cold, and his leg looked dislocated." ‌ The man's condition is currently unknown. It comes months after a Brit was left fighting for his life after being punched by a bouncer outside a Benidorm nightclub. Andrew Frazer, 43, was allegedly floored by a doorman in an 'unprovoked' attack during a lads' break to the famous Costa Blanca resort just over a week after proposing to long-term partner Carrie Howard. The father-of-two, from St Helens, Merseyside, had to have part of his skull cut away to relieve swelling on the brain. He was taken back to the UK with a gruelling 27-hour journey in the back of a private ambulance because his injuries were too severe for a medical flight. Overnight it emerged a 42-year-old Romanian man had been arrested over the early-hours incident on November 14 outside a pub in Benidorm's famous Little England area. The unnamed suspect was held last week on suspicion of a crime of wounding.